Showing posts with label Nobel Prize for Economics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Nobel Prize for Economics. Show all posts

Monday, April 1, 2024

Famous Behavioural Economist Daniel Kahneman Passed Away (1934-2024)

 “everything I’ve done has been collaborative.”

The famous behavioural economics Prof Daniel Kahneman passed away few days ago. He was aged 90. His many great insightful and pathbreaking works has paved many new dimensions in economic analysis.

He was awrded with the Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences in 2002 for his works - “for having integrated insights from psychological research into economic science, especially concerning human judgment and decision-making under uncertainty”

Different thoughts of people on his life and works:

He wrote in his popular 2011 book, “Thinking, Fast and Slow.”

Dr. Kahneman presented his ideas to a general audience in “Thinking, Fast and Slow,” which distinguished between two modes of thought: System 1, in which the mind, acting quickly, relies on intuition, immediate impressions and emotional reactions; and System 2, in which the mind, slowing down, functions more rationally and analytically and is able to correct errors made by System 1.

“His central message could not be more important,” the Harvard psychologist and author Steven Pinker told The Guardian in 2014, “namely, that human reason left to its own devices is apt to engage in a number of fallacies and systematic errors, so if we want to make better decisions in our personal lives and as a society, we ought to be aware of these biases and seek workarounds. That’s a powerful and important discovery.” More here.

Princeton University obituary 

His major works at Econlib.

Nobel Committee report on his works.

"Economics is a notoriously imperialist discipline: economists are more prone to colonising other scholarly fields than to be colonised by them. The single biggest exception was Daniel Kahneman, the social psychologist who was awarded the 2002 Nobel Memorial prize in economic science for how he revolutionised the field." more here.


Friday, April 16, 2021

Macro-economist Robert A Mundell (1932-2021): RIP


‘Impossible Trinity’

Recently, world renowned macro economist and Economics Nobel Prize winner Prof Robert A Mundell passed away.

Some of his early research were bath-breaking in the fields of international macroeconomics especially on the currency, trade, monetary policy and exchange related issues. 

He was awarded the 1999 Nobel Prize in economics “for his analysis of monetary and fiscal policy under different exchange rate regimes and his analysis of optimum currency areas.” A brief note on his major works are here.

The debate between great free market economist Milton Friedman and Mundell is really fascinating even after decades of its happening.

The following are some of the obituary articles explaining Prof Mundell's contribution in the world of economics:

Nobel prize winning economist Paul Krugman argues many dimensions of Mundell's contributions in international economics. 

Remembering Robert Mundell


Robert A. Mundell, a Father of the Euro and Reaganomics


The Euro Hero Economist dies


Dr. Mundell was widely regarded as one of the most consequential economists of the late 20th century, his work often compared or even equated with that of John Maynard Keynes and Milton Friedman. 


RIP, Robert Mundell: The economist BJP needs to adopt

The Zeus Of Economics Has Died

Father of International Economics by Martin Wolf

Former student of Mundell: The genius of Robert Mundell

Monday, October 28, 2019

2019 Economics Nobel for Economics of World Poverty

After 21 years of first Economics Nobel Prize won by Indian born economist Prof Amartya Sen in 1998, this year, again Indian born economist and researcher Dr Abhijit V Banerjee won Economics Nobel prize along with his fellow economists Michael Kremer and Esther Duflo.

It is also interesting to see that both Banerjee and Duflo has came out a interesting book titled Good Economics or Hard Times

While it is both delight and slight disappointment on the prize for the works awarded. Nevertheless, the larger message from their experimental research about poverty reduction or eradication made significant elaborated debate in mainstream academia and researchers. 

The following are some of the interesting reactions on the Economics Nobel Prize from Indian media and public:

Tuesday, May 6, 2014

Tuesday, October 15, 2013

Nobel Prize for Economics 2013

Professor Ajay Shah has good piece on this years Nobel Prize winners in Economics. He starts with the following para:

However, I really wonder what is the science in it in the stock market prices to give such a huge credit? Its just any other analysis in my view, though they all might have used well thought out innovative ways to look at it. I fear there must come time to give such a huge credit to the works of mass movements of social developmental works especially in the developing economies. The dynamic forces like the NGOs dilutes the State as well as the market forces which would in the long run create huge problems in the society.

