Showing posts with label Rule of Law. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rule of Law. Show all posts

Monday, January 13, 2020

The path to Dharma AND path of Adharma

The most critical aspects of humanity facing ever since the human common senses are used purposefully for bettering are two things which also often get infuriated or fanatical in the public debates all over the world: these are religion and the ideology of politics.

I write this post after reading a small article by a senior advocate R Venkataraman who has such an amazing skills to put down the complex things into a clear and lucid manner.

Sometime back, he wrote a article on senior advocate's legal skills and the impact of certain principles of religion in his arguments of cases in court for decades. 

I find some of the his lines of thoughts most interesting and compelling to read and read again to ponder and understand the meaning of the words (m)used by R Venkataraman.

The following are some of the excerpts from the article:

"Religious philosophy is neither caste specific nor gender biased. It only imparts the transformative process to every human being, from the path of Adharma to the path of Dharma. Like Adharma which has universal belonging, the opposite of it namely Dharma has universal application and is relevant in law. The core of Dharma is free from both gender and caste discrimination.Self realisation or emancipation is again free from the clutches of either caste or gender sensitivity.

It is critical to look at religious philosophy as one that is broad-based in its practice and classifies human attitudes on the basis of Dharma and Adharma.....

It is important to remember that religious philosophy is concerned only about Dharma and Adharma and prescribes the method without any favor or bias towards any class or gender."

  

Friday, November 22, 2019

Economics of Patterns

Kapil Viswanathan has good piece in Livemint on economics of modern vs traditional. Some excerpts:



"Friedrich von Hayek, the Nobel prize-winning economist, believed that there are no laws in economics; only patterns, and we must learn to recognize these. Doing so involves breaking away from a Newtonian mindset of definitive and predictive models and equilibria, and approaching the study of economics from a fundamentally different perspective."

"As Hayek advises, we must attempt not to shape results as a craftsman shapes his handiwork, but rather to cultivate growth by providing the appropriate environment, as a gardener does for plants."

Monday, July 21, 2014

Some good reading

How a corrupt Judge continued in the Madras High Court-"Katju’s story, three CJIs were complicit in continuing, confirming and promoting an allegedly corrupt judge"

NGO mania in India: "Between 1993 and 2012, the number of registered associations (NGOs) rose from 15,039 to over 41,844, but through all these years only 54 per cent to 64 per cent filed details of foreign remittances received. In 2011-12, 16,756 had not filed returns. Those that did had receipts climbing from Rs 1,865 crore to Rs 11,548 crore. The principal donors in 2011-12 were from the United States of America, Germany, the United Kingdom, Italy, Spain and the Netherlands. "

About 53% of AIIMS graduates actually leave the country, most permanently, and you cannot really point a finger at them

Sunday, October 27, 2013

"I have charted a different course, sir"

In any literature, the most interesting area is (auto)biography. In that order, the second most interesting is a narrative like this one by Mr.Prasad in today's The Pioneer.

There is a lot to say on how Mr.Prasad has charted a different course. The Hayek's two types of individual has some answer to it.

Other useful reading:




Friday, April 26, 2013

Some links

"India is a vibrant democracy, and as the economic system failed the economically weak, the political system tried to compensate."

Why we still need to read Hayek: Hayek Lecture at Duck by Professor John B Taylor

"He doesn’t want the odium of polarized votes to overshadow his development and governance agenda. At best it should be a collateral benefit. He is smart enough, certainly, to know that young Indians, while deeply religious themselves, have moved beyond wanting to see religion used as a political tool."

"Learned Hand once wrote something that seems like an apt description of the wider context: "A community is already in the process of dissolution where each man begins to eye his neighbour as a possible enemy, where non-conformity is a mark of disaffection, where denunciation, without specification or backing takes place of evidence, where orthodoxy chokes freedom of dissent, and where faith in the eventual supremacy of reason has become so timid that we dare not enter our convictions in open lists." More here.

“He must be prepared to speak about everything, and often about nothing. He is expected to preserve temples, to keep the currency steady, to satisfy third-class passengers, to patronise race meetings, to make Bombay and Calcutta each think that it is the Capital city of India, and to purify the police… If he does not reform everything that is wrong, he is told that he is doing too little, if he reforms anything at all, that he is doing too much.

Saturday, March 16, 2013

Week end reading

The more and more I read articles like this I feel that I should reread the beautiful book The Law by Bastiat.


