Showing posts with label Narendra Modi. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Narendra Modi. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 22, 2020

Embracing Decentralisation to Speed-up Smart Cities Projects

I have new article in the CPPR blog about the assessment of five years of implementation of smart cities projects in India:

The main arguments are in the below para:

"The dismal performances of Smart City Mission projects are attributed to many elements such as lack of good governance and decentralisation at urban local bodies’ level even after the Constitutional Amendments made close to three decades ago. Moreover, Smart City Mission projects mainly were faced with lack of political leadership to drive effective transformations at national, state and city levels; the lethargic bureaucratic planning, project designs minus citizens’ participation; complete dilution of mission guidelines and norms of special purpose vehicles (SPVs); not including subject experts from industry and public policy practitioners in the planning stage itself; lack of transparency in detailed projects preparations by private consultancy firms; and more importantly, corruption in tendering process with political interferences, especially in Tamil Nadu. Also, there were no links between the actual projects initiated and initial reports prepared by private consulting firms involving citizens for feedback."

Friday, May 15, 2020

Self-reliant India, as New Economic Model

Economist S Gurumuthy's analysis of Indian economy is always different and fascinating on many counts. In a recent Interview to a English magazine, he said:

"The illiterate economic thinkers and institutions in India, whose training is based on foreign ideas and theories, have not been able to come to terms with the diversity of India. The financial model applicable to listed companies is being thrust on the rest of the economy. The swadeshi approach calls for factoring in the diversities of India. Actually, jobs are provided only by the MSMEs which are the backbone of the economy. This was understood only after Modi constituted the Mudra finance plan. So jobs will be generated only through bottom upwards and top-down economic model which will suit only the cosmopolitan kind of society."

and on internal migration issues:

"This problem is there, but it is blown out of proportion. Let us look at the facts. There are 31 crore intra and interstate migrants in India according to 2011 census. Out of that 4.2 crores are interstate migrants. How many out of that are going back? Not even 10%. When you are planning a lockdown you cannot give two days or even ten days time for people to move. That would have led to chaos and stampede. Particularly when they did not know how long it would take to flatten the curve. So the migrant issue is a creation of the media and the opposition."

Thursday, November 14, 2019

The leapfrogging of Indian Smart Cities


The leapfrogging of Indian Smart Cities

B.Chandrasekaran, works in public policy

Indian cities were evolved as a driving force for development and growth in the last thirty years by infusion of mass migration for education and employment opportunities. Most of the Indian cities are not developed in a particular design with an order either by the State or by the societal norms or market forces which evolve spontaneously. Hence, most of the urban population in India lives not in orders with designs of civic amenities and public services. In other words, the cities are facing huge challenges in dealing with social equity, economic viability, and environmental sustainability on access to the services and facilities of common utility.

The pace of urbanisation has been increasing in recent decades without the basic livable amenities which are more threats in the short term than opportunities. India has 4,041 cities and towns. According to Pratap Padode, Founder of Smart Cities Council India Chapter, "China has developed 30 cities in the last thirty years with over 1 million population. India has 53 cities or rather urban agglomerations with over 1 million population while China has over 160. The municipal act needs an overhaul if we expect a commitment for building sustainable cities that will last centuries." Even after more than two decades of passing the 74th Amendments in 1992 which empowers urban local bodies to govern its affairs with autonomy is yet to be realized fully.

Further, according to UNDP’s Research Paper (2000) titled “Decentralisation in India Challenges & Opportunities” which revealed that “it is not surprising that most municipalities were and still exist in a financially precarious position. In 1986-87, the income of all municipal bodies in Class 1 towns exceeded their expenditure only by Rs.311 million. The overlapping territories and responsibilities between ULBs and Development Authorities led to problems of non-co-ordination, and more seriously increased corruption and lack of accountability".

The main impediments faced by cities across India are Municipals Acts which are redundant in many ways resisting to change its bureaucratic mindsets towards the aspirations of millennials. Any city qualified to be the best in its quality should have excellences in services delivery in basic services like equitable access to roads, potable water, sewage systems, street lights, footpaths, power supply, and proper education and healthcare facilities with the precision of compliance systems to the residents with open and transparent governance systems. Without the above, the tweaking here and there will only help short-term gains of social attention and political gimmicks to the vested interests groups of which the larger public are not a party to.

