Showing posts with label Climate Change. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Climate Change. Show all posts

Sunday, July 20, 2014

NDA's First Budget 2014

First Thought: Given the conditions of prevailing Indian political economy, the Union Budget for 2014-2015 is a good start for many new thinking of the new government. In many ways, the government has clarified the official focuses and intentions in many sectors particularly in small entrepreneurs development, infrastructure development, energy sector, and so on. The income tax and other tax saving exemptions are very important positive development for millions of people.

Sensible good people agree on all the right directions of the Budget and expose the wrong intentions. On that line here are some good points from the random experts. I do not agree with everyone on all the matters of budgeted issues/challenges.


To start with. Dr Bhalla says the "Budget 2014-15 (but not the long “everything and don’t forget the kitchen sink” speech) is one of the best content budgets of the last two decades." 


PBM says "This budget is a cross between bad elements of UPA 2 and NDA 1; there is no new Modi 1 in sight yet. The budget has no poetry and uncertain plumbing."


Dr.Desai on "the gigantic statue of Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel. I am a great admirer of him; I met him for the last time just two months before his death. But a statue of him is of the same order as the elephants erected by Mayavati, only a hundred times more wasteful."


Other useful links:


If you care about global warming, blame Keynes and follow Hayek.

What does socialism do to ethics




Saturday, December 17, 2011

Blinking links

Surjit S Bhalla argues ....At the outset, let me state that there are sufficient rumours about the possibility that the RBI is being dictated to by the Delhi combine of Manmohan Singh and his chief (and it appears, only,) economic adviser, C. Rangarajan. 

Barun point how India missed yet again at Durban....."India has improved its carbon intensity by 32% in the past 15 years as it began to reform its economy and prepared to compete globally. Yet today, India’s carbon intensity is still seven times higher than Japan’s (Chart 2). This indicates there are still huge structural and policy challenges that are preventing India from adopting the best technologies and practices currently available in the world."

Can we have like this one (or more) for spreading liberals values in India?

"Godrej supports the contentious provision. “What the Companies Act envisages is that there is a recommendatory level of 2% of profit after tax for corporate social responsibility and in case you’re not able to spend that much, you must explain it in your annual report,” Godrej said on the sidelines of the second annual conference of the Dalit Chamber of Commerce and Industry. “I think that’s a fairly reasonable provision and I personally do support it.”

Surath Giri from Nepal argues.......quite interestingly that "Free market capitalism that rewards entrepreneurship, risk-taking and innovation, and at the same time provides easy universal access to economic activities to all citizens is a blessing. There are enough evidences that when allowed to work, the market has lifted more people out of the mud and misery of poverty than any government. And it has been true regardless of the culture, tradition, religion, economic base, and civilization of the society practicing it. The most prevalent myth about free market capitalism in Nepal is that in free market capitalism the economy is dominated by cartels and syndicates."

Tuesday, June 8, 2010

Baseless Cup-sup-hope

One can view the below lines with a Zen sense of mind!

  • “We are a mosaic of societies caught in the crossfire of history and modernity, and to surge forward to industrial-age efficiency, we need lateral competitive ability rather than the small, elitist segment to which it is presently restricted.”

However, it is not that easy to accept the bogus survey results like the one below because the kind of political propagandas implemented is of the view of against of human action but not on the natural causes. A truly educated youths would not take the view of this survey because that is what the liberal art education provides.

  • “It’s truly a marvel that consciousness about global warming and the environment is not an urbane idiom any longer. An overwhelming proportion (67.4%) of Indian literate youth (67.4% regardless whether dropout or not) felt these are serious issues whereas just 7.4% said they were not. About 80% of respondents recognised the threat to biodiversity as serious while 86.5%assertedthegovernmentmusttakeserioussteps to address the problems of the environment.
  • The urban-rural gap, insofar as overall environmentalism is concerned, is quite slim actually. For instance, while 73% of town youth felt for global warming, we have 64% of villagers with the same view. For biodiversity, we have 82% of city youngsters worried, while the consciousness is as high as 77% for village-bred youngsters.”

Read the full piece here.

Thursday, May 20, 2010

Climate mind


Shreekant Gupta on “Let The Market Work Its Magic”


  • The point often missed in terming China and India big emitters is that global warming is not caused by current emissions of GHGs but by their accumulated stock in the atmosphere. Once released, these gases can stay in the atmosphere for up to 100 years. A tonne of CO2 emitted by industrial revolution-era Britain in the late 1800s is almost as bad as a tonne of CO2 emitted by China or India today. So, EU with 16 per cent of current emissions accounts for nearly 27 per cent of cumulative emissions, ranking second only to the US. For the UK, an early industrialiser, the difference is even more pronounced: its historic share is nearly three times its current share. Conversely, the historic share for many developing countries is sharply below their current share of global emissions. China's and India's cumulative shares (7.6 per cent and 2.2 per cent, respectively, since 1850) are only half their current shares.
  • The most transparent and objective way resource transfer can occur is through the creation of a global carbon market and the assetisation of the global atmospheric commons coupled with an equitable distribution of these assets. Any country wanting higher per capita levels than the safe limit would have to buy this right. This is how markets work: property rights are traded at a prevailing price and in that exchange is implicit a transfer of money (which in India's case could be used to finance clean and renewable energy without depending on the patronage of aid or having to deal with donor fatigue and sermonising).

Thursday, February 18, 2010

There is no poetic justice in this whole drama of Climate Change!!


