Showing posts with label Manish Sabharwal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Manish Sabharwal. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 26, 2013

Stupidly unfair

Manish has a great piece in today's IE on minimum wage in India. He argues very perceptively that the "The trade union demand is a predictable positioning of narrow self-interest as national interest but the government's acceptance of their demand is unfair, delusional and economically stupid."

Friday, March 1, 2013

Budget Reading

I have never commented on the India's Railway Budget. But I wanted to say something on this year's Budget. This year's Railway Budget has missed a great opportunity to open the railway sector for private sector investments in a more focused manner. Just one example, nothing has changed at Nizgamuddin station in Delhi in the last ten years in terms of modernization or cleaning the dirty things in and around the Station. Secondly, I have been hearing increasingly that you will always find uncleaned platforms in northern region railway stations compared to southern and western region railway stations. I really wonder is there something culturally wrong or right?

Come to the general Union Budget.

All kinds of 'if' and 'buts' are there everywhere both in the print media and electronic media and not to miss the social media.

One must at least the following articles to understand the useful for this year budget. However, I must add, the most sensible article I have read so far is the one by economist Laveesh Bhandari. Some may think there is nothing new in his arguments but the fact is that few opening para is suffice to say at least according to me because not many people think in that way. 

The other article not very interesting but one should it. Its by economist Ashok V Desai. Just a bit:
  • But the results are dire; nine years of Congress rule have seen the budget getting utterly cluttered with dozens of populist schemes for people young and old, male and female, rural and urban; people are cut up into interest groups, and each is rewarded with schemes named after members of the Nehru family. Chidambaram did not eschew this approach entirely; he had to come out with a proposal of a women-only bank. He did not disclose whether he would be inaugurating it, what he would wear on the occasion, whether men would be allowed to enter the bank, and up to what age boys would be allowed to accompany their mothers into the bank.
Other article is by Manish Sabharwal. Unlike the previous budgets, he is very happy this time after seeing the funds provided for the skilling things.  

And lastly one should carefully between the lines in this article by Shanmuganathan. 

Saturday, December 8, 2012

Midnight’s children or reform babies

Manish has a very genuine assessment about the lively impact of foreign direct investment in retail sector in India. Most people who take interest in FDI in retail debate misses the below points which are extremely important at this juncture in Indian economy.
  •  We know that kirana (unorganised retail) shop owners are a much smaller population than exploited kirana workers. We know that unorganised retail is the biggest user of child labour. We know the tragic costs of informal employment (no PF, no ESI, no appointment letters and no minimum wages). We know that 100% of net job growth since 1991 has been in informal jobs; the slavery of the 21st century. We know that kids don’t view employment as a lifetime contract (mai-baap) but a taxicab relationship that is intense, intimate and short. We know that 10 lakh kids will be joining the labour force every month for the next 20 years. We also know that a sales job is the most blue-collar white-collar job. The notion that agricultural jobs or manufacturing jobs pay more, provide higher job satisfaction or offer better physical environments is not a myth; it is a lie. I am not sure where the romanticism of shop floor or fields comes from but our economy is driven by domestic consumption—strength as the global crisis enters its sixth year—and that means sales and customer service will be the biggest job creator in the next two decades. So, there is nothing horrible about “India becoming a nation of sales boys and girls”. This will be a less poor India.




Tuesday, August 21, 2012

Interesting reading

Manish on rightly asks why there is no narrative for youth in India in the contemporary political setups. The following para is really suburb:

  • The garibi hatao card does not work because voters are jaded by the lack of execution of promises since that slogan was coined 40 years ago. The free electricity card does not work because it leads to no power, which infuriates the people further. The reservation card does not work because we have reached the limits of confiscating capacity in hiring, education and promotions. The big state that is financed with deficits is discredited because the economic mayhem of the past few years shows that there is no magical “multiplier effect”, and deficit financing leads to inflation with no boost in output. The freebies card is less effective because it has to be given to everybody, since fixing the plumbing to target its distribution is so difficult to achieve. The majboori card is less potent because of prosperity; it is much harder to get people to migrate to big cities than it should be. The foreign enemy card does not work because Pakistan is imploding and we are hardly surrounded, like Israel is. The mystique of the incumbent does not work because the 24-hour news cycle encourages breathless breaking news over reflection. The “young blood” card does not work because the only pathways in politics are geriatric. The corruption card does not work because, um, if everybody lives in glass houses, everybody needs to answer the bell. 