Probably, its worth to read this interesting article on Shiller's recent book.

Mint has some interesting observations:
  • This year’s Nobel shows the economics discipline in all its frustrating, admirable splendour. With apologies to Harry Truman’s jaundiced view of economists, it’s only a matter of time before the joke starts making the rounds: Did you hear about the two economists who couldn’t agree on how markets work? Yeah, they won a Nobel for it.

Friday, September 6, 2013

Professor Ronald Coase, passed away at 102

Dr.Ronald Coase, was perhaps the only economics professor who lived such a long years upto 102 rather its more than a 101 economics. He passed away on September 2, 2013. He won the Nobel Memorial Prize for Economics in the year 1991 for his work on "for his discovery and clarification of the significance of transaction costs and property rights for the institutional structure and functioning of the economy".

I am a long admirer of his work on property rights. Prof Coase was also admirer of Prof F A Hayek's idea of choices in currencies and against of monopoly legal tender. 

Read this paper titled "Other things equal: the so called coase theorem".

His very opening line of his Nobel lecture was very candid. He begun by saying:

  • "In my long life I have known some great economists but I have never counted myself among their number nor walked in their company. I have made no innovations in high theory. My contribution to economics has been to urge the inclusion in our analysis of features of the economic system so obvious that,..."

"in a 60-year career he wrote only about a dozen significant papers and used little or no mathematics, yet his impact on his discipline was profound."

Here are some obituaries links:

The life and legacy of Ronald Coase
Ronald Coase : 1910 – 2013
RONALD COASE AND THE MISUSE OF ECONOMICS

Nobelist Who Studied Corporations
Remembering Ronald Coase
Ronald Coase has died, but his individualist dogma is everywhere

Thursday, January 10, 2013

Professor James M. Buchanan, no more

The most liked line from his work is this: “My task has been to ‘uneducate’ the economists.”

"James M. Buchanan, who died Wednesday at age 93, was one of history's greatest economists. Though he won the Nobel Prize in 1986, Jim at heart was always a farm boy from Tennessee—an old-fashioned, hardworking American who disdained unearned privileges as well as deeply distrusting the promises of politicians and the passions of collectives." More here. 

"As Buchanan put it in “Liberty, Market and the State” (1986), politics is “a process within which individuals, with separate and potentially differing interests and values, interact for the purpose of securing individually valued benefits of cooperative effort.” More here.

  • "Buchanan believed that government is necessary to produce public goods (mainly security, but a few others too), hence politics as exchange. The problem in this sort of exchange is that the majority (or perhaps a minority, like bureaucrats) will be tempted to exploit the rest of the population. Rational individuals will want to protect themselves against this danger with a unanimous, if only implicit, social contract that constitutionally limits what the state can do. We must, as the subtitle of The Limits of Liberty indicates, stand “between anarchy and Leviathan.”

Thursday, August 23, 2012

Why Amartya Sen likes Prof James Buchanan's theory of public reasoning?


Meeting different people is not all that bad even if some one is really thinking differently about them. I had brief opportunity to meet Prof Sen early this month. He had mentioned about one of his new article and that is the one I am citing here. It is worth to read the entire article for the below para alone.
  • "Public reasoning is not only crucial for democratic legitimacy, it is essential for a better public epistemology that would allow the consideration of divergent perspectives. It is also required for more effective practical reasoning. It can bring out what particular demands and protests can be restrained in interactive public reasoning, in line with scrutinized priorities between a cluster of quite distinct demands. This involves a process of “give and take” which many political analysts, from Adam Smith and the Marquis de Condorcet in the eighteenth century to Frank Knight and James Buchanan in our time, have made us appreciate better."


Friday, June 15, 2012

Prof Elinor Ostrom (1933-2012)

By this time, many of you might have already read the sad news of passing away of a great classical liberal economist and the only Noble Prize winner in Economics so far. I am talking about Prof Elinor Ostrom. 

Here are some interesting introspects which enriches our ignorance.

