Showing posts with label Indian or Indian Orgin Winners of Nobel Prize. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Indian or Indian Orgin Winners of Nobel Prize. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 21, 2010

Tips from Nobel laureate-Venkatraman Ramakrishnan


Top to bottom

  • “There is no magic formula for winning the Nobel Prize” 
  • “If India wins a single Nobel Prize it does not mean Indian science is okay” 
  • “Don’t work on anything that you’re not interested in — day-to-day science is extremely tedious,” 
  • “If you don’t gossip about the problem, then you’re not really interested in it. It’s (got to be) something you can’t help talking about. The problem has to be bugging you when you have a coffee” 
  • “Also aim to go to the best place for your work,” 
  • “You can change fields with humility, 
  • “It’s a paradox that the biggest benefits of science to humanity have come from the fundamental science problems”


What one did not say has already been said about another Nobel Laureate in Economics science:

“And unlike that imposter Amartya Sen, this is the real deal. Ladies & Gentlemen, Professor Dixit”

Saturday, November 13, 2010

Chandra vs Chandra

  • Today, the astrophysicist, Subramaniam Chandrasekhar (Chandra) seems an almost distant and iconic figure. He is the stuff of legend, and unfortunately his family and friends have stuffed it further. He almost sounds like a theorem-formal, elegant and unapproachable.

  • Chandra was generous. The astronomer Arthur Eddington’s opposition to his ideas virtually destroyed his career. It took several decades of research to vindicate him. I remember asking him with my political impetuousness, was Eddington a racist? Chandra looked shocked at the idea. Eddington was still the great Eddington. He might have forced him into virtual exile but Chandra immaculately correct, treated it as a difference of two scholars.

  • Chandra was a nationalist but I think he had a little sense of politics beyond that. He read controversies in an almost antiseptic way which was revealing. Asked about Satyam Bose, Chandra claimed he was brilliant. But then added, “when Einstein snubbed him, he retreated.” Bose had one flash of insight and he then added, “it takes two to make a genius”. He felt a sense of wonder and sadness about that early generation of scientists.

(From Remembering Chandra by Shiv Visvanathan)

Wednesday, January 6, 2010

“Hills Road 6 form student wins Nobel Prize.”

Venkatraman Ramakrishnan said in his interview to Indian Express Walk The Talk:

Shekhar Gupta: Science is a good beginning. I’m happy to say that about myself — I’m from a generation of musicians forced to study science.
  • Venkatraman Ramakrishnan: My feeling is that even if you are not a scientist you really should have a certain minimum education in science because we live in a highly technical society. How do you know that the right decisions are being made by your government or people around you? We talk about pollution or global warming. How can you even judge if these things are meaningful or not? If you have a fundamental background in science even at the high school level, it does help you come to grips with the problem instead of taking someone’s word for it.

Wednesday, October 28, 2009

Nationalism and state processes are never evidence based

B Ashok says:

  • ....Science seeks truth; nationalism is about perceived justice. Nationalism and state processes are never evidence based. Nationalism satisfies without explaining, provokes without deep thought. So the power-hungry manipulate it.
  • We are discomfited by Ramakrishnan’s refusal to be celebrated. The truth is, he has done us a great service. His gentle advice that we should show interest in his work, not his person, demonstrates robust scientific fundamentals. Self-seekers amongst us wouldn’t mind appropriating and iconising him as a fig leaf for our collective failures. Rejecting this make-believe, he has indicated that science should transcend politics. His message – ‘leave me alone and serve science’ – has been more important than his moment of glory at Stockholm.

Read also

A Nobel face in the Indian crowd

Tuesday, October 27, 2009

Values revere syndrome

Chetan on “Where's My Nobel Prize?”- “people designing the system never took talent into account.”

T C A on “Sick men of Asia and the West”- “the EU has deliberately chosen not to have a central government which would soon become dysfunctional, we have started with one and then made it dysfunctional by paralysing it neck upwards politically because of electoral considerations and neck downwards administratively because, as Arun Shourie pointed out, even a section officer can veto a proposal and any joint secretary can sabotage a Cabinet decision.”

Tuesday, October 20, 2009

Success has many fathers while failure is an orphan.

EQ versus IQ


Ramakrishnan is reported to have expressed disgust at the outpouring of fan mail received by him from India, especially from Tamil Nadu, after the conferment of the Nobel. On two issues, his anger is understandable, though perhaps expressed at the wrong time, the wrong place and in the wrong manner. He may be right in pointing out that several teachers have suddenly discovered him as their student in his school/college days in India, while he remembers none of them. Secondly, he has expressed resentment at being contacted by persons who had chosen to ignore him for decades but started expressing new-found love after the Nobel win.

Both sentiments are understandable, may even be justifiable, though Ramakrishnan can scarcely believed to be innocent of the universal creed and global phenomenon, not at all peculiar to India, that success has many fathers while failure is an orphan. That this universal phenomenon should surprise Ramakrishnan is surprising. He would surely have encountered enough of it in the American and European cultures in which he has worked for decades to not treat it as uniquely Indian, as his observations suggest.

But these parts of his statement are not the subject of this critique. What is deplorable is Ramakrishnan's equation and linkage of something as lofty and noble as patriotism and nationalism with something as banal and ridiculous as the clogging of his e-mail accounts and a general disgust at being troubled by his countrymen. When a Rajasthani, or a fellow citizen from Jodhpur, gets an outstanding international award, i feel a wee bit extra joy and exhilaration than my other Indian compatriots, because i was born in Jodhpur and hail from Rajasthan.