Monday, July 23, 2012

Ruining the drive from sitting backseat

Mr.Manish  writes:


  • "Today, policymaking in Delhi has seven backseat drivers — the judiciary, the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG), the Central Vigilance Commissioner (CVC), the CBI, the National Advisory Council (NAC), non-government activists, and the media. Each of them is trying to outdo — and out-scream — the other in second-guessing every policy decision of the past with the benefit of knowing what finally happened. However, fraud, incompetence and plans not working to plan are three different scenarios."



Sunday, July 22, 2012

India's cult unionism

From Manish's article in today's ET: 

  • "There are three possible explanations. The first one comes from Joseph Stalin who recognised that anecdotal evidence makes better storytelling than logic and said “When one person dies it is a tragedy but when millions dies it is a statistic”. The second comes from the work of economist Mancur Olson who researched interest groups. He described how a small minority in a democracy that is vocal and organised can hijack the agenda in democracy. His work on “distributional coalitions” is a tight explanation of what we see in a shortage economy like India where dividing the pie in your favour is the only option when the pie is not expanding." 

Monday, November 28, 2011

Blinking links


  • Manish Sabharwal writes "...the most articulate non-economic case for urbanisation was made by Nandan Nilekani in his book Imagining India: “It has been fashionable in our cultural commentary to refer to India’s cities as places of vice, corruption and loss of innocence. But cities are, and have historically been, a powerful catalyst for political reform. Leaders such as B.R. Ambedkar recognised this and found the Indian city liberating after the sink of localism and den of inequity that was the village. Upward mobility for the backward castes is therefore most tangible in our cities because it becomes difficult to enforce silly notions of caste purity and pollution in the forced proximity of our city buses and trains.”


  • Niranjan reviews a new book Grant Pursuit..."The Industrial Revolution had shown glimpses of a better future, though there was little historical reason to believe that societies could escape the poverty trap. Karl Marx and Friedrich Engelspredicted that capitalism would inevitably push workers into penury and the entire economic system would collapse in a heap. Engels comes across better than Marx in Nasar’s book. Marx, it seems, wrote about the horrors of industrial life without even once seeing the inside of a factory. He lived in London not too far away from two outstanding thinkers: Charles Darwin and George Eliot. He never bothered to either meet or correspond with them."

Monday, April 11, 2011

Profitable Education


Mr.Manish Sabarwal of Teamlease Services writes: 
  • Rabindranath Tagore has a wonderful story called Kartar Bhooth where the perceived static wishes of a dead leader make life difficult and kill innovation. The ghost of non-profit in education has similar consequences: 90% of education capacity created since 1991 has been for-profit but in the guise of non-profit because of legislation. This regulatory cholesterol reduces the ability of professionals like teachers to attract third-party capital for entrepreneurship. 
  • More dangerously, it rewards regulatory arbitrage abilities and, consequently, most education entrepreneurs today are land mafia, criminals or politicians. This low-quality private sector capacity creation becomes a self-reinforcing argument against legitimising a professionally-managed, well-regulated and quality-minded for-profit private sector. But the most expensive school is no school and the primary case for private sector is not quality but capacity and cost. We should not care whether a school is government, not-for-profit, not-for-loss, for-less profit or for-profit. All that matters is a good school or a bad school. Let biodiversity explode. 

Wednesday, January 12, 2011

Scrap the Right to Education Act (RTE)

The Right to Education Act comes when there is no issue of enrollment but huge drop-out ratio. What it makes mockery of school education in this chaotic democracy is for the private schools and that is too by law!! Read the article and ponder what else more one need for scraping this RTE!!

Some excerpts:
  • It is said that one of most damaging virtues of George W Bush was his steadiness; he believed the same thing on Wednesday that he believed on Monday - no matter what happened on Tuesday. Unfortunately, the well-meaning or self-interested people - these are the only two kinds pushing for swifter implementation of the Right to Education Act (RTE) - seem to share this dangerous steadiness despite new information. 

