Showing posts with label Indian Urbanization. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Indian Urbanization. Show all posts

Thursday, May 20, 2021

Cities need to adopt a bundle of fundamentals: Case study of Erode in Tamil Nadu

This my new article on how cities governance has to be shaped up with a case of a tiny Erode city in western Tamil Nadu.

A slice from the piece:

"Public policies in cities need to provide an enabling environment and a level-playing field to promote and nurture its      common identities with a strong governance system in place and to protect the interests of all. However, a tiny city like Erode in the western part of Tamil Nadu indicates anything but this  in the sense of good governance. Recently, there was news that the district administration of Erode has invited suggestions from the public to improve its road traffic systems, although the district administration has a very limited role in the growth and development of city administration and reforms."

My other articles on Erode city governance, growth and development are here, here,


Wednesday, February 10, 2021

Biodigester: An Antidote to Cities’ Septage Management Challenges

I have a new article on one of the underpinning cities of cities in India. It is even grave situation in state like Tamil Nadu.

Few years ago DRDO, GoI, had came out with a decentralized technology to address the septage waste management, despite its high potentials, this technology has not been revolutionized yet. This year Union Budget has also talked about it a bit.


This article explains the need for revolutionary of decentralized septage waste management with bio-digester technology,


Very few companies makes cost effective DRDO model bio-digester septage tanks with its technology, MAK India Limited is one such company which makes quality bio-digester with cost effective manner.

Friday, October 23, 2020

India Needs Dynamic Ecosystems for Making Smart Cities Work

I have new article on Smart Cities Initiatives in India published by the CPPR. In India, the cities are still governed by State capitals and National Capital instead of decentralized form of governance to improve for ease of living by all means.

The piece mainly discusses the below issues:

"As part of the smart cities initiatives guidelines, the Union Ministry of Urban Development had notified in September 2016 to create a City-Level Advisory Forum (CLAF) comprising all major stakeholders including elected representatives of that city, local youth, technical experts, associations of taxpayers, residents’ welfare, trade and commerce associations, etc. However, this Forum was not functional until recently and most Smart Cities in the country including Tamil Nadu were created this year or in the last few months only."

Wednesday, July 22, 2020

Embracing Decentralisation to Speed-up Smart Cities Projects

I have new article in the CPPR blog about the assessment of five years of implementation of smart cities projects in India:

The main arguments are in the below para:

"The dismal performances of Smart City Mission projects are attributed to many elements such as lack of good governance and decentralisation at urban local bodies’ level even after the Constitutional Amendments made close to three decades ago. Moreover, Smart City Mission projects mainly were faced with lack of political leadership to drive effective transformations at national, state and city levels; the lethargic bureaucratic planning, project designs minus citizens’ participation; complete dilution of mission guidelines and norms of special purpose vehicles (SPVs); not including subject experts from industry and public policy practitioners in the planning stage itself; lack of transparency in detailed projects preparations by private consultancy firms; and more importantly, corruption in tendering process with political interferences, especially in Tamil Nadu. Also, there were no links between the actual projects initiated and initial reports prepared by private consulting firms involving citizens for feedback."

Wednesday, March 4, 2020

Trichy’s Initiatives to Enhance Ease of Living

My new article discusses the challenges before the Trichy City Corporation in achieving the vision of ‘ease living for all’. It also sheds light on how a slew of innovative initiatives undertaken by it, involving citizens in most of the programmes, have yielded good results.

Friday, February 14, 2020

Can Good Governance Fetch better Ranking for Erode City?

This is my 3rd article on the issues and challenges faced by Erode City which is situated in western part of Tamil Nadu. It is a tiny city with few lakh population, a highly dynamic city with global markets link but the city's basic infrastructure services are pathetic. Full article is here.

This article explains about the ranking of Erode city at national level on different parameters over the past years, very bad shape!

I have lived last few years in Erode city experiencing the worlds of involving closely with the city corporation as development professional. At the end of it, it does not make any sense of most of the efforts taken in the name of Development at city level without involving citizens participants and taking advantages of technology in reforms of governance systems riddled with corruptions at all levels. 

