Showing posts with label CCS. Show all posts
Showing posts with label CCS. Show all posts

Friday, July 29, 2011

Essay won for C Rajagopalachari Essay Competition 2011


Here is concluding para of an essay that won the “C Rajagopalachari Essay Competition 2011” The beautiful and lucidly explained essay is by Neeraj Kumar Singh.

Neeraj says:
  • “If one could travel through time to mark the times and places when men have been prosperous, those points would be coincident with greater economic, political and personal freedom. The economic progress that India has seen in the last 20 years is a result of increased freedom. Through this essay I have tried to bring forth the areas where our freedoms are still restricted by the state. If these un-freedoms are removed, India can achieve its true potential and simultaneously move towards being a freer society.  The project of liberty has never been carried to its conclusion anywhere and India is no exception. The road remains only half-built.  The bottom-line is that the road to liberty needs to be built soon enough. I sincerely hope that this project is not contracted out to the government.” 

The full essay is available here (PDF).

Thursday, May 5, 2011

Some good news links


The Pragati’s May Issue is out now. You can find PDF here.

Don’t forget to read the piece on “Jan Lok Pal: unconstitutional, unnecessary” by Amba.

The Centre for Civil Society has announced “Colloquium on Property Rights: Law, Liberty & Livelihood” 

Friday, February 18, 2011

MPS Asia Regional Meeting-Three


I will cover the first session on February 11, 2011. You can see the speakers paper here.

The First Session on Inclusive Growth: The Unfinished Road to Reforms was chaired by Mr Suman K Bery, Director General, NCAER, New Delhi. He did not talking anything interesting (at least to me). This is one peculiar nature of talk often one can hear from any Indian economists!

Professor Amir Ullah Khan talked about the Liberalisation of the Informal Sector. The talk was more or less as usual that the reforms process has not been able to touch the informal sector where the majority of working age population is engaged in India. Much of this working age group population is directly shifted from agriculture without any marketable skills. But this story is off filled with not pure water but of bathwater!!

However, I asked him, have you ever come crossed any study which has looked the factors like informal sector influences with political groups and government machinery vis-à-vis the incentive mechanisms that operate between these groups on various aspects. His answer, as I hunched, was a big NO.

The issues related to Politics of Growth: Constraints and Opportunities were addressed by Mr.N K Singh, who is a Member of Parliament (RS). Instead of giving the reality of the politics in today’s India he kept himself focusing on the populist polices to convince the audience that the politics of growth is on right track!! He also seems to be not clear about what is all about functional democracy. All the major areas in which he had stressed was macro view. However, there was few crossing reference for useful reforms that is appreciable.

According to him the issue of income inequality is more of methodological and distributive matters rather than the usual assumptions.

Mr Surjit S Bhalla discussed about the Delivering on Promises: Public Private Partnerships, UID, and Social Entrepreneurship. As one often read his works, it is not surprise when he says that “India is a great path of testing liberal values” at this juncture.

He also agreed that India’s economic growth is taking place despite of the government and not because of the government. But in China, the economic growth is because of the State, and not despite of the State. Moreover, the economic freedom have delivered what is suppose to be rather than often claimed notion that the political freedom actually delivered the fruits of economic growth.

He gave very interesting analysis of income inequality as experienced in India and elsewhere.

What was quite disturbing to hear from his talk was the applauding for Bihar’s Chief Minister Policy to promote girls education by giving bicycles. This has been done through the direct cash transfer to the child or parents instead to buy the cycles and distribute to them as done in Tamil Nadu and other southern states some years ago. This is absolutely mockery the cycle as an incentive has not held to girls for enrolling in higher education that did not happened in Tamil Nadu and probably will not happen in Bihar. But we have to wait and see where the bucks stop!! 

Earlier posts: 1 2

Thursday, February 17, 2011

MPS Asia Regional Meeting-Two


Let me give you some sort of mixed picture from what I have noted from the various talks given by economists and experts in the MPS meeting on the opening dinner (Feb 10th, 2011).

Dr.Parth J Shah gave introduction with few facts about the CCS’s success stories such as its campaign (BAMBOO IS NOT A TREE!) against bamboo as a tree instead a grass, school choice campaign (education voucher or 25 percent reimbursement by Government) etc. He also mentioned that this is the second meeting organized in India.

He also mentioned that the amendments in the Shop and Establishment Act by the Government of Haryana paved a major window of opportunity to open call centres in India. Haryana was the first State in India to reform the above Act.

Professor Deepak Lal, who was immediate past President of MPS, gave Welcome Address. What was interesting from his address was that unfortunately the MPS society is divided when it comes to the debate of foreign polices!! He also said that this Society is not addressing the issues raised in the context of foreign polices.

The present President of MPS is Professor Kenneth Robert Minogu and he gave President Address. Few points from his address: (i) one point we should not be too taken by media that India, the global power, it is dangerous to think this and the State, (ii) he talked about the Prof F A Hayek’s works on the false government aims , promotion of welfare with debts, and (iii) the universal orders or spontaneous orders.

The MPS Asia Regional Meeting’s Inaugural Address (Full Paper in PDF) was given by Shri. Arun Shouri. Some major points from my noting: (i) India’s economic growth story is taking place despite of the government and not because of government has claimed to be, (ii) the former prime minister of India who initiated the economic reform in 1990s was the “honest crook”!!!, (iii) please do not go by your vision, please do not go with their past record, (iv) the Hayek’s notion of liberalism, (v) all political parties in India run by people who believe in nothing, (vi) the Indian family values for care each other which is actually the driving force for growing economy, (vii) morality is public life, (viii) the welfare polices are being promoted, despite of its weakness, with the blessings of people like Amartya Sen, (ix) natural order of society, virtual foundation of society, (x) a dog with a bone is his mouth cannot park.

