Showing posts with label Tamilian World. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Tamilian World. Show all posts

Thursday, November 23, 2023

Nani A. Palkhiwala donated Rs.12 crore so Sankara Nethralaya

In 1998, the legal luminary, Nani A. Palkhiwala donated Rs.12 crore so Sankara Nethralaya could buy Lady Willingdon Hospital in the same neighbourhood and expand. Ratan Tata donated Rs 5.5 crore. Today, the multi-storied blocks equipped with state-of-the-art medical infrastructure are buzzing with patients from across the country and the world. Badrinath encouraged his team to find cost-effective, scalable solutions.

More here.


Friday, December 16, 2022

India’s fiscal federalism is still evolving… by B. Chandrasekaran

 India’s fiscal federalism is still evolving… by B. Chandrasekaran

The article titled "The poor state of India's fiscal federalism by Kalaiyarasan. A" published in The Hindu on July 28, 2022, makes several sweeping statements without substantial data to prove on larger policy perspective and beyond taking the ideological position. The author’s statements cannot be taken as academic interest because it has public policy ramifications in many respects, mostly misleading.


At the outset, the article paints abjectly the state of India's fiscal federalism with allegations like the “centralisation of fiscal power”, “political centralisation” and "cultural nationalism", etc., especially since 2014. The pitch is set out very well before any data to substantiate for inferences to be drawn to conclude meaningfully.


One of the greatest economists of twentieth-century India was Dr. B.R.Ambedkar who never advocated for centralised planning or power centre except to protect the country's sovereignty by integrating the regional administrations as one country. Indeed, he always strived for decentralised planning for socio-economic development, and that dream is yet to be fulfilled in Independent India even after 75 years.


While the basic structure of India’s tryst with destiny was always found to be lubricated around conflict of visions with which the democracy unfolds and still drives for bettering. Alas, across the country, the autonomy of administrative power and devolution of financial power are yet to be transferred from State capitals to village panchayats and local bodies which rarely need now to make real growth centres across the country.


Interestingly, most seem to be forgotten now conveniently that unlike before 2014, no Chief Minister is visiting New Delhi now for approval of State’s Annual Plan budgetary provisions finalisation, including sectoral allocations, grants, etc. The Planning Commission structure was reformed with financial devolution power has been decentralised more now than in the past since independence.


The author’s statement “States lost their capacity to generate revenue by surrendering their rights in the wake of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) regime, their expenditure pattern too was distorted by the Union’s intrusion, particularly through its centrally sponsored schemes” is deeply flawed on many grounds.


A dynamic democracy like India had debated for a decade on a comprehensive indirect tax system and had powerfully exercised the tools of consensus building through political dialogs to align the states on their own will with facts and figures on the table at a common goal of the Goods and Services Tax system which may not be the perfect one but it was a fair beginning. The structure is still in evolving state with pros and cons to argue, but not to deny the fact that it can be done away with it completely.


For years, many states did not clean up their own awfully managed already fiscally stressed financial health and wasteful expenditures especially soon after the elections and just before the next elections on the lofty promises made to the electorate. When the states were having provisions of their own tax revenues even then they would not able to fulfill the promises made to the electorate and then invariably asked the union government to provide grants or special funds were underestimated by the author's article under review.


According to the report, titled “Central Transfers to States in India Rewarding Performance While Ensuring Equality” authored by economist M Govinda Rao “in 2012, there were 147 such schemes initiated by various Central ministries and many of them were directly implemented by numerous implementing agencies specifically created for the purpose and the grants were given to them directly bypassing the States.”


Whereas, at present, the union government provides funds to states through Centrally Sponsored Schemes (CSS) which has been effectively reduced to 28 schemes from 66 schemes including flagship schemes. The CSS has been rationalised based on the recommendations of the Sub-Group Report Submitted by the Chief Ministers in 2015. The implementation of CSS was mainly on key sectors of national importance because the state governments were strategically not giving due importance for the past many years.


