Showing posts with label Sudha Shenoy and B R Shenoy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sudha Shenoy and B R Shenoy. Show all posts

Thursday, November 23, 2023

Classical economist B R Shenoy warned Sri Lanka in the 1960s

Classical economist B R Shenoy warned Sri Lanka in the 1960s when the country started its first IMF program after printing money (mostly for rural credit re-finance), not to engage in revenue based fiscal consolidation, which he called a ‘statistical alternative of balancing the budget’.


“This alternative is beset with pitfalls,” Shenoy warned in a report commissioned by ex-President J R Jayewardena.


“Past experience in Ceylon, which is in line with experience in virtually all parts of the world, is that in a democratic set up political and other pressures are heavily on the side of more and more spending by the government.


“When Revenues increase, under the weight of these pressures, expenditures too increase to meet, or even exceed, Revenue collections. In Ceylon during the past seven years Revenues rose by 45 per cent and Expenditures charged to Revenues by 48 per cent.”


From December 2014 to November 2019 tax revenues went up 65 percent to 1,612 billion rupees and recurrent spending went up 55 percent to 2,053 billion rupees, before taxes were cut in December to target ‘potential output’.


Revenue based fiscal consolidation, which is in line with a ‘heedless spending’ ideology that emerged among English speaking academics (US ‘progressives’ or post-Keynesians) combined with nationalized central banks, led to a spike in spending to GDP as salaries and subsidies were hiked with no restraint from 2015.


More here.

Prof B R Shenoy is still deemed too dangerous to be taught widely.

A quote from Sanjeev Sanyal:


"The Left dominance over the intellectual establishment has its roots in the systematic “ethnic cleansing” of all non-Left thinkers since the 1950s. One of its early victims was liberal economist B.R. Shenoy who questioned Nehru’s economics. He was squeezed out of the establishment and persecuted, but continued to write against socialist planning. ... The result of the systematic cleansing was that there were no non-Left academics remaining in the social sciences field in India by the early 1990s. ... Since the 1990s, the more explicitly Soviet-derived material has been removed from curriculums, but they remain heavily dominated by the Left. Thus, economics students are mostly taught material written by Amartya Sen and his stable of academics but exposed only in passing to the thoughts of Friedrich Hayek, Milton Friedman or Jagdish Bhagwati, Sen’s intellectual rival. Even when non-Left thinkers are included, their ideas are lumped together as exotic curiosities to be critiqued, rather than imbibed. Shenoy is still deemed too dangerous to be taught widely. The situation is much worse in other disciplines like sociology and history."

More reading see here.

Tuesday, November 12, 2019

Free Market Economist Prof B.R. Shenoy and German Socialism

The thirty years After Fall of The Berlin Wall is now a major debate around the world. The main comparison being made by many are on socialism vs capitalism, the free market capitalism. It is interesting that the Indian free market economist Prof B.R.Shenoy's article has been widely referred on the east Germany vs western Germany.  Prof Shenoy wrote a article titled "East and West Berlin: A Study in Free vs. Controlled Economy" on August 15, 1960 issue of The Indian Libertarian.

The following are some excerpts of article referred by different writers on the eve of thirty years Fall of The Berlin Wall:


From Rep. French Hill: 30 years after the fall of the Berlin Wall, America can't repeat East Germany's mistakes


An economist from India, B.R. Shenoy, had a first-hand look at the difference between the east and the west. In a 1960 article, Shenoy documented, “The main thoroughfares of West Berlin are near jammed with prosperous looking automobile traffic, the German make of cars, big and small, being much in evidence. ... The departmental stores in West Berlin are cramming with wearing apparel, other personal effects and a multiplicity of household equipment, temptingly displayed.”
Like my visits to East Berlin in 1986, Shenoy continues, “Food shops in East Berlin exhibit cheap articles in indifferent wrappers or containers and the prices for comparable items, despite the poor quality, are noticeably higher than in West Berlin. ... Visiting East Berlin gives the impression of visiting a prison camp.”

From "30 Years After The Fall Of The Berlin Wall, Socialism Is Staging A Comeback"

B.R. Shenoy, a prominent economist in India, noticed the significant differences of the two economic models in the divided city of Berlin in as early as 1960. He observed that in West Berlin, “Rebuilding is virtually complete…The main thoroughfares of West Berlin are near jammed with prosperous looking automobile traffic, the German make of cars, big and small… The departmental stores in West Berlin are cramming with wearing apparel, other personal effects and a multiplicity of household equipment, temptingly displayed.” 