In 2011 interview with NDVT she said not something new but an important aspect which otherwise gets credits of take always granted.
  • I urge people to respect the indigenous people. In terms of health knowledge, there is a lot of indigenous knowledge about herbs and other things that work for illness and how to manage illness in an effective way. But we also find that sometimes indigenous knowledge is wrong and as we do tough science, we say “no, that’s wrong”. What I object to is the presumption that the government officials have got all the knowledge and locals have none.
There are many obituary's on Prof Ostrom. Read some of these here, here, here, here. Finally, her last article published is here.

Tuesday, November 15, 2011

Biased human life

Read this four part articles by Nobel prize winner in economics. He says "the people who have the greatest influence on the lives of others are likely to be optimistic and overconfident, and to take more risks than they realize."

Wednesday, October 12, 2011

Nobels-political prizes

The today's Indian Express editorial says:

  • The Nobel prizes, we are sure, incorporate political signals. The literature prize rewards political consciences: Dario Fo to the left, Mario Vargas Llosa to the right, Günter Grass to the centre. And, of course, Harold Pinter, the eternal dissident. Peace has been even more obvious: Pinter-like European disdain for George W. Bush was expressed though awarding political alternatives — Carter, Gore, Obama. The surest sign, perhaps, that economics is far from being a pure science is that its award, too, is invariably seen as political. Amartya Sen’s prize marked the move towards an inclusive development economics, and the rise of the Indian growth model. Edmund Phelps’ 2006 prize was seen as a warning to triumphalist free-marketeers; and Paul Krugman’s seemed to have obvious political overtones. So how should we judge this year’s award, to Christopher Sims of Princeton and Thomas Sargent of NYU?
And further
  • Although they unquestionably deserve the prize, the question remains: why now? As Europe teeters on the brink, has the Committee passed up the opportunity to make a statement about the solution?
  • It may well have not. Sargent’s most memorable paper is from 1981, on the futility of trying to control inflation through monetary policy. In today’s high-inflation times, as central banks worldwide struggle with their mandates, that’s hardly apolitical. And Sims’ work focused for years on trying to make sense of simple Keynesian models; he ended up concluding that it underestimated the links between fiscal and monetary policy, the degree to which they are inextricably twinned through the government’s budget constraint — precisely the error that has landed the European project in such trouble. That’s a relief: the prizes are not, after all, completely apolitical. They wouldn’t be as much fun if they were.

Tuesday, February 15, 2011

Professor Elinor Ostrom in Walk The Talk


Professor Elinor Ostrom, a 2009 Nobel prize winner in economics and the first woman to win the Nobel for Economics says in her interview with Indian Express: 

SG: So, this very special idea of going and engaging with communities...does it come from your political science education or was it something that evolved in your mind as you analysed economics?

Both. I was very much influenced by James Buchanan and Gordon Tullock and their early work on the logic of constitutional choice. They focused on polycentric systems, only they didn’t use the term. They were looking at self-governance and how people form organisations and Buchanan did win a Nobel Prize. So I was very much influenced by Buchanan. I am very much influenced by Amartya Sen.

SG: Even in India, it’s a common expression—seven generations, saath peedhi, even if a politician makes a lot of money, he has made enough for his seven generations. Or if somebody has done a lot of pious work, you say he has earned enough credit with the almighty for his seven generations.

That’s interesting. But I think that is one of the reasons I urge people to respect the indigenous people. In terms of health knowledge, there is a lot of indigenous knowledge about herbs and other things that work for illness and how to manage illness in an effective way. But we also find that sometimes indigenous knowledge is wrong and as we do tough science, we say ‘no, that’s wrong’.

What I object to is the presumption that the government officials have got all the knowledge and locals have none. On the other hand, I don’t want to say the government officials don’t have any because there are times when you can have access to good scientific information at a large scale.

Monday, January 17, 2011

Nobel Prize for Mises!!

Prof Pete Boettke of George Mason University says that:

  • Important to recognize that Mises, despite the fact that he was always a little bit out of step with the profession, he also was recognized. He was the Distinguished Fellow of the American Economics Association (AEA) in 1969; there was a large segment of people who pushed to try to get him the first Nobel Prize in economics. He won the highest medal of honor for scientific accomplishment from his own country, Austria. 
Listen the talk here. Also another one on Hayek is here.

Tuesday, January 11, 2011

The local resources vs local problems

Elinor Ostrom, who won the Nobel Prize for Economics in 2009, says in her interview with DNA:

One of the major theses of your work is that beyond market and state, it is the communities that can manage things.

