Showing posts with label Adam Smith. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Adam Smith. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 11, 2013

Capitalism, Caste and Society (CCS)

Here is a very interesting interview with two powerful, yet persuasive minds working on mission to do something concretely with the idea of Capitalism, Caste and Society. And thus they say "'Capitalism is changing caste much faster than any human being. Dalits should look at capitalism as a crusader against caste". A bit from the interview:

"What has happened during the past 50 or 60 years is that the state's welfare measures or methods or reservations got slightly misunderstood and also slightly misused by the "victims".

...10 per cent of MSMEs registered with the Government of India are Dalit-owned, which is about 1,64,000 across the country. 

...the silencer in the Tata Nano is produced by a Dalit entrepreneur.

Affirmative action has given Dalits a launch pad. A launch pad is a launch pad. You need that to take off. Ambedkar gave you the launch pad. Now don't run on the launch pad, take off.

Because of economic reforms, globalisation, you can't produce everything under one roof. You will have to outsource work. Most of the Dalit entrepreneurs of today are beneficiaries of outsourcing.

Along with globalisation came Adam Smith to challenge Manu. So that's why for the first time, money has become bigger than caste.

there is an economic process, that capitalism is changing caste much faster than any human being. Therefore, in capitalism versus caste, there is a battle going on and Dalits should look at capitalism as a crusader against caste.

what man failed to do, capitalism is doing. Let us go with capitalism that is changing caste faster than your reforms

People who are working on poverty have a better life than people like us, because if you work on poverty, then you fly. You work on poverty, you live in five-star hotels. If you work on poverty, you are in touch with big foreign funding agencies. So, talking poverty makes you strong, makes you rich.

The inspiration behind DICCI is the economic thought of Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar. The second is the black capitalism in America."

Monday, August 27, 2012

Of that interesting reading

In this worst of the best Session of parliamentary mess in India what can one expect to respect the ruler whom we elected knowingly or unknowingly. The answer is nothing. Stop reading the political economics columns for a while to really kind of ponder about what is happening behind the door. There is no many harsh statement on many things. It become a sort of habits that many people just say what they would not have said if they really thought through it with commonsense.

I am not the one who recommends every time when Narayan Ramachandran writes about anything that he think is good to tell others about it. But this article is really worth spending your time perhaps I strongly recommend any one who is interested in the subject of invisible hand or the markets in society. The piece is absolutely excellent.

Thursday, August 23, 2012

Prime time ahead for F A Hayek

"To an Austrian, the economy is incomprehensibly complex and constantly changing; and technocrats and politicians who claim to have figured out how to use government are deluded or self-interested or worse. According to Hayek, government intervention in the free market, like targeted tax cuts, can only make things worse." More here.

Saturday, November 13, 2010

M K Gandhi on Free Trade!!


When I get time to read long essays, other than the daily reading of newspaper, magazine, blogs etc I dwell on Universities/institutions working papers on development economics and Indian economics.


The recent one which I read is “Indian Planning and Development Economics” by Lawrence H. White published on August 31, 2010. This is a Working Paper (No. 10-53) and is Chapter 10 from The Clash of Economic Ideas his 2008 book.


No doubt this paper would add some value addition to the subject but there are some serious and dangerously wrong interpretation and misunderstanding in this paper. Let me say the following two of course the second is a little minor one! But the former is really a big misunderstanding!


Mr.White writes:

  • “In sharp contrast to Adam Smith, who had recommended ending such transfers by instituting free trade between former British colonies and Britain, Gandhi called for ending trade. He favored a form of national selfsufficiency for India bordering on autarky.” (p.320)

  • “Jairam Ramesh, India‘s finance minister 1996–98, notes that western advisors strongly supported Nehru‘s planning efforts”: (p.327)


Let me take the second one first. India’s Finance Minister during 1996-98 was P.Chidambaram not “Jairam Ramesh”. For more see 1 2.