Unlike in the past, States have more flexibility now to implement certain schemes as per the state-specific requirements with the check and balance systems. As many as 45 Central Sector schemes are implemented by States for specified purposes.


The article talks about the case of Tamil Nadu which took steps “to look at Centre-State fiscal relations and recommend more transfers and taxation powers for regional governments.” The point is well taken. One is tempted to ask why Tamil Nadu’s discom has been ranked as the top worst in the country for many years. Moreover, several state-owned public-sector enterprises continue to make a loss but are buried under the carpet from any reform steps. The author fails to heed some of these deeply poor governance structures.


Also, why the decentralisation of financial and administrative power is still not accorded to local bodies in Tamil Nadu? While its neighbours like Kerala and Karnataka have the best decentralised process of governance in the country despite the challenges of welfare politics and administrative misgovernance. Because the depth of the democratisation process has stopped in Tamil Nadu with power welded at the state capital even now by deep-rooted vested interests in anything and everything.


The fact that regional disparity emanates partly from the fact that the state capital power centre still refuses to transfer the democratic power to local bodies which are duly elected by the people for direct democracy with trusts. Moreover, what is the status of major state's State Finance Commissions are upto? Are they performing the requisite role of the state development and bridging the gaps of disparity like inequalities of rural-urban divide, disparities among intra regions, etc? It seems that not much attention is given either academically or in public policy discourse even in states like Tamil Nadu which is being branded as a developed state.


To sum up, it has been several months since Tamil Nadu’s 6th State Finance Commission report for the period of 2022-2029 was submitted to the state government, acceptance of its recommendations and timeline for implementations are yet to be known to the people. Strangely, the report is not even made public. This is the Dravidian model of governance. None of the academic or policy institutions will raise their voice against such poor governance because they will lose funding from the state government or be humiliated for their right to express in the interest of the public cause.


(The author is an economist and public policy expert)

Thursday, July 21, 2022

My public policy articles published Tamil over the last few months and more

 தமிழக பொருளாதாரமும், திமுக அரசு செய்ய மறுக்கும் சீர்திருத்தங்களும்




















My public policy articles published both in English and Tamil over the last few months and more

 ‘Tamil Nadu economy: Binging on borrowing’

‘  Tamil Nadu Defence Corridor a non-starter due to state govt’






Wednesday, February 10, 2021

Biodigester: An Antidote to Cities’ Septage Management Challenges

I have a new article on one of the underpinning cities of cities in India. It is even grave situation in state like Tamil Nadu.

Few years ago DRDO, GoI, had came out with a decentralized technology to address the septage waste management, despite its high potentials, this technology has not been revolutionized yet. This year Union Budget has also talked about it a bit.


This article explains the need for revolutionary of decentralized septage waste management with bio-digester technology,


Very few companies makes cost effective DRDO model bio-digester septage tanks with its technology, MAK India Limited is one such company which makes quality bio-digester with cost effective manner.

Thursday, October 8, 2020

Chakravarti Vijayaragavachariar – The Lion from The South!

I have new article in the Spontaneous Order Website of Centre for Civil Society, a classical liberal think tank in India. This is my nineteenth article on forgotten Indian liberal scholars and thinkers whom the left intellectuals were always treated as untouchables for well known reasons. These left leaning thinkers include economists, social scientists, etc. 

I have also published the same article in Tamil Magazine in this month edition here.

Mostly, it is not possible to get publish an article in more than one languages at a time.

"Vijayaraghavachariar supported the non-violent approach publicly. Lord Birkenhead, the Secretary of State of India had once stated that Indians were incapable of drafting their own constitution. Vijayaraghavachariar took up the challenge and prepared the Swaraj Constitution of India (1930). He wanted a strong central government and therefore had proposed a Unitary Constitution."

