Showing posts with label C Rajagopalachari. Show all posts
Showing posts with label C Rajagopalachari. Show all posts

Thursday, November 23, 2023

A notable exception was C. Rajagopalachari

This is somthing the Indian political leaders forget and forgetten for long time: 

"A notable exception was C. Rajagopalachari, who had held the office of the governor-general of India—the last one to hold it and the only Indian—yet went on to serve in Jawaharlal Nehru’s cabinet and then as chief minister of Madras."

Read more here.

Saturday, January 9, 2021

C.Rajagopalachari’s Venerable Thoughts on Culture


I have new  piece on thoughts of one of greatest statesmen of twentieth century India, C.Rajagopalachari who had profound thoughts about "culture" which is the most abused word in the literature anywhere in the world. But his views are civilization transition in nature and has relevance for all times.

According to Rajaji “civilisation has two instruments to achieve the object of curbing the sensual instincts and preventing or deterring over-indulgence.” He explains that one instrument is the government's enforcement of the law through penal codes and other instruments, importantly, the “civilisation is culture which acts through family training, tradition, religious belief, literature, and education. Culture puts down over-indulgence acting as an internal force, as distinguished from penal laws which operate from outside. Where it fails, it acts, though social obloquy and in very bad cases, through social ostracism". 



Thursday, August 13, 2020

Rajaji on Communism and Indian Communists

I have new piece on the forgotten thoughts of India's one of greatest classical liberal thinker C.Rajagopalachari or Rajaji on Communism and the real nature of Indian Communists.

Few paras from the piece:

"Rajaji also understood the maligning method of human psychology used by Indian communists. He noted that “the Communists are humble in the beginning, how they are smooth and oily and get into every group and try to get first the G.C.M. as I would call it and then by multiplying it by a convenient figure get the L.C.M. ”. 

He further beautifully observed that “the Communists first find out the Greatest Common Measure of everybody who have grievances and take possession of the G.C.M. and then multiply it by a factor which I call exaggeration and the exaggerated G.C.M. becomes the L.C.M. the Least Common Multiple. This is the arithmetical formula of the Communists. I have not discovered it here. It has been discovered during the last few decades to be the process by which Communists are operating in Eastern Europe…The formula has not been discovered by the Communist Party here. It is the result of long research in human psychology. They know how to work on human psychology.”  

Across the world, the “Communism works through this G.C.M. method, it gets hold of the people and the industries, and then everything is changed. Let me warn the country and the people as to what will happen in any country where Communists are to rule. After all, the fruit is the test of the tree” said Rajaji.




Tuesday, July 28, 2020

India, China: ancient civilisations, different paths

I have new article in SO website by Centre for Civil Society.

My article on India- China's ancient civilisational roots and their social, economic and political paths looks what many commentators especially the strategic geo economic commentators tend to ignore the historical past, they go upto 1962 or the times of Nehru or Patel letters!

"If anything, India could do well to learn from Deng himself: “… political independence and economic independence are inseparable. Without political independence, it is impossible to achieve economic independence; without economic independence, a country’s independence is incomplete and insecure.” With such leaders at the helm, little wonder that China has reached the stage it has."

Wednesday, May 13, 2020

Forgotten Speeches of GK Sundaram – Part I

                                           GK Sundaram-1914-2009

I have piece on GK Sundaram's forgotten speeches delivered in Indian Parliament when he was leader of Swatantra Party during the socialist era of Indira Gandhi.

Here is a slice from the piece:

In August 1969, Sundaram suggested the following eight measures to the government for framing pragmatic policies towards economic growth and inclusive development:
“(1) First and foremost is payment by result in industrial, agricultural, private, public, Government and other fields. This alone can achieve the goal. You may verify that countries which have devalued have stabilised their economy by sheer work. By hard work only they have come up and not by just planning or by fooling the people. 
(2) A substantial reduction in taxation is absolutely necessary to rebuild the industrial development. 
(3) We do not want an Everest effort. An earnest effort is necessary in agricultural production which we never had all these 15 years. 
(4) We must create confidence and give opportunity for the people to invest in industry. 
(5) Then, industrial development should not be impeded by controls. We must be free from controls. 
(6) Industry must have adequate rupee finance. At least, if you cannot provide with your money, do not stop them from getting it. 
(7) Provide enough incentive for exports wherever it is found absolutely necessary. 
(8) And last of all, reduce your expenditure drastically, whether it is private or public sector, but never attempt deficit financing either openly or secretly. 
The strength of the currency ultimately depends upon the level and growth of production. Economic policies should be made liberal, planning realistic and administration efficient.”