On the point of “......Gandhi called for ending trade.............” In absolute sense Gandhi was not against of free trade per say! He in fact said the following:


  • “To reject foreign manufactures merely because they are foreign and to go on wasting national time and money to promote manufactures in one’s country for which it is not suited, would be criminal folly and a negation of the Swadeshi spirit. A true votary of Swadeshi will never harbour ill-will towards the foreigner; he will not be moved by antagonism towards anybody on earth. Swadeshism is not a cult of hatred. It is a doctrine of self-less service that has its roots in the purest ahimsa, that is, love” (1931) (From Yeravaa Mandir, 1957, p. 66).


M.K Gandhi also wrote in Young India:

  • Q. What is your opinion about the importation of foreign goods other than cloth into India? Are there any foreign commodities which you would like to see immediately under prohibition? What do you think should be the nature of India's foreign trade in the future?

  • A. I am more or less indifferent with regard to trade in foreign goods other than cloth. I have never been an advocate of prohibition of all things foreign because they are foreign. My economic creed is a complete taboo in respect of all foreign commodities , whose importation is likely to prove harmful to our indigenous interests .This means that we may not in any circumstance import a commodity that can be adequately supplied from our own country . For instance I would regard it a sin to import Australian wheat on the score of it's better quality but I would not have the slightest hesitation in importing oatmeal from Scotland, if an absolute neccesity for it is made out, because we do not grow oats in India. In other words I would not countenance the boycott of a single foreign article out of ill will or a feeling of hatred. Or to take up a reverse case , India produces sufficient quantity of leather , it is my duty therefore to wear shoes made out of Indian leather only , even if it is comparatively dearer and of an inferior quality in preference to cheaper and superior quality of foreign leather shoes . Similarly I would condemn the introduction of foreign molasses or sugar if enough of it is produced in India for our needs. It will be thus clear from the above that it is hardly possible for me to give an exhaustive catalogue of foreign articles whose importation in India ought to be prohibited. I have simply indicated the general principle by which we can be guided in all such cases. And this principle will hold good in future too as long as the conditions of production in our country remain as they are to-day (Young India, 15-11-28. p.381).

Tuesday, October 26, 2010

Remind the liberals

Jonathan Alter has an interesting but reminding article on The State of Liberalism.

Some excerpts:

  • Liberals are also at a disadvantage because politics, at its essence, is about self-interest, an idea that at first glance seems more closely aligned with conservatism. To make their more complex case, liberals must convince a nation of individualists that enlightened self-interest requires mutual interest, and that the liberal project is better constructed for the demands of an increasingly interdependent world.
  • That challenge is made even harder because of a tactical split within liberalism itself. Think of it as a distinction between “action liberals” and “movement liberals.” Action liberals are policy-oriented pragmatists who use their heads to get something important done, even if their arid deal-making and Big Money connections often turn off the base. Movement liberals can sometimes specialize in logical arguments (e.g., Garry Wills), but they are more often dreamy idealists whose hearts and moral imagination can power the deepest social change (notably the women’s movement and the civil rights movement). They frequently over indulge in fine whines, appear naïve about political realities and prefer emotionally satisfying gestures to incremental but significant change. Many Democrats are an uneasy combination of realpolitik and “gesture politics,” which makes for a complicated approach toward governing.
  • Action liberalism has its modern roots in empiricism and the scientific method. Adam Smith was the original liberal. While “The Wealth of Nations” (1776) has long been the bible of laissez-faire conservatism, Smith’s first book, “The Theory of Moral Sentiments” (1759), pioneered liberal ideas of social and moral inter dependence. By today’s standards,Abraham Lincoln’s support for large-scale government spending on infrastructure and appeals to “the better angels of our nature” would qualify him as a liberal. In the 20th century, progressives cleaned up and expanded government, trust-busted on behalf of what came to be known as “the public interest,” and experimented with different practical and heavily compromised ways of addressing the Great Depression.
  • The quintessential example of the pragmatic core of liberalism came in 1943, when President Franklin D. Roosevelt announced that “Dr. New Deal” had become “Dr. Win the War.” Roosevelt believed that the ends of liberalism — advancing democracy, expanding participation, protecting the environment and consumers (first promoted by a progressive Republican, Theodore Roosevelt), securing the vulnerable — were fixed, but that the timing and means of achieving them were highly negotiable, a distinction that often eludes modern liberals.