It would be interesting to see the outcomes of major projects initiated under India's Smart Cities Mission because the structural reforms which were said to be prerequisite were not carried out to make concrete efforts to improve the basic amenities for better living of all. In the process, though much has gone into the underpinning challenges faced in the reorientation of the process for urban planning and designing which are no less than the age-old red-tape system yet to adopt new changes.
The Union Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs had launched targeted programmes to improve the basic amenities in 100 cities through Smart City Mission in June 2015. Now, it has been more than four years eloped since the launch of Mission. Out of 100 cities, 90 of them were selected between January, 2016 and June, 2017. The under the Smart Cities Initiatives, the involvement of critical masses was often faced with the dilemma of expansion of existing cities or the creation of new ones. Mostly, the existing cities are decided to repair it instead of building new cities.

While launching the latest Progress Report 2019 on Indian Smart Cities, the Secretary of the Union Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs informed that till now total projects completed in various cities are 1,100 only which is worth Rs.201 billion. Also, Pratap Padode said that only “10% of the planned projects have been completed in the past three years.” This is very minuscule compared to what has been aimed to achieve by end of March 2019.

However, more on the pipelines, out of the 5,000 projects taken up across 100 cities, nearly 3,880 or 78 percent of the project proposed were given tenders for implementation. The tendered 3,880 projects are worth Rs.1,418 billion and projects under implementation are 3,100 which is worth Rs.1,004 billion. Also, the Progress Report highlights the cities which have tendered for various projects are 12 Smart Command and Control Centres for the comprehensive city-centric data management system, 92 public-private partnership projects, 107 smart road projects, 10 Smart Solar projects, 31 wastewater treatment projects, and 46 Smart Water projects. It could be possible that many of these projects were designed in the pretense of OUTCOME based approach for the sustainability of assets created.

It clearly shows that the present urban local body’s capacity to scale up the initiatives with smart solutions are stuck with its bureaucratic mode of planning, designing and implementation with little or no space for public participation. Urban local bodies have to constantly upgrade the skills and capabilities to their functionaries to overcome emerging challenges. Though, the current systems of urban local bodies are under tremendous pressure from stakeholders to change its styles of functions with more transparency. They should strive to involve the private agencies which have high creditability among the public to develop the process and designs to implement the projects in a time-bound manner.

The framework of Special Purpose Vehicles (SPV) for Smart Cities was said to be well-thought-out plan but very little has been grounded to effect changes. For example, out of 11 Smart Cities in Tamil Nadu, only Chennai Smart City had appointed CEO and other staff under SPV. All other cities are functioning without CEOs and thereby the SPVs are ineffective. Moreover, many Smart Cities are yet to appoint the subject experts from the private sector as Directors in their SPVs to have an inclusive process of decision making. Therefore, the foundation for building cities of the 21st century nature is still far away from the foreseeable future.

Tuesday, November 12, 2019

Can’t we have Comprehensive Vision for $5 Trillion Economy by 2025?


Can’t we have Comprehensive Vision for $5 Trillion Economy by 2025?

B.Chandrasekaran, works in public policies.

At a time when the economy is moving towards a downward spiral rapidly, the most contested public debate among economists is about the rationale of achieving a $5 trillion economy by 2025. Largely, the debate is about whether the economic growth slowdown is temporary or likely to be the longer and an economist's terms “cyclical” or “structural” trend. In the process, the best of minds seems to be undermining the sectoral focus of the most critical sub-sectors which have large junk of labour forces in the economy.

The vision of a $5 trillion economy by 2025 was first announced on October 11, 2018, by the Ministry of Commerce and Industry, Government of India. The ministry also announced that “the underlying strengths” and "dynamics provide us grounds to target achieving 1 trillion dollars from agriculture and allied activities, 1 trillion from manufacturing and 3 trillion from services" sectors. In November, 2018, the Modi Government had also released the Niti Aayog’s “Strategy for New India@75” which aims to achieve “a USD 4.0 trillion economy” by 2022. However, the vision of a $5 trillion economy by 2025 has become the main agenda for all policy templates.

Though, there are several underpinning challenges and opportunities in the primary, secondary and tertiary sectors which have been failed to articulate in the Working Group Report of the Ministry of Commerce and Industry to achieve the $5 trillion economy by 2025. More importantly, the growth of the manufacturing sector has been stagnated for decades which need to be strategically unleashed by reforming the land and labour laws. Further, the Report’s identified measures for specific policy actions in sectors are not in tune with the ground realities. Also, the Niti Aayog’s strategy document’s sectoral visions are not in confirmatory with the government’s actions in the implementation of policies and programmes. The idea of $5 trillion economy is not just numbers which need to be boasted but it’s the impact on billion more people.