  • Shastri saw that clearly when he took charge of the country after Nehru. Nayar says Shastri was never a big votary of planning. P.N. Dhar, one of the best policy minds of his generation and later a close adviser to Indira Gandhi, pointed out in Indira Gandhi, the ‘Emergency’ And Indian Democracy, his memoir: “Lal Bahadur Shastri, the unassuming prime minister who had succeeded the charismatic Nehru, seemed an unlikely person to face up to the (economic) situation. But in his own quiet way he did initiate a series of steps which would have not only brought the economy out of the existing crisis but possibly put it on a high-growth path in the long run. He wore no ideological blinkers; he saw facts as they were in all their starkness. Chronic food shortages made him shift investment from basic industries to agriculture. Roaring black markets persuaded him to make a relative shift from controls to incentives, and the glaring inefficiency of the public sector made him accept a larger role for the private sector and foreign investment. He also took measures to shift the locus of economic decision-making from the Planning Commission to the ministries and from the Centre to the states. These measures reduced the influence of the Planning Commission—which had developed a rigid, almost doctrinaire outlook on economic policies—and at the same time decentralized decision-making.”

Thursday, March 7, 2013

End of law-OLD Draft


  • “The attitude of the British towards India’s claim for freedom has since the Mutiny of 1857 undergone a complete change. There was a time when the British government held the view which was a complete negation of India’s claim for freedom. It was proclaimed by Lawrence whose statue in Calcutta has the motto: ‘The British conquered India by the sword and they will hold it by the sword.’ This attitude is dead and buried and it is no exaggeration to say that every Englishman today is ashamed of it. This stage was followed by another in which the argument of the British government against India’s freedom was the alleged incapacity of Indians for parliamentary institutions. It began with Lord Ripon’s regime which was followed by an attempt to give political training to Indians, first in the field of Local Self-Government, and then under the Montagu-Chelmsford reforms in the field of Provincial Government. We have now entered the third or the present stage. The British government is now ashamed to say that they will hold India by the sword. It no longer says that Indians have no capacity to run parliamentary institutions. The British government admits India’s right to freedom, even to independence, if Indians so desire. The British government admits the right of Indians to frame their own Constitution. There can be no greater proof of this new angle of vision than the Cripps Proposals. The condition precedent laid down by the British government for India’s freedom is that Indians must produce a Constitution which has the concurrence of the important elements in the national life of the country. Such is the state we have reached [in 1946].” (What Congress and Gandhi did to the Untouchables; Thacker; 1946; page 177).

Sunday, March 25, 2012

Another vote motive

The imbecile is talking about striking balance of federalism in India. Why can't the Union Government better manage the national security first and leave all else to State Governments?

The DNA newspaper chief editor Mr Aditya says, rightly, that:
  • "No governance means that citizens will be spared large social expenditures such as the farmers’ loan waiver or the proposed food security bill or other such plans which are basically meant to bribe a section of voters. No governance means that we will not suffer crony capitalism such as the gifting away of land or coal or gas or other natural resources to big industrialists in an opaque and suspect manner. No governance means less chance of a scam, now that everyone is breathing down the government’s neck, ready to whip out a draft CAG report when there’s a whiff of graft or pestering it for a Lokpal bill."

Saturday, March 24, 2012

Self-Talk at travel and land of M K Gandhi

If I was asked to go by sarker Airline I felt every time how I am going to manage the shoddy people who continues to behave "mai baab sarker" while serving the customer. This was greatly cooled by two beautiful kids (less than 6 year old) during my recent visit to Hyderabad. These kids were asking all kinds of nice questions.

Another painstaking journey, yet again by sarkar airline today morning. Unlike my usual practice of self musing, I was not really  musing myself on anything. In fact, I had forgotten the fact that I am coming after 6 years to the land of the great man who was born on this land and lifted the ignorance of world masses.

Quite surprisingly, how the time takes me to places where I have been put up today! I was not determined to write this blog from such a important place any time soon or my life time at all. Yes, I am writing this from the very place where the great Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi faced the trial of sedition in the Central Hall of the Government Circuit House at Ahmedabad on the 18th of March in 1922 under "section 124A of the Indian Penal Code" and and sentenced to six years' imprisonment. Read the full story from here. From today's context the relevant of sedition and need for reform.