Tuesday, April 7, 2020

GK Sundaram: Swatantra’s Forgotten Tamil Leader

From my recent piece on GKSundaram (1914-2009), a tall classical liberal leader in Swatantra Party in Tamil Nadu:


"Rajaji had high regard for Sundaram’s leadership skills and abilities; thus, he was nominated as Swatantra Party Member to the Rajya Sabha and served from 1968 to 1974. As a member of Rajya Sabha, he actively participated in debates and contributed to the house from the perspectives of liberal principles. Sundaram’s speeches on deliberations on the Delhi Motor Vehicles Act, Gold Control Act, Nationalisation of Banks, Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices Act, The Essential Commodities Act, the Unlawful Activities Prevention Bill, etc. were noteworthy and made the government rethink its ill-conceived policies.
GK Sundaram argued that the Gold Control Act “would increase smuggling” and also eventually create “harm to internal security” which was witnessed later until the 1991 reforms. He also vehemently criticised the bank nationalisation. Regarding the MRTP Act, he said that the government aimed to merely to enforce the command and control without the view to provide economic freedom to produce more domestically. He had warned the Union Government that the MRTP Act “could cause a lot of hassles in the long run”, which indeed it did."

Sunday, April 5, 2020

The Forgotten Swatantra Party Leader in Tamil Nadu: G.K.Sundaram


Recently I read two articles on the Swatantra Party leader in Tamil Nadu GK Sundaram who was close associate of C.Rajagopalachari or Rajaji. These articles were published by Rajesh Govindarajulu in Simplycity Coimbatore.

The true history of Swatantra Party is yet to be written. Also the history of key leader of Tamil Nadu is also yet to be chronicled systematically. 

GK Sundaram's contribution to Swatantra Party in Tamil Nadu and national political economy is important but has been forgotten by all stakeholders.

Rajesh's two interesting articles are here and here.

Thursday, March 19, 2020

"To move resolution for removal of ‘socialism’ from Constitution"

This news is really interesting to see through the Upper House of Indian Parliament Member's move "to move resolution for removal of ‘socialism’ from Constitution"

It has been now close to five decades that the word "Socialism" was forcefully inserted in the Indian Constitution and which was not there in the original Constitution approved by founding fathers like BR Ambedkar, Rajaji, etc.

Every time, the issue of removal of the word socialism erupts, almost all kinds of people sites the below para to ponder over how prophetic thinker Ambedkar was.

“Ambedkar had argued that the Constitution is just a mechanism to regulate the work of the various arms of the states, and that the matters like how the policy of the state and the society’s organisation in the social and economic side should be matters which must be decided by people according to the time and circumstances. He argued and won the argument that it should be left to people to decide,”


Tuesday, January 7, 2020

VS Srinivasa Sastri – Forgotten Liberal Intellectual – Part 1

I have new article about VS Srinivasa Sastri (1869-1946) in the Spontaneous Order Online Publication of Centre for Civil Society- a top Free Market Economics Think Tank in New Delhi. This is first of two part serious on Sastri's life and works.

Almost all of us know about MK Gandhi's prominent role in India's Freedom Struggles. However, very few people know about the freedom struggles pursued by leaders like M.G.Ranade, GK Gokhale and VS Srinivasa Sastri.

Sastri opposed mostly Gandhi's politics for good reasons!

In his home land, Tamil Nadu, VS Srinivasa Sastri was ignored in the post independent period because he was Brahmin despite the fact that he had given financial assistance to several poor students for their education. He even adopted poor students!


Saturday, December 14, 2019

Reading on Veteran Statesman -Rajaji's 14st Birth Anniversary

On 10th December, 141st Birth Anniversary of Rajaji was celebrated across the country albeit in a small way. He was one of the great modern India's free market economic thinker Statesman. The social media attributives went too late recognizing the birthday of Rajaji!

The following are some of the major remembrance of Rajaji's great contributions to the Indian economy, society and polity by various people:

From Swarajya Magazine- On Rajaji’s Birthday: Four Must Read Articles





Saturday, December 7, 2019

LET NOT INDIA FORGET RAJAJI-A BRILLIANT, FAR SIGHTED INTELLECTUAL


The Indian media both print and electronic are very sacrosanct about giving importance to political news and negative news for publication rather than giving a much needed importance of liberal ideas. The article like the below would not get published in right time in Indian media including at regional level. That is the sad state of affairs. Approximately, every media gives at least 60 percent of the publication spaces to the political and advertisements rather than the much needed deserving matters and things. Hence, I am producing the entire article below for record:


When Nehru passed away, Rajaji was devastated and paid tributes to Nehru stating that Nehru was "Eleven years younger than me, eleven times more important for the nation and eleven hundred times more beloved of the nation”.

