Showing posts with label Indian States. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Indian States. Show all posts

Friday, December 16, 2022

India’s fiscal federalism is still evolving… by B. Chandrasekaran

 India’s fiscal federalism is still evolving… by B. Chandrasekaran

The article titled "The poor state of India's fiscal federalism by Kalaiyarasan. A" published in The Hindu on July 28, 2022, makes several sweeping statements without substantial data to prove on larger policy perspective and beyond taking the ideological position. The author’s statements cannot be taken as academic interest because it has public policy ramifications in many respects, mostly misleading.


At the outset, the article paints abjectly the state of India's fiscal federalism with allegations like the “centralisation of fiscal power”, “political centralisation” and "cultural nationalism", etc., especially since 2014. The pitch is set out very well before any data to substantiate for inferences to be drawn to conclude meaningfully.


One of the greatest economists of twentieth-century India was Dr. B.R.Ambedkar who never advocated for centralised planning or power centre except to protect the country's sovereignty by integrating the regional administrations as one country. Indeed, he always strived for decentralised planning for socio-economic development, and that dream is yet to be fulfilled in Independent India even after 75 years.


While the basic structure of India’s tryst with destiny was always found to be lubricated around conflict of visions with which the democracy unfolds and still drives for bettering. Alas, across the country, the autonomy of administrative power and devolution of financial power are yet to be transferred from State capitals to village panchayats and local bodies which rarely need now to make real growth centres across the country.


Interestingly, most seem to be forgotten now conveniently that unlike before 2014, no Chief Minister is visiting New Delhi now for approval of State’s Annual Plan budgetary provisions finalisation, including sectoral allocations, grants, etc. The Planning Commission structure was reformed with financial devolution power has been decentralised more now than in the past since independence.


The author’s statement “States lost their capacity to generate revenue by surrendering their rights in the wake of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) regime, their expenditure pattern too was distorted by the Union’s intrusion, particularly through its centrally sponsored schemes” is deeply flawed on many grounds.


A dynamic democracy like India had debated for a decade on a comprehensive indirect tax system and had powerfully exercised the tools of consensus building through political dialogs to align the states on their own will with facts and figures on the table at a common goal of the Goods and Services Tax system which may not be the perfect one but it was a fair beginning. The structure is still in evolving state with pros and cons to argue, but not to deny the fact that it can be done away with it completely.


For years, many states did not clean up their own awfully managed already fiscally stressed financial health and wasteful expenditures especially soon after the elections and just before the next elections on the lofty promises made to the electorate. When the states were having provisions of their own tax revenues even then they would not able to fulfill the promises made to the electorate and then invariably asked the union government to provide grants or special funds were underestimated by the author's article under review.


According to the report, titled “Central Transfers to States in India Rewarding Performance While Ensuring Equality” authored by economist M Govinda Rao “in 2012, there were 147 such schemes initiated by various Central ministries and many of them were directly implemented by numerous implementing agencies specifically created for the purpose and the grants were given to them directly bypassing the States.”


Whereas, at present, the union government provides funds to states through Centrally Sponsored Schemes (CSS) which has been effectively reduced to 28 schemes from 66 schemes including flagship schemes. The CSS has been rationalised based on the recommendations of the Sub-Group Report Submitted by the Chief Ministers in 2015. The implementation of CSS was mainly on key sectors of national importance because the state governments were strategically not giving due importance for the past many years.


Unlike in the past, States have more flexibility now to implement certain schemes as per the state-specific requirements with the check and balance systems. As many as 45 Central Sector schemes are implemented by States for specified purposes.


The article talks about the case of Tamil Nadu which took steps “to look at Centre-State fiscal relations and recommend more transfers and taxation powers for regional governments.” The point is well taken. One is tempted to ask why Tamil Nadu’s discom has been ranked as the top worst in the country for many years. Moreover, several state-owned public-sector enterprises continue to make a loss but are buried under the carpet from any reform steps. The author fails to heed some of these deeply poor governance structures.