Tuesday, September 27, 2011

Consultants for Courts in Jharkhand

There is a news which says;

"Jharkhand High Court has moved to appoint 24 professionally qualified court managers — armed with B-school degrees in management and IT systems — to reduce the tottering backlog of cases."

Saturday, June 25, 2011

The land saga of Singur and Poletown


“Private property is an essential concept in market-driven economies. Therefore, one must have a solid argument that demonstrates how the objectives of a market economy can be better served if private property rights are suspended. While there exist sound theoretical arguments to support the involuntary transfer of private ownership to public ownership in the construction of, say, public goods, there are no sound arguments for the government forcing a private party to give up land to another private entity. In other words, there is no reason for the government to act as a non-market intermediary in what is an essentially private transaction in the land market.

It is now up to us to come up with a land acquisition policy that is consistent with a market economy and the principles originally enshrined in our Constitution.”

See for full article here.

Friday, February 4, 2011

Dividendnomics


From Nitin’s new fortnightly column in DNA: 
  • Dilip Rao, a blogger at Law and Other Things, found a Freakonomics-like correlation between birth rates and terrorism in some states. He notes that a spurt in birth rates in the early 1970s in Punjab and Jammu & Kashmir meant that there was a youth bulge available in the 1980s to answer the separatists’ call. We can trace back the rise of terrorist violence in these states to Operation Blue Star or the rigged 1987 state election, we can prove that Pakistan used these conflicts to conduct proxy war, but Heinsohn goes to the extreme to argue that the cause itself is immaterial - if there is a youth bulge, it will be accompanied by violence. 

  • While these studies do not indicate or claim a definitive causal link, the data are sufficient for us to regard youth bulge violence as a long-term risk to national security. Going by the National Commission on Population’s projections to the year 2026, Uttar Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh and Delhi will experience a net increase in young people. The 15-24 cohort will grow in Bihar, Assam, Haryana, Uttarakhand, Jammu & Kashmir, Maharashtra, Jharkhand, and Gujarat. States that cannot both reduce grievances and create enough opportunities are likely to get into trouble. 

  • The best way to minimise grievances is not by pandering to them individually, but by delivering overall good governance. The politics of entitlement that the UPA government seeks to make respectable under the veneer of “inclusive growth” breeds more grievances for every entitlement. These are already expressed through the idiom of competitive intolerance and coercive violence. While they must be rolled back, those politically opposed to the Congress must do so without themselves creating and appealing to grievances.

Wednesday, February 2, 2011

Getting polluted for power


It sounds big when Mr.Kiran asks: 
  • Why, the writers might enquire, is technology not being used to ensure an efficient and transparent transfer of funds to the beneficiaries, as also to streamline the public distribution system for food grain? Why is our world-beating IT industry's expertise not being more extensively used to first reengineer and then make cost-effective the systems and processes connected with governance, healthcare, law enforcement, traffic management, etc?  

But the reason of his mind goes all the way to square one which is nothing but the absolute power hunter in the business cum politics in local and global. See what he said in the same column: 
  • The letter might reiterate the collective aspiration of a happy, healthy, caring and compassionate society, with equality of opportunity and social justice. It would ask whether present policies are attuned to this goal, and urge that the right to good health and right to food be enacted as laws, along with a universal right to livelihood (as a progression from right to work). It would condemn the illegal campaign of intimidation against human rights activists, demand the release of Binayak Sen and an end to state-sponsored, private, armed gangsters who are only spurring an escalating cycle of violence. 

Tuesday, December 21, 2010

Clean up or perish should be the message

 Mr.Rekhy is one of the finest human beings. I had brief opportunity to work with him some years ago.

From Good governance creates value By Richard Rekhy


  • While liberalisation paved the way for India’s success story, the cue was picked up by the corporate world and it is private enterprise and corporate leadership that has steered India towards this growth. Corporate India understands the importance of governance. Well-governed companies have always got better valuations and have inspired other entrepreneurs to follow in their footsteps. Maybe, it is time for corporate India to lead the way and infuse the country with good governance practices. Clean up or perish should be the message. Companies sho­uld make it clear through policy and action that there is zero tolerance to fraud and corruption. Let us not blame the eco system of this country for fraud and corruption to exist and thrive. There are many examples of ethical and well- governed companies in India that we can learn from.