Rajaji (C.Rajagopalachari) was born on 10th December ,1878 and passed away on 25th December, 1972.

In the month of December, on the occasion of the birth and death anniversary of Rajaji, as one remembers his life history that was marked by robust thinking, simple life style, principled approach to the issues and guidance for the nation, one can see that most of the far sighted thoughts of Rajaji are highly relevant to the present time.
Let us highlight some of the actions and thought process of Rajaji that have stood the best of time.
Conscience Keeper :

Rajaji had close friendship with Mahatma Gandhi that was marked by mutual respect.
While speaking about Rajaji, Mahatma Gandhi said that Rajaji was his conscience keeper. What can be greater tribute to Rajaji’s sagacity more than what Ganhiji said about him ?.
Gandhiji led a glorious life of activities that was guided by his conscience. When Gandhiji said that Rajaji was his conscience keeper, it reflected on Rajaji’s brilliant intellectual capability combined with ethical and moral force.
Inter caste marriage :

Several critics of Rajaji, then and now, in Tamil Nadu made castiest remarks about Rajaji in a motivated manner .
However, it has been seen that most of such critics and some politicians in Tamil Nadu pay only lip support for inter caste marriage, though they speak loudly about the need for it to eradicate casteism.
On the other hand, Rajaji gave his daughter in marriage to Gandhiji’s son, though Rajaji and Gandhiji belonged to different caste. In this process, Rajaji ensured greater respectability and approval for the inter caste marriages in the country.
India Pakistan relationship:

Due to several historical reasons, it appears that it is almost impossible task for India and Pakistan to live in peace and harmony.
Rajaji realized such situation immediately after independence and said that people to people relationship was the need of the day between India and Pakistan. He said that development of mutual good will and understanding between citizens in various walks of life in India and Pakistan would force the politicians in both the countries to strive for amity.
Even today, this Rajaji’s suggestion appears to be the only way for India and Pakistan to live without animosity in the long run.
Opposition to Hindi :

During the pre independent days, Rajaji strongly advocated that every person in Tamil Nadu should learn Hindi language.
However, after the independence, when central government took measures that amounted to imposition of Hindi in non Hindi speaking states, Rajaji took strong objection and started opposing imposition of Hindi very strongly. At the same time, Rajaji repeatedly pointed out that he did not hate Hindi language.
When central government realized that even Rajaji was opposing the imposition of Hindi, it reversed it’s policy.
Prohibition in Tamil Nadu :

Rajaji was a strong advocate of prohibition and wrote several articles and made speeches in support of prohibition.
Rajaji was shocked when the then Chief Minister of Tamil Nadu Karunanidhi decided to lift prohibition to boost government ‘s income.
In spite of his ripe old age and inspite of the fact that Rajaji had the status of the former Governor General of India and in pouring rain, Rajaji went to Karunanidhi’s house and Rajaji appealed to Karunanidhi not to lift prohibition. However, Karunanidhi rejected Rajaji’s appeal and went ahead to lift prohibition.
Today, Tamil Nadu’s social fabric is severely disrupted, as large number of people have taken to liquor habit. Life of several women and many poor families have been shattered, as many menfolk have become liquor addicts.
Many people in Tamil Nadu think that Karunanidhi’s decision to life prohibition has become a curse for Tamil Nadu’s future and it’s social stability and progress. If Karunanidhi had listened to Rajaji’s appeal and refrained from lifting prohibition, perhaps Tamil Nadu would have emerged as model state for India.
Simple life style :

It is known that inspite of the lofty government positions he held , Rajaji used to wash his own clothes everyday.
Can we see today any politician or minister adopting such simple life style?
Population control :

Today, there is widespread concern in the country that level of population in India is increasing at alarming rate.
Inspite of several steps initiated by Government of India over the years, population growth could not be brought to acceptable level.
Rajaji anticipated this problem and said that population cannot be controlled by spreading contraceptive awareness amongst the people.
Rajaji said that with the spread of education and poverty eradication and better awareness of the issues involved, people themselves would realize the disadvantage of having large family and reduce the family size.
This is already happening in some parts of the country to some extent.
Political culture :