Tuesday, December 24, 2019

The Planned Chaos of Erode City



I have new article published on The Planned Chaos of Erode City by Centre for Public Policy Research. The below are some excerpt of article.

Unsound Cities

Out of 100 big cities in India, 10 cities are in the State of Tamil Nadu (Chennai, Madurai, Coimbatore, Salem, Tiruchirappalli, Tirupur, Erode, Thirunalveli, Vellore and Thoothukkudi) in terms of population size with four lakhs and above. Tamil Nadu is the most urbanised state in the country. These cities are Tier I, Tier II and Tier III and have become rattled with many challenges and critical issues that were debated for decades. But few were piloted for plausibility in implementation and fixing the gaps to scale it up. In the last 25 years, hardly anything achieved in Tier I cities in Tamil Nadu substantially to showcase as “The Model” for Tier II &III cities and towns for implementing the so-called “Best Practices” on public civic deliverables. The age-old centralisation of power and control mechanisms are still a daunting factor to defeat the 18 delegated functions envisaged in the 74th Constitutional Amendments made in 1992 to strengthen urban local bodies.  
However, in order to shackle the redundant decades-old challenges and critical issues of cities such as solid waste management, construction of toilets for individual houses/community, quality drinking water, hygiene and sanitation, sewerage management, protecting water streams from pollution, streamlining streets for all kind of people and not merely for mighty vehicles, Green Parks, streets lights, etc., there were few initiatives in the last five years mainly driven by the Government of India’s initiatives to identify ways and means to address by streamlining city governance structure with the aid of technology and institutional collaborations.

Thursday, November 14, 2019

The leapfrogging of Indian Smart Cities


The leapfrogging of Indian Smart Cities

B.Chandrasekaran, works in public policy

Indian cities were evolved as a driving force for development and growth in the last thirty years by infusion of mass migration for education and employment opportunities. Most of the Indian cities are not developed in a particular design with an order either by the State or by the societal norms or market forces which evolve spontaneously. Hence, most of the urban population in India lives not in orders with designs of civic amenities and public services. In other words, the cities are facing huge challenges in dealing with social equity, economic viability, and environmental sustainability on access to the services and facilities of common utility.

The pace of urbanisation has been increasing in recent decades without the basic livable amenities which are more threats in the short term than opportunities. India has 4,041 cities and towns. According to Pratap Padode, Founder of Smart Cities Council India Chapter, "China has developed 30 cities in the last thirty years with over 1 million population. India has 53 cities or rather urban agglomerations with over 1 million population while China has over 160. The municipal act needs an overhaul if we expect a commitment for building sustainable cities that will last centuries." Even after more than two decades of passing the 74th Amendments in 1992 which empowers urban local bodies to govern its affairs with autonomy is yet to be realized fully.

Further, according to UNDP’s Research Paper (2000) titled “Decentralisation in India Challenges & Opportunities” which revealed that “it is not surprising that most municipalities were and still exist in a financially precarious position. In 1986-87, the income of all municipal bodies in Class 1 towns exceeded their expenditure only by Rs.311 million. The overlapping territories and responsibilities between ULBs and Development Authorities led to problems of non-co-ordination, and more seriously increased corruption and lack of accountability".

The main impediments faced by cities across India are Municipals Acts which are redundant in many ways resisting to change its bureaucratic mindsets towards the aspirations of millennials. Any city qualified to be the best in its quality should have excellences in services delivery in basic services like equitable access to roads, potable water, sewage systems, street lights, footpaths, power supply, and proper education and healthcare facilities with the precision of compliance systems to the residents with open and transparent governance systems. Without the above, the tweaking here and there will only help short-term gains of social attention and political gimmicks to the vested interests groups of which the larger public are not a party to.

It would be interesting to see the outcomes of major projects initiated under India's Smart Cities Mission because the structural reforms which were said to be prerequisite were not carried out to make concrete efforts to improve the basic amenities for better living of all. In the process, though much has gone into the underpinning challenges faced in the reorientation of the process for urban planning and designing which are no less than the age-old red-tape system yet to adopt new changes.
The Union Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs had launched targeted programmes to improve the basic amenities in 100 cities through Smart City Mission in June 2015. Now, it has been more than four years eloped since the launch of Mission. Out of 100 cities, 90 of them were selected between January, 2016 and June, 2017. The under the Smart Cities Initiatives, the involvement of critical masses was often faced with the dilemma of expansion of existing cities or the creation of new ones. Mostly, the existing cities are decided to repair it instead of building new cities.