  • Governance is a state of mind, it does not need rules and regulations. While regulation and law can assist governance, the place we in India have to get to is where we follow governance in every walk of life; and ethics penetrate the heart and soul of every action that we take. As we end the year 2010, let us hope that India will move towards a culture of good governance and that the government will recognise that it will fail in its mission to build India into an economic powerhouse unless it lays down a strong foundation of ethics and values and de­monstrates that through action. What we need is enforcement and examples of the guilty being given appropriate punishment for their crimes.

Wednesday, November 24, 2010

“It appears that not all these laws have had the intended good effects that we would like to see on the ground”

India’s Prime Minister say's (I don’t know to whom he ask these questions, whether it is for Labour Minister etc,.)

  • ……..we have enacted several progressive labour laws since independence and some even before that. But it appears that not all these laws have had the intended good effects that we would like to see on the ground. We need to consider the possible role of some of our labour laws in contributing to rigidities in the labour market which hurt the growth of employment on a large scale. Is it possible that our best intentions for labour are not actually met by laws that sound progressive on paper but end up hurting the very workers they are meant to protect? Do we have empirical evidence on the changing nature of employment generation with changes in labour legislation, not just in our own country but in the neighbourhood as well? If we want to draw more and more workers into the organized sector where they can claim the benefits that currently cover such a very small proportion of our labour force, do we need to rethink the nature of the laws that enforce such benefits?

Friday, November 19, 2010

Virtue of individual right

In an interview to ET Janata Party president Subramanian Swamy said:


After all, rights of the individuals have to be protected. Governments are not known anywhere in the world to be responsive to an individual’s rights. It’s the courts which sanctify the rights of the people...

Tuesday, October 26, 2010

Promote migration

Apoorva from the American Enterprise Institute, Washington DC. Writes:

  • Kerala has the fourth highest level of private health expenditures in the country - more than 86 per cent of total per capita healthcare spending in Kerala is conducted in private institutions. Consider also the massive impact of migration on the state. Yes, Kerala has outpaced Gujarat in economic growth over the last several years, but this has been driven completely by remittances, which made up more than 20 per cent of the state's income in 2007. Indeed, Keralites simply voted with their feet, travelling abroad for the economic opportunity they lacked at home.

Tuesday, September 14, 2010

Law that does not matter

Bihar’s Dy CM said in an interview to TOI:

Has your government turned Bihar's economy around?


  • Ours has been a major achievement in road, health and education sectors. Good law and order is a sine qua non for turning around an economy. That's because no industrialist, realtor, contractor, service provider or farmer can work in a place that is infamous for crime. Bihar was like that before we came to power. We ensured the conviction of 50,000 criminals through speedy trials and now the law and order situation is there for everyone to see. Families can be seen watching night (film) shows, which was unthinkable during the 15 years of Laluji's jungle raj.

  • Also, yo u need manpower to execute development projects. When we assumed power, there were no doctors, teachers, block development officers or circle officers, because appointments were not made during the preceding 15 years. We appointed 4.3 lakh people. The process of giving jobs to another 1.7 lakh would be completed by the time we complete our term in November. For the first time in the last two decades, you can find one BDO and one CO in every block of the state.


Monday, July 19, 2010

Dig that court, not that Supreme


If the Supreme Courte of India lies, what you do?


Certainly you should not hang yourself in the nearest lamp post like it continuously doing with the word “socialism” in the name of “nothingness”.


Bibek Debroy has a nice piece exploring the “nothingness of socialism”:


  • But for the Preamble, we wouldn’t have had Section 29-A of Representation of the People Act, 1951, inserted in 1989, specifically Clause (5), requiring the political party to abide by “principles of socialism”. This would have been understandable in 1976. In 1989, the year in which the Berlin Wall collapsed (effectively, so did the Soviet system), this socialism bit in Clause (5) probably got inserted without a great deal of thought, because of the other elements of Section 29-A. Hence, a political party has to be “socialist” for it to be registered.

  • The NGO Good Governance Foundation rightly challenged this — that is, challenged both amended Preamble and Section 29-A(5). In 2008, the Supreme Court ducked. It allowed the challenge to Section 29-A(5), but not the Preamble. Now, on the challenge to Section 29-A(5), the Supreme Court has ducked again, calling the issue “academic and hypothetical”. Why is it academic and hypothetical? Because no registered political party has refused to swear allegiance to socialism? And because the Election Commission (EC) hasn’t so far refused registration to a proposed political party on grounds of non-adherence to socialism. Let that situation crop up, and then we (the Supreme Court) shall see.