In contrast, when Shenoy went to East Berlin, he saw “a good part of the destruction still remains; twisted iron, broken walls and heaped up rubble are common enough sights… Buses and trams dominate the thoroughfares in East Berlin; other automobiles, generally old and small cars, are in much smaller numbers than in West Berlin… The food shops in East Berlin exhibit cheap articles in indifferent wrappers or containers and the prices for comparable items, despite the poor quality, are noticeably higher than in West Berlin.”
Interestingly, if we leave the specification of location in this paragraph blank, what Sheony observed could have been replaced by any socialist countries mirroring the same scene, whether of China in the 1970s, or Venezuela in 2010. Socialism consistently produces similar devastating results, no matter where it has been attempted.
Shenoy wasn’t the only one who noticed the drastically distinct economic situations of East and West Germany in 1960. People in East Germany were aware of their poverty and political oppression, in contrast to the freedom and prosperity their families and friends enjoyed in West Germany since as early as the 1950s. East Germans wanted out.

Wednesday, July 10, 2019

BR Shenoy’s Early Life and Association with Independence Movement and Dissent Note

In the below videos, Prof BR Shenoy's son Prof Subodh R Shenoy explains about his father's early journey into freedom movement, early education and landing at LSE to study under Prof FA Hayek. 


According to Centre for Civil Society, New Delhi "B.R. Shenoy is the only Indian economist to write a note of dissent to the second Five Year Plan. Why did Shenoy, India's first monetary economist, think that “the only hope of eradication of corruption on the current scale is a complete U-turn in our policies”

BR Shenoy - A Prophet Without Honour?



Prof BR Shenoy - A Prophet Without Honour? in his own country!


Prof Subodh R Shenoy who is a son of Indian free market economist Prof B R Shenoy who thundered the socialist planned economy of early 50, 60 and 70s.

Prof Subodh interestingly explains in this video produced by free market and public policy institute in India, Centre for Civil Society, New Delhi.

Several years ago I had published a long essay about Prof B R Shenoy's works in Mises Institute's Blog.

Monday, August 11, 2014

The unheeded lesson from BR Shenoy


The IIM-Bangalore Professor Vivek Moorthy has written wonderful piece on Professor B R Shenoy in today's FE. Its must read article all. He starts his piece with the below lines:

  • "In the aftermath of finance minister Arun Jaitley’s maiden Budget, our policymakers would do well to read and reflect upon the writings and policy recommendations of BR Shenoy (1905-1978). Most readers of this newspaper—or other papers, for that matter—are not likely to have heard of his name. Indeed, the same would apply to economics students and even to many economists in India."

Thursday, January 9, 2014

Professor Bhagwati's Poor Economics!

During the debate on Sen vs Bhagwati, I uttered to a friend that I am not big fan of Professor Bhagwati. I could not give him a good solid reference, but here goes:

For all those Indian liberals especially my generation I wanted to inform them what Prof.Bhagwati said about Prof B R Shenoy (1905-1978). While reviewing Shenoy's book (Indian economic policy, 1968) in the Economic Journal in 1969 (
Vol. 79, No. 315 (Sep).

Prof Bhagwati said:

"his overall view of Indian economic policies is flawed seriously by his antipathy to planning per se"

Bhagwati also did not agree on Shenoy's criticism about foreign aid. 


This is what Bhagwati said about Shenoy on foreign aid:

"his unfortunate tendency to condemn foreign aid (which he shrewdly sees as making the expansion of the public sector relatively more rapid and easy) for the wrong reasons."


Some people argues that Prof.Bhagwati might be too young and have changed his views about Shenoy in later years but that seems not very clear. When Bhagwati wrote the above lines, he was about 35 year old and was educated in England and USA. It seems to be that he was like any other typical persons who had views of mainstream economists.

What I wanted to say is that we should not forget these facts while crediting for his good old ideas of advocating for globalization, liberalization, free trade etc. Even he changes his views about Shenoy, it is still important for me to judge him his economic thoughts. We know he was one of economic adviser to Indira Gandhi in the 60s. "Mrs. Gandhi followed the advice of her economic advisers, including Bhagwati, and devalued the currency, with all its attendant complications".

Another point is that while Bibek Debroy accuses Manmohan Singh for coining the Garibi Hatao slogan for Indira Gandhi, why not for Bhagwati for his role in devaluing the rupee in Indira Gandhi's government?

Wednesday, April 24, 2013

Interesting reading

I have been travelling a bit for some time and will be back soon!

Meanwhile, you may like to read the following articles:
  • "What do you call an Indian economist who keeps attacking Indo-US economic ties? A US diplomat posted in India in the 1970s called professor B R Shenoy of the Delhi-based The Economics Research Centre, "a decent but a crackpot economist" whose "pearls of wisdom" have often been sent to various US political figures." More here.
"Among many thing that Dr Ambedkar’s party promised, the following were key issues that it would deal with on a priority basis if it came to power:
  1. Agriculture must be mechanised. Agriculture in India can never prosper so long as the method of cultivation remained primitive
  2. To mechanise farming, cultivation on small holdings must be replaced by large farms
  3. To increase the yield, there must be provision for adequate manure and for the supply of healthy seeds But here is a contradiction which is monumental in nature. The Communist movement opposed mechanisation of agriculture. In fact, opposing mechanisation of agriculture has been a big issue for them." More here.