Nevertheless, why the vision for only the overall size of the economy? Why not also have bold visions on sectoral aspects of the country? Can’t we have some constructive vision documents with goals to be achieved by 2025 by revisiting the Niti Aayog’s Strategy? The following aspects will play a major role to define what we mean by New India either positively or negatively depends upon the kind of policies that the Modi government envisions and implement it in the next five years to 2025:

 (1) How to increase the one million employment opportunities every year for youth? At present, 10 million Indian youth enter the workforce every year.

(2) How do we ensure the unrestrained flow of credit access to millions of micro, small and medium enterprises in the country? Though Government is saying that they have mission-mode project of creating 5 crore jobs in next 5 years in the MSME sector.

(3) How to achieve the learning outcomes of children in primary schools by adopting psychological methods of teaching tools?

(4) How to reduce different kinds of violence against children and women; the demographic dividend will be defined better how the government policies and programmes are dealt with children and women?

(5) How do we minimize the millions of court cases pending (32 millions) for decades especially the heinous criminal cases against children, women and elderly people?

(6) How do we handle the challenges of municipal solid waste which has been projected to be 150 million tonnes by 2030 three times of present 55 million tonnes?

(7) How to recycle the municipal sewage and industrial effluents of millions of liters (40,000 million) which has been let out into the rivers, streams, channels, lakes, ponds, bore wells, etc. across the country causing health hazardous for millions of people, animals, birds, etc?

 (8) How are we going to manage the growing urban population of 590 million by 2030 from the present 340 million without adequate civic developments?

(9) How to handle the electronic waste generation of 20 lakh tonnes (2017) which has increased from 1.47 tonnes in 2005. India is the 5th largest e-waste generated and has recycled only 0.036 MT per annum in 2017.

(10) How to rehabilitate and provide sustainable likelihoods to nearly half a million destitute, shelters less and beggars people in the country? Do they don't have an aspiration for New India?

The idea of new India is worth if only the governments make sincere efforts to try and understand the urgency of the above issues and challenges besides others to help 1.3 billion people to achieve their aspirations bestowed on the governments. It’s high time to think about how ease is dealing with each of the above issues in terms of responses from the government departments for improving the lives of the people.

Once in five years, the people's faith in political leadership is not for the rhetorical wisdom of having a vision for a $5 trillion economy by 2025 but also how to unfold that vision into sub-sets of objectives and goals to achieve the aspirations of billion more people. Unfortunately, the present governments are not showing interest in having a constructive vision for the subsets of the $5 trillion economy by 2025 for inclusive New India.

Friday, July 26, 2019

India's Flawed Skill Development Mission

The title of this post is a new article I have contributed in Deccan Herald on this Monday commenting of the recent Union Government Budget. 

The current Union government budget did not speak about two aspects in details, one is achievements of last five years on skilling youth and the initiative of smart cities for 99 cities. Both have received bare minimum focus, is it because the previous Modi government failed miserably? 

The institutional capacity to expand the skilling of youth has not increased as it was expected when the Vision 2022 was launched in 2015. Moreover, the quality of imparting skills to youth by different training institutions whether it is government run or private run, both were lacking the marketable skills for employ-ability.

We need to set right the institutional governance first and then we need to focus on private sector driven funding for the skilling with mutual interests.  


Sunday, July 20, 2014

NDA's First Budget 2014

First Thought: Given the conditions of prevailing Indian political economy, the Union Budget for 2014-2015 is a good start for many new thinking of the new government. In many ways, the government has clarified the official focuses and intentions in many sectors particularly in small entrepreneurs development, infrastructure development, energy sector, and so on. The income tax and other tax saving exemptions are very important positive development for millions of people.

Sensible good people agree on all the right directions of the Budget and expose the wrong intentions. On that line here are some good points from the random experts. I do not agree with everyone on all the matters of budgeted issues/challenges.


To start with. Dr Bhalla says the "Budget 2014-15 (but not the long “everything and don’t forget the kitchen sink” speech) is one of the best content budgets of the last two decades." 


PBM says "This budget is a cross between bad elements of UPA 2 and NDA 1; there is no new Modi 1 in sight yet. The budget has no poetry and uncertain plumbing."


Dr.Desai on "the gigantic statue of Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel. I am a great admirer of him; I met him for the last time just two months before his death. But a statue of him is of the same order as the elephants erected by Mayavati, only a hundred times more wasteful."


Other useful links:


If you care about global warming, blame Keynes and follow Hayek.