At different scales. We have ignored enabling local communities to manage water, forests and pasture lands.

You are not an economist in the traditional sense as it is understood in the last 50 years.
My official degree is in political science with a minor in economics. I am very much influenced by Douglass C North, Vernon Smith, James Buchanan, and Amartya Sen.

One of the issues in Indian agriculture is whether farmers should be given free power.

I don’t think anyone should be given free power. Overuse of power is a very great threat, a major threat to us all.

Even if it is meant as an incentive in a sector like agriculture, which is supposed to require some help?

No. I think they should be paying for water and power because you want them to use it efficiently.

Thursday, January 6, 2011

Tuesday, December 21, 2010

The genius of The Nature of the Firm turns 100


As I have posted here the Economist now has a piece (Why do firms exist? Ronald Coase, the author of “The Nature of the Firm” (1937), turns 100 on December 29th) on the grand giant firm theory revolutionary figure: Professor Ronald Coase who is going to turn 100 year by next week.

Few excerpts from the piece:

  • Today most people live in a market economy, and central planning is remembered as the greatest economic disaster of the 20th century. Yet most people also spend their working lives in centrally planned bureaucracies called firms.
  • The man who restored the pin factory to its rightful place at the heart of economic theory celebrates his 100th birthday on December 29th. The economics profession was slow to recognise Ronald Coase’s genius. He first expounded his thinking about the firm in a lecture in Dundee in 1932, when he was just 21 years old. Nobody much listened. He published “The Nature of the Firm” five years later. It went largely unread. 
  • But Mr Coase laboured on regardless: a second seminal article on “The Problem of Social Cost” laid the intellectual foundations of the deregulation revolution of the 1980s. Eventually, Mr Coase acquired an army of followers, such as Oliver Williamson, who fleshed out his ideas. In 1991, aged 80, he was awarded a Nobel prize. Far from resting on his laurels, Mr Coase will publish a new book in 2011, with Ning Wang of Arizona State University, on “How China Became Capitalist”. 
  • How much light does “The Nature of the Firm” throw on today’s corporate landscape? The young Mr Coase first grew interested in the workings of firms when he travelled around America’s industrial heartland on a scholarship in 1931-32. He abandoned his textbooks and asked businessmen why they did what they did. He has long chided his fellow economists for scrawling hieroglyphics on blackboards rather than looking at what it actually takes to run a business. So it seems reasonable to test his ideas by the same empirical standards. 
  • Mr Coase’s theory continues to explain some of the most puzzling problems in modern business. Take the rise of vast and highly diversified business groups in the emerging world, such as India’s Tata group and Turkey’s Koc Holding. Many Western observers dismiss these as relics of a primitive form of capitalism. But they make perfect sense when you consider the transaction costs of going to the market. Where trust in established institutions is scarce, it makes sense for companies to stretch their brands over many industries. And where capital and labour markets are inefficient, it makes equal sense for companies to allocate their own capital and train their own loyalists.

Tips from Nobel laureate-Venkatraman Ramakrishnan


Top to bottom

  • “There is no magic formula for winning the Nobel Prize” 
  • “If India wins a single Nobel Prize it does not mean Indian science is okay” 
  • “Don’t work on anything that you’re not interested in — day-to-day science is extremely tedious,” 
  • “If you don’t gossip about the problem, then you’re not really interested in it. It’s (got to be) something you can’t help talking about. The problem has to be bugging you when you have a coffee” 
  • “Also aim to go to the best place for your work,” 
  • “You can change fields with humility, 
  • “It’s a paradox that the biggest benefits of science to humanity have come from the fundamental science problems”


What one did not say has already been said about another Nobel Laureate in Economics science:

“And unlike that imposter Amartya Sen, this is the real deal. Ladies & Gentlemen, Professor Dixit”

Wednesday, December 1, 2010

So, countdown for run upto 100 year old Professor Ronald Harry Coase!!

At last, the winty December has come, wait!!

"Human beings have, since time immemorial, taken the credit for whatever has gone right while shifting the blame for all that has gone wrong to the unfortunate year! Thus, 1992 was described by the British monarch Queen Elizabeth II as annus horribilis, Latin for a horrible year that saw not just a fire in the royal home of Windsor Castle but an announcement in December of the formal separation of the Prince and Princess of Wales.

