Showing posts with label World Financial Crisis. Show all posts
Showing posts with label World Financial Crisis. Show all posts

Friday, June 28, 2013

B R Ambedkar, please!

S.Gurumurthy has very interesting article in the BL on global financial crisis and its impact on real economy. The most interesting part is below para:

  • "Milton Friedman suggested that governments must statutorily limit the rate of money expansion to the rate of growth of the real economy. That is, there must be direct correlation between money and growth. But now, post 1990, the financial economy has grown 10 times the real economy."
The essence of the above arguments was the pioneering work of Dr.B R Ambedkar in the early 1920s. But nobody had have interest to read and understand from his point of view.

Wednesday, July 4, 2012

Of that fault lines

Finally, I read the book "Fault Lines: How Hidden Fractures Still Threaten the World Economy" by Professor Raghuram Rajan. Its a wonderful book. All those interested in understanding the global economic issues and challenges should read it at least once. He gives great narrative in each chapter in the beginning and good summary at end.

The chapters I enjoyed reading are chapter 2 and chapter 9.

The full introduction chapter is freely available here.

Some of the interesting book reviews:

WSA piece here, here is another piece by Rajan's friend highlighting the essentials, here is must read piece and the last one I would like to cite is here. 

Friday, December 23, 2011

Prof Amartya Sen: conflicts in liberalisation

On December 16th of this month, I had a great opportunity to listen to Prof Amartya Sen. This is the first time I got to see him closely and observe his actions in telling something about economics, politics and his friends like Dr Manmohan Singh. The session was chaired by Business Standard Chairman Mr T N Ninan.

The reader of this blog know that I came to know the fact that Prof Sen won 1998 Nobel Prize in Economics Science through my Tamil Language teacher.

Any way, Prof Sen delivered a lecture at Hotel Le Meridien, New Delhi and it was a part of 2011 Delhi Economics Conclave. Prof Sen's lecture was not on any specific topic. He briefly touched broadly on: (i) global financial crisis, (ii) the Euro crisis, (iii) implications on Indian economy and (iv) poor performance of social development indicators in India.

Prof Sen's understanding on 2008 financial crisis might be exceptional but given the ideological lean what he informed the hundred of industry member was not new at least in my view. So basically, he summarized by stating simply that the 2008 crisis erupted due to over confidence of banks (on lending, risks, etc), lack of rational confidence and inability of regulator. He also said that Adam Smith never used the word "capitalism" in his all works. According to Prof Sen Adam Smith only used the word "market" to analyse the players in the society.

On Bush and Obama: Prof Sen explained that Bush era saw the unrestrained capitalism, crisis of government and bailout to banks.

On Euro: Prof Sen said Euro is not worth having because there is no fiscal union in the political economy of EU. He also pointed out that the central problem of Euro crisis is epistemology and the crisis of government efficacy resulting from the fundamental like freedom and actions of key decision makers. He further went on to argue that the people who are reading the crisis in wrong side. He also talked about the 1943 EU movement of unity in Euro.

On Indian economy: Prof Sen's views are not new but some of his views expressed during this lecture is worth reading from the print media:

  • "We [India] need to maintain economic growth as growth generates public revenue and with public revenue we need to do things such as health care, immunisation, education...The government has to do a lot more,"
  • "I spent an hour with Manmohan Singh yesterday but I did not have any illusion that if I could convince him that everything will go fine, not because he is not a good Prime Minister, as I think he is, because that's not the way Indian democracy works".
  • "In a democracy, you have to carry the party, the coalition and the political system, including the opposition with you."
  • "I do not think that there is any conflict in liberalisation.... Each time you have to see if it is doing good for the people or not," 
  • "What we need is economic reforms, but reforms are not just about doing enough to addressed issues which are of great importance to those relatively prosper...Reforms are right but the formula that works for the only 20 per cent people of the country is not right,"
I must record here that Prof Sen rejected the way in which the Team Anna is trying to do with fighting corruption in India. I consider fasting for corruption is age old wrong doing. And I agree with him when he said that:
  • "What I had, in fact, said was that the judgement and penalty for corruption cannot be a matter for street justice, and must come through the democratic procedures that we cherish in India, including the courts and Parliament," he said in a communication.
  • "we do not not have to tie accused people to trees to deliver summary justice to meet the demand of most Indians to extend the process of democratic accountability in a more full-blooded way to corruption."