What does socialism do to ethics




Thursday, June 12, 2014

Professor Kancha on CM turned PM Modi

Prof.Kancha Ilaiah wrote in 2002 something very interesting about BJP and Modi. Those wise wisdowms become true to the words of Prof. The following are two paras the beginning and the concluding one:

  • "NARENDRA MODI'S victory with a two-thirds majority in Gujarat has signalled the emergence of a strong, independent OBC (Other backward Class) leader in the BJP. Earlier, two independent OBC leaders — Laloo Prasad Yadav and Mulayam Singh Yadav — had emerged from the fold of socialist politics in Bihar and Uttar Pradesh. But that was in the context of the Yadavs emerging as landed gentry with some socio-economic capital.


  • There is a lesson here for the secularists and the communists. As Hinduism did not allow Dalits to get into temples they began to move towards Islam, Christianity and Buddhism. If the secularists and the communists do not allow the OBCs to grow in their organisations Mr. Modi will become their national leader and their Prime Ministerial candidate too. And in such a situation, feeble OBC voices like mine will be drowned."

Saturday, May 24, 2014

Interesting time, ahead

However, it may be the case for nature to have some or other odd events in the world of Indian economy, but for sure, a very very interesting time is ahead for all of us in India. 

Let's not underestimate a body of man's mind and actions over the nature to do right things in life. Life changes when you change your actions or you simply be in actions, all the time to do right things with one simple tool: commonsense.

The following are some good reading:

The Modi magic: why voters kicked out liberal economics along with cong?

A call to arms: Modi offers window to push liberal agenda by Seetha

  • The Swatantra had limited success because the intellectual climate in the sixties and seventies was overwhelmingly leftist. That is no longer the case. 

Salli secularism doses by S.Gurumurthy

PBM's ponderings and musings on history of Indian polity: 

  • "The key distinction is between those who wanted a conception of citizenship beyond compulsory identities and those who did not. Many who wanted a united lndia, like Abul Kalam Azad and Gandhi, thought, nevertheless, that India was a collection of distinct communities, which could flourish together. Nehru and Ambedkar wanted to transcend that India. Azad and Muhammad Iqbal may have different implications for the territorial unity of India, but their metaphysics of community identity is more similar. An intellectually underrated figure these days, like Lala Lajpat Rai for example, is actually closer to Nehru and Ambedkar in the way he thinks about finding a conception of citizenship transcending community than his politics would suggest."
  • "The compromises of practical politics and opportunism blurred these intellectual lines and created strange bedfellows. This is a heretical thought. But in terms of underlying positions, in any other world, Nehru, Lajpat Rai, M.G. Ranade, Syama Prasad Mookerjee, Ambedkar, perhaps even Jinnah, would have been in a similar party: looking for conceptions of citizenship that transcended traditional community affiliations and created space for individual freedom. They happened to disagree on whether you could do it in one diverse nation. Gandhi, Azad, Purushottam Das Tandon, Deendayal Upadhyaya, and perhaps Iqbal, would have been in a similar camp: the modernist project as enacting community identities rather than transcending them."

Saturday, May 17, 2014

Modi: India, Indians and its economy

The new idea of India is here. The 2014 Lok Sabha elections have really changed many usual musings of social scientists in India and abroad, of course for the betterment of India and Indians. During the announcements of the elections results its always very interesting to listen people who have bothered to utter something before the elections and now match with the change if their mind and muddles.

Here are the reactions of some liberals in India:

Towards Economic Freedom

Seven Thoughts on Modi’s Mandate



Sunday, April 6, 2014

India "move towards a centrist politics"

Some useful reading:

"India is definitely ahead of Europe in how so many diverse cultural, linguistic and even religious communities have all kept together in a federal political system. Look at Europe — it has become more and more divided into countries. Within several countries that are much smaller than India, deep and violent divisions persist. Ireland is one example...

But I must add that one dangerous phenomenon has emerged — post-election alliances. What should happen is that parties get together before an election, declare some kind of common programme and then face the electorate. Instead, I see parties openly declaring that they will enter into alliances after the results are out. This is not fair to the voters and leads to problems in the political system. " More here.

The quality of governance matters, not 10-year averages.

 the Praetorian guards of the “idea of India”

No political party can hope to win even a municipal election in India by relying on the votes of rich Indians. 

Socialist parties have had the enduring slogan of Bharat verses India. Leaders and intellectuals have argued that cities are colonising the countryside and creating a conflict between villages and cities. 

