Showing posts with label P. R. Brahmananda. Show all posts
Showing posts with label P. R. Brahmananda. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 18, 2011

From an article published on Oct 16, 2002 in FE

Full article is here.

  • It is indeed sad that most Indian economists still believe in the Keynesian analysis that recessions are caused by insufficiency of demand and that the solution is a fiscal stimulus. Indian economists — barring Brahmananda and perhaps Surjit Bhalla — are totally oblivious to the Austrian business cycle theory, best articulated by Hayek. According to Hayek, recessions are brought about by excess supply, which is brought about by overinvestment. Each boom contains the seeds of the subsequent recession and each recession, the seeds of the subsequent boom. Readers would do well to study the above-mentioned Economist special issue which succinctly explains the Hayekian analysis (pages 8-9).
  • Hayek argues that if central banks hold interest rates below the equilibrium rate (that is, the rate at which the supply of savings equals the demand for investment funds), credit and investment would rise too rapidly and there would be a shortage of savings. Cheap credit and inflated profit expectations cause overinvestment and malinvestment in the wrong kind of sectors. Eventually, the mismatch between savings and investment can be resolved only by a rise in interest rates, making some investments unprofitable. Excess capacity will reduce profits and lead to investment collapses, ushering in a recession. As excess capacity is cut, profits rise and investment eventually recovers.
  • According to this analysis, the only way to prevent the turn of the cycle is to inject more credit which becomes unsustainable. A recession is not only inevitable, but necessary to correct the imbalance between saving and investment. The Economist argues that recent business cycles in the US and Japan have typical Hayekian features. The right policy response is to raise interest rate well before the boom spins into a downturn. But if inflation is low, central banks are reluctant to raise interest rates and as the cost of capital is way below the expected return, there is a surge in credit and investment to unsustainable levels. It is overinvestment which causes the return on capital to decline. The Hayekian analysis would point to the repeated easing of interest rates to be wrong as it merely delays the correction of past excesses.
  • Sir John Hicks,as far back as 1966, argued that developing countries typically fit into the Hayekian overinvestment mode. A recession is necessary to work off an imbalance between too much investment and too little saving. The moral is that injecting created money and lowering interest rates only delays the cleansing process. The output losses would be much less if central banks prevent the boom from reaching unsustainable levels by a timely increase in interest rates when growth rate and investment goes into an unsustainable upswing. Monetary policy is most effective when it cools the overheating; it is totally impotent during the downturn of activity. Lowering interest rates would be ineffective and only delay the adjustment.

Monday, August 24, 2009

Ramachandra Guha’s bad understanding about F A Hayek!

Mr Ramachandra Guha had written something on F A Hayek in his book “India After Gandhi” published in 2007. It has some nasty view on Professor F.A.Hayek!

In way I’m astonished to see such a comment on Professor F. A. Hayek who made many discoveries in Economics. I’m very sad to see the following paragraph from the book in page number 221:

  • “….there were dissenters. In the West there was Friedrich Hayek, who advocated a retreat of the state from economic activity. His ideas, however, were treated with benign –and sometimes not-so- benign –contempt. (He could not even get a position in the Department of Economics in the University of Chicago, being placed instead in the ‘Committee on Social Thought.’)”

Why one need to be a professor of university to make a debate? Why everybody need to be a professor of particular university?

Of course I can not compare with anyone but take for example:

Montek Singh Ahluwalia and Suman K. Bery never had a PhD degree nor taught any university! In fact Mr Bery has been exposing as a PhD holder for sometime. Don’t you think these people are not writing, debating on social and economic issues?

I have read many of Professor F A Hayek writings including the most important one http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Use_of_Knowledge_in_Society

The younger generations choose ideas based on the well know teachers, writers, leaders, etc and most importantly people who have commented honestly and rightly.

How do you know he or she writes honestly?

If you read carefully and keep on observing any persons works defiantly one can figure out what he or she is talking about.

Way back in 2002 Anand Chandavarkar reviewed a book Friedrich Hayek (A Biography) by Alan Ebenstein in the EPW (19 January). Anand’s review is titled as “Did Hayek Deserve the Nobel Prize?”. From the title alone you can think what kind of review this guy going to give for readers certainly I’m not shocked in way because many in Indian academic community did not want to see some ideas at all.

When I heard first about this article I felt what nonsense. But certainly there was a another professor quite shockingly the Indian professor late P R Brahmananda wrote a short commentary (Hayek’s Nobel Prize) such a beautifully in the EPW on 9 February 2002 .

I will take you to some of interesting paras:

  • "I be permitted to point out a few of Hayek’s contributions, mostly in money and capital theory, which are deemed as sufficiently original to make him richly deserve the Nobel Prize in economics
  • There is no such thing as a general price level, since different sets of prices do not all move together at the same rate and in the same direction; he distinguished between the prices of consumption goods and the prices of capital goods and works in process; the process of excessive credit expansion leading to a lower rate of interest than otherwise would lead to a shift in the allocation of resources between consumption goods and capital goods.
  • The relative prices of the former will fall and the relative prices of the latter will go up. Similarly, when the credit flow becomes more scarce than otherwise, the rate of interest will become higher than otherwise and this will lead to a relative reduction in the prices of capital goods and a relative rise in the prices of consumption goods.
  • When the quantity of money increases or decreases due to excessive credit expansion or credit contraction, the time structure of production gets disturbed and changes towards processes involving a greater distance of time between primary inputs and consumption goods when the interest rate is artificially lowered and changes towards processes involving a shorter distance of time between primary inputs and consumption goods when the rate of interest is artificially raised.
  • The role of money when it is excessive or deficient is to tilt the rate of interest from its natural level and to cause elongation and shortenings of the time structure of production; hence, money’s neutrality towards the choice between production processes of different time lengths between inputs and consumption goods is disturbed.
  • Hayek was among the first to emphasise the saving in potential transaction costs to society emerging from decentralised decision-making. No central authority can have the knowledge and information available to myriad micro units in an economy. Hence, from an efficiency angle, central planning with a totalitarian approach can make errors in choices in production including in investments.
  • Hayek’s concept of competition as a process and not as an equilibrium is a very important contribution by itself.
  • May I also mention that Hayek’s name is associated with that of the distinguished psychologist Hebb in the matter of external impulses/stimuli/ shocks, etc, affecting the nerves in the brain which tend to store and use such information. Thus the link between external environment and the internal working of the nervous system in the brain is supposed to have been first perceived by Hayek and his name is prominent in the world of modern psychology."