Monday, September 20, 2010

Adam Smith: An Enlightened Life


That is the new biography book by Nicholas Phillipson. I am posting full review by V V in the BS for record. Before you read the review article. I want you to know few things. Prof Ronald Coase is the longest living economist with Nobel Prize in Economics and he is going to be 99 by this December! Last year I have read the book Life of Adam Smith by John Rae and its worth to read and ponder the life of great philosopher of life.


V V: The wealth of Adam Smith


V V / New Delhi September 18, 2010, 0:03 IST Business Standard


The main activity of economists since 1776 has been to fill the gaps in Adam Smith’s system, to correct his errors and to make his analysis vastly more exact
—Ronald Coase, Nobel Prize Speech, 1991

  • It is now widely accepted that biographies of great writers are interesting only insofar as they illuminate their work, and to do this effectively requires a discursiveness on the part of the biographer which alone would tell you what turned the writer on to do the work she did in her lifetime. Not to emphasise the work would be to reduce the biography to an exercise of hagiography like most of our biographies of the big and famous that tell us of lives too good to be true. Nicholas Phillipson’s Adam Smith: An Enlightened Life (Allen Lane/Penguin, Special Indian Price, Rs 899) places his work, widely regarded as the foundation of modern economics, firmly within the larger scheme to establish a grand “Science of Man” that encompassed law, history, aesthetics, economics and ethics — more a work of philosophy than of pure economics.
  • Possibly because An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations (1776) was multidisciplinary and broadened the study that Adam Smith began in The Theory of Moral Sentiments nearly 20 years earlier in 1759, there has been no unanimity on what precisely his influence was based on. Was it because he was the masterly advocate of laissez faire? That he was opposed to every effort by a government to control the self-interested activities of individual economic actors, so granting the licence to greed and other vices, and malpractices, and quite content that markets should be the battlefield from which the most oppressive combatants would emerge as “victors”?
  • Should the “Invisible Hand” of the market decide? What does his statement that “it is not from the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer, or the baker that we expect our dinner but from their regard to their self-interest” really mean? Quite apart from the fact that these iconic statements can be interpreted in different ways, there is also the sad fact that not many economists have read The Wealth of Nations as a whole; they have snatched bits and pieces and drawn their half-baked conclusions that we have accepted as the truth because they came down to us from experts.
  • The basic question we need to ask is whether Smith wholly approved of a society in which man’s economic activities are actuated by self-interest. In his Theory of Moral Sentiments, Smith had identified human perfection with virtue and virtue of the highest order with altruism. Phillipson’s biography provides a balanced picture of Adam Smith’s work against the background of the Scottish Enlightenment and the influence of his philosopher friend, David Hume. A good biography is itself a kind of a novel. Like the classic novel, a novel believes in the notion of a “life, a story that begins at birth, moves on to a middle part, and ends with the death of the protagonist”. So, it is here but it is primarily “an intellectual biography, one which traces the development of his mind and character through his published and unpublished texts, one that is set in a country that was generating its own form of Enlightenment”. Phillipson succeeds in showing that all of Smith’s writings make up a single coherent whole. He begins by giving a compact account of Smith’s life and times and of the intellectual traditions that he drew on and modified.
  • Given this background, Phillipson turns to his central undertaking, pointing out that, according to Smith, a commercial society tends to promote certain virtues among its members. By eradicating poverty, it reduces incentives for individuals to resort to crime and nations to enrich themselves by wars of aggression.
  • By maintaining a stable Constitution, especially if courts are independent and markets are free, a commercial society enhances individual freedom, which is a precondition of moral choice. Competition in markets compels individuals to exercise self-control, prudence and industriousness, virtues which, though imperfect, are attainable by ordinary people. Although these virtues promote the well-being of the individual rather than the good of others, they unintentionally benefit others. Phillipson suggests that Smith’s practical aim throughout the Theory of Moral Sentiments is “designing the decent society”.
  • The Wealth of Nations, which is a follow-up to Moral Sentiments, shows how men can live and work well together. Accordingly, Smith urged governments to do two things — promulgate justice and foster institutions that improve people’s moral conduct. Basic among such institutions is the family, which lays the foundations of moral conduct by training the child to restrain its will and respect others.
  • Smith’s practical proposals aimed to improve both material and moral conditions of people. Because his books have not been read as a whole, today’s social scientists and proponents of public policy have ignored or distorted his outlook. Above all, they have ignored Smith’s constant theme that unintended consequences of good intentions are often bad. The biography sums up Smith’s intellectual contribution and for this alone, the book needs to be read, and not just by economists.