Tuesday, October 25, 2011

Blinking links

SA writes; "Political philosophers tracing the evolution of society define the period before governments as the State of Nature where every man was a law unto himself. It is the period before social contracts, commandments and rule of law came into being to bring order in society. It is only after the evolution of social contract, defining rights and obligations, that society migrated from the State of Nature and accepted the Nature of the State. If one looks at the headlines of the day and raging rant beamed into living rooms, it does often seem that India is drifting into an ungovernable chaos. The Nature of the State is seemingly regressing into the State of Nature."


The demand doctor who killed the world economy in the past and is still killing the same.


TCA on the quality of chief economic advisers who served in the Indian Federal Finance Ministry. Just to note (from TCA column):



"The good, the bad and the undeserving
Sometimes, you tend to look back and wonder about this and that. My time has been largely misspent in the company of economists who, I have concluded, are of three types: the good, the bad and the undeserving.
The best amongst the good ones speak in murmurs, the bad ones do regressions and the ugly ones preen like a brigade of frogs at a beauty parade. I write this because recently I had to put up with some very self-congratulatory talk.
My own view, after having studied the matter in depth, and at close range, is that the worst of the last group are the ones who served as chief economic advisors (CEAs) between 1982 and 2002.
During this period there were five and a half, the half being a “chief consultant”. He was the best by far and therefore ousted after 15 months. In the 1980s, one left after two years and another after about a year and half."

Wednesday, September 21, 2011

Foolish governments, smart women

The title of this post is the beautiful chapter in the great slim book "India Unincorporated" by Professor R Vaidyanathan.

SOme blinking Links:

The another round of crisis is already underway either by the actions of Indian government or by the actions of other countries especially the USA and the EU. More here.

"Put the three together and you get the logical conclusion that the government’s heavy role in the sector has been only to distort pricing. Its involvement has neither resulted in energy availability for the consumer nor a friendly climate for investors"

Monday, September 5, 2011

Make sense

Shankkar Aiyar writes:

  • India is doubtless the home of paradoxes. It has arguably the largest number of banks and the lowest level of financial inclusion. The RBI informs us that there are 33 foreign banks, 21 private sector banks, seven new private sector banks, 20 nationalised banks, six banks of SBI and its associates…not to mention a host of cooperative institutions. And yet over 50 per cent of the households find themselves outside the formal banking and financial system, and 73 per cent of farmers have no access to formal credit. Is it then the claim of the government that new banks and indeed corporate houses will deliver what the existing pantheon of 80 banks and over 1,000 cooperative institutions are struggling to achieve?
  • The very obvious need is for more branches or access to banking services. If financial inclusion is the stated objective, why has the policy shut out public institutions like the Life Insurance Corporation and India Posts which have been clamouring for banking licences? Indeed, if there is one organisation which can deliver access, geographical reach and inclusion, it is the India Posts which has over 155,000 offices of which 1,39,000 are spread across rural India. Yet, India Post has been shut out of the process of expanding banking and delivering financial inclusion.
It makes sense to argue like this but the services delivery is terribly poor in post offices. I have experienced all kinds of non senses in vising post offices for years. Unless, the post office system takes help of technological development it cannot provide any kind of services with cost effective.

Tuesday, February 8, 2011

Raghuram Rajan on Economics crisis



 He writes in his blog: 
  • these expectations could have been distorted by ideology – it is hard to get into the past minds of economists. But there is a better reason to be skeptical of explanations relying on ideology. As a group, neither behavioral economists, who think that market efficiency is a joke, nor progressive economists, who distrust free markets, predicted the crisis. 

  • Like medicine, economics has become highly compartmentalized – macroeconomists typically do not pay attention to what financial economists or real-estate economists study, and vice versa. Yet, in order to see the crisis coming, you had to know something about each of these areas, just like it takes a good general practitioner to recognize an exotic disease. Because the profession rewards only careful, well-supported, but necessarily narrow analysis, few economists try to span sub-fields.

Saturday, February 5, 2011

Bastard Keynesianism!!



I indeed wanted to post after the celebration of 75 year old Keynes book on General Theory. The damages done by this book is now history.

Moreover, Ann Pettifor writes in Blooomberg: 
  • This “bastard Keynesianism,” as British economist Joan Robinson called it, subverted and continues to block the Keynesian revolution both in vision and in method. Monetarists were concerned with the quantity of money. Keynes’s overwhelming concern was with the rate of interest on money. He argued that monetary policy should always support the private and public economy, stimulate it, and prevent recession. 
The Austrian school of economics main concerns is unlimited money creation and artificial creation of interest rate. So biting the money with extremely low interest rate is the culprit for economics crisis.