Also, why the decentralisation of financial and administrative power is still not accorded to local bodies in Tamil Nadu? While its neighbours like Kerala and Karnataka have the best decentralised process of governance in the country despite the challenges of welfare politics and administrative misgovernance. Because the depth of the democratisation process has stopped in Tamil Nadu with power welded at the state capital even now by deep-rooted vested interests in anything and everything.


The fact that regional disparity emanates partly from the fact that the state capital power centre still refuses to transfer the democratic power to local bodies which are duly elected by the people for direct democracy with trusts. Moreover, what is the status of major state's State Finance Commissions are upto? Are they performing the requisite role of the state development and bridging the gaps of disparity like inequalities of rural-urban divide, disparities among intra regions, etc? It seems that not much attention is given either academically or in public policy discourse even in states like Tamil Nadu which is being branded as a developed state.


To sum up, it has been several months since Tamil Nadu’s 6th State Finance Commission report for the period of 2022-2029 was submitted to the state government, acceptance of its recommendations and timeline for implementations are yet to be known to the people. Strangely, the report is not even made public. This is the Dravidian model of governance. None of the academic or policy institutions will raise their voice against such poor governance because they will lose funding from the state government or be humiliated for their right to express in the interest of the public cause.


(The author is an economist and public policy expert)

Friday, June 26, 2020

Imperatives for Power Sector Reforms in Tamil Nadu

This is my piece on reforms of power sector in Tamil Nadu and its political economics. 

I have concluded the piece with the below para:

"To make the State power sector commercially viable and more sustainable for all stakeholders, the concessions enjoyed by the industry have to be revised on priority. Otherwise, TANGEDCO would become bankrupt and cause problems for all customers. Therefore, the State must take up reforms in the power sector and strengthen them for sustaining an efficient and competitive economy."

Saturday, March 29, 2014

Free the market in Indian agriculture sector

Very insightful thoughts from Ashok Gulati. Many interesting things he shares with BS. I did met him in one of the conference in Delhi recently. Inf act, he had shared most the following things in that talk he gave:

  • "export controls is one way of taxing the peasantry by suppressing prices"
  • “The problem is the government is trying to achieve equity through price policy and not using income policy, so you have massive misallocations. This is how Soviet Russia collapsed. We need to get out of this socialist mindset and allow markets to function,”
  • “This is the area where the second Green Revolution is supposed to happen. It was a bumper year, but you had export controls so you didn’t allow foodgrain to go out, you restrict the private sector domestically, plus you are not procuring. So the market collapsed for farmers in Bihar. Yet you are procuring from Punjab, which earns Rs 4,000 crore extra by charging a tax of 14.5%, what the heck!”
  • “He said, ‘Tumne saare desh ka theka le rakha hai? [are you responsible for the whole country?] The government has made you a chairman. Enjoy life’.”
  • He found Agriculture Minister Sharad Pawar “progressive, more market oriented than other ministers and with a broad vision.”
  • “Well, the food minister wanted to protect consumers, the agriculture minister the farmer. Each ministry works in a silo, so, really, it is for the prime minister to take a call. That’s when you need a leader.”
  • “Vajpayee didn’t say much but he listened. Once, there was a discussion on deficit financing and Montek talked about how we need to disinvest in Maruti, Ashoka Hotel and so on. Vajpayee’s response was, ‘Bawaal khada ho jayega’ [it will become a problematic issue]. Yet, 15 days later, that’s exactly what the government announced. That’s leadership.” 

Tuesday, June 25, 2013

Some links

Very interesting interview by Goa Chief Minister particularly his views about Gujarat Chief Minister is very candid and fairly well said arguments.