In the independent India, Rajaji and Nehru had serious difference of views with regard to economic development programme for the country.
While Nehru strongly believed in promoting public sector enterprises, Rajaji was of the view that without strengthening and encouraging private sector, Indian economy would not improve to the desirable level. As a matter of fact,Rajaji founded Swatantra party to spread his views and there were strong exchanges between Rajaji and Nehru on matters of economic approach.
However, their mutual respect and admiration remained intact reflecting the civilized political culture of both these leaders.
When Nehru passed away, Rajaji was devastated and paid tributes to Nehru stating that Nehru was “Eleven years younger than me, eleven times more important for the nation and eleven hundred times more beloved of the nation”.
Economic programme :

Rajaji strongly advocated the promotion of private enterprises in a big way and said that private initiatives are much needed for industrial and economic growth. He also criticized Nehru’s economic policies as “permit license quota raj”
Today, it is seen that central and state governments in India are taking special care to encourage private sector and are adopting industrial economic policies almost similar to what Rajaji advocated.
Pride of Tamil Nadu :

Tamil Nadu has seen in the past great personalities with blemishless personal life and strongly committed to the cause of human welfare , disapproval of division of society on any ground and they had unflinching loyalty to the cause of India.
Such great personalities who hailed from Tamil Nadu in the pre independent days include Kamaraj, Bharathiar, V.O. Chidambaram, Periyar, Rajaji and others.
Periyar and Rajaji were often thought by people as political adversaries. However, it was known that Periyar consulted Rajaji on personal matters and both of them had healthy relationships, inspite of different political views.
When Rajaji passed away , in his ripe old age sitting in a wheel chair, Periyar went to the cremation ground and wept inconsolably.
Today, we see in Tamil Nadu some political leaders belonging to different parties even hate to meet or speak with each other. They need to learn from Rajaji and Periyar about political culture.
Appeal to indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi:
While India remembers Mahatma Gandhi, Jawaharlal Nehru, Sardar Vallabhai Patel and a few others on their birth and death anniversary, Rajaji does not get such national attention which he richly deserves.
On forthcoming birth anniversary of Rajaji on 10th December, I appeal to the Prime Minister Modi to remember Rajaji and pay his tributes to this great man that will receive national attention and the younger generation will understand and appreciate Rajaji’s high qualities of wisdom, honesty and intellectual brilliance and contribution to the national cause. Such role models are the need of the day.
N. S. Venkataraman is a trustee with the "Nandini Voice for the Deprived," a not-for-profit organization that aims to highlight the problems of downtrodden and deprived people and support their cause. To promote probity and ethical values in private and public life and to deliberate on socio-economic issues in a dispassionate and objective manner.

Tuesday, November 12, 2019

Remembering Tall Leadership of C.N.Annadurai


Remembering Tall Leadership of C.N.Annadurai

B.Chandrasekaran, interested in Indian Economic History

During the period of last century, Tamil Nadu always had tall leaders with vision for the development of people and protecting the interests of the State. Notably C.Rajagopalachari, Periyar E.V.Ramasamy, K.Kamaraj, M.Bakthavatsalam, C.N.Annadurai, M.Karunanidhi, M.G.Ramachandran and J.Jayalalithaa have all played a pivotal role in the politics of Tamil Nadu. These leaders have also possessed remarkable assertiveness and played a catalytic role at national level to get the demands of the State from Central government.

For the first time, there is an unprecedented vacuum in today’s Tamil Nadu politics without strong leadership especially after the demise of both J.Jayalalithaa and M.Karunanidhi in 2016 and 2018 respectively. Their mentor C.N.Annadurai’s fiftieth death anniversary marks this year. Annadurai was passed away on 3rd February, 1969 at a midst of most active in politics and leaving a remarkable political career. He was born on 15th September, 1909 at a place called Kancheepuram near Chennai to a weaving family. He rose to a tall formidable stature. He was called Bernard Shaw of South. He had many hats, a prolific writer, orator, publisher, editor, etc.

Tamil Nadu is now not only a leaderless State but leaders without vision and caliber to attract masses. The leaders who are at the helm of the affairs are neither clean image nor dutiful to the masses who voted them into power. Indeed, it is ironic that today’s political leaders are fumbling with Central government for favours without strong political leadership skills to represent the concerns of the people and demand what is due from the Central government in constitutional provisions.