Monday, January 17, 2011

Knowledge problem- None of them truly understood the machine they were put in charge of……

The Lords of Finance Liaquat Ahamed on precisely what happened in 1920s depression: 
  • ………..in the 1920s who made grave mistakes and led the world to the Great Depression — was one that called it an “autopsy of a generation” of policymakers and their follies. Ahamed says “autopsy” is a reasonably good description. 

  • “It is about a group of men who made terrible blunders...they killed their patients...I don’t know if it is so much an autopsy as an inquest, but I don’t disagree with that generally.” 

  • Ahamed feels Federal Reserve chairman Ben Bernanke has done a good job lately. “Listen, he is like a doctor who allowed his patient to do all the wrong things: smoke, eat fattening foods, and then when the patient had a heart attack, he started doing the right things,” he says 

Read the full interview here. 

My earlier post is here. 

Tuesday, January 11, 2011

Lords of Finance by Liaquat Ahamed

I got an emergency call yesterday from a friend of mine. He insisted that he will not tell me why he wants to meet. When I reached his place, it was big surprise to me because we together went  for a fascinating discussion with Pulitzer Prize-winning author and investment manager Mr.Liaquat Ahamed on the economic bottom up/down climate and his book the "Lords of Finance: Bankers Who Broke the World." Dr.Sanjaya Baru, Editor, Business Standard had conversation with Mr.Ahamed.

Indeed, it was a great opportunity to meet Mr.Ahamed. Some time back I  read first chapter of his book. It is a must read for all the student of finance, because most of them now take granted about the way in which Central Banks behaves world over.  

Points noted from the discussion:

But one thing I kept on myself asking why I don’t like reading Mr Baru’s articles for quite some time now? It was clear to me from his yesterday discussion. He begun by saying “as a student of Keynes”, and “Keynes is my hero etc”. Let me say here a few words about the BS. In less than two years many key/senior journalists have left the BS. The list includes T.C.A Srinivasa Raghavan, Sunil Jain, Surjit Bhalla etc. The reason you know now.

The book gives great details about biography of four central bankers who were crumbling with money printing machine in 1930s, historic picture of financial crisis, economy, and geopolitics.

As Joe Nocera wrote: The lords of finance who constitute the title of this book are the four central bankers who dominated that postwar era: Benjamin Strong of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York; Montagu Norman, the longtime head of the Bank of England; Émile Moreau of the Banque de France; and Hjalmar Schacht, who headed the Reichsbank.

What was interesting to me was the Mr.Ahamed talk. Of course he said that “Keynes was not a hero” but he merely employed his energy to analyze the financial crisis in fresh way of looking at.

Mr.Ahamed clearly said that all financial crises had have happened till now due to the bad decisions taken by men who were in charge of the Central Banks. He also said that these central bankers were ignorance of not only the real economic situation but also their own field of finance. He even said that there was no established economics in the 1930s.

Thereafter, there were all kinds of questions were thrown from audience. I did ask him what is his take on Austrian School of Economics and its ideas on boom and bust cycles.

Mr.Ahamed said that he agree with what Austrian School of Economics have being saying about the unlimited expansion of credits which inflates the instability of financial crisis. However, he feels that the solutions offered by this school is suffering (let them bust attitude) which is something one would not prefer in any case in the modern world.

On the whole, Mr.Ahamed talk showed that he is all that not friendly to neither the State nor the Central Bankers.

Book review in The Economist. 

Also read Dilemmas in Central Bank Communication Some Reflections Based on Recent Experience: Second Business Standard Annual Lecture delivered by Dr. Duvvuri Subbarao, Governor, Reserve Bank of India.

Skill development for US economy

Prof Raghuram Rajan writes: 
  • Government spending—especially on unemployment benefits, aid to states, and some construction projects—probably helped avert a more wrenching downturn, but continued red ink worries households, which are also trying to rebuild savings and reduce debt after a spending binge. 

  • Instead of constantly trying to boost spending and potentially creating problems for the future, a more sustainable way to improve job growth is to facilitate the “re-skilling” of the unemployed, especially those who were in construction-related jobs. Eventually, better labour force supply will create healthier and more sustainable demand.

Sunday, December 5, 2010

Stability to whom?

Dr Y V Reddy on need of new regulatory structure in world financial system (perhaps rightly said so):


  • The whole world talks about introducing stability in the regulatory framework. Remember, the instability came in from half a dozen countries only—the US, UK, EU area. Instead, there was talk about a world regulatory framework, even as most countries were just affected by the contagious effect and their financial system was not in a mess. So why are we creating prescriptions for medicines for mistakes created in some other countries? This just shows the dominance of the thinking itself.