In the beginning, a National Democratic Front

Mating as marriage' judgment is a shocker

A bit from this article A 10-step programme to tap India’s enormous potential:

  • Last week, I made a quick visit to see the chief minister of Gujarat,Narendra Modi. He’d asked me to give a presentation on how India could realize its still-enormous potential. I went through points I’d first discussed in a paper I co-wrote with Tushar Poddar in 2008:Ten Things for India to Achieve its 2050 Potential. It’s striking to me that, five years later, our recommendations don’t need revising (They do need elaborating, and I’ll get into more detail in an updated study and further columns. Modi and I are planning a conference of experts before the end of this year).
  • I’ll state no opinion on Modi’s chances of becoming prime minister after next year’s general election—it has been announced that he’ll lead the opposition Bharatiya Janata Party’s (BJP’s) campaign. He’s a controversial figure. Detractors call him a sectarian extremist. I will say this: He’s good on economics, and that’s one of the things India desperately needs in a leader.

Wednesday, June 5, 2013

Nehruvian condescension

Good friend Harsh has great article in today's Livemint newspaper. A bit from the piece:
  • "It is a construct that manufactures distrust in society and encourages Indians to be suspicious of each other because the state emphasizes our differences, rather than our common heritage, while making us compete for goods and services for which an artificial shortage is created by faulty economic policies. "
 

Wednesday, May 1, 2013

"Economic reforms are very important for creation of wealth"

The below is a bit from the interview of Mr.Chandrababu Naidu, former Chief Minister of Andhra Pradesh:
After losing two elections, are you regretting the economic reforms you initiated ? 
No. I have no regrets. In hindsight, I think I should have gone with reforms carefully, in phases. Had I done so, the state would have been on a different footing altogether by now. Today both people are suffering and I am also suffering. I am now making extra efforts to educate the public about my policies. 
So you are not going to give up on economic reforms, right? 
Economic reforms are very important for creation of wealth. I am conscious now of the importance of taking the benefits of such economic reforms to the common man. We have to balance between reforms and their benefits. Otherwise there is no meaning for economic reforms. 

Interesting reading

Why Indian economy slowed? 

Dr. Bhim Rao Ambedkar had cautioned us in his speech on November 4, 1948, delivered in the Constituent Assembly that: “The form of the administration must be appropriate to and in the same sense as the form of the Constitution ... [It] is perfectly possible to pervert the Constitution, without changing its form by merely changing the form of the administration and to make it inconsistent and opposed to the spirit of the Constitution … Constitutional morality is not a natural sentiment. It has to be cultivated. We must realise that our people have yet to learn it.” More here.


"A laissez faire economy is characterized by the absence of non-market pressures such as taxes, subsidies, tariffs, though the very definition of a free market economy has been the subject of vociferous debate. In a free market/economy, individuals are free to contract, where the only regulations, in theory, would be to safeguard against coercion and theft. Certain economists have postulated that competition would thrive in a free market economy, perhaps even through a praxeological approach. However, given the different theoretical models of free-market economies and the opposing practical reality(ies); class differences, income inequities and the resultant dominating powers do allow for a powerful class to emerge and skew market conditions through monopolies and the abuse of dominant positions." More here.

Saturday, March 16, 2013

Learn TRUTH from good people

We need to think over what Gujarat Chief Minister says. A bit from his lecture today at India Today Conclave:
  • "After inaugurating Ashoka Hotel in Delhi, Nehru came to Parliament and said 'I am very happy that I inaugurated this hotel today'. To this, Atal Behari Vajpayee, then a young leader, said 'this is the saddest day in my life when the prime minister inaugurates a hotel instead of a hospital': 
  • Govt has no business to do business, Modi says disapproving the role of PSUs.
  • We are wasting our youth power and our women power. We need to pay attention to that.
  • Why can't our rail infrastructure be manufactured privately? 
  • The biggest strength of democracy is its grievance redressal system
  • The country does not need Act (legislation). It needs action
  • Once I was with the PM. He didn't say anything. So I started speaking. What else could I have done"

Tuesday, January 29, 2013

The State of Indian State

This is a very interesting analysis about the functions of Indian State in the modern era. You can agree or disagree, everyone of us are looking at The State with some special attention musing that IT CAN DO EVERYTHING FOR US! 

The following few para are from a article by Dr Mehta. There is also a interesting lecture titled The Burden of Democracy – India After 65 Years by him. The video is here.

