Showing posts with label Arvind Panagariya. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Arvind Panagariya. Show all posts

Saturday, May 3, 2025

The World Trade is in Turmoil

World Trade Economics are yet again at cross road historically. Students of economics have exciting learning curve at this juncture.

Also, the world trade and globalization are changing its operations models.

The New President of USA, Donald Trump’s policies especially the trade policies are causing greater impacts on most countries which do exports and import of goods and services.

Eminent Trade Economist Dr Arvind Panagariya has expressed his views, though his views give basic ideas how the USA intend to play given their economy vis.a.vis other economy like China, India, etc.

Below are links to Prof Arvind Panagariya interviews:

Arvind Panagariya: US deal will be a big positive for India

With Trump’s new tariff order, Arvind Panagariya highlights key trade risks for India

Arvind Panagariya on Trump and International Trade


Tuesday, July 30, 2013

Indian Economists and Economics

Dr.Ashok V Desai has written a great article on how some of the great economists studied, worked and made impact on Indian economics over the years. Every one who is interested in Indian economics should read the article.

Prof Panagariya has also given us very timely interview in IE, wherein he says very perceptively that "From the beginning, the Left has been pretty strong in India, intellectually. The kind of Right that exists in other parts of the world, like Thatcherite or Reaganite, doesn't even exist in our system. All of us are by that measure left-of-centre." 

Wednesday, April 17, 2013

"The bloated and suffocating socialist model"


Interesting book review:
  • "Joseph Stiglitz, Belgian-born Jean Drèze and Harvard's Amartya Sen, for being "intellectually lazy and unwilling to learn from the ruin they had visited on India and its poor."
  • "Between 1965 and 1975, per capita income in India rose by a minuscule 0.3% annually. If you were to draw up a list of post-colonial leaders responsible for economic crimes against their people, Indira Gandhi's name would figure near the top. By one Cato Institute estimate, India would have had 175 million fewer poor people by 2008 had it embarked upon reforms in 1971 instead of 1991."



Sunday, September 16, 2012

Thankless Polity

Indian economists especially the one who is leaning towards Congress by default don't tell us their heartless-gut-feelings. However, here is one such good belief:

From Professor Arvind Panagariya interview:
  • … even the minority governments of IK Gujral and HD Deve Gowda were much better than the UPA. So this whole idea that coalition doesn’t let you do reforms is an eyewash. The larger problem is sitting within the Congress party. A lot of the Congress men don’t want reforms. Congress leadership today is extremely sceptical of reforms. And of course their coalition is extremely mismanaged.
  • …even the BJP did not do the nation a service by forcing Sonia Gandhi to appoint Manmohan Singh as the PM.                                              

Excerpts from Gurcharan Das’s latest book titled IndiaGrows at Night: A Liberal Case for Strong State.
  • Merchants and bazaars, however, emerged even earlier as centres of exchange in the towns of the Indus Valley (3300–1500 BCE) or even in the Neolithic age, soon after Indians first engaged in agriculture and there was a surplus. As Jean-Jacques Rousseau has taught us, inequality also had its origins with the birth of agriculture because with it was born private property.
Tavleen Singh point out that the:
  • "..truth about the incalculable losses made in our socialist decades by a public sector that almost never made a profit."





Saturday, June 30, 2012

Interesting reading

Bibek Debroy on "We stupid brutes": "I have some money in my wallet.  A thief comes along and steals some of it.  For most people, the reaction should be one of anger.  The anger should remain, even if it is somewhat muted, if the thief explains this theft has been done because that money has to be donated to the poor.  This is not as bizarre a metaphor as one might think, because that’s precisely what has happened since 2004." 


Niranjan Rajadhyaksha on "Returing to the age of Ranade": "The quest to build a modern India began in those decades, and the early university graduates and progressive rulers such as Sayajirao were umbilically linked to this quest. India in the last decades of the 19th century was akin to Europe in the years of the Renaissance— rediscovering its roots as well as yearning for a modern future."


Anjuli on "Hold them accountable": Why is this a big deal? After all, any corporate hospital offers the same facility. The big deal is that one, the facility at Gudiyattam is free (private hospitals, on the other hand, charge a hefty fee). Two, the facility is available across 220 government hospitals and the same unique registration number can be used at any one of these to access a patient’s medical records.