When an Indian gets a prestigious global award, all Indians feel proud, and even jingoistic, whereas the same award to a foreigner is merely another statistic in a newspaper. This is not to suggest that we are, or i am, casteist, regional or practising false nationalism. Patriotism can be distorted and misused as the "refuge of the scoundrel" but, at its core, it has an intersection of noble values which, in this case, appear to have completely escaped the mind of a brilliant Nobel laureate.

These are the values of link and affinity with a culture, a people, a territory and a national identity. It is this sentiment alone which connects India and Indians, despite this country being the greatest aggregation of diversities on this planet.

Yes, Mr Ramakrishnan, the place and nation of your birth may be "accidents of history", as you put it, but you are woefully and grievously wrong to suppose that the overwhelming tidal wave of affection for you from fellow Tamilians and Indians can be seen or explained merely as an accident of history. Your comments illustrate not merely an absence of EQ but the arrogance of relative youthfulness and an assumption that you can see and analyse everything from the mind while deadening your heart. I can wager a bet that when you grow old (maybe over 75 by western standards, but 65 by Indian standards), you will hark back and hanker for the peace, tranquillity and cultural affinity of the same Chidambaram town, whose eulogising e-mails you are currently castigating.

The writer is an MP and national spokesperson of the Congress party.

Friday, October 16, 2009

Nobel laureate Venki Ramakrishnan and India

The following write-up is published in today’s TOI in which Nobel laureate Venki Ramakrishnan clarifies certain issues like mass e-mails, misunderstanding of the notion of “nationality being an accident of birth” etc.

A little less nationalistic hero worship, please

16 October 2009, 04:15am IST, Times of India

  • I am distressed by the reaction to my comment about being deluged by emails from India, and realize I have inadvertently hurt people, for which I apologize. I hope people realize that I have no personal secretary and use my email mainly for work, so finding important communications became very difficult.
  • I want to make it clear that I was delighted to hear from scientific colleagues and students whom I had met personally over the years in India and elsewhere, as well as close friends with whom I had lost touch. Unlike real celebrities like movie stars or people in sports, we scientists generally lead a quiet life, and are not psychologically equipped to handle publicity. So I found the barrage of emails from people whom I didn’t know or whom I only knew slightly almost 40 years ago (nearly all from Indians) difficult to deal with.
  • People have also taken offence at my comment about nationality being an accident of birth. However, they don’t seem to notice the first part of the sentence: We are all human beings. Accident or not, I remain grateful to all the dedicated teachers I had throughout my years. Others have said I have disowned my roots.
  • Since 2002, I have come almost every year to India. In these visits, I have spent time on institute campuses giving lectures or talking to colleagues and students about their work, and stayed in the campus guest house. I have not spent my time staying in fancy hotels and going sightseeing without them. The people I visited, e.g. at the ICGEB in Delhi, CCMB in Hyderabad, the University of Madras or the IISc in Bangalore can vouch for this. Finally, at a personal level, although I am westernized, many aspects of culture like a love for classical Indian music or South Indian or Gujarati food are simply a part of me.
  • The best way to take pleasure in someone’s achievement is to take an interest in their work and feel motivated to learn more about science. I remember reading about Gellman’s work as an undergraduate in Baroda, and, when he won the Nobel prize, rushing upstairs to tell my parents. It did not matter to me whether he was Indian or not. In my case, I am lucky to have had a combination of education, opportunities and a great team of co-workers to have made a contribution to an important problem. I am not personally that important. If I hadn’t existed, this work would still have been done. It is the work that is important, and that should be what excites people.
  • Finally, there are many excellent scientists in India and elsewhere who will never win a Nobel prize. But their work is no less interesting and people should find out about what they do. My visits to India confirm that it has great potential and bright young students. A little less nationalistic hero worship will go a long way to fulfil that potential.

Thursday, October 8, 2009

Indian or Indian-origin winners of Nobel prize

The below table and the information compiled below the table is from TOI here.

Winner

Year

Area

Work

Rabindranath Tagore

1913

Literature

Gitanjali, a collection of poems, described as “profoundly sensitive, fresh and beautiful verse”

Chandrasekhara Venkata Raman

1930

Physics

Discovery of “inelastic scattering of light”, named Raman effect after him

Hargobind Khorana

1968

Medicine

Interpretation of the genetic code and its function in protein synthesis. He shared the prize with Robert W Holley and Marshall Warren Nirenberg

Mother Teresa

1979

Peace

The Albanian-born nun, who made India her home, won the prize for "work undertaken in the struggle to overcome poverty and distress, which also constitutes a threat to peace".

Subramanian Chandrasekhar

1983

Physics

Theoretical structure and evolution of stars. He shared the prize with William Alfred Fowler

Amartya Sen

1998

Economics

Welfare economics

Venkatraman Ramakrishnan

2009

Chemistry

Mapping ribosomes, the protein-producing factories within cells, at the atomic level. He shares the prize with Thomas Steitz and Ada Yonath.

India’s other Nobel connections:

  • In 2007, the UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change headed by India’s R K Pachauri shared the Nobel prize in peace with Al Gore.
  • V S Naipaul, Trinidad-born British writer of Indian origin, won the Nobel prize in literature in 2001.
  • Abdus Salam, born in undivided Punjab and a citizen of Pakistan, shared the Nobel prize in physics in 1979 with Steven Weinberg for his work on electroweak unification, one of the important puzzles of modern theoretical physics.
  • British author Rudyard Kipling, born in Bombay (now Mumbai) in 1865, won the Nobel prize in literature in 1907.
  • Ronald Ross, born in Almora, Uttarakhand, in 1857 was awarded the Nobel prize in medicine in 1902 for his work on malaria. He was a British citizen.