See also an interesting post in the MR.

Wednesday, October 7, 2009

Economics of Babu Gandhi and Adam Smith

Recently Bharat Dogra wrote a piece on “Economics & Gandhi's human touch” in the ET. Few bits from the piece:

  • …Mahatma Gandhi was to bring economics closer to human concerns: "What we seek to do is substitute false and non-human economics by true and human. Not killing competition but life giving co-operation is the law of the human being."
  • Gandhi's views on international trade: "That economics is untrue which ignores or disregards moral values. The extension of the law of non-violence in the domain of economics means nothing less than the introduction of moral values as a factor to be considered in regulating international commerce."

Gopalkrishna Gandhi, the Governor of West Bengal wrote an article on the “Economy of words and writing” where he reproduces some of early letters of babu Gandhi’s writings and logics of using pen to bring words into a paper. Would it be possible that pen marries men without paper or vice versa to bring words from heaven?

Thursday, September 10, 2009

Random note: Private property and The State

The following note was taken during my visit to National Institute of Rural Development (NIRD) library, for presenting my paper in its Foundation Day Seminar in 2006. The paper was peer reviewed one and was also paid a lump sum as Honorarium for the paper!

The State by Anthony de Jasay

“Young Marx- He spoke of the ‘general secular contradiction between the political State and civil society’, and contended that ‘when the political State…comes violently into being of civil society…... it can and must proceed to the abolition of religion, to the destruction of religion: but only in the same way as it proceeds to the abolition of private property (by imposing a maximum, by confiscation, by progressive taxation) and the abolition of life (by the guillotine) (K Marx, The Jewish Question, Early writings, 1975, pp.220, 222, 226).

  • For Marx State as essentially as instrument then Engels, Lenin
  • For Hobbes it keeps the peace
  • For Locke it upholds the natural right to liberty and property
  • For Rousseau it realise the general will
  • For Bentham and Mill it is the vehicle of improving social arrangements
  • For today’s liberals it overcomes the incapacity of private interests spontaneously to co-operate
  • Collectively proposed public goods of order, defence, clean aid, paved streets and universal education.

For ‘non market choice’ or public choice school, the interaction of private choices through the instrument of the State is liable to overproduce public goods and fail in other way to attain prepared outcomes (as one of the founders of this school puts it, welfare economics is about market failures, public choice theory is about government failures) (James M Buchanan, The Limits of Liberty, 1975, ch.10).

People who have been to rely on the State never learn the art of Self-reliance nor acquire the habits of civil action.

State action may or may not achieve its intended effect. “Civil society governs itself”

The ‘Origin of the State is conquest’ and the ‘origin of the State is the Social Contract’ are not two rival explanations.

“Social Contract”

Robert L Carneiro, ‘A Theory of the Origin of the State’ in JD Jennings and E . Hoebel (eds),

The origin of capitalist ownership is that ‘finders are keepers’. Possession to ownership; to good title to property, independently of its particularities, of who the title- holders may be and also of the use he may or may not make of the property.