Tuesday, June 30, 2020

S Ambirajan’s forgotten classic `A Grammar of Indian Planning (1959)’


This is my second article on Prof.S.Ambirajan's liberal economic thoughts. His works are largely forgotten and conveniently neglected for decades in India. And the reasons are well known. 

A para from my second piece which was out yesterday in the Spontaneous Order website of Centre for Civil Society, New Delhi.

His observations on Prime Minister Nehru, who became a hero of Independent India, where even Patel and Rajaji were ignored, are perceptive indeed. “In a sense, our, Prime Minister, Jawaharlal Nehru, is our greatest asset, for while he enjoys the prestige and wields the authority of a dictator, he has also the emotional nuances and ready adaptability of a true democrat. Even as he is conscious of the possibilities of planning, he is not unwilling at the same time to acknowledge the limitations of democratic planning. But the Prime Minister is not the whole of the administration, and there is always the danger that circumstances may turn the best asset into a dangerous liability. The Prime Minister should be an example, not a glittering facade for others to hide behind and pursue their respective ends.”

Friday, June 26, 2020

Prof S Ambirajan – the forgotten liberal political economist (1936-2001)

                                      Photo by Dr Prema Nandakumar, sister of Prof S Ambirajan                                                     
This was my piece out few days ago on one of the greatest Indian political economists in the twentieth century.

Prof Ambirajan was a prolific writer for over four decades and published more than two dozen scholarly books and monographs, among other works, which were appreciated among renowned scholars across the world. He wrote hundreds of articles and columns in The Hindu and The Economic Times for several years. Sad to say, but his scholarly works have found more takers abroad than in his own country or state, where his papers have not been accorded the respect they deserve.


Monday, June 22, 2020

SV Chitti Babu, academician, educationist and reformer par excellence (1920-2020)


I had a piece on the great education thinker Prof SV.Chitti Babu in SO.

Prof Chitti Babu's pragmatic views and suggestions were welcomed by one and all, as they provided succour to everyone who sought help. The nonagenarian headed many committees and commissions, co-opting himself in the role of even a simple member in committees related to the education sector, both in Tamil Nadu and the national level.

Wednesday, June 17, 2020

Eminent Economist Prof. A.Vaidyanathan-1931-2020


On 10th June, eminent economist and Prof A.Vaidyanathan passed away at Coimbatore city in Tamil Nadu. 

He had professional career ranging from economic policy institute to government, academic teaching and research, and grass-rout movements for making difference in environment, rural livelihood etc. 

He was known for multi-facets of economics, in terms of his professional contribution to the areas such as policy research, empirical research studies, public policy, and a gamut of sectoral issues and challenges. 

He was moreover known as data driven economist of any sort, but the data must be the critical sources for any findings and inferences to be drawn upon it. 

The following are some of the obit articles and news items written by various people including some were close to him.


Business Today - Remembering India's Data Man- Prof Vaidyanathan

The Wire- someone knew him very closely 

Remembering A. Vaidyanathan, the Scholar Who Changed the Role of Data in India


  

Monday, June 8, 2020

Cho Ramaswamy: India’s classical satirist and liberal, 1934-2016


I have a new piece on "Cho Ramaswamy: India’s classical satirist and liberal, 1934-2016"

A slice from the piece"

"Cho Ramaswamy was a multi-faceted personality, a scholar, thinker and above all, a man opposed to the tyranny of Dravidian politics. He was among the few political analysts who had a fine balance of reason and logic. He used them to impact public policy with the help of humour, sarcasm and biting satire." 

Friday, May 15, 2020

Self-reliant India, as New Economic Model

Economist S Gurumuthy's analysis of Indian economy is always different and fascinating on many counts. In a recent Interview to a English magazine, he said:

"The illiterate economic thinkers and institutions in India, whose training is based on foreign ideas and theories, have not been able to come to terms with the diversity of India. The financial model applicable to listed companies is being thrust on the rest of the economy. The swadeshi approach calls for factoring in the diversities of India. Actually, jobs are provided only by the MSMEs which are the backbone of the economy. This was understood only after Modi constituted the Mudra finance plan. So jobs will be generated only through bottom upwards and top-down economic model which will suit only the cosmopolitan kind of society."

and on internal migration issues:

"This problem is there, but it is blown out of proportion. Let us look at the facts. There are 31 crore intra and interstate migrants in India according to 2011 census. Out of that 4.2 crores are interstate migrants. How many out of that are going back? Not even 10%. When you are planning a lockdown you cannot give two days or even ten days time for people to move. That would have led to chaos and stampede. Particularly when they did not know how long it would take to flatten the curve. So the migrant issue is a creation of the media and the opposition."

Wednesday, May 13, 2020

Forgotten Speeches of GK Sundaram – Part I

                                           GK Sundaram-1914-2009

I have piece on GK Sundaram's forgotten speeches delivered in Indian Parliament when he was leader of Swatantra Party during the socialist era of Indira Gandhi.

Here is a slice from the piece:

In August 1969, Sundaram suggested the following eight measures to the government for framing pragmatic policies towards economic growth and inclusive development:
“(1) First and foremost is payment by result in industrial, agricultural, private, public, Government and other fields. This alone can achieve the goal. You may verify that countries which have devalued have stabilised their economy by sheer work. By hard work only they have come up and not by just planning or by fooling the people. 
(2) A substantial reduction in taxation is absolutely necessary to rebuild the industrial development. 
(3) We do not want an Everest effort. An earnest effort is necessary in agricultural production which we never had all these 15 years. 
(4) We must create confidence and give opportunity for the people to invest in industry. 
(5) Then, industrial development should not be impeded by controls. We must be free from controls. 
(6) Industry must have adequate rupee finance. At least, if you cannot provide with your money, do not stop them from getting it. 
(7) Provide enough incentive for exports wherever it is found absolutely necessary. 
(8) And last of all, reduce your expenditure drastically, whether it is private or public sector, but never attempt deficit financing either openly or secretly. 
The strength of the currency ultimately depends upon the level and growth of production. Economic policies should be made liberal, planning realistic and administration efficient.”


Monday, May 11, 2020

Mariadas Ruthnaswamy: Liberal Educationalist, Statesman and Writer


My new piece on forgotten history of India liberalism and economic thoughts. The piece is about great liberal scholar Mariadas Ruthnasamy, who was nominated twice to Indian upper house of the parliament in the high days socialism in India in the 60s and 70s.

A slice from the piece:

"Throughout his life, Mariadas Ruthnaswamy championed the pivotal role of the principles of liberty, equality, and economic freedom. He was an untiring reader and authored several books wherein the assimilation of his thinking and mastery over the issues of India covering several centuries is truly mesmerizing. He was profoundly active with reading and writing even at the age of 92, days before his death in June 1977. Alas, many of his great works were consciously marginalised by propagandists even after the fact that he was a scholar from the minority community. His own community itself had treated his works as untouchable because he was a distinguished scholar and thinker of classical liberal principles."

Political Economy of Tamil Nadu

I have a new piece on political economy of Tamil Nadu and its high growth trajectory. A slice from the piece below:
 
"However, despite their divisive polity, a competitive spirit can be seen among the leaders across the political spectrum towards inclusive development and growth of Tamil Nadu. At times, it is astonishing to see a sustained progress of the Tamil Nadu economy compared to other states in India. What drives Tamil Nadu is its core competence and capacities of sectors like healthcare and nutrition, education and entrepreneurship which are the main ingredients of the State’s sustained high growth trajectory. The average growth rate in the two decades following liberalisation was 7 per cent per annum."

Wednesday, May 6, 2020

GA Natesan (1874-1949): Liberal Scholar and Publisher

I have a new piece on Indian economic thoughts, this piece is about life and works of G A Natesan (1874-1949). He was doyen of publisher of all kinds of works in Tamil languages and English during the British India. Moreover, he was liberal scholar and wrote several books and edited many besides editing the The Indian Review journal for five decades.