Arvind Panagariya on "A forgotten revolutionary": "We are determined to address the problems of the economy in a decisive manner," Rao said in his stoic voice. "This government is committed to removing the cobwebs that come in the way of rapid industrialisation. We will work towards making India internationally competitive, taking full advantage of...opportunities offered by the evolving global economy...We also welcome foreign direct investment so as to accelerate the tempo of development, upgrade our technologies and to promote our exports. Obstacles that come in the way of allocating foreign investment on a sizable scale will be removed. A time-bound programme will be worked out to streamline our industrial policies and programmes to achieve the goal of a vibrant economy that rewards creativity, enterprise and innovativeness." 

Monday, January 2, 2012

Blinking links


Interesting readings on Indian political economy:

The year of living angrily by Prof Ashutosh Varshney


Reforms and the great divide by Yashwant Sinha

Par for the course by TC A Srinivasa Raghavan

Cracking the kerala myth by Prof Arvind Panagariya

Why one should give some credit to Dr Singh for telling the truths of socialist era of India? Read his address to the nation on the eve of New Year.

Thursday, June 30, 2011

The confused left during this choices and competition era

“The left critics could never figure how to deal with Suresh as an unwavering advocate of economic reforms. So beyond reproach was his commitment to poverty alleviation that they did not dare try to dismiss him with the pejorative label "neo-liberal". With his impeccable credentials as a student of poverty, Suresh could fearlessly defend policies that he saw as in the national interest even if they made him unpopular with his peers. Thus, for example, as a member of the last Pay Commission, he became the lone dissenter to the recommendation of salary increase for civil servants without any consideration of merit.”


From With the passing away of Suresh Tendulkar, India lost a leading light by Arvind Panagariya

Wednesday, February 23, 2011

Amartya Sen’s nod to the licence-permit raj


Prof. Arvind Panagariya politely says that the acclaimed leftist economist Prof.Sen favours the growth killer "licence-permit raj" even now!!.

Some excerpt: 
  • Sen leaves the impression that growth is at best a sideshow when it comes to the well- being of the poor. He essentially ignores the direct contribution growth makes to the creation of income and employment for the poor when he states: “The central point to seize is that while economic growth is an important boon for enhancing living conditions, its reach depends greatly on what we do with the fruits of growth. To be sure, there are large numbers of people for whom growth alone does just fine, since they are already privileged and need no social assistance.” Thus, contrary to the evidence that growth directly benefits the poor, Sen emphasises the accrual of such benefits only to those “already privileged” with the benefits to the poor depending principally on how what the government does with the “fruits of growth” . Why does it matter whether you choose to see growth as central to improving the wellbeing of the poor or as a sideshow ? Because the policies you would advocate critically depend on this choice. Bhagwati, who sees growth as central, has long advocated policy reforms that enhance growth prospects while also recommending increased expenditures on antipoverty programmes. 
  • Sen, who sees growth as a sideshow, has rarely spoken in favour of promarket reforms, implicitly giving a nod to the licence-permit raj, which denied higher incomes and better employment opportunities to the poor. All politicians now recognise the centrality of growth in generating revenues to finance expenditures on health, education and employment programmes in a poor country like India. Because India started extremely poor at Independence and also grew very slowly for nearly four decades, successive governments failed to muster enough revenues to finance expenditures on these sectors. As a concrete example, Article 45 of the directive principles of state policy in the Constitution had required free compulsory primary education . But despite repeated attempts throughout, the goal remained unfulfilled until 2010 when accelerated growth finally yielded sufficient revenues to permit the implementation of the right to education as a fundamental right. 
The article published by Prof Sen in The Hindu is here.

Friday, February 26, 2010

Going back to no-reforms

Prof Arvind Panagariya point out in his piece in Yesterday ET titled “Indian growth miracle faces threat”


Some excerpts:


“Even those such as Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, home minister P Chidambaram and Planning Commission chief Montek Singh Ahluwalia, who had fought hard for economic reforms in the 1990s, show little keenness for continued pro-market reforms. Indeed, the fear is no more that still-incomplete reform process will not move forward under the present government — that is now old hat — it is that there are realistic prospects of the clock being turned back.