  • Secondly, every regulation is being talked about in the context of emphasising stability, whereas for many countries like India, want to have growth. So how the financial sector will help growth and how to structure regulation to help growth— that’s more important for developing countries. But you do not find that type of discussion even in G20 debates. Frankly, in terms of analytical framework for global public policy, the impression is that there were some loopholes here and there. You fix them and things will be alright, and that’s the way things have been working since then. There are a lot of fundamental things that have to be addressed and I don’t think there is much evidence on that.

Wednesday, December 1, 2010

Make this crisis also misunderstand

Nobel laureate (Economics) and Professor Michael Spence says:

  • …….they don’t understand what they are doing. If they are trying to protect the housing market, pump up asset value to get a little more energy. But people are not stupid. On the whole, it does not make any sense to me. Really, I think the housing markets are fragile and mortgages are expensive. Emerging economies have begun to start thinking of it as a kind of nuisance.

  • I am not a central banker but If I was, I would target the additional credit or credit terms at the housing markets. But, that’s meddling with the market. There could be an asset bubble. Inflation is already a problem in China. In India, you have a current account deficit so you can do with importing capital for a while because it makes sense with the overall growth scenario. But, things could go out of hand very quickly. I would certainly manage the exchange rate. There are variety of ways to do that, and you probably use them all. You can accumulate reserves but they can be a pain and not a good investment and so you can rescue the reserves or tax hot money inflows.

Friday, November 26, 2010

Hayek’s Revenge

That’s how it sounds in the current EPW article by Robert H Wade from LSE

  • The Republican blockage rests on a resurgence of “anti-government”, especially anti-federal government sentiment in the US. One of its strangest aspects is the return to right wing favour of Friedrich Hayek’s book, The Road to Serfdom. As of early 2010 the book stood at number 241 on the Amazon best-sellers list: not bad for a book first published in 1944. Hayek warned that infringements of economic freedom-to-do, such as the Beveridge welfare state, put the UK on the slippery slope to political serfdom. The book’s current popularity stems from boosts by conservative “thinkers” like Glen Beck and Rush Limbaugh, who tell their listeners that The Road to Serfdom is a road map to what the Obama administration is doing. They say that Obama’s healthcare reform, the bank bailouts, and just about everything else the administration has tried to do (excepting military adventures) constitute rising “government intervention” in the economy; and the resulting curbing of economic freedom leads on to the curbing of political freedom. In Rush Limbaugh’s words,

  • Friedrich von Hayek brilliantly laid it right out. It’s all about power. It’s all about control, and that’s what Obama’s about (Farrant and McPhail 2010).

  • The fact that the Beck-Limbaugh version of Hayek fails just about every empirical test one can think of has not stopped many millions of Americans from believing the argument and using it to fuel up the McCarthyite tendencies of the Tea Party movement and the Republican right.

Friday, October 22, 2010

Neo-liberal economists find new battlefront


There is war of debate is going on about the stimulus packages with respect to many issues like unemployment etc. It’s quite interesting to read and ponder how the "so called experts reacts".


I am posting the full debate below for record (dont' forget to read the Prof Lal's comments):

Neo-liberal economists find new battlefront

Michael Janda reported this story on Thursday, October 21, 2010 12:44:02

ELEANOR HALL: While many have criticised the scale of Britain's spending cuts one of the world's most powerful economic groups has praised the move to slash public debt, urging other nations to follow the UK's lead.


The Mont Pelerin Society held its biennial global meeting in Sydney and launched a stinging attack on the stimulus policies used to fight the global financial crisis.

The society's president professor Deepak Lal spoke to business reporter Michael Janda.

MICHAEL JANDA: Unbeknownst to most Australians one of the world's most powerful economic groups has recently visited our shores.

The Mont Pelerin Society was started just after World War II by Nobel Prize winner Friedrich von Hayek in an effort to fight back against communism, socialism and the Keynesian welfare state.

DEEPAK LAL: The society is literally there to promote the ideals of liberty - economic and political. The society has had, I can't remember - eight, nine Nobel Prize winners.

MICHAEL JANDA: That's the society's president professor Deepak Lal, a development economist from the University of California in Los Angeles.

And while its fight against communism largely ended in the early 1990s the society sees new battlefronts. One is the looming competition for economic supremacy between a free-market India and a state-controlled China.

DEEPAK LAL: China for 1500 years has been a tightly controlled bureaucratic authoritarian state. India for 2,000 years has been a completely anarchic society. Governments have never succeeded in doing anything.

And so as a result in India you've got civil society which actually manages to do all the things governments can't do. And that's its great strength.

In China if something happens to the state there will be another big band because the legitimacy that Chinese Communist Party which is the current dynasty, if that is eroded you could have chaos.

MICHAEL JANDA: Professor Lal says Australia should be careful not to over-commit to China.

DEEPAK LAL: If you're taking bets on the long-run, 20, 30 years, then clearly India is a better bet in my view, yeah.

MICHAEL JANDA: Another is the fight to quickly roll back the stimulus that most developed nations pumped into their economies during the financial crisis. And Professor Lal says the society is having some success.

DEEPAK LAL: The trouble is many other Western countries over the years have built up huge entitlement economies - welfare states in which you know they create politically determined income streams for all sorts of people.

And these then lead to a debt crisis. And this means that just trying to use the old Keynesian method, spending more, in fact makes this problem worse. And Britain for instance has bitten the bullet. It now decides, it's decided quite rightly the only way to deal with this is to reduce public debt levels.

MICHAEL JANDA: The society has a history of success, influencing the economic policies of conservative leaders such as Ronald Reagan and Margaret Thatcher in the 1980s.

A look at the guests at last week's conference shows the influence it has in Australia with former prime minister John Howard one of the key note speakers.

A key function of the society is attacking government intervention in financial markets and the economists who advocate it such as Nobel Prize winner Joseph Stiglitz.

DEEPAK LAL: Joe Stiglitz is a very smart theorist but he's got no sense as far as public policy is concerned. They've had all this stimulus and what has happened? Unemployment is still very high, no sign of it coming down. So they're going to try this next thing, print money.

MICHAEL JANDA: Professor Frank Stilwell who teaches political economy at Sydney University says the power of the Mont Pelerin Society to influence government policy shouldn't be underestimated.

FRANK STILWELL: Kevin Rudd at the time of the global financial crisis announced here the end of neoliberalism. But frankly a couple of years on it doesn't look like that. The neoliberals are resurgent.

And the meeting of the Mont Pelerin Society is I think part of that process whereby the right wing economists get themselves reorganised for a new assault on this Keynesian response to the crisis.

MICHAEL JANDA: And he's banded together with some other left-wing Australian economists to mount an irreverent challenge to free market economics through the Monty Pelican Society.

FRANK STILWELL: The name is of course ironic. But it's a serious attempt to provide a counter to these neoliberal views, stressing the need for governments to take responsibility for a more secure and a more equitable society.

MICHAEL JANDA: I'm guessing it's not quite as well funded and doesn't hold its meetings at the Hilton Hotel?

FRANK STILWELL: (Laughs) Absolutely no funding at all. And the small meetings are held periodically in a public place.

ELEANOR HALL: That's Sydney University professor Frank Stilwell ending that report by Michael Janda.

Tuesday, October 19, 2010

Man and economics

Two thousand four hundred years ago, one man tried to discover the meaning of life. His search was so radical, charismatic and counterintuitive that he become famous throughout the Mediterranean. Men — particularly young men — flocked to hear him speak. Some were inspired to imitate his ascetic habits. They wore their hair long, their feet bare, their cloaks torn. He charmed a city; soldiers, prostitutes, merchants, aristocrats — all would come to listen. As Cicero eloquently put it, “He brought philosophy down from the skies.” For close on half a century this man was allowed to philosophise unhindered on the streets of his hometown. But then things started to turn ugly. His glittering city—state suffered horribly in foreign and civil wars. The economy crashed; year in, year out, men came home dead; the population starved; the political landscape was turned upside down. And suddenly the philosopher's bright ideas, his eternal questions, his eccentric ways, started to jar. And so, on a spring morning in 399BC, the first democratic court in the story of mankind summoned the 70-year-old philosopher to the dock on two charges: disrespecting the city's traditional gods and corrupting the young. The accused was found guilty. His punishment: state-sponsored suicide, courtesy of a measure of hemlock poison in his prison cell.

(From Socrates — a man for our times by Bettany Hughes)

“We can make fun of economics, and I’ve made a professional habit of it,” said Professor Ariely. “But there’s a good reason that human irrationality isn’t part of the standard economic models, and this gets to the dilemma of economics. If you have a simple problem, you can offer a simple solution. But the economy is a hugely complex problem. So we either simplify the problem and offer a solution, or embrace the complexity and do nothing.”

(From The X Factor of Economics: People by David)