While C.N.Annadurai had groomed next level of leadership to take over from him, but his admires both M.Karunanidhi and J.Jayalalithaa carefully avoided grooming the next level of leadership. As a result, the ability of Edappadi K.Palaniswami and O.Panneerselvam is not only clueless but appears deep-rooted lethargic attitude in government machineries. Also, these leaders have no credibility of any kind except the benami gangs and their own baggage of corruption charges. But one thing is common for all of them which is the lack of an assertive political leadership and decisive in matters of importance of the State’s interest.

Therefore, there is a lot to learn from CN.Annadurai’s strong leadership and his vision for the State. Despite his differences with Rajaji and Kamaraj on many aspects, he always maintained high regards to both of them for their knowledge and clean image of simplicity with which they served for the state and country.

Annadurai clearly emerged as tall leader who was admired by masses after Rajaji and Kamarai to take over the political leadership of the State in 1969. Both Rajaji and Kamaraj worked with Mahatma Gandhi for freedom movements. But Annadurai worked with Periyar E.V.Ramasamy for social reforms and parted with his own vision. Unlike Rajaji, Kamaraj, and Periyar what distinguishes Annadurai was that he had a vision for his people and the State to work with it and strived relentlessly till his last day.

Reading original works of Annadurai reveals sadly a big gap between what he envisioned for his people and the State and the parties which ruled the last fifty years in ignoring greatly. His concern for poor people’s suffering is something which was not followed in letter and spirit for bettering after his demise.

He founded the Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (DMK) in 1949 with his supporters after parted from his political guru Periyar. Its myth that Annadurai followed Periyar’s crude methods of social reforms, he actually had his own approach as moderate with adjustable temperament. Anna disagreed and condemned his political guru Periyar's fanatics about the burning of Hindu God's photos in public places and using vulgar languages in public meetings against Hindu God. He also understood the pitfalls of extremist’s ideas and current underpinnings of the social norms which are centuries old which cannot be eradicated through electoral politics or iconoclasm approach.

According to P.C.Ganesan, who wrote a biography of C.N. Annadurai (1982) under the serious of ‘Makers of Modern India’ published by The Publications Division of Government of India, Annadurai was never an “atheist” (page 108). 

In an interview which has been mentioned in the Ganesan’s book, Annadurai himself had said that “I was always pleading for real faith in god. I mean by real faith, prayer to God through service and work which will be related to the generating of faith in society. I have always tried to see that our people do not lose faith in god. At the same time, I had been anxious that they do not become hypocritical in their life”. Ganesan worked with Annadurai who edited an English Weekly “Homeland”.

Annadurai admired Mahatma Gandhi for his simplicity and his vision for the country. Anna stood by Gandhi for the prohibition of liquor in Tamil Nadu throughout his life but M.Karunanidhi lifted the prohibition after his demise. Both Rajaji and Kamaraj pleaded to Karunanithi not to lift the prohibition but he did not agree on the ground of revenues. Similarly, M.G.Ramachandran who came to power after split from DMK by forming All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam also followed the same as Karunanithi. J. Jayalalithaa promised for total prohibition both in power and when not in power but gigantically failed by blaming the DMK!

Moreover, Annadurai strongly believed and stood by it throughout his political career that there should be a considerable distance between the political leader who is having a higher position in government and their family to serve the people impartially without nepotism and despotism. He also believed that there should be a considerable distance between the ruling party in government and the party affairs to serve equally, the concerns of all sections of people represented by different political parties.

Both DMK and AIADMK did not follow these aspects in the last fifty years of ruling Tamil Nadu. Indeed, there was no difference between the DMK’s past President M Karunanithi and his family. If DMK voted to power only Karunanithi would become Chief Minister and it was ruled out long back that he can only be the party Chief also. But Anna did not encourage the policy of one person having both CM and Party Chief.  The party and political power were enormously glowing with each other paving all kinds of nepotism. Anna’s true Dravidian principles were put into a vain soon after his death but carefully used for vote motives.

In the case of AIADMK, it was few families who did the same kinds of nepotism practiced by the DMK. The democratic values propounded by Annadaurai were in vain soon after his passing away in both the parties which also applies to all other parties in Tamil Nadu. This is not something which Annadurai could have expected from his trusted lieutenants. Tamil Nadu was once cherished with tall political leaders who adhered to political principles without expecting favours of any kind. Now, it is daunting quite dangerously that the mighty power and money become a rule book for entry into politics.  