Locke’s famous words “enough and as good”

Adam Smith- describes political economy as a branch of the ‘Science of a Statesman’ and ascribes to it in the role of two distinct objects: first to provide a plentiful revenue or subsistence for the people or more properly, to enable them to provide such a revenue or substance for themselves; and secondly, to supply the State or commonwealth with a revenue sufficient for the public services. It proposes, he says, to enrich both the people and the sovereign (The Wealth of Nations, Cannan’s Edition vol I, 395).

The following are from ‘Politics and Economics Papers in Political Economy by Lord Robbins’ 1963, Macmillan & Co, New York.

  • Keynes-in the end, the world is governed by ideas and by little else.
  • The world’s freedom and ‘order’ each appeal to our emotions.
  • ‘I desire freedom as an end in itself. I desire order as a means to freedom’
  • We decide to rely on private property as a basis of dispersed initiative and freedom, we must be prepared to tolerate the existence of some inequality arising from this source also.

Diffusion of property…

From Globalisation and Its Discontents by Joseph E. Stiglitz (2002)

  • I saw divisions were often made because of ideology and politics. I believe in privatization, if markets are competitive and efficient and lower’s prices for consumers.

Friday, April 3, 2009

Smith third law: a theory of government

Karan Horn has quite interesting article on Adam Smith and his idea. What was interested me was:

 “We actively educate ourselves so that we can hope to be truly praiseworthy.” 

“The question has to do with the natural harmonisation of interests. Is there any way in which the interests of government are spontaneously aligned with the interests of the governed? Is political action possible without destroying the checks and balances of the spontaneous order? Smith doesn't give us an answer. Maybe he had found that there was no such way”.

Thursday, August 14, 2008

Adam Smith- A Primer or Frontier by Chandra

It is the nation and its men who do things better by trying every alternatives, no harm in that. Than where is the question of need of Government yes they do need but stupidly for only to protect men from external conflicts.
Here is a simple idea of what the man is all about in an economy written plain language by EAMONN BUTLER, Director of Adam Smith Institute.

"The wealth of a nation is not, as the mercantilists believed, the quantity of gold and silver in its vaults, but the total of its production and commerce – what today we would call gross domestic product.

In a free exchange both sides become better off. Nobody would enter an exchange if they expected to lose from it. Imports are therefore just as valuable to us as exports are
to others. We do not need to impoverish others to enrich ourselves. Indeed, we have more to gain if our customers are wealthy.

Regulations on commerce are ill founded and counterproductive. Prosperity is threatened by taxes, import tariffs, export subsidies and preferences for domestic industries.

A nation’s productive capacity rests on the division of labour and the accumulation of capital it makes possible. Huge increases in output can be gained by breaking down
production into many small tasks, each undertaken by specialist hands. This leaves producers with a surplus for investment.

A country’s future income depends on the rate of capital accumulation. The more that is invested in better productive processes, the more wealth will be created in the future.

When there is free trade and competition the market system automatically remains focused on the most urgent needs. Where things are scarce, people are prepared to pay more for them. There is more pro. t in supplying them, so producers invest capital in order to produce more.

Prosperity grows most rapidly when there is an open, competitive marketplace, with free exchange and without coercion. Defence, justice and the rule of law are needed to maintain this openness. Freedom and self-interest do not lead to chaos, but – as if guided by an ‘invisible hand’ – produce order and concord.

Vested interests use government power to distort the market system for their own benefit. Employers and professionals may promote regulations that stifle competition, such as
entry barriers that prevent people from practicing particular trades.

Taxes should be proportionate to income and ought to be certain and convenient to pay. They should be cheap to collect, should not hamper business, should not be so onerous as to encourage evasion and should not require frequent visits from tax gatherers.

Human beings have a natural ‘sympathy’ (or empathy) for others. This enables them to moderate their behaviour and preserve harmony. It is also the basis of moral judgements about behaviour and the source of human virtue. Human nature is a better guide to the creation of a harmonious society than the overweening reason of zealots and visionaries".

The Full paper!