Attempts to enforce the minimum wage are bound to give rise to exactly the same problems in the unorganised as in the organised sector. Producers will shift into more capital-intensive sectors and technologies. Mechanical car washes, construction equipment, agricultural implements, washing machines and power-driven lawnmowers will gradually replace many activities currently performed by hands. And when that happens, the workers so released will have nowhere to go.


The third and final example of a recent policy that potentially sets back progress is the refusal by the environment minister Jairam Ramesh to allow the cultivation of genetically modified (GM) brinjal. Just as the ultra-high standards of social legislation in the area of labour have led to stunted industrial growth, environmental concerns that ignore scientific evidence can thwart a second Green (Gene?) Revolution. Indian farmers have already handsomely reaped the benefits of GM cottonseeds.



GM foods are also not new: they have existed in north and south America for more than a decade. Moreover, based on extensive study by agricultural research institutes, universities, and expert panels , one of which had been appointed by the Supreme Court, our government’s Genetic Engineering Approval Committee has given the brinjal a clean chit. Yet, bowing to groups such as Greenpeace that are committed to opposing GM foods under all circumstances, minister Ramesh has denied our farmers the benefit of the new variety.”

Saturday, October 31, 2009

Some Questions Are Best Buried in the modern India

Prof. Arvind Panagariya writes in the TOI:

  • Singh has done a great service by sensitising us to the importance of a better understanding of India's immediate pre-independence history………
  • …………..the progressively inflexible position of Jinnah, the only way the Congress could have preserved a united India was by accepting his demands in entirety. But in view of his long struggle for independence that included many years spent in jail, his national integration aspirations, and the dream to build a modern democratic India, Nehru could hardly be expected to make such a sacrifice and that too in favour of someone who had not spent a day in jail, was solely focused on the preservation of the interests of a single community, and had little inclination to work cooperatively with the Congress to build a modern India. The experience with the 1946 interim government, administered jointly by the Congress and the Muslim League, confirmed the unworkable nature of their relationship. There came to exist a virtual vertical wall between the departments held by the Congress and the Muslim League from the minister at the top right down to the orderly at the bottom.
  • Prior to the arrival of Lord Mountbatten, the Cabinet Mission of May 1945 represented the only serious attempt by the British towards independence. To woo Jinnah, the Mission proposed an all-India federation with a three-tier governance structure with a weak Centre at the top, weak provinces at the bottom, and strong groupings of provinces in the middle. Three groupings were proposed: Group A with three contiguous Muslim majority provinces, Group B containing six Hindu majority provinces and Group C clubbing the vast Muslim majority Bengal with a much smaller Hindu majority Assam. Each group was to write its own separate constitution with the Centre's jurisdiction limited to defence, foreign affairs and communications. Predictably, the Congress refused to embrace the groupings idea.

Thursday, October 22, 2009

Cut-off Kapil Sibal idea of 80% nor current 60%

Prof. Arvind Panagariya on Indian Education System: The State and the Private Sector’ role’

  • “….must first end the tyranny of the University Grants Commission (UGC) by abolishing it altogether. After nearly six decades of central control, our colleges and universities are surely mature enough to handle their own affairs.
  • Ten years ago, gross enrolment ratios in higher education in China were below India’s. Today, they are more than one and a half times ours. If we rely solely on the state to catch up, we can be sure to fall further behind. The state has neither the resources nor ability to fill the vast gap that now exists between the demand for and supply of college and university education. Absent massive private entry, severe skill shortages await our industrial and services sectors.”

Thursday, June 25, 2009

The Rao’s debacle!

Prof Arvind Panagariya writes “To make the announcement credible, he should appoint Dr Govinda Rao, arguably India's foremost public finance expert, as the 'GST Czar' for a two-year term with the sole mandate to ensure that at the end of his term India has a well-functioning GST in place.”



Thursday, May 28, 2009

The English learned TWO dogs were foregone with scooter, rickshaws, bicycles and bullock carts…………….