The current Dravidian polity becomes a too tangled with either in Tamil language or the most paralyzed identity of Tamil culture. Both are deeply rooted with vested interests of the political establishments which invariably either polarize or bipolarize the vote banks. At times, it looks even too circumvention when both DMK and AIADMK followers paint with block colour on the names written in Hindi at national highways/railways/central government offices in Tamil Nadu. It’s ridiculous but that these parties have indoctrinated their cadre with chauvinism. It’s nothing but anti-national.

Ironically, the Dravidian parties which hate Hindi language but a large number of Hindi speaking labourers have been employed in industries run by Tamil people who do not like the Hindi. It is a mockery, nowhere in the world is seen a situation like this. Moreover, there are all kinds of Hindi speaking traders from north India who are ranging from tiny Paani Puriwala to big shopkeepers and mall owners in all across Tamil Nadu.

I have come crossed many children of northern Indian families studying in government schools in Erode learning not only Tamil language but studying other subjects in Tamil too. If Annadurai is alive today, according to his biographer R.Kannan “Anna would have treated the question of language as a personal one, leaving the choice in the individual's hands.” Therefore, learning Hindi in Tamil Nadu as an optional subject would not harm Tamil language rather it would aid greatly to strengthen the Tamil language market to rest of India. Also, the States in North should not hesitate to introduce Tamil as optional subject in their schools.

Ideology does not matter to him always but yet Annadurai was an independent thinker and writer who genuinely concerned about the welfare of people. He was very much conscious of an active political career not having enmity in any manner with other leaders. He also did not hate or poke with lose languages on anyone in the political arena and that is what everybody admires him even after fifty years of demise. His life and works have great lessons to contemporary politicians who are aiming to capture the power. Their understanding of the State’s core challenges is very poor.  Thus, these leaders neither have leadership caliber nor clear vision for the State.

Annadurai always believed that a leader has to be genuinely concerned about people's plights rather than aiming to capture the political power within a year of founding a party. He also strongly believed that founding a political party is quite different from coming to power with the trusts of people. He called this as mature politics should always venture in contributing to the challenges of the State and concerns of people. DMK came to power only after matured politics of 18 years with genuine concerns over issues and challenges of the State. He did not oppose anything blindly but invited openly others to convince him with facts and arguments to serve better in the interests of common people needs. Will our politicians learn from Anna or for that matter what is good from both Karunanithi and Jayalalithaa? Only time will tell us the truth.

Friday, August 16, 2019

1909-2019: Remember ONE NEW PERSON on Independence Day

Friends,

Yesterday was a important day for all of us. Its our Independence Day!

I have a bit of different take for this year's Independence Day.
Let's pledge each one of us to the truth that our Nation attained freedom because of the tireless life of millions of people who fought for our well being, safety, peace and prosperity. And we should not merely pay homage to only one or two who has been branded mistakenly by many in the contemporary world.
So, my humble request to all of you is to remember at least ONE NEW PERSON whom you never heard till now but he or she would have given their life to our beloved country's independence.
Past one month, I have been reading the works of several people who have done great jobs securing the constitutional methods of approach to attaining freedom from evils regimes in British India.
When I say constitution, do not mistaken me only with B R Ambedkar or the galaxy of people in the drafting committee or panels. He did great works no doubt about it but who else have done equally great works is our duty to remember faithfully that they don't merely pass away from our dutiful memory.
The independent India's intellectuals have done great injustice to many great classical liberal thinkers of first half of twentieth century. These classical liberals were the main freedom fighters unbelievably working closely with British Empire before the hegemony of Gandhi and Nehru period.
Indeed, there is quite striking similarity between the current year 2019 and 1909. For first time, the Indian National Congress was split on major reform policies evolved during 1908-1909 into two groups: main leaders were called extremists vs liberals. This split in major reform policies mindset and the ideology still hunts us in today's contemporary public policy making whether it is Congress or BJP or any other family run State level parties.
So, there is a amount of rational way of bringing reforms and policies through constitutional methods instead of protests, fasts, strikes, blacking public vehicles etc. The constitutional approach to protest for policy reforms was adopted by Dadabhai, Ranade, Gokhale, VS Srinivasa Sastri, Ambedkar, etc. The fasts protests etc were adopted by Tilak, Pal, Rai, Gandhi, Nehru, etc. Is these extremists leaders who captured the mainstream political power by ignoring the voices of the liberals scholars.
But the contributions to freedom struggles by Ranade, Gokhale and Sastri, etc. were completely ignored by every section of the society. I find this as ridiculous to continue for several generations.
The entire gamut of public policy making minds in India since the independence are the second rate category with protests, strikes etc without any differences in political parties.
We need to come out of this crude mind set of wild act without any logical reasoning on subjects. There is great amount of tragedies done through the act of strikes, protests, etc. both morally and psychically in the name of one community or segments of population or particular region.
Therefore, do take few minutes to ask your parents, grandparents, friends etc to remember the freedom fighters in your locality and also try to know some of the forgotten great souls of our freedom movements. 

