Showing posts with label Hernando De Soto. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hernando De Soto. Show all posts

Friday, September 3, 2010

Corruption, Corps and Bureaucrats

Prof Prabhudev Konana writes:

  • To prevent the exploitation of the system, the law-makers — who are part of the corrupt system — introduce greater regulations, inspections, and restrictions, without recognising that adding so-called “oversight” leads to even greater potential for corruption. Hernando de Soto, the Peruvian economist, famously said in his seminal book Mystery of Capital: Why Capitalism Thrives in the West and Fails Everywhere Else, that in most countries “it is very nearly as difficult to stay legal as it is to become legal.” He stated this in the context of private property rights and bureaucratic hurdles, but it applies to every aspect of government transactions.

Tuesday, July 6, 2010

Property means wealth creation


Once again we have the grand Walk The Talk Show with Peruvian economist Hernando de Soto:


Some excerpts:


Shekhar Gupta: So the classical capitalists have got their discourse wrong.

de Soto: I don’t think most of our Western friends realise how their wealth coincided with the industrial revolution, and the industrial revolution came about because there was a breakdown of the feudal system, and because essentially every guy got the property and the business right and a uniform rule of law was applicable to everybody.


Shekhar Gupta: How would this apply to, say, tribal India, where we see the rise of Maoism now?


De Soto: So, having a property title doesn’t only mean that you own something, it means that it’s that with which you raise capital. So the question you must ask yourself, which I would do if I were Indian, is: How many of the people that are in these areas where you have natural resources actually have a piece of paper that you can take to Wall Street? And if they don’t, they are in a situation of inferiority.

Wednesday, March 10, 2010

Property rights for future migrants

That is the article in today’s BS by Sanjeev Sanyal. He argues that the:

“…..public policy should focus less on getting rid of slums and more on rethinking property rights, especially those of the poor……… the first problem with recognising squatter rights is that we create problems of governance by potentially encouraging land-grab. We not only have to think about today’s urban poor, but also about the incentive structure presented to the next generation of migrants. Second, the formalisation is usually done on the basis of a cut-off date. This often recognises the rights of better-off old-timers against those of poorer newcomers. Finally, and most importantly, in next generation cities like Gurgaon, the poor live in the “urban villages” where property rights are very clearly defined and any tampering would cause serious social upheaval. So, what should we do?



Identity as a property right: The single-most important, and sometimes only, asset of a poor migrant is her identity. Without any form of identification, it is very difficult for a newcomer to fit into the urban landscape — no gas connection, no mobile phone, no voter rights, no credit and so on. It is nearly impossible for such an individual to apply for jobs in the formal economy or sometimes even as domestic help. Thus, a reliable and robust system of identification is invaluable. This is why Nandan Nilekeni’s Unique Identity Number scheme may turn out to be a major intervention.

Wednesday, February 17, 2010

Property titling has to extend to everything

Empowering the poor: De Soto says no titling process of homes in slums such as Mumbai’s Dharavi is going to work unless the government includes all aspects of life. Madhu Kapparath/Mint


There is fantastic Mint interview with Hernando De Soto on many issues including the inside feeling of UPA II.

Tuesday, February 16, 2010

Rule of law is what gave capitalism its strength


Dhiraj Nayya of Indian Express interviewed Mr. Soto, the big giant of Private Property Right and economic freedom.

Also read here

Monday, February 15, 2010

Property Rights

Mr. Hernando de Soto President, Institute for Liberty & Democracies, Peru back to India.

"Mr. Hernando de Soto also cautioned the government from looking at a system of property rights in a vacuum. He believed that it was necessary to build a system of public memory that legally identifies all their people, their assets, their business records and their transactions in such a way that they can unleash their economic potential to benefit, both themselves and the country at large."

For more see here.

Monday, September 7, 2009

Friday, July 31, 2009

The road to Ludhiana from Kolkata= road to Uttar Pradesh from Tamil Nadu!

It is amazing to see how schools and colleges and universities are not teaching a simple truth, that at least in economics that every resource has an alternative use in some or other way which is the basics of market economy. Time and again our ideas giants have reminded us that the market alone can allocate these scare resources into alternative uses efficiently.

Years after I learned these facts from none other than Sowell’s beautiful book The Basic Economics.

Just see what other giant L. E Read said that the “aim of teaching is to evoke thinkers, not followers. The mark of a teacher’s success is to have his students surpass him”.

By this time you must have reached the conclusion why millions of our younger people become followers rather than thinkers? Even we had thinkers without attending schools.

I never heard any single teacher from Indian education system as of now who stood for the Mr Read's words. Yet, I read somewhere that the IIPM Delhi teaches Dr. Sowells Basic Economics book in their MBA classes!

Rajesh Chakrabarti in an article published in the financial express writes:

  • “in economics, the questions never change. So when, back in the 1980s, the Peruvian economist Hernando De Soto subtitled his book The mystery of capital with the query Why capitalism triumphs in the west and fails everywhere else, he was asking a question development economists have wrestled with for decades. The broad answer, institutions, was not new either—indeed Douglas North would soon win a Nobel Prize for having said so. Nevertheless there was something starkly different this time around. De Soto showed— by actually starting a business!—that an entrepreneur in Peru needs 289 days to register a business, and almost seven years to get the permit to build. It’s just plain torture to start and run a formal, law-abiding, tax-paying business in most developing countries. Little wonder the system does not work.”

Samuel Paul & Kala Seetharam Sridhar from Public Affairs Centre, Bangalore writes:

  • “In a recent study we have completed, we find that India’s southern states have performed distinctly better than their northern counterparts. Taking the example of Tamil Nadu from the south and Uttar Pradesh from the north, we found a marked upward shift in per capita income and reduction in poverty which TN experienced when compared with that of UP since the mid-1980s. This is true even though a comparison on the poverty rate showed that during the 1970s until about 1985, TN was actually about the same as, or perhaps worse than, UP as far as the extent of poverty was concerned! Judged by per capita income, we found TN was always ahead of UP by a modest margin, but TN had moved far ahead of UP by 2005 (50% higher in 1960-61 vs 128% higher in 2005-06).
  • In order to examine the efficiency of resource use, we examined expenditures on sectors (such as roads and primary education) which are inputs, and their outcomes such as the change in road length in TN and UP. Outcomes manifest themselves only with a lag after the initial expenditure/investment has been made. Hence, based on the data available, in the case of roads, we used the 1980-85 period for examining expenditure and with a 5-year lag, used the period 1985-90 for observing the outcome, i.e., road length. We found that TN spent a total of Rs 92,483 during 1980-85 for creating every additional kilometre (km) of road during 1985-90, whereas UP spent 3.5 times more than that of TN, Rs 328,788 over 1980-85 to create an additional km of road during 1985-90.
  • We take another example from the social sector (primary education) to demonstrate the relative efficiency of resource use in the case of the two states. Two surveys done by the Public Report on Basic Education in India (PROBE) team in the Hindi-speaking states (in 1996 and 2006), showed that despite the fact that schooling infrastructure had expanded rapidly, classroom activity levels had not improved during the decade. For instance, there was an impressive increase in the number of primary schools between 1996 and 2006, with one out of every four government schools being set up during this decade. Further, the proportion of schools in UP with at least two pucca rooms went up from 26% in 1996 to 84% in 2006.
  • Next, in 1996, free uniforms and textbooks were provided respectively only in 10% and less than half of schools, which increased to more than half of the schools and nearly 99% of schools in 2006. Let us compare this to outcomes. In rural north India, in 1996, about half of the time, there was no teaching going on in primary schools. However, despite all the increases in resources and inputs during 1996-2006 reported above, a resurvey conducted in 2006 found that nothing had changed with respect to educational outcomes — half of the government schools still had no teaching activity when the investigators arrived.”

What kind efficiency is there in our states economy you can find?

PS: I did many review studies on doing business in Indian cities but my feelings are nothing, yet a terrible!

Monday, March 23, 2009

Well defined private property rights matter ………

Professor Maitreesh Ghatak who teach economics in LSE says in today's FE that:

  • “…where property titles are ill-defined, where legal disputes takes decades to settle, where poor farmers or small businessmen face eviction threats, it is difficult to imagine how they can behave like textbook economic agents, namely, taking a long-run view, saving, investing, and climbing their ways out of poverty. Security of property rights therefore is of utmost importance. 
  • The term property right refers to an owner’s right to use a good or asset for consumption and/or income generation (referred to as “use rights”). This can also include the right to transfer it to another party, in the form of a sale, gift or bequest (referred to as “transfer rights”). A property right also typically conveys the right to contract with other parties by renting, pledging, or mortgaging a good or asset, or by allowing other parties to use it, for example, in an employment relationship. 
  • By property rights, economists typically refer to private property rights, a key feature of which is being able to legally exclude others from using a good or asset. This affects resource allocation by shaping the incentives of individuals to carry out productive activities involving the use of the good or asset, undertake investments that maintain or enhance its value, and also, to trade or lease it for other uses.”

Tuesday, February 24, 2009

Proper Property right under rule of law is the solution to prevent future financial crisis

Yes Proper Property is the solution to prevent future financial crisis says Peruvian economist Hernando de Soto in the newsweek article. 

See some of those interesting discussion. 

  • “This poisonous paper is scaring off potential creditors and investors who lack the legal means to understand what this paper signifies, how much there is, who has it and who might be a bad risk. Finally, policymakers in the White House seem to be coming to grips with the real enemy: the debasement of the legal financial documents that represent value, allow it to be transferred and signal risk. 
  • You are able to hold, transfer, assess and certify the value of such assets only through documents that have been legally authenticated by a global system of rules, procedures and standards. Ensuring that the relationship between those documents and each of the independent assets they represent is never debased requires a formidable system of legal property rights. That system produces the trust that allows credit and capital to flow and markets to work. 
  • In recent years, governments have debased paper by carelessly allowing into the market a biblical flood of financial instruments derived from bad mortgages nominally valued at some $600 trillion or more—twice as much as all the rest of the world's legal paper, whether it represents cash, traditional financial assets, or property, tangible or intangible. 
  • The main challenge for Obama and Geithner is to restore trust in the prime vehicle of credit—not money, which we know how to control, but paper, which we clearly don't. The overwhelming amount of available credit is made up of proprietary paper, such as mortgages, bonds and derivatives, all of which is not money per se but has some of the financial attributes of money—what economists used to call "moneyness." To prevent the debasement of paper and adequately infer its value, the Obama administration must turn to well-tested rules ensuring paper's credibility. 
  • Moreover, every financial deal must be tethered to the real performance of the originating asset, ensuring that the amount of debt secured on the basis of assets does not become dangerously "out of scale" with those assets underlying the debt—the most prominent cause of a recession, according to the economist John Kenneth Galbraith. And assets can continue to be leveraged and repackaged—but only to improve the value of the original asset. Finally, it must be recognized that clarity and precision are indispensable for creating credit and capital through paper. 
  • Still another challenge to Obama is that many of those involved in resolving the crisis now claim that it is virtually impossible to identify and value all the toxic paper now on the financial institutions' books. Yet in the past U.S. and European lawyers and bureaucrats have proved brilliant at sorting out toxic paper whether it referred to bad debt, confusing claims or opaque legislation. In doing so, they have untangled claims after the California gold rush, picked up the pieces of Europe's crumbling precapitalist order, converted Japan's feudal enclaves into a market economy after World War II and reunified Germany after the fall of the Berlin Wall. That's the process of capitalism: continuous detoxification. And we're hard at it today, too, in developing countries, searching for toxic paper in our shadow econ-omies—informal titles, licenses, contracts, laundered money and identity documents —in an effort to bring their people into the mainstream”.  

"What does the fish know about the water in which it swims?"

There is interesting Peruvian economist Hernando de Soto interview in the Newsweek. The following are some of those: 

  • “How does this relate to the financial crisis? 
  • The enormous amount of derivatives that had poured into the market—there are close to $600 trillion of these papers around—are also not recorded in a global or centralized manner, or in a manner that allows you to begin to quantify them. [Former SEC Chairman Christopher] Cox thought that maybe the toxic part of all of these assets was $1 trillion to $2 trillion. [Treasury Secretary Timothy] Geithner told us there's maybe $3 trillion or $4 trillion. Nobody really knows, so in a way [they've created an] informal or shadow economy. This unidentified paper is the source of uncertainty and the credit contraction. 
  • Has the subprime mortgage market become a shadow economy? 
  • Subprime mortgages are not a shadow economy. But what happened is that a lot of these mortgages got repackaged into securities. Then they became collateralized debt obligations and some of these mortgages were sliced and diced and put into tranches. When some of these mortgages went sour and people started defaulting on their payments, then of course a lot of the securities tied to them also started defaulting. But when you try and trace who's ultimately responsible for the value of that paper, you couldn't find it. That's the part of the market that has become the shadow. 
  • So basically ill-defined property rights in the subprime mortgage sector caused a meltdown. Does the same happen in the developing world? 
  • Yes. That shadow hopefully is a temporary condition in the United States and in Western Europe. And it might pass in a year or 10 years, but it will pass. That passing condition that's occurring now in developed countries, that's a chronic condition in developing countries. We're always chronically in credit crunches—because you don't know who owns what, nobody dares lend to somebody else. Bringing the law to emerging markets is possibly the most important measure that can be taken to help these countries become rich. Look at the Iranians, look at the North Koreans—they're building nuclear plants. Look at the computer—they're being built in northern India. The issue isn't the expansion of technology. We can all get it, borrow it, buy it or steal it. The issue is how do you get a legal system that allows people to cooperate so as to create more complex systems and objects. 
  • So at this point, a Wall Street banker in a $10,000 suit is encountering basically the same problem that Nairobi slum dwellers have had to deal with for decades or more. 
  • Absolutely. The difference, however, is that in Nairobi they are still struggling to understand that a property system is the best way that they can do things. In the United States, every piece of land, every house, every automobile, every airplane, every manuscript for a film, every patent is written up and recorded and described. There's only one thing in the United States which is not recorded in such a way and that's derivatives. We're only talking about 7 percent of the subprime market being in default, yet it is causing a major contraction in your economy. You're not getting your credit flowing because you don't know what is where and who it belongs to.
  • What's the answer? How do we assign "property rights" to derivatives? 
  • The banks and the holders of all of these instruments have got to report them in such a way that your government and the public knows who owns what and where. Once the light shines, you will know who's solvent, who's insolvent. You'll be able to have a clean debate as to who to help and who not to help. And you're going to have a much better idea of the consequences of not helping or helping. Right now you're talking about all of those issues, but you still don't have the facts. So the first thing is to have the law require those people who own these things to fess up”.