Professor Arvind Panagariya article published in The Economic Times (23 April 2009) was a beam beat which came after the Samajwadi Party supremo Mulayam Singh Yadav who announced if his party voted he will ban the English in Uttar Pradesh “ this is brilliant idea” said Prof Panagairya but ‘worse yet’ the article begun by quoting the below lines: 

They said Ned Ludd was an idiot boy

That all he could do was wreck and destroy 

He turned to his workmates and said:’ Death to Machines’

They tread on our future and they stamp on our dreams. 

(Poet and performer Robert Calvert from his 1985 album Freq) 

Why I am taking note of this article meant this article was not posted in online before the election. 

There is quite interesting lines in his article: 

  • “In the early 19th century, great Luddites, so named after the fictive Ned Ludd, fought against the Industrial Revolution that introduced wide-framed automated looms. Protesting the job losses, the Luddites destroyed many of these looms and even clashed with the British Army. 
  • But unappreciative, British government subjected them to a mass trial, eventually executing some of them. With the IT revolution unleashing the computer, history may now be poised to repeat itself. The Mulayamites have declared war against the computer. Will the electorate reward them? Or will it give them the same treatment the British government gave the Luddites in the early 19th century? ” 

And he has written another article in today’s The Economic Times in which he says: 

  • “…a dog that did not bark but for a reason, just as in the famous Sherlock Holmes tale Silver Blaze by Arthur Canon Doyle, and the other of a dog that did bark but no one noticed.  
  • It needs reminding that in social sciences, usually no single theory explains everything. Especially when three or more candidates contest for the same seat, even minor alternative factors can tip the balance. Therefore, counter-examples showing the victory of non-performers and defeat of performers can scarcely invalidate the anti-incumbency hypothesis.  
  • So meticulous was the Election Commission that in Banej village of Junagarh constituency in Gujarat, it established a polling station for a lone voter! With some exceptions, polling stations carried voter lists that included photos of voters to prevent impersonation. On top, voters were required to bring their photo identifications. Polling was spread over four weeks and carried out in five phases. 
  • Finally, thanks to electronic voting machines, counting of the results was completed within a day. Even recounting in closely fought elections was completed amicably within the same day and, unlike in the United States, actual votes rather than judiciary decided the outcome! “

Tuesday, May 26, 2009

Naïve economists.....

If anyone talks about the nuts and bolds of “socialist policies of India's first three decades following independence” my mind simply goes to those days people’s standard of living and the kind of choice they had in that time is ringing like anything. This is ironic when Professor Arvind Panagariya writes in WSJ that “The socialist policies of India's first three decades following independence brought little relief to the poor, while the ad hoc liberalization of the 1980s followed by more systematic reforms subsequently have led to a significant cut in poverty rates.” 

By doing this he insult himself, the honest people, the analyst, the economy and everybody else as fool because the notorious notion of socialism has ruined our nation. 

I have no idea how Prof Arvind Panagariya says that “The socialist policies of India's first three decades following independence brought little relief to the poor..” 

Monday, April 6, 2009

Heterodox Austrian school of economics- why China and Russia want gold Standard?

Atul Sethi writes in the TOI “Now, countries like China and Russia want gold to be more than a steady asset. Russia recently advocated partial restoration of the gold standard — the old system of anchoring a country's currency to a specific amount of gold — to make for greater stability in the world monetary system. ”

However, the reasons expressed by economist like Arvind Panagariy is not at all clear.


Thursday, March 26, 2009

The holy trinity c-o-w-s……..

Well, this is as usual election time, but in different time. Many things have changed except the Darkness India which lives outside the domain of every policy maker, leader, official’s mindset.   

Nevertheless, Chacha Manmohan Singh has tried his best to do in the last five years like an open mind child trying to learn and do in primary school (class one to five). I am sure he will get pass mark for last five years but I am not sure whether this will help him to enter his sixth class. 

One outside Darkness teacher says all the “good men” become ‘bad men’ at the end of the five years term except Chacha Manmohan Singh. People in Darkness still do not know what these good men turned bad men did for them. It’s not the mistake of these Darkness people but it might be a big mistake of these good men turned bad men. 

No matter how bad men all these persons but they are all good friend in their past and future life.