Jai Hind,
Chandra....

Monday, July 1, 2019

Forest Rights, Third Pillar and Jawaharlal Nehru was an A-minus intellectual


Forest Rights, follow Gujarat Model says SA Aiyar in ToI:
"The folly of this becomes clear when we look at events in Dediapada taluka, Gujarat. Forest officials have been reluctant to recognise tribal rights fully. But in 2009, the bamboo forest in Dediapada flowered and died en masse. The dry fallen bamboo constituted a major fire hazard. So, the local divsional forest officer authorised local tribals to collect, transport and sell the dead bamboo.
With assistance from ARCH Vahini, a local NGO, the tribals struck a deal with the nearby JK Paper Mills to sell dry bamboo at Rs 2,815 per tonne. Between April 2014 and June 2015, the tribals supplied 96,000 tonnes of bamboo, yielding Rs 12 crore in wages and a net profit of Rs 6.5 crore, kept in a panchayat account for further investment in plantations. JK Paper Mills offered free saplings and technical advice to expand the bamboo groves."
"Finally, Reddy also laments the lack of funding for the third pillar, municipal and village government. Here he faults the states for not taking Panchayati Raj seriously, and for not periodically setting up State Finance Commissions that would allocate funds between the state and its local bodies. States are guilty of doing to their local bodies what the Centre has done to them."
Natwar Singh discloses that:

Rajaji: You should have come with me to the Columbia University meeting. The boys and girls were very intelligent and asked meaningful questions as to what dharma is and what karma is. I told them dharma was universal duty plus natural order. They said, then it was socialism. I said, “Yes, if it was voluntary, but not the Indian Government’s socialism.” It was not a public meeting, so I said it. I do not want to do anything to embarrass you or the Government here.


Saturday, June 8, 2019

Why Swatantra?

The following are other important articles and books links for the readers to muse how and why the Swatantra demise took place in liberal Indian context:


 Why Swatantra? by C. Rajagopalachari 

The Rise And Fall Of The Swatantra Party

Swatantra Party @ 60

The greatest Indian liberal C Rajagopalachari alies Rajaji founded the Swatantra Party, 60 years ago to fight with Nehru's socialist ideas and project.

The following some of the interesting reading, which is worth to read and ponder for the current political economy of India:



The full book is available in PDF here.

I have read the Chapter 5 on Why India does not have a Liberal Party? by Kumar Anand.

The following are my comments to the above chapter:

Mr Kumar says in the above chapter "The market does exist for a liberal party. Farmers are waiting.It is up to the liberals to take
advantage of this. (Page 75)"

Since, the property right has been removed out of fundamental rights under Indian Constitute, nobody would like to talk about it because it is a right like any other right under the constitution. So we need to restore the property right back to Fundamental Rights. In India, among liberals, who is convinced to fight for it now? So this is also ruled out that it is not going to happen in our lifetime. Also, the general feeling is that why do we want to get back to fundamental rights? SO there is not demand for it now. First, most fails to understand the urgency of it and secondly the mobilizations to fight for it is not happening.

Moreover, the political market in India is closed within the ambit of "Socialist" values in the Indian Constitution allegedly amended by the Indira Gandhi during the Emergency period. Unless, we liberals remove the word socialist under Indian constitution, the dream for liberal party is not possible in our lifetime.
 
In 1976, "The 42nd Amendment amended Preamble and changed the description of India from "sovereign democratic republic" to a "sovereign, socialist secular democratic republic", and also changed the words "unity of the nation" to "unity and integrity of the nation"."

So, talking about socialism and welfare state is a vital tool for all political parties in India to get engaged with public for vote and other matters.
If you talk about free market in political platform, it is a sin and always favours for crony capitalists,that is how the public memory is now, for long time. And the Election Commission of India will ban the political parties which is not adhering to the socialist values.