  • As a company at the exit gate of the education system - we have hired somebody every five minutes for five years but only 5% of the kids who came to us for a job - we see and suffer the tragic consequences of India's education emergency. True impact in public policy – unlike election campaigns - does not lie in poetry but in plumbing.  

  • RTE makes it impossible for education entrepreneurs to compete on price since many states propose to regulate fees and uncertainty has paused the Cambrian explosion of energy in school entrepreneurship. This means lower capacity and lower competition. And that means schools don't have clients, but hostages. 

  • Third as enrolment ratios cross 100% it fights yesterday's war of quantity and fails to focus on quality and learning outcomes. We don't need more cooks in the kitchen but a different recipe. RTE not only fails this test but poisons the ecosystem by sabotaging other ways to get India educated.

Monday, January 3, 2011

Glimpse of reading

National Skill Development Corporation's CEO says “.....vouchers for trainees may become the big government innovation of this decade.”

The chairman of Teamlease Services Mr.Manish Sabharwal says “Unfortunately, 2010 saw the activation of the poisonous Right to Education Act that will lower school capacity, increase corruption, raise costs, lower competition and increase confusion. It represents a license raj of the 1980s, while education needs a deregulation of the 1991 kind. A bad school is better than no school. The most expensive school is no school. The good is not the enemy of great. An education and training system that does not produce employable children amplifies to low productivity informal employment because it produces low productivity people.”

Bihar Chief Minister Mr.Nitish Kumar says “I believe that direct cash transfers are the way forward. Give money to the people and give them the choice to buy what they want from the market…. My policy will be to provide mostly cash transfers in state schemes in the future as well.”

Mr.Soli J. Sorabjee writes Chinese sex education: The Chinese have hit upon an innovative way of sex education which allows boys and girls to peep into each other’s bathroom in order to understand gender roles and observe what behavioural differences there are between the two sexes. According to Zhang Meimei, a sex education expert, the bathroom of the opposite sex can be a mysterious place. “I have known a lot of third and fourth grade boys who would sneak into the lady’s room just to see what it is like. Therefore, visiting the bathroom can be a good technique in teaching gender codes to students.” One wonders what is the take of our dynamic Education Minister Kapil Sibal on the Chinese method.

Prof Mehta writes “R-squared variances will replace the close reading of the Mahabharata and Montaigne as the only way to understand human psychology and it is not clear this will be for the better. The kids will be smarter, but perhaps none the wiser.”

Mr.Subroto Bagchi writes “What are the chances that you are an 11-year-old reading this article right now? I would give it one in a billion. And if you are not an 11-year-old, you would not know what it would mean to be 20 in, 2020. As you try and decipher the many strands of thought I have presented in this article, the 11-year-old is stalking the enemy on his device. What he is using will vary from a Nokia cellphone to the X-Box,

Wednesday, November 17, 2010

Need a 100-day apprenticeship programme NOT nrega?

Manish Sabharwal of Teamlease writes:

  • NAC is upset that the NREGS violates the Minimum Wages Act. But everybody knows that NREGS violates 37 labour laws, including the Provident Fund Act, ESI Act, Industrial Disputes Act and Contract Labour Act. I have never received a reply to my repeated letters to the government asking for the rationale of the temporary job apartheid under which a non-fiscal, minimum wage and social security paying 100-day job offered by the private sector is viewed as a disease to be eradicated, while the inefficient, non-market, non-real job based NREGS is considered the labour market innovation equivalent of cell phones.

  • But NREGS is here to stay and the good is not the enemy of the great. So we must tweak the current structure of NREGS payments to be apprenticeship stipends for 100 days of on-the-job training. These apprenticeships could be complemented or combined with 100 days of classroom or satellite training to produce skilled manpower that earns wages which reflect productivity. If the NAC really wants to innovate, it must propose a solution that amends the Apprentice Act of 1961 and transfers some NREGS money to the starving but effective modular employment skills programme of the ministry of labour. A 100-day apprenticeship under NREGS that combined learning-while-earning and learning-by-doing would surely move the needle on the horrible skill deficit that keeps our people out of jobs or in working poverty. The current campaign to equate minimum wages with NREGS payments almost legislates that the bridge to productivity becomes the destination. In the name of our poor who need a chance and not charity, it must be resisted

Monday, September 27, 2010

Key hulchul Trust?