"The architecture of the Indian state is now being seriously contested. Indian practices of exercising power were founded on six principles that are no longer tenable."
  • " The first principle was vertical accountability. To be held accountable meant being held accountable by your superiors, not by citizens or other parts of the system. So long as the powers that be did not ask questions, did not prosecute or pursue you, no one else did. This is slowly beginning to change. There are potentially a lot more sites for horizontal accountability within the state. But most importantly, there is a clamour to be held accountable to citizens, not just in some diffuse way through elections, but in terms of the services the state provides."
  • " The second principle was relative secrecy. The state had a great informational advantage over citizens in two senses. The state’s own inner workings were relatively secret. And the state was a primary source of information about our well-being. Both those propositions are no longer true. It would be foolish for any state to now assume that its legitimacy can rest on keeping secrets. But perhaps more importantly, citizens craft a sense of well-being through information outside of the state. A couple of decades ago, you may not have known your water or air was poisoned because the state did not tell you."
  • "The third principle of state power was wide discretion. To a degree, all states require discretionary power. But they need to justify its use through an exercise of public reason, where those reasons take into account all stakeholders. In every major decision the government has been involved in, whether allocating spectrum or land, siting SEZs or designing water schemes, it has failed to engage in public reason. It assumed it could get away with shoddy justifications for its actions." 
  • "The fourth principle of the state was relative centralisation. Despite the fact that you have so many regional parties that share power, India remains one of the most administratively centralised states in the world. The degree of centralisation, where the Planning Commission micromanages every small rule associated with a centrally sponsored scheme with tragically perverse effects, is untenable in a society as vibrant and complex as India. Local bodies, whether urban or rural, are still not seen as instruments of self-government, as institutions that will resolve local conflicts."

Thursday, August 23, 2012

Not a bad idea

"The major problem with many micro issues is that these are under the jurisdiction of states. Each state has its own peculiarities and contours that vary according to the leader in charge. One way forward is to establish a non-partisan Chief Ministers' Governance Forum, as advocated by former Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayeein 2002, which can offer a structured platform for exchange of experiences of successes and failures. In our own experience comparativeness exchanges help hugely." More here.

Thursday, August 2, 2012

Feeding POWER and Friedman on India

Interesting reading:

There is a interesting lines in one of Prof Milton Friedman's article which blinks the current political situation of Indian polity. Here is the lines from his 1999 article "No Third way to the market":

  • Today, the "market" is said to be either utterly triumphant or a grave threat. Politicians everywhere quest for a "third way" around its rigors, yearning for "national champions" in industries like telecoms capable of holding off globalization. The market, however, is simply a mechanism that can be mobilized for any number of purposes. Depending on the way it is used, the market may contribute to social and economic development or inhibit it.
In the same article Friedman explains the bicycle industry's in Punjab in India:
  • In India's Punjab there was a plant producing bicycles. Government rationed steel to users rather than selling it at a market price. The bicycle producer could not get the amount of steel needed at the official price. However, there was a private market in finished or unfinished steel products. So the bicycle manufacturer supplemented his rations through buying semifinished steel products and melting them down - hardly an efficient way to convert iron ore and coal into bicycles.
Read from a Focal Point for Friedman @ 100 a list of very interesting articles by Friedman. 

Monday, May 7, 2012

Rules for caste

  • "Too many empirical facts about Gujarati history, society, culture, politics and economics challenge the schizophrenic discourse that is for or against Modi, and remains fixated either on the abyss of 2002 or on the myth of “Swarnim Gujarat”." 
  • "It is difficult to imagine Indian academia, particularly the study of politics in India since the 1960s, without a number of Gujarati scholars, activists and public intellectuals. Rajni Kothari, D.L. Sheth, Ghanshyam Shah, Bhikhu Parekh, Meghnad Desai, Achyut Yagnik, Asgar Ali Engineer, I.P. Desai, A.M. Shah, Girish Patel, Teesta Setalvad and Tridip Suhrud, among others constitute a proud roster of some of the best minds and the most ethical, proactive citizens of the past half-century. The cliché is that the Bengalis, the Maharashtrians and the South Indians dominate the post-colonial Indian academy, but look carefully, and you will find that Gujarat has a more than robust representation. If we go back a generation or two, we are looking at Mahatma Gandhi, Sardar Patel, Mohammed Ali Jinnah and K.M. Munshi — figures who played such an enormous role in our politics that we cannot account for our modernity without them". More here.
  • "Nehru was a great man but his many small mistakes have harmed the country to this day". More here.