Saturday, April 5, 2014

Must read


Swatantra's Real - AAP's Fly by Night Politics


"Independent politicians like Masani, who did not believe in the socialist route taken by Nehru, rallied around Rajagopalachari. In the General Election of 1962, within three years of its formation, the Swatantra Party won 22 Lok Sabha seats. The next election in 1967 was its highpoint. It got 44 Lok Sabha seats and was the largest opposition party. It got 9.6 per cent of all votes polled and won 256 assembly seats in various states. And then, just as abruptly, by the polls of 1971, it slipped to eight Lok Sabha seats with just 3.1 per cent of votes polled. By 1974, the main party had ceased to exist." More here.

"The Swantantra Party had become the more legitimate voice of the free market...A decade ago, Mr. Vajpayee’s free market policies were staunchly opposed by Sangh affiliates such as the Swadeshi Jagran Manch. Mr. Modi managed to banish them all from Gujarat, making it a middle class utopia. The anti-capitalist strand in the Hindu right that repelled the modernising, pro-market middle class is now invisible and inaudible." More here.




The impending demise of the Left....on May 16, do not forget to note history in the making, with the Left seats in the low teens if not at a single-digit level.

Chinese president Mr.Xi says "Constitutional monarchy, imperial restoration, parliamentarism, a multi-party system and a presidential system, we considered them, tried them, but none worked,"

"Indian society internalised the Victorian critique"

Saturday, March 8, 2014

Narendra Modi Mania-Tall Order or Tall Leader

There comes time when someone seems as ordinary becomes special and extraordinary in a few months time. Like this can only happen in the open-media society like the one we are blessed with now and enjoying in the middle of this revolution. Narendra Modi become one such person for all the good reasons and causes. Modi's ideas have been hot debate now more intensively. Some are very interesting and few are more political in nature. But that is always the case for any persons who work in the political process in any country.

The purpose of this post is to re-count the economic ideas of Mr Modi. Some grant ideas.

  • urbanisation, infrastructure, education and healthcare, apart from cracking down on scourges such as inflation and black money... Modi...wish list includes Indian Institutes of Technology, Indian Institutes of Management and All India Institutes of Medical Science in every state, 100 new smart cities and bullet trains to all four corners of the country. 
  • "If the railways is modernised, we can give impetus to progress. By the time the country celebrates the diamond jubilee of independence (2022), we should have bullet trains going in four directions. The world will start seeing us with a new vision,"
  • Modi spoke also of building Brand India through 5 Ts - talent, tradition, trade, tourism & technology and said India’s demographic and democratic dividend along with these plans will set in motion the investment cycle and revive India’s stalled growth.
  • 'Nobody has a textile policy like us. It is based on five Fs. Farm to fibre; fibre to factory; factory to fashion; fashion to foreign,' 
Here are some articles: One, second, third, four, five, six, seven, eight, nine, ten, eleven and twelve. Other articles: here,

Saturday, January 25, 2014

Interesting reading

"the Gandhian inspiration of AAP politics calls for serious rethinking. Gandhi’s use of civil disobedience was very infrequent. Only the issues of gravest significance required that mode of protest. A dharna, too, requires systematic prior analysis before it is undertaken as a mode of non-violent protest.

Socialism as an ideology has lost its meaning in the 21st century; especially in India, some of the worst forms of government conduct emanated from a socialist state, which also kept the masses poor; and as a purely pragmatic matter, the so-called aspirational millions and the urban elite, who have flocked to the AAP, have no taste for socialism any more." More here.

The following sentences has serious flaws:

"The two strands, initially represented by the Jana Sangh and the Swatantra parties, remained on the margins. It was the Ayodhya movement and economic liberalisation that created the conditions for a viable Right, so far a work in progress."

Revisiting the grammar of democracy in the eternal words of B.R.Ambedkar:
  • "...if the parties place creed above country, our independence will be put in jeopardy a second time and probably be lost for ever.
  • that political power in this country has too long been the monopoly of a few and the many are only beasts of burden, but also beasts of prey." 


Journey to Change The Nation

"The first Indian from the south of the Vindhyas to ever preside over the Dilli darbar was P V Narasimha Rao. Technically, it was C Rajagopalachari, as the first Indian to be governor-general. But CR’s post was titular. 

Narendra Modi is different. He fulfils all the qualifications of being an outsider, except that he speaks chaste Hindi. The business and military elite love him, but the cultural elite do not and the political elite remain wary. If he succeeds in winning power this year, he could well alter the nature of the Dilli darbar. That is what unnerves so many darbaris." More here.