In India, which philosophically takes a much, much longer perspective of happenings, everything bad is attributed to the world currently going through an age called kaliyuga, which is aeons removed from nobler eras in a very distant past.

Those who are not philosophically inclined take a much simpler view. Instead of ruminating about why things have gone wrong, they prefer to plan out where they should see the last sunset of the old year or the first sunrise of the new one."
(From ET see here)

Yes I have been watching and reading ever since I presented a research paper at the NIRD Foundation Seminar in 2006 in November (also got some cash award for the paper!!!) when this month will come, it now says ‘I am here’!! The research paper was on environment and private property rights and human action.


Before posting next big quote let’s say one thing which I wanted to share with you. Professor Ronald Coase is the only economist who is going to celebrate his 100th birthday by end of this month!! and too after winning Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences. Long live Professor Coase!!!


From Library of Economics and Liberty:

  • Ronald Coase received the Nobel Prize in 1991 “for his discovery and clarification of the significance of transaction costs and property rights for the institutional structure and functioning of the economy.” Coase is an unusual economist for the twentieth century, and a highly unusual Nobel Prize winner. First, his writings are sparse. In a sixty-year career he wrote only about a dozen significant papers—and very few insignificant ones. Second, he uses little or no mathematics, disdaining what he calls “blackboard economics.” Yet his impact on economics has been profound. That impact stems almost entirely from two of his articles, one published when he was twenty-seven and the other published twenty-three years later.

  • Coase conceived of the first article, “The Nature of the Firm,” while he was an undergraduate on a trip to the United States from his native Britain. At the time he was a socialist, and he dropped in on perennial Socialist Party presidential candidate Norman Thomas. He also visited Ford and General Motors and came up with a puzzle: how could economists say that Lenin was wrong in thinking that the Russian economy could be run like one big factory, when some big firms in the United States seemed to be run very well? In answering his own question, Coase came up with a fundamental insight about why firms exist. Firms are like centrally planned economies, he wrote, but unlike the latter they are formed because of people’s voluntary choices. But why do people make these choices? The answer, wrote Coase, is “marketing costs.” (Economists now use the term “transaction costs.”) If markets were costless to use, firms would not exist. Instead, people would make arm’s-length transactions. But because markets are costly to use, the most efficient production process often takes place in a firm. His explanation of why firms exist is now the accepted one and has given rise to a whole literature on the issue. Coase’s article was cited 169 times in academic journals between 1966 and 1980.
  • “The Problem of Social Cost,” Coase’s other widely cited article (661 citations between 1966 and 1980), was even more pathbreaking; indeed, it gave rise to the field called law and economics. Economists before Coase of virtually all political persuasions had accepted British economist Arthur Pigou’s idea that if, say, a cattle rancher’s cows destroy his neighboring farmer’s crops, the government should stop the rancher from letting his cattle roam free or should at least tax him for doing so. Otherwise, believed economists, the cattle would continue to destroy crops because the rancher would have no incentive to stop them.

There is some interesting information about his childhood:

  • Aged 11, I was taken by my father to a phrenologist. What the phrenologist said about my character was, I feel sure, determined less by the shape of my skull than by the impressions he derived from my behaviour. Out of the various printed summaries of character in his booklet, that chosen for "Master Ronald Coase" started: "You are in possession of much intelligence, and you know it, though you may be inclined to underrate your abilities." This printed summary also included the following remarks: "You will not float down, like a sickly fish, with the tide... you enjoy considerable mental vigour and are not a passive instrument in the hands of others. Though you can work with others and for others, where you see it to your advantage, you are more inclined to think and work for yourself. A little more determination would be to your advantage, however." In the written comments, the pursuits recommended were: "Scientific and commercial banking, accountancy. Also, horticulture and poultry-rearing as hobbies." Added were some comments about my character: "More hope, confidence and concentration required - not suited for the aggressive competitive side of business life. More active ambition would be beneficial." It was also noted that I was too cautious. It was hardly to be expected that this timid little boy would one day be the recipient of a Nobel Prize. That this happened was the result of a series of accidents.


Some of his important works: