Showing posts with label Chacha Manmohan Singh. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Chacha Manmohan Singh. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 27, 2021

Thirty years of economic reforms of 1991-II

Thirty years of economic reforms of 1991 is remembered on major way to look ahead for next decade, or more. 

The following are some of very interesting analysis of what went right and wrong in the last thirty years while implementing various reforms in Indian economy.

If there is any big takeaway from India’s post-Independence history, it lies in the effects of the 1991 reforms. Those reforms essentially consisted of the government retreating from large parts of the economic space of the country. The result: A doubling of GDP growth and the lifting of over 200 million people out of poverty in the two decades that followed. This was the effect of individual and corporate enterprise being unleashed under relatively less controlled regulatory conditions.


The demographic dividend will go into reverse gear. Government programmes in earlier years aimed at population reduction but will now switch to promoting larger families. The old slogan “Do ya teen bas” will be replaced by “Sirf do ya teen, bas?”

The character of higher education and the governance and standards of the professions in India are likely the principal reasons why the social and political role of the Indian middle class has been so wanting.

Another problem is that most of our public discussion of reforms focuses on what the central government should do, but water, electricity distribution and health are critical areas which are all in the state sector. If you check what politicians are saying in state elections you will see that it does not reflect an awareness of the need for reforms.

Looking at the recent discussions on agricultural marketing reforms, the best course of action now may be to leave these measures to each state to decide whether they want these legislations or not. That will set the stage for experimental economics and farmers themselves will be able to see the best possible solution for different crops and conditions.

India proved resistant to the sweeping transformation that would boost many East Asian economies. Too often, Indian politicians packaged measures designed to aid an individual business or industry as economic reform, when the measures in fact retard competition and growth. Pro-business is not the same as pro-capitalist, and the distinction continues to elude us.


Tuesday, May 13, 2014

What's on your Head?

Yes, the nunny State and the nation of elections are over, yet the fever created by the nunny state is still with us perhaps the new animal would be born on 16th May to govern the beast of government and its apparatus of mechanics. 

By the way, it is interesting to note a study's findings with which I was musing since this morning. My take is this. While we celebrate the Indian elections in the name of democracy, here are some ironies. Out of 83 crore eligible voters in India, only 55.13 crore (66.42%) have voted in the elections. Thus, 27.87 crore (33.58%) eligible voters did not vote. This is huge number! 

Here are some good reading to bite meanwhile:

Accidents of history, and how they might be corrected by Ashok V Desai
The message in the increased voter turnout



Sunday, April 13, 2014

Its ALL about elections in India

The election time is here and running up quiet fast. Bad time to read good things about anything under the sun. Everybody lies about anything but future of polity and politics. The citizen is once again fooled by all kinds of promises about material and non-material things in society. Not matter, its all about groups in which you favour.

Big storms are here and there for all kinds of political reasons. Here are some strange readings about India and its economy-policy, polity and people.

I have waited long to read Dr.Sanjay Baru's book on Manmohan Singh. Here are first excerpts from the book. Its must read for all Indians.

Amit Verma writes about Indian polity and politics over election fever.
  • "There are two factors that shape politics in India. One is the nature and structure of government. Ours is far more powerful than it should be, with an excess of discretionary power over the common man. We are worse off under our government, regardless of which party is in charge, than we were under the British. Our government is effectively set up not to serve us, but to rule us — and to extract hafta. Think of political parties as rival mafia gangs fighting for the right to loot us for five years."
Shanu has good piece in the DNA on Sanjay Baru's book on Prime Minister Singh.

Whatever you say wrong about Gujarat. It is the top state with higher level of economic freedom which means more chances to produce wealth and prosperity for the people.

Sunday, April 6, 2014

India "move towards a centrist politics"

Some useful reading:

"India is definitely ahead of Europe in how so many diverse cultural, linguistic and even religious communities have all kept together in a federal political system. Look at Europe — it has become more and more divided into countries. Within several countries that are much smaller than India, deep and violent divisions persist. Ireland is one example...

But I must add that one dangerous phenomenon has emerged — post-election alliances. What should happen is that parties get together before an election, declare some kind of common programme and then face the electorate. Instead, I see parties openly declaring that they will enter into alliances after the results are out. This is not fair to the voters and leads to problems in the political system. " More here.

The quality of governance matters, not 10-year averages.

 the Praetorian guards of the “idea of India”

No political party can hope to win even a municipal election in India by relying on the votes of rich Indians. 

Socialist parties have had the enduring slogan of Bharat verses India. Leaders and intellectuals have argued that cities are colonising the countryside and creating a conflict between villages and cities. 

Saturday, April 5, 2014

Must read


Swatantra's Real - AAP's Fly by Night Politics


"Independent politicians like Masani, who did not believe in the socialist route taken by Nehru, rallied around Rajagopalachari. In the General Election of 1962, within three years of its formation, the Swatantra Party won 22 Lok Sabha seats. The next election in 1967 was its highpoint. It got 44 Lok Sabha seats and was the largest opposition party. It got 9.6 per cent of all votes polled and won 256 assembly seats in various states. And then, just as abruptly, by the polls of 1971, it slipped to eight Lok Sabha seats with just 3.1 per cent of votes polled. By 1974, the main party had ceased to exist." More here.

"The Swantantra Party had become the more legitimate voice of the free market...A decade ago, Mr. Vajpayee’s free market policies were staunchly opposed by Sangh affiliates such as the Swadeshi Jagran Manch. Mr. Modi managed to banish them all from Gujarat, making it a middle class utopia. The anti-capitalist strand in the Hindu right that repelled the modernising, pro-market middle class is now invisible and inaudible." More here.




The impending demise of the Left....on May 16, do not forget to note history in the making, with the Left seats in the low teens if not at a single-digit level.

Chinese president Mr.Xi says "Constitutional monarchy, imperial restoration, parliamentarism, a multi-party system and a presidential system, we considered them, tried them, but none worked,"

"Indian society internalised the Victorian critique"

Saturday, March 29, 2014

Free the market in Indian agriculture sector

Very insightful thoughts from Ashok Gulati. Many interesting things he shares with BS. I did met him in one of the conference in Delhi recently. Inf act, he had shared most the following things in that talk he gave:

  • "export controls is one way of taxing the peasantry by suppressing prices"
  • “The problem is the government is trying to achieve equity through price policy and not using income policy, so you have massive misallocations. This is how Soviet Russia collapsed. We need to get out of this socialist mindset and allow markets to function,”
  • “This is the area where the second Green Revolution is supposed to happen. It was a bumper year, but you had export controls so you didn’t allow foodgrain to go out, you restrict the private sector domestically, plus you are not procuring. So the market collapsed for farmers in Bihar. Yet you are procuring from Punjab, which earns Rs 4,000 crore extra by charging a tax of 14.5%, what the heck!”
  • “He said, ‘Tumne saare desh ka theka le rakha hai? [are you responsible for the whole country?] The government has made you a chairman. Enjoy life’.”
  • He found Agriculture Minister Sharad Pawar “progressive, more market oriented than other ministers and with a broad vision.”
  • “Well, the food minister wanted to protect consumers, the agriculture minister the farmer. Each ministry works in a silo, so, really, it is for the prime minister to take a call. That’s when you need a leader.”
  • “Vajpayee didn’t say much but he listened. Once, there was a discussion on deficit financing and Montek talked about how we need to disinvest in Maruti, Ashoka Hotel and so on. Vajpayee’s response was, ‘Bawaal khada ho jayega’ [it will become a problematic issue]. Yet, 15 days later, that’s exactly what the government announced. That’s leadership.” 

Saturday, January 25, 2014

Journey to Change The Nation

"The first Indian from the south of the Vindhyas to ever preside over the Dilli darbar was P V Narasimha Rao. Technically, it was C Rajagopalachari, as the first Indian to be governor-general. But CR’s post was titular. 

Narendra Modi is different. He fulfils all the qualifications of being an outsider, except that he speaks chaste Hindi. The business and military elite love him, but the cultural elite do not and the political elite remain wary. If he succeeds in winning power this year, he could well alter the nature of the Dilli darbar. That is what unnerves so many darbaris." More here.

Tuesday, December 31, 2013

Goodbye 2013

Thank you all for your kind support and being part of the Hayek Order blog. 

I will try and post more and more blog posts often in 2014.

It’s time, to say goodbye to the year 2013, as always, the year 2013 was both good and bad to me both personally and professionally. But personally, the year was more bad than good! Professionally it is actually other way around. Anyway, it’s ending finally.

Wish you all happy new year, may the almighty and the nature give you a good health, peace and prosperity in new year.

I sincerely hope to do some good work in 2014. Some new and interesting assignments have already landed!

Looking at the prevailing politico economics of India at the moment, its really disturbing in many ways. The hardcore liberals are once again disintegrating themselves and moving apart to join other parties hands. And others are in silence as usual in the past. These are bad signal for youth in India who have seen the fruits of economic reforms and globalization etc. I will try my best and do good works in my own way.

Here are my major publications in 2013:

English articles
2.  Aspirations of emerging giants,Pragati: The Indian National Interest Review, June, 2013
3. History of Indian economic thought: the forgotten subject, Pragati: The Indian National Interest Review, March, 2013

Tamil Articles (on National Food Security Act, Amartya Sen vs Bhagwati, free market economic thoughts of B R Ambedkar, Manmohan Singh's UPA in line with Indire Gandhi govt.):


Other unedited blog post articles at CPPR.

