Showing posts with label Private Property Rights. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Private Property Rights. Show all posts

Monday, August 24, 2020

Factors of production and land titling polices, the need for reform

I have new piece on The Commune Magazine website. It talks about the broad contours of factors of production in India and its implications on economic growth and development.

It also talks about India's yet to realize the importance of proper land titling systems reforms with emphasis on private property rights which was originally adopted in the Indian Constitution.

The concluding para is below:

"The real antidote lies not on merely better governance systems through government alone but the most effective use of technology and communication systems. The land digitization process is underway since 2008, although in a slow space. Under Constitution, the subject of land is in the State list but States are not proactive to enact a comprehensive law to make an appropriate framework to govern on land tilting systems. Hence, there is a dire need for the Union Government to bring model legislation for a comprehensive titling system that can unleash the potential of Indian economy and help us increase the pace of realizing an Atmanirbhar Bharat."


Wednesday, June 3, 2020

Need to Rope in Private Sector Hospitals in the Fight against COVID

I have new article on why we "Need to Rope in Private Sector Hospitals in the Fight against COVID"

My key points are as follows:

"Why is there no effort from the Union Government to bring out a comprehensive policy framework to engage private hospitals across the country to augment the efforts of public health systems in the fight against COVID-19?"

"Lack of a unified public policy to rope in private hospitals paves only confusion and contradiction in the collective fight against the pandemic."

We should make a strategic plan for effective partnership with private hospitals and make them part of the country’s strategy in the fight against COVID-19." 

Friday, June 6, 2014

Good reading


"You could, at a stretch, be permitted the luxury of advocating market economics and criticising India’s socialistic pattern of development. But since the Swatantra Party had gone into voluntary liquidation in 1973, this was an indulgence the socialist Establishment conceded to those whose only expression of organised opposition lay in attending Nani Palkhivala’s annual budget sermons in Bombay and Calcutta."

Why Gujarati Muslims are with Modi



Friday, September 6, 2013

Professor Ronald Coase, passed away at 102

Dr.Ronald Coase, was perhaps the only economics professor who lived such a long years upto 102 rather its more than a 101 economics. He passed away on September 2, 2013. He won the Nobel Memorial Prize for Economics in the year 1991 for his work on "for his discovery and clarification of the significance of transaction costs and property rights for the institutional structure and functioning of the economy".

I am a long admirer of his work on property rights. Prof Coase was also admirer of Prof F A Hayek's idea of choices in currencies and against of monopoly legal tender. 

Read this paper titled "Other things equal: the so called coase theorem".

His very opening line of his Nobel lecture was very candid. He begun by saying:

  • "In my long life I have known some great economists but I have never counted myself among their number nor walked in their company. I have made no innovations in high theory. My contribution to economics has been to urge the inclusion in our analysis of features of the economic system so obvious that,..."

"in a 60-year career he wrote only about a dozen significant papers and used little or no mathematics, yet his impact on his discipline was profound."

Here are some obituaries links:

The life and legacy of Ronald Coase
Ronald Coase : 1910 – 2013
RONALD COASE AND THE MISUSE OF ECONOMICS

Nobelist Who Studied Corporations
Remembering Ronald Coase
Ronald Coase has died, but his individualist dogma is everywhere

Saturday, March 2, 2013

Two great men passed away in different world


Today I wanted to write about two great men recently passed away in two different world. Both passed away last month. Both are strong believer of free market principles like limited government, rule of law, private property right etc. Both are great teachers in their own field. One taught economics and other man taught engineering subjects. I am talking about Prof P V Indiresan and Prof Armen A Alchian.

Professor P V Indiresan who passed away on 24th February, 2013 in Pune where he was about to chair a Session on " the Election Commission’s technical committee meet on electronic voting machines."

When I first heard the news I was terribly saddened. Though I was in office at that time and could not do anything except to simple sit down  and pray for his peace. Two things connects me. First, I have been reading his articles at least since 2002 and secondly, I had the opportunity to meet him in 2012 and freely discuss things that interest us. He wrote his last India 2020 column in The Business Line on 22nd February, 2013. 

I am sure he would have written a great piece on this year budget if he were to alive today. His column use to appear on Saturday. You can read all his BL columns here. He also written regular columns in The Hindu newspaper long ago, some are available in the website but one need to do some technical search to get the article. He has also written a column in The Indian Express. The most interesting thing about Prof Indiresan is that he could easily yet lucidly about economics even the economists in India cannot think of such ideas. I am referring to his articles on differential interest rates of RBI.

Here are news item/articles on his passing away:


Very recently only I was introduced to Prof Armen Alchian. Good friend Vipin gifted me the two volume of collected works of Prof Alchian by gently saying "Alchian is equally important economist as Prof F A Hayek was" on decoding the private property right and many other issues. Here are some good links to get quick understanding about his works. See 1,2,3,4.

Saturday, September 17, 2011

Amendments History of Private Property Right

I post here the full article for record:


Land acquisition and right to property by Sudhanshu Ranjan
"Right to property has seen various mutations, in effect, granting more powers to the State to acquire for ‘public purposes'
The issue of land acquisition by the State and the compensation paid to the owner has been a cause of turmoil in recent times. The problem, however, is not new. This is borne out by the repeated amendments that have been made to the ‘right to property'.
The proposed new law on land acquisition, which may be placed in Parliament soon, would virtually re-open the legal debate on the right to property, where the courts and Parliament have been at loggerheads.
The power of eminent domain — the legal capacity of the State to acquire the private property of individuals for public purposes— has been recognised as an essential attribute of a sovereign State.
The Supreme Court, however, held in Kameshwar Singh v. State of Bihar (1951) that though this power is recognised, Constitutional provisions define safeguards subject to which the right may be exercised. The State has, in turn, sought to spell out exceptions to the right to property from time to time. What we see today is a situation where eminent domain has been exercised on dubious grounds.
Statute changes
Article 31 of the Constitution made the right to property a fundamental right, which clearly stated that no person would be deprived of his property save by authority of law, and it would not be acquired save for a public purpose, and most crucially, it provided for the payment of adequate compensation.
Article 31 was amended six times before it was repealed. In its place there were a number of Constititional Amendments, essentially circumscribing the right to property.
The Fourth Amendment to the Constitution stated that acquisition of property cannot be challenged on grounds of adequacy of compensation. The six amendments to Article 31A were aimed at enhancing the power of the State.
The Fourth Amendment restated more precisely the power of the State for compulsory acquisition and requisition of private property, and distinguished it from cases where State caused “deprivation of property”. The Seventeenth Amendment further restricted the fundamental right to property. The concept of “estate” was expanded to overcome the Supreme Court's decisions and those of the Kerala High Court. Ryotwari estates were specifically included in Article 31A, even as the Supreme Court held in Karimbil Kunhikonam v. State of Kerala that ryotwari estates did not fall within the ambit of Article 31A. At the same time, the State was restrained from acquiring any self-cultivated land within the ceiling fixed by law till compensation not less than the market value was paid.
DIFFERING VIEWS
Many of these changes were placed under the Ninth Schedule, rendering them immune to judicial review.
The confrontation between the court and Parliament veered around the right to property. When the court persisted in its interpretation of the word “compensation”, Parliament substituted it with the word “amount” in the Constitution (Twenty-Fifth Amendment) Act, 1971. During Nehru's time, 17 amendments to the Constitution were effected.
The controversial ones were those which restricted judicial review in respect of the right to property.
The propertied class was worried and challenged the validity of those amendments on the grounds that they attacked the fundamental rights.
The issue was whether Parliament could use the power of amendment to deprive the people of fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution.
Article 13 (2) says that the State shall make no law that takes away or abridges the fundamental rights. The question is whether Constitutional amendments are “law” or not.
In a landmark judgement in 1967 the Supreme Court in I. C. Golaknath v. State of Punjab held that a Constitutional amendment effected under Article 368 was a “law” within the purview of Article 13(2). The case called into question the inclusion of the Punjab Security of Land Tenures Act, 1953, in the Ninth Schedule, the court observing that the First, Fourth and Seventeenth Amendments themselves were unconstitutional as they precluded judicial review of laws relating to property.
The inclusion of the Mysore Land Reforms Act (10 of 1962 as amended by Act 14 of 1965) was assailed on the same grounds.
A Constitution Bench of 11 judges heard it and the court decided by a majority of 6:5 that none of the fundamental rights could be taken away or even abridged.In 2007, the Supreme Court held that laws placed under the Ninth Schedule after April 1973 would be open to review.
Current context
The recent agitations of farmers against land acquisition and compensation stem from the fact that the State governments have been behaving like property dealers. In Uttar Pradesh, land acquired at the rate of Rs. 880 per square metre was sold to builders at the rate of Rs 4,800 and an additional Rs 2,600 was allegedly paid ‘below the table'. If farmers sell directly to builders they could have earned more.
The Land Acquisition Act, 1894, provides for taking private property for public purposes, the eminent domain principle. In 1984, this Act was amended radically, providing that compensation once announced by the government cannot be reduced as could be done under the 1894 Act, and that compensation is to be provided at projected market rate.
Besides, it provided for ‘solatium compensation' for psychological injury caused because of displacement.
Now, another Land Acquisition Bill is likely to introduced in the next session of Parliament.
A just formula of compensation has to be worked out, and the buyer must be forced to return the land to the seller if it is not developed within a reasonable time span."
(The author is a Senior TV journalist and columnist.) (This article was published on June 14, 2011 in The Business Line)

Friday, August 12, 2011

Nehru’s blunders


The below paras are from the article by Sharad Joshi who is an eminent liberal economist and former parliamentarian in India. 
  • “The fact is that most recent problems relating to industrialisation and development of infrastructure could have been resolved at the dawn of Independence itself, had not Jawaharlal Nehru brought Soviet-brand socialism into independent India. 

  • The legislation Nehru brought in to abolish zamindari was rejected by most courts in the country as being violative of the fundamental right to property, including its acquisition, maintenance and disposal. Undaunted, Nehru moved the very first amendment to the Constitution — to abridge the fundamental right to property. His daughter, Indira Gandhi, gave that right a final burial. This established here the principle of eminence juris, copied from the British system, broadly meaning that the land belongs to the monarch and can be taken away only through due legal processes. This was unknown in the Indian system, where the land was considered to be the property of the village. Jairam Ramesh, had he done his homework properly, would have found that he is now grappling with a problem created by Jawaharlal Nehru and Indira Gandhi, both near-deities to the Congress.”

Saturday, June 25, 2011

The land saga of Singur and Poletown


“Private property is an essential concept in market-driven economies. Therefore, one must have a solid argument that demonstrates how the objectives of a market economy can be better served if private property rights are suspended. While there exist sound theoretical arguments to support the involuntary transfer of private ownership to public ownership in the construction of, say, public goods, there are no sound arguments for the government forcing a private party to give up land to another private entity. In other words, there is no reason for the government to act as a non-market intermediary in what is an essentially private transaction in the land market.

It is now up to us to come up with a land acquisition policy that is consistent with a market economy and the principles originally enshrined in our Constitution.”

See for full article here.

Thursday, June 16, 2011

What stops?


What stops to simply argue for private property right is not clear. Unlike in the past, many left-wing supports now understand the need for private property right but they refuse to defend property right. This is simply a bizarre.

Wednesday, May 25, 2011

Make market forces work


From the article “Leave It To The Market” by Dilip Modi
  • However, the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, gives sweeping legal powers to the government or its authorised agencies to acquire almost any private land or property provided such acquisition is for "public purpose". Invariably this route is adopted. This is also known as 'eminent domain', regarded as an inherent right of the state to take private property for public use. It is legal in many countries, including the US, UK and France. 
  • The problem lies in interpretation of the term "public purpose". Unfortunately the Act does not define the term. So interpretation was left to the courts. The Supreme Court in 1971 took a very wide view of the term in the case Jage Ram vs the State of Haryana. Yet it did not provide any definition and left it to the state governments to define and thus (mis)interpret the term. Strangely the judgment was delivered when 'right to private property' was still a fundamental right. Subsequent apex court judgments further widened the scope of interpretation. 
  • The economics behind eminent domain and thus the interpretation of the term public purpose assume that the state would always act in the public interest and, therefore, any taking of private property would be to provide certain "public goods" that otherwise would not be provided by the markets. 
  • Lighthouses or clean air are typical examples. One or several ships can use the light at the same moment. Yet no single ship owner would build the lighthouse. The government needs to build it - in other words, provide public goods as the market will not provide them automatically. 
  • This clearly implies the Act's provisions should only be used when the government itself is to provide infrastructure facilities (public good). They should not be used for land acquisition for private investments, whatever the benefits. For such transactions, the market must play out. The government should not undermine market processes. 

Thursday, May 5, 2011

Some good news links


The Pragati’s May Issue is out now. You can find PDF here.

Don’t forget to read the piece on “Jan Lok Pal: unconstitutional, unnecessary” by Amba.

The Centre for Civil Society has announced “Colloquium on Property Rights: Law, Liberty & Livelihood” 

Saturday, April 2, 2011

India’ property rights index

Parth Shah of CCS discuses the improvement of property rights index in the new report:  
  • One may argue as to how could political stability in India might have declined, as the government at the Centre as well as ruling regimes in states are comparatively more stable than earlier years. It is because the index does not measure only stay of the governments in office, but all sorts of disruptive movements like naxal and Telangana, explained Dr Parth J Shah, president of the Centre for Civil Society, partner of Property Rights Alliance in India for this index.
  • He said there are incidents of human rights violation in J&K and north eastern parts of the country. Besides, special and arbitrary powers are given to army through the Armed Forces Special Powers Act (AFSPA)in Jammu and Kashmir.
  • As expected, the report says that judicial independence is slightly on the rise in India. Without naming court's interventions in alleged scams in spectrum allocation for 2G and commonwealth games, Shah said there are instances of the judiciary challenging the executive in recent times in India.
  • In physical property rights, India scored 6.6 points in 2011 index, same as in 2010. However, Indian system of keeping records relating to physical property are too archaic. Even the last major land survey was conducted during British times.
  • “So far as property rights are concerned, the poor continue to fight the battle against forceful acquisition of their land by either the government or private parties. This remains a point of serious concern for India even as we achieve high rates of growth every year” Shah said.

Tuesday, February 1, 2011

Make that republic institutions work for resource-poor people


Mr. Arun Maira wrote on 26th January, 2011 that: 
  • One school of thought proposes that the quality of public services will improve by handing them to the private sector, which, with its focus on efficiency and profits, will cut out the waste. The same school of thought also believes that environmental damage is caused by a “tragedy of the commons” when no one “owns” the water, the forests, and the atmosphere. It believes that creation of private property rights (including tradable rights to pollute the atmosphere) will induce human beings to behave more responsibly. 

  • The basic premise of this school is that a market in which self-interested persons can trade, will always produce good outcomes. It believes that institutions for progress must be founded on principles of private property rights and competition.

  • Institutions are the wheels on which the cart of progress moves. The need to tune up government is evident. And the need to redesign market-and-property based institutions to meet challenges of inclusion and sustainability is evident too: in increasing public interest in new concepts of business accountability, social entrepreneurship, producer companies, and so on.

Wednesday, January 12, 2011

Scrap the Right to Education Act (RTE)

The Right to Education Act comes when there is no issue of enrollment but huge drop-out ratio. What it makes mockery of school education in this chaotic democracy is for the private schools and that is too by law!! Read the article and ponder what else more one need for scraping this RTE!!

Some excerpts:
  • It is said that one of most damaging virtues of George W Bush was his steadiness; he believed the same thing on Wednesday that he believed on Monday - no matter what happened on Tuesday. Unfortunately, the well-meaning or self-interested people - these are the only two kinds pushing for swifter implementation of the Right to Education Act (RTE) - seem to share this dangerous steadiness despite new information. 

  • As a company at the exit gate of the education system - we have hired somebody every five minutes for five years but only 5% of the kids who came to us for a job - we see and suffer the tragic consequences of India's education emergency. True impact in public policy – unlike election campaigns - does not lie in poetry but in plumbing.  

  • RTE makes it impossible for education entrepreneurs to compete on price since many states propose to regulate fees and uncertainty has paused the Cambrian explosion of energy in school entrepreneurship. This means lower capacity and lower competition. And that means schools don't have clients, but hostages. 

  • Third as enrolment ratios cross 100% it fights yesterday's war of quantity and fails to focus on quality and learning outcomes. We don't need more cooks in the kitchen but a different recipe. RTE not only fails this test but poisons the ecosystem by sabotaging other ways to get India educated.