Raj Cherubal had asked the important question which people like us ponder: what would the answer of Professor F A Hayek if he is alive in the mid’s of today’s crisis in India and abroad?

Mr Shouri answered rightly that the development and growth is taking place in a particular society not because of government but despite of it. But one can easily argue that Mr.Shouri is biased.

Previous posts: 1  

Tuesday, February 15, 2011

MPS Asia Regional Meeting- One

The 2011 MPS meeting theme was: India as Global Power: Practicing Liberal Values at Home and Abroad

This is the Second MPS meeting in India till now. The primer free market economics think tank in India, the Centre for Civil Society (CCS) had co-organized the First Mont Pelerin Society in Goa on January 27-30, 2002. The theme was: Freedom and Development: Making Democracy Work.

Attending the MPS Asia Regional Meeting was more than interesting but it was great fun. I have learned a lot. I have met many persons whose writings I read for several years. I had long conversation with some of these hard-core liberals on different issues. I have also met people whom I knew and are all concerned about liberalism in India. Thanks to the CCS for giving me the opportunity to participate in the MPS Meeting. However, I had expected some of others persons who are all often talk and write about liberalism in India; but they did not come for the MPS Meeting. I really have no clue about why they did not turn for this event.

But eight years after the democracy is stuck now rather to work. But we did not stop talking about the superpower!! This is the difference between the basic value or principle of Indian epic Mahabharata and Greek epic. In the later case you can get on to the next level of doing things but in the former case you have to justify why do we stuck, who is responsible etc. But this is not to say that we are all argumentative Indian!!

My earlier post: 1

Monday, January 31, 2011

Back to blog!!


I had another great opportunity to present my paper here and meet few interesting people also. I was also away from the NET world so I could not post anything that I think is important for this blog.

Some good news:

Prof.Ken is very kind to include my few words in his For News of Jonathan Gullible and the Philosophy of Liberty. You can see me by scrolling down!!!!

The other good news is that we have new Seminar:

The Mises-Hayek-Shenoy Seminar
Economics Beyond Keynes and Friedman
February 9-10, 2011
New Delhi

If any one of you interested to participate please do write to me, or to vipin.veetil@gmail.com andghanshyamsharma1985@gmail.com

Tuesday, December 28, 2010

Blame the hollowness of pity politics, not good economics

When we all see and read the words written on the walls of print media, electronic media, blogosphere etc in almost everyday; the unfettered drama and hollowness of pity politics and the mass murder of people in this republic is no less than the increasing of shamefulness on our face. I use the word “our face” meant to imply the liberals of India. 

Of courses there is a demand for movement for second independence, the economic freedom. The movement being called upon is visible yet only among few groups of people. But what reminds me always the words of “thunderous silence of stones not being thrown in” at masses in this country to evoke against the pity politics which neither have good understanding of good economics nor have good intention to understand them first. Let it be clear about the movement of change that we all wanted to have in India in this twenty-first century. The movements are unfolding almost like scattered lights on the sky year after year! The journey of Centre for Civil Society (Delhi) is almost fourteen years old, the Sanjeev Sabhlok’s journey is more than a half dozen years old, the one man army of Sauvik Chakraverti’s movement is perhaps equal to the CCS’s journey or one of the longest journey if you take into account overtime works!!

What prompt me to say above lines is very simple that the blame game on India’s economic reform is mounting like anything. I am not referring the mass scams and corruptions which we all witnessing now. The process of pity politics has inflated the mass suicides of farmers in India and not by economic reforms. One can say more ‘if’ and ‘but’ taking many other issues of social and cultural aspects. I think I have conveyed the message I wanted to record here.

Monday, October 18, 2010

Thursday, June 17, 2010

Indian Liberals


Amit has narrated very nicely about the Indian Liberals and Colour Pictures



PS: I am luckily happen to be one of the participants of this great colloquium!

.

Friday, March 12, 2010

Empower parents to make choice in education


Yesterday I had gone to CCS’s Student First discussion at IHC. The subject putout for discussion was “Implementing the 25% in RTE Act: Developing a Model”.


The newly joined Associate Director for School Choice Campaign Mr Jan Sjunnesson Rao made a presentation highlighting the following issues:


  • How are weaker and disadvantaged sections defined and verified?

  • How will the government select these students?

  • Should there be any admission criteria?

  • How can the admission process be made simple and easy for weaker sections and disadvantaged groups?

  • Would the admission lottery be conducted by each school or neighbourhood or by entire village/town/city? How would the supply-demand gaps in each neighbourhood be addressed?


After listening different viewpoint I felt a mixed feeling I mean the whole debate even officially ignores the ROLE OF PARENTS in the child education. Whatever the criteria set by government to enroll these children will be based on who the parent is? And how we define the whole set of institutional setup which will allow them to play what is good for them. Undermining their role in the process of educating child will face nightmare like the present higher education system.


There was little or no discussion on the following issues but was highlighted as core issues:

  • What will be the mechanism for reimbursement to private school?

  • How will the government monitor the whole process? What type of external vigilance/social audit would be allowed/encouraged on the process?

  • What would happen if some of these students need to be change school in higher classes?