Thursday, June 13, 2013

Factious Polity over Prosperity

Here is a brief piece which I wrote in 2012 when the debate on FDI in retail was headline.  The Prime Minister Manmohan Singh said the below para in his lecture at Raman Research Institute, Bangalore. At that time he was not holding any official post in the government.
  • “...those who wish to persist with the old policy framework of India must realise the tremendous social and economic cost they are asking the people of India to pay for their preferences…To argue for greater openness is not to argue that globalisation processes, involving liberalization of trade and capital flows, do not pose risks. Competition can certainly hurt those who are not prepared for it. But a country like India, with its vast human and material resources, and with the ambition of becoming a major global economic player, cannot take such a defeatist view. We ought not to underestimate the capabilities of an India that can produce computer programmers for the Silicon Valley. We must have a coherent strategy to come to term with globalisation, a process we cannot stop even if we do not like it”.

Monday, March 18, 2013

Nation’s cost

Eminent Indian economist S L Rao asks "...will the Wharton gang who got the university to disinvite Modi be consistent if it invites Manmohan Singh, Sonia or Rahul Gandhi, or other top Congressmen to speak at its forums? If Modi is guilty of Muslim deaths and uneven development, so are they. These people carry the blot of the Sikh killings in Delhi and the uneven, non-inclusive, unequal, and poor development of India. The University of Pennsylvania’s reaction was immature and unworthy of a great American university. It brings discredit to the university and the gang who made this happen, not to Modi. He did not deserve the insult of being invited and then having it withdrawn on the plea of a confused and attention-seeking junior teacher." I strongly recommend to read his article in full.

Thursday, March 7, 2013

Occupations pass just like-OLD Draft

Dr.Manmohan Singh said in the following words before the Hiren Mukherjee Memorial Lecture 2010 by Professor Jagdish Bhagwati
  • “Jagdish has since earned for himself an enviable place in the world of economics. As a trade theorist he is in a class of his own. He has not only influenced international trade theory and become a familiar name in every economics classroom across the world, but he has also helped shape trade policy. He is among the architects of the World Trade Organisation, and continues to guide it. 
  • He and Padma were pioneers among economists who questioned the efficacy of the Licence-Permit Control Raj. Their highly influential book became the beacon for policy reform in India . He was among the first to study the phenomenon of ‘brain drain’ and identify its benefits for our economy. 
  • Today we in India are experiencing the benefits of the reverse flow of income, investment and expertise from the global Indian diaspora. The problem of ‘brain drain’ has been converted happily into the opportunity of “brain gain”. We are drawing on the global “brain bank” of people of Indian origin world wide. Jagdish Bhagwati is one of the shining stars of that community of global Indians. 
  • Professor Bhagwati is a true patriot, a loyal son of our Motherland and a truly liberal and secular Indian. Over the years I have greatly benefited from his expertise and his incisive analysis of the Indian and the state of world economy. He has combined his commitment to academic rigour and discipline with an equally passionate commitment to popular education. He has sought to engage his critics and win them over with his persuasive intellectual skills and his gracious charm and good humour. You will be witness to both his wit and wisdom. 
  • I have been a proud member of our Parliament for nearly two decades now. It is not often that I have had the opportunity to welcome a college-mate of such great distinction to these august premises. Today ladies and gentlemen I am truly delighted to have this unique opportunity and honour! I thank you.” 
The full text of lecture is here and excerpts published in the IE is here

Thursday, February 21, 2013

"Congress gain is nation's loss"

Prof Arvind Panagariya has very timely and brave article in The Economic Times. It is titled as "Congress' bail out of bankrupt Scooters India is party's gain at nation's loss"

Read the tragedies here:
  • "Prime Minister Manmohan Singh later instructed him to prepare a bailout package in consultation with the BIFR. That proposal has now culminated in the Rs 200-crore dole to the company. To his credit, finance minister Chidambaram protested in the Cabinet meeting but Singh, almost surely under instructions from Congress president Sonia Gandhi, overruled him. It makes no economic sense to throw hard-earned rupees of taxpayers at a company that has been declared sick by the BIFR, a verdict the bureau rarely delivers, preferring to advise restructuring. With an aged workforce whose protection is probably the sole purpose of the bailout, 1970s machinery that should have been retired decades ago and management that hails from civil service and has no real expertise in auto manufacturing, there is no chance that it can compete against the modern day auto giants that together produce 8,50,000 three-wheelers every year.Why did the government ignore the obvious? The easy explanation is politics. Scooters India is located in the capital city of Uttar Pradesh (UP), the home state of the Gandhi family."