Here is a slice from the piece:

"In 1917, Natesan wrote a book on “What India Wants: Autonomy Within the Empire” presenting the case for liberty, freedom, self-government through constitutional reform and urged for providing opportunities to educated Indians in all branches of the British government. Gandhi, PS Sivasamy Aiyer, and VS Srinivasa Sastri wrote forewords to the book which presented with historical views of various Indian and British intellectuals who voiced for advancing the complete freedom from British for various countries including India. In the preface, GA Natesan noted that – “I have also endeavoured to show that the constitutional reforms now urged by the Indian people through their leading political organisations are in the line of continuous growth of the Indian polity and involve no violent departure from the principles or methods hitherto recognised by authority”. He believed that maintaining law and order, by all means, is a must for any government in society. Therefore he strongly opposed Gandhi for provoking the country towards civil disobedience movement." 


Tuesday, April 7, 2020

GK Sundaram: Swatantra’s Forgotten Tamil Leader

From my recent piece on GKSundaram (1914-2009), a tall classical liberal leader in Swatantra Party in Tamil Nadu:


"Rajaji had high regard for Sundaram’s leadership skills and abilities; thus, he was nominated as Swatantra Party Member to the Rajya Sabha and served from 1968 to 1974. As a member of Rajya Sabha, he actively participated in debates and contributed to the house from the perspectives of liberal principles. Sundaram’s speeches on deliberations on the Delhi Motor Vehicles Act, Gold Control Act, Nationalisation of Banks, Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices Act, The Essential Commodities Act, the Unlawful Activities Prevention Bill, etc. were noteworthy and made the government rethink its ill-conceived policies.
GK Sundaram argued that the Gold Control Act “would increase smuggling” and also eventually create “harm to internal security” which was witnessed later until the 1991 reforms. He also vehemently criticised the bank nationalisation. Regarding the MRTP Act, he said that the government aimed to merely to enforce the command and control without the view to provide economic freedom to produce more domestically. He had warned the Union Government that the MRTP Act “could cause a lot of hassles in the long run”, which indeed it did."

Sunday, April 5, 2020

The Forgotten Swatantra Party Leader in Tamil Nadu: G.K.Sundaram


Recently I read two articles on the Swatantra Party leader in Tamil Nadu GK Sundaram who was close associate of C.Rajagopalachari or Rajaji. These articles were published by Rajesh Govindarajulu in Simplycity Coimbatore.

The true history of Swatantra Party is yet to be written. Also the history of key leader of Tamil Nadu is also yet to be chronicled systematically. 

GK Sundaram's contribution to Swatantra Party in Tamil Nadu and national political economy is important but has been forgotten by all stakeholders.

Rajesh's two interesting articles are here and here.

Wednesday, March 4, 2020

Trichy’s Initiatives to Enhance Ease of Living

My new article discusses the challenges before the Trichy City Corporation in achieving the vision of ‘ease living for all’. It also sheds light on how a slew of innovative initiatives undertaken by it, involving citizens in most of the programmes, have yielded good results.

Thursday, February 27, 2020

PS Sivaswamy Aiyer: Forgotten Indian Liberal – Part II


This is my send piece on the great Classical Liberal of India PS Sivasamy Aiyer whose life and works are forgotten in his home country. He had interesting thoughts and views on Nehru and M.K Gandhi.

I conclude the piece with the below para:


"PS Sivaswamy Aiyer had maintained an extraordinary independent thinking and intellectual integrity throughout his public life. He was profound thinker and contributor towards the building of constitutional liberalism conceived in liberal principles. Thus, there is enormous scope to rewrite the history of pre-independent India with recounting the monumental contribution of liberal thinkers like Sivasamy Aiyer who have contributed significantly to the Indian liberalism."