While launching the latest Progress Report 2019 on Indian Smart Cities, the Secretary of the Union Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs informed that till now total projects completed in various cities are 1,100 only which is worth Rs.201 billion. Also, Pratap Padode said that only “10% of the planned projects have been completed in the past three years.” This is very minuscule compared to what has been aimed to achieve by end of March 2019.

However, more on the pipelines, out of the 5,000 projects taken up across 100 cities, nearly 3,880 or 78 percent of the project proposed were given tenders for implementation. The tendered 3,880 projects are worth Rs.1,418 billion and projects under implementation are 3,100 which is worth Rs.1,004 billion. Also, the Progress Report highlights the cities which have tendered for various projects are 12 Smart Command and Control Centres for the comprehensive city-centric data management system, 92 public-private partnership projects, 107 smart road projects, 10 Smart Solar projects, 31 wastewater treatment projects, and 46 Smart Water projects. It could be possible that many of these projects were designed in the pretense of OUTCOME based approach for the sustainability of assets created.

It clearly shows that the present urban local body’s capacity to scale up the initiatives with smart solutions are stuck with its bureaucratic mode of planning, designing and implementation with little or no space for public participation. Urban local bodies have to constantly upgrade the skills and capabilities to their functionaries to overcome emerging challenges. Though, the current systems of urban local bodies are under tremendous pressure from stakeholders to change its styles of functions with more transparency. They should strive to involve the private agencies which have high creditability among the public to develop the process and designs to implement the projects in a time-bound manner.

The framework of Special Purpose Vehicles (SPV) for Smart Cities was said to be well-thought-out plan but very little has been grounded to effect changes. For example, out of 11 Smart Cities in Tamil Nadu, only Chennai Smart City had appointed CEO and other staff under SPV. All other cities are functioning without CEOs and thereby the SPVs are ineffective. Moreover, many Smart Cities are yet to appoint the subject experts from the private sector as Directors in their SPVs to have an inclusive process of decision making. Therefore, the foundation for building cities of the 21st century nature is still far away from the foreseeable future.

Saturday, September 21, 2019

The Challenges of Erode City

I have new article published in The Kathir Times, a online publication. I have never read anyone written the below lines or anything like that in the past. This is something ignored by everybody in the mainstream public debate. And may be conveniently ignored for their vested interests!

"The Dravidian ideology cannot stop the army of labourers who are moving in large numbers since the last two decades from north to south for education and employment opportunities. How people in Tamil Nadu are employing Hindi speaking labourers in industries from the north without even knowing the Hindi language is interesting? Partially, it’s done through bigoted managers, contractors, and modern bonded labourer systems! But it is ironic that some of the Tamils like Hindi speaking labourers but not the Hindi language."

Monday, June 24, 2019

M K Gandhi and F A Hayek needed for New India

Sanjeev Sabhlok has very interesting article wherein he says beautifully 
"Hayek’s best-known paper – the exhilarating The Use of Knowledge in Society – expounds an extraordinarily complex theory in plain English. Till the end of his life, such as with his last book, “The Fatal Conceit”, Hayek continued to show socialists that they do not have, cannot have, the knowledge necessary for a society to succeed. His Nobel lecture was beautifully entitled, The Pretence of Knowledge.
But socialists are oblivious to his insights. Full of the fatal conceit he cautioned against, confident in their pretence of knowledge and ability to plan for the “masses”, they reject Hayek without having read him. A senior former IAS officer told me that Hayek is irrelevant since he advocated an unbridled free-market. Such socialists give Hayek a bad rap without having read him, just as Gandhi rejected Adam Smith without reading his work." More here.