Do read this article by eminent lawyer

Saturday, August 2, 2014

Good read


No labour pain? Rajasthan clears business blockades to encourage industrial activity, generate jobs

"Yesterday, a office driver told me that there i high level of inflation in India because there is too much loan handouts in the society. When I asked what you mean by too much loan, he said almost for anything there is some or other ways to get loans for upper middle class and middle class community both in urban and rural areas and that is creating higher inflation. Too many people chasing too few goods."

Rajaji said to the governors: “You should not imagine that you are just figureheads and can do nothing… Our prime minister and deputy prime minister do not hold that view. They want you to develop your influence for good and they expect you to find means for achieving it without friction and without prejudice to the march of democracy.”

Swatantra Party and Thiruvalluvar's birthday

Thanks to Seetha for her wonderful article on the case for "The Swatantra Party’s relevance today comes through in Rajaji’s inaugural address to the party, where he warned of the dangers of the state becoming a Leviathan, “menacingly poised against the citizen, interfering with his life at all points...hypnotising the people with slogans that are mistaken for thought and wisdom, a scheme of government in which it is taken for granted that the citizen is ignorant of what is his own interest”. 

Thanks to the great imprinting voice by Shri.Tarun Vijay, who spoke in the upper of the Indian Parliament about the need for learning of southern and other regions languages by northern Indians. The following are from his speech in the parliament on 31st July, 2014:

"The glorious history of all Indian languages is unique and supremely great. We must work to develop feelings of appreciation and respect for each other.

In this regard it is necessary that people from North India be encouraged to learn any one Southern language through a free choice option.

For example the incomparable golden heritage that we have in the form of Tamil should make every Indian proud.

Tolkappiam, ,app 5000 years old. And on a broad spectrum Silappadigaram, Chintamani, Manimekalai, Valayapathi and Gundalakesi are great classics of Tamil literature.

The onus of the greatest classic in Tamizh literature undoubtedly goes to Kambar's Ramayana, the epic poem


One of the greatest works in Tamizh, which is widely preached even to this day, is Tiruvalluvar's Tirukkural .



Its imprints are found in various parts of the globe. How many of us know about the global influence and public services of great emperors likeChera, Chola, and Pandya kings ? Only Ashoka and Vikramaditya are not India, unless we have an all encompassing respect for Cholas, Krishnadev Rayas and Pandyas also. Similarly we have great history of Bangla, Malayalam, Telugu and other languages.

I demand observing Thiruvalluvar's birthday as Glorious Indian Languages Day in all parts of the country symbolising respect for all Indian languages and introducing Tamil also in North Indian schools as an optional subject for strengthening national unity. Mr Tarun Vijay ended his special mention with Palamaiyana Tamil Mozhiyar Vananguhiren."

Sunday, July 27, 2014

Odd reading

At times in the dynamic world of human interaction it is good to follow a odd reading habit. I say odd with blinking  muse of three different worlds, yes three worlds within us-the society, the economy, and the politics.

I also find more useful and also peaceful to simply read things at lea-nth rather to co-opt to write and argue the same stuffs with different slang in languages.

Here are the recent odd reading:

Most of my last decade was spent working with nuts in govts.....At no point I can bear with good B.............ts as saying there are exceptions.


... there are too many people and too much paper money around.

Politics over new head of ICHR- I tend to agree more with S.Dasgupta than R.Guha.

From Guha's piece: "Contrary to what is sometimes claimed in the press, there are many fine historians in India. From my own generation of scholars, I can strongly recommend — to student and lay reader alike — the work of Upinder Singh on ancient India, of Nayanjot Lahiri on the history of archaeology, of Vijaya Ramaswamy on the bhakti movement, of Sanjay Subrahmanyam on the early history of European expansion, of Chetan Singh on the decline of the Mughal State, of Sumit Guha on the social history of Western India, of Seema Alavi on the social history of medicine, of Niraja Gopal Jayal on the history of citizenship, of Tirthankar Roy on the economic consequences of colonialism, of Mahesh Rangarajan on the history of forests and wildlife, and of A.R. Venkatachalapathy on South Indian cultural history."

From Dasgupta's piece: "as repeated controversies have indicated, history is too serious a business to be left to the “eminent historians”. For the past few decades, India’s awareness of its own past has shrunk on account of the growing insularity of its historians. Judging by the dense and jargon-infested prose, India’s historians are no longer communicating with the wider world but engaging in closed-door conversations. This has to change." 

Rajaji said to the governors: “You should not imagine that you are just figureheads and can do nothing… Our prime minister and deputy prime minister do not hold that view. They want you to develop your influence for good and they expect you to find means for achieving it without friction and without prejudice to the march of democracy.”