Barun on “India Supports a Toothless IPCC”

A bit from his piece

  • “The explanation for this support is simple: It is in the Indian government's interest to perpetuate a weak IPCC and a toothless Mr. Pachauri at its helm. Given the recent scandals, the IPCC is hardly in a position to lobby India for carbon concessions. No one from the IPCC can again cavalierly dismiss their critics as promoting "voodoo" science or "vested interests," as was Mr. Pachauri's wont. By offering scientific support to the IPCC, the Indian government is actually confirming its lack of confidence in the U.N. body's scientific credentials.
  • Mr. Pachauri is now in his second term as the head of IPCC. He is not a climate scientist—or indeed a scientist at all. He is an able science administrator who built his institute from scratch. Influential governments in the rich world probably accepted Mr. Pachauri not just for his redoubtable skill in institution-building, but also in the hope that by placing an Indian like him at the head of IPCC, he might be able to influence Indian policy.”

Saturday, January 30, 2010

Climate-politics-I

Prof Deepak Lal on man made global warming

"Dr Pachauri, a railway engineer with a PhD in economics, as being “arrogant”

Saturday, December 12, 2009

Dreams never die

Charles Krauthammer on “The new socialism” and environmentalism

A bit from his piece:

  • “With socialism dead, the gigantic heist is now proposed as a sacred service of the newest religion: environmentalism.
  • The idea of essentially taxing hardworking citizens of the democracies to fill the treasuries of Third World kleptocracies went nowhere, thanks mainly to Ronald Reagan and Margaret Thatcher (and the debt crisis of the early '80s). They put a stake through the enterprise.
  • This naked assertion of vast executive power in the name of the environment is the perfect fulfillment of the prediction of Czech President (and economist) Vaclav Klaus that environmentalism is becoming the new socialism, i.e., the totemic ideal in the name of which government seizes the commanding heights of the economy and society.”

Friday, December 11, 2009

The road to Climate Change is death mark


Don't let the climate doubters fool you

Thursday, December 10, 2009

The road to Climate Change is death mark

George F. Will writes:

"The travesty is the intellectual arrogance of the authors of climate-change models partially based on the problematic practice of reconstructing long-term prior climate changes. On such models we are supposed to wager trillions of dollars -- and substantially diminished freedom."

Wednesday, December 9, 2009

The road to Climate Change is a death mark

Here is what Barun words:

"Barun Mitra, however, had a different argument. He said it is growth which leads to a green and clean environment.

"Economic growth invariably creates energy efficiency and leads to a greener environment, while poverty makes people vulnerable," said Mitra.

"If we can get rid of poverty we can solve the problem," he added.

At this, Mitra reiterated his point and said, "Poor always pays the highest price in all casualties because of the fact that he is poor. The only way to deal with the poor issue is growth."

Mitra gave a new argument and claimed there has been nothing like climate change in the world.

"Science is not about answers, it is a quest, a search. The email-gate clearly establishes how corrupted the scientist community can be when they hand in glove with the political establishments," he emphasised."

Tuesday, September 29, 2009

'kuch mahol banta hai’

No no no no no!!! Don’t believe after all the present talks on climate change are political monks!! Talk.

Jairam Ramesh, the Union minister for Environment and Forests says:

  • The UN convention is really a talk festival. It is not a negotiating forum -- it is a forum where presidents and prime ministers of the world are going to make political statements and reinforce the consensus for arriving at an agreement at Copenhagen.
  • We are not even going to have serious discussions. As they say in Hindi, 'kuch mahol banta hai', an atmosphere will be created. But the real work is being done in the negotiating forum.
  • Of course there are difficulties we are facing. The US is finding it very difficult to make meaningful commitments on emission cuts for the year 2020. We are insisting on 2020 because in the year 2050, who knows, none of us are going to be around to be held accountable.
  • The EU has made an offer for a cut by 2020, as did Japan, but not the United States. But without getting into finger-pointing and the blame game, what I am trying to convey is that India has not caused the problem, but India wants to be part of the solution. India wants to be a deal maker and not a deal breaker at Copenhagen.

Wednesday, September 23, 2009

Can emission be cut without hurting growth?

The answer is never be yes or no but the emerging “Alternatives Are Simply Too Expensive” especially for the emerging markets.

Read:

Yes: The Transition Can Be Gradual—and Affordable

  • Consider this: From 1990 to 2007, while world emissions rose 38%, world economic growth soared 75%—emissions per unit of economic activity fell by more than 20%. Critics argue we can't possibly increase efficiency enough to hit the 80% goal. In a very limited sense, that's true. Efficiency improvements alone, like the ones that propelled us forward in the past, won't get us where we need to go by 2050. But this plan doesn't rely solely on boosting efficiency. It brings together a host of other changes, such as moving toward greener power sources. What's more, making gradual changes means we don't have to scrap still-productive power plants, but rather begin to move new investment in the right direction.

No: Alternatives Are Simply Too Expensive

  • “Proponents suggest that we give developing nations lower goals to start with, to help them catch up to the rest of the world. But some of the biggest developing nations—and biggest greenhouse-gas emitters—have indicated they won't accept any kind of cap. For one, India has been pretty straightforward for a long time: They'll think about emissions limits when they are as wealthy as the industrialized world is today. How many times do India and China have to say "no" to emissions limits before we believe them?”

Monday, September 14, 2009

How to word a moment where the change remains change?

T C A on Economics and Climate Change:

  • “There’s this to be said about economists: they go where the money is. When poverty studies had the funding, they went there; now that climate change has it, they are herding there. Their studies on poverty made no difference to poverty, except their own; their studies on climate change will make no difference to the climate, either.
  • I have asked scores of economists, including three Nobel Laureates, about this problem. Not one had an answer because, in fact, there is no answer. And it should be noted: this has nothing to do with the idea of a social rate of time discount.
  • It should be evident from this that it is impossible to work out anything that is even remotely sensible. And the reason for that is that economics is not the right intellectual tool to apply to the perceived problem of climate change. The answer lies in changing the energy base of the world. That needs science and technology, not economics.”