If you have read the Nandan's Book Imagining India: Ideas for the New Century, probably you would be knowing how many law suits Mr.Manish Sabharwal has been facing. Its over 1500!!. In a recent article he brings an interesting news of how the actually looting takes place in public in the most celebrated democracy of India: Here is a bit:

  • Despite his recent bail, Ramalinga Raju of Satyam has learnt the hard way that those who ride tigers end up inside them. But the hole he created—about Rs 10,000 crore—is small relative to the Rs 50,000 crore deficit in the Employee Pension Scheme (EPS) created by the trustees of the Employees Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO). If the trustees are not willing to take responsibility for this hole they must be held liable or made to resign so that we fix the birth defect in the governance structure at EPFO, which allowed the introduction of what is possibly the world’s only pension scheme that has defined both benefits and contributions.

  • More importantly, the decision by the trustees to pay an above-market rate return to members is symbolic of the lack of “fiduciary” perspective at the EPFO Board. First, this money has not been earned but created by a kind of accounting that is of not much higher quality than Satyam. Second, if this mythical Rs 2,000 crore does exist, why not use it to fill in the EPS hole? Third, why reduce benefits under EPS and EPFO that are in good enough health to declare an investment bonus?

Monday, March 15, 2010

An alibi for trade unions to sabotage


If anyone have read Mr.Nandan Nilekani’s book of Imagining India would know how many lawsuits Mr. Manish Sabharwal have been facing in the various aspects. It is more than 1,500!!!


OK, Mr.Manish Sabharwal of Teamlease Services writes in today’s ET about the trade unions tragedy in understanding of free market and financial:


  • “THE trade union arguments of class struggle and tyranny of capital are well-known, ancient and stale. But Indian trade union leaders have now updated their rhetoric with wrong lessons from the global economic crisis — a recent letter to the prime minister said, “The global financial and economic crisis is structural and the current free trade paradigm is a major part of the problem. The financial crisis has shown that free markets and free trade cannot correct themselves.” Global unions are not far behind, with the International Trade Union Federation saying, “We warned business and politicians of dangerous instability in the global economy, but most were more than happy to continue to reap the short-term benefits of the failing model of deregulation. Business and governments created this crisis on their own, but they won’t be able to solve it unless they work with unions to stop the global jobs haemorrhage, kickstart the world economy and put a proper regulatory framework in place.”
  • “Thus, the average person in the world of 1800 AD had the same life expectancy as the average hunter gatherers of 100,000 BC. Stature, a measure of quality of diet and of children’s exposure to disease was actually higher in the Stone Age than in 1800 AD. But modern free market economies are now 20 times better off than the 1800 AD average.”
  • But trade union prescriptions may be worse than the disease because they confuse financial markets with free markets and mirror image the error of market fundamentalist in recommending that the state should substitute for markets or reduce their volatility. This misunderstands the sources of prosperity and job creation.
  • It would be a tragedy if the global financial crisis becomes an alibi for trade unions to sabotage our march of entrepreneurship and poverty reduction.”


Wednesday, September 23, 2009

Choices in education

Manish Sabharwal says:

  • “………..the risk of sounding like an old crank confusing nostalgia with amnesia,
  • ……horrifying as these truths sound, educational institutions are not like Athena in Greek mythology who sprung fully formed from the head of Zeus—they need time and competition to mature.
  • The difficult choices of quantity, deregulation and fee freedom required of the education regulator are bound to horrify parents and policymakers but our situation is not very different from Winston Churchill in the Second World War who said: “I know the difference between right and wrong and I can tell good from bad. I also know the more difficult decisions come when we have to choose between good and better. But the toughest calls of all are between bad and worse”. Years of myopia and corruption in higher education force us to make the bad choice of quantity over quality because a worse choice would be to waste our demographic dividend. Effective and inclusive higher education will be the difference between a demographic dividend and a demographic disaster. It will also be the difference between busy children and restless or jobless youth. Most importantly, it could be the difference between peace with prosperity and crime with civil unrest.”