Monday, April 16, 2012

Calcutta into London

A resident of calcutta writes in "....let me tell you how the last four British prime ministers have been portrayed in cartoons in London newspapers: John Major, always wearing his underpants outside his trousers; Tony Blair, as a one-eyed monster, sometimes as a one-eyed poodle trotting after George W. Bush; Gordon Brown, as a square, financial thug and bouncer; David Cameron, repeatedly, as an empty, blown-up condom. Along with these, they have also repeatedly had George Bush as a rampant, psychopathic chimpanzee, (once actually wiping his bottom with the UN logo), they’ve had Nicolas Sarkozy as all sorts of ferret-like animals, Berlusconi as a lecherous octopus and, recently, Angela Merkel as a dominatrix in skimpy black leather costume and fishnet stockings, wielding a financial whip over the exposed backsides of other European leaders. Besides this, one of the most widely read British satirical magazines, Private Eye, almost always has actual photographs of leaders and royalty with fictional speech bubbles coming out of their mouths, saying the most outrageous things. Let me tell you, no one has ever sued about these portrayals, no one is beaten up, no one is arrested, no one even lodges a written protest."

Sunday, April 8, 2012

Interesting readings

  1. New socialism in Uttar Pradesh of India
  2. The world of Masanis:  Minoo Masani, as we all know, began his political career with strong socialist leanings, only to abandon it in the wake of communist totalitarianism. He then became among the early champions of the Swatantra Party (India’s only true liberal party ever), opposing tooth and nail Jawaharlal Nehru’s socialist policies. He finally settled with the anti-Indira Gandhi post-Emergency coalition, only to be finally disillusioned with active politics. His personal life was no less troubled, spanning relationships with various women, which did not end with his third marriage (to Shakuntala, the author’s mother). 
  3. A shoebox of ashes; 
  4. "My father's role as the founder leader of Swatantra Party, India's first serious parliamentary Opposition, is well known; and it is ironical that our present Prime Minister Manmohan Singh acknowledges Minoo Masani as his main ideological inspiration, rather than Pandit Nehru," the London-based Zareer writes. 




  5. Dangerous lies by Tavleen Singh: Ms Roy was among a handful of privileged Indians who inhabited a tiny oasis of prosperity in an ocean of desperate poverty. She taught aerobics at the Taj Palace in Delhi and made forgettable films with silly names. As one of the people in her aerobics class, I had opportunity to converse with Ms Roy often and remember her as being astoundingly apolitical. She appears to have developed her whole political philosophy after becoming a celebrated novelist (ex-novelist?) and has a very limited understanding of economic and political issues.

Sunday, March 25, 2012

Another vote motive

The imbecile is talking about striking balance of federalism in India. Why can't the Union Government better manage the national security first and leave all else to State Governments?

The DNA newspaper chief editor Mr Aditya says, rightly, that:
  • "No governance means that citizens will be spared large social expenditures such as the farmers’ loan waiver or the proposed food security bill or other such plans which are basically meant to bribe a section of voters. No governance means that we will not suffer crony capitalism such as the gifting away of land or coal or gas or other natural resources to big industrialists in an opaque and suspect manner. No governance means less chance of a scam, now that everyone is breathing down the government’s neck, ready to whip out a draft CAG report when there’s a whiff of graft or pestering it for a Lokpal bill."

Tuesday, December 27, 2011

Lessons for Lokpal, from Karnataka Lokayukta


The following are a excerpt from the article by Narayana A., Sudhir Krishnaswamy and Vikas Kumar (faculty at Azim Premji University, Bangalore):
  • …..between 1995 and 2011, Karnataka’s Lokayukta carried out only 357 suo motu raids against individual officials but received and responded to over 2,159 complaints against 2,681 officials (and 59 private persons). In other words, for every six cases investigated in response to citizen complaints, only one is initiated by the department suo motu. 

  • Institutional leadership is seen to have a significant impact on the agency’s performance as more than 66 per cent of the raid cases were initiated between 2006 and 2011, when Justice Santosh Hegde was the Lokayukta.
  • A department-wise analysis of prosecution of corruption by the Karnataka Lokayukta reveals that more than 80 per cent of the trap cases are related to four essential functions of government: local government (24.06 per cent), administration (37.65 per cent), welfare (17.61 per cent) and regulation (2.54 per cent). The rest of the cases are divided between agriculture and irrigation (3.76 per cent) and economic activities (12.75 per cent). Analysis of raid cases reveals a similar departmental distribution.

  • In Karnataka, nearly half of the officials against whom Lokayukta has proceeded against are officials in the lower bureaucratic scale while about 10 per cent are senior officials. Only 0.8 per cent belong to the IAS, IPS, IFS and KAS cadres. 
  • The core of the problem for the Karnataka Lokayukta is the criminal trial, over which it has little control. Over 95 per cent of the cases in which charge sheets have been filed are under trial. The cases under trial are, on an average, more than five years old. In any event, only 16 cases overall have resulted in convictions. This is a conviction rate of 20 per cent of completed cases and a small fraction of pending cases. This is much lower than the rate of convictions in criminal prosecutions in anti-corruption cases in India in recent years, which is between 34 and 40 per cent. Hence, the key problem at the core of a criminal conviction model for tackling corruption in India is the trial stage.

Wednesday, November 23, 2011

Break for better governance, rule of law and economic freedom II

There are interesting confrontation on breaking larger states into smaller one in India. I am not taking about the current confrontation which is surely at the misplaced one, I am referring the confrontations prevailed between and among the founding fathers of this nation. Some excerpts from the B R Ambedkar's views on Rajaji.


From Linguism trap by A G Noorani.

  • The other disclosure is far more startling. C. Rajagopalachari, better known as Rajaji, had, in a press statement issued on November 26, 1955, said, “If it is impossible to put the States Reorganisation Schemes in cold storage for the next 15 years, the only alternative is for the Centre to govern India as a unitary State and deal with district officers and district boards directly, with regional Commissioner’s supervision. It would be utterly wrong to fritter away national energy in dispute over boundaries and divisions conceived in the drawing room and not on the background of conditions that have resulted historically.

  • “Apart from the general convictions of mine, I feel that a large southern State is absolutely essential for preserving the political significance of that part of the country. To cut the South up into Tamil, Malayalam, and other small States will result only in complete insignificance of everybody and, in the net result, India as a whole will be the power.”
  • Commenting on this, Ambedkar wrote “Mr. Rajagopalachari has not expressed himself fully. He did so fully and openly to me when he was the Head of the State and I was the Law Minister in charge of drafting the Constitution. I went to Mr. Rajagopalachari for my usual interview which was the practice of the day. At one such interview Mr. Rajagopalachari, referring to the sort of constitution which the Constituent Assembly was making, said to me, ‘You are committing a great mistake. One federation for the whole of India with equal representation for all areas will not work. In such a federation the Prime Minister and President of India will always be from the Hindi speaking area. You should have two Federations, one Federation of the North and one Federation of the South and a Confederation of the North and the South with three subjects for the Confederation to legislate upon and equal representation for both the federations.’
  • “These are the real thoughts of Mr. Rajagopalachari. They came to me as a revelation coming as they did from the innermost heart of a Congressman. I now regard Mr. Rajagopalachari as a prophet predicting the break-up of India into the North and the South. We must do everything to falsify Mr. Rajagopalachari’s prophecy.” That has been accomplished by Indian nationalism.