Wednesday, May 29, 2013

Rural Gandhi vs Urban Ambedkar

From Niranjan Rajadhyaksha's article in today's Livemint:
  • Indian public policy suffers from a well-known Gandhian bias, with a pious belief in rural development even though development patterns the world over show that countries have emerged out of poverty through urbanization. B.R. Ambedkar, who had a very direct experience of social oppression, had little patience with the glorification of village life: “The love of the intellectual Indian for the village community is of course infinite, if not pathetic… What is a village but a sink of localism, a den of ignorance, narrow mindedness and communalism?”
  • But what is less well known is that Ambedkar was a trained economist who argued in one of his earliest papers, written in 1918, that India needed to help people migrate from agriculture to industry: “A large agricultural population with the lowest proportion of land in actual cultivation means that a large part of the agricultural population is superfluous and idle…this labour when productively employed will cease to live by predation as it does today, and will not only earn its keep but will give us surplus; and more surplus means more capital. In short, strange as it may seem, industrialization of India is the soundest remedy for the agricultural problems of India”.
  • There has been a robust debate in India on the relative merits of the Gandhian versus Ambedkarite visions on the direction the country should take in the future. The varying demographic trends in modern India—especially the rapid decline in rural population growth in some states—could create disagreements in the political system that in some ways echo the old debates on a rural versus urban future.

Friday, November 2, 2012

Back to Normal!!

Friends thanks for bearing with me! I got married on 18th of last month. Hence, no post for long period. Not many things happening in India in terms of new good economic policy making. Anti-corruption movement wallas taking up self-stage for granted partly believing that the voters are their side or for that matter the funding parties.

Though, there were many interesting readings in the past two weeks. Here some of them.



IAC should go beyond corruption by Prof P V Indiresan




Monday, April 16, 2012

Calcutta into London

A resident of calcutta writes in "....let me tell you how the last four British prime ministers have been portrayed in cartoons in London newspapers: John Major, always wearing his underpants outside his trousers; Tony Blair, as a one-eyed monster, sometimes as a one-eyed poodle trotting after George W. Bush; Gordon Brown, as a square, financial thug and bouncer; David Cameron, repeatedly, as an empty, blown-up condom. Along with these, they have also repeatedly had George Bush as a rampant, psychopathic chimpanzee, (once actually wiping his bottom with the UN logo), they’ve had Nicolas Sarkozy as all sorts of ferret-like animals, Berlusconi as a lecherous octopus and, recently, Angela Merkel as a dominatrix in skimpy black leather costume and fishnet stockings, wielding a financial whip over the exposed backsides of other European leaders. Besides this, one of the most widely read British satirical magazines, Private Eye, almost always has actual photographs of leaders and royalty with fictional speech bubbles coming out of their mouths, saying the most outrageous things. Let me tell you, no one has ever sued about these portrayals, no one is beaten up, no one is arrested, no one even lodges a written protest."

Monday, August 8, 2011

Uninspiring map of city and sex

Here is a lines to ponder hugely:

In aravind Adiga’s Last Man in Tower, a doctor commenting on builder Dharmen Shah’s admiration for China, says astutely, “The first experience of Shanghai to a middle-aged Indian businessman [is] what the first experience of sex is to a teenager.”

More here

Tuesday, May 31, 2011

Dalits affairs on capitalism

Here is my piece in today’s Wall Street Journal (Asia) which argues for the free market ideas of B.R.Ambedkar. It also talks about his views on English, urbanization etc.

Friday, October 29, 2010

Das on Cities:

  • Because of the harsh, ugly reality of urban squalor, we try to escape in pastoral dreams of the countryside. Mahatma Gandhi, a man of the city, had such a romantic view before B.R. Ambedkar, corrected him: 'What is the village but a sink of localism, a den of ignorance, narrow-mindedness and communalism?'

Thursday, August 19, 2010

Urban apathy

According a Government of India’s Ministry of Urban Development:

  • Rating of 423 Class- I cities on various sanitation related parameters has been conducted under the National Urban Sanitation Policy (NUSP) during the period December, 2009 to March, 2010. The aim of the exercise was to assess the performance of the cities in the area of sanitation with respect to outputs, processes and outcomes including environmental and health outcomes. 189 cities were categorized as red cities scoring less than 34 marks out of 100 marks and 230 cities as black cities scoring 34-66 marks out of 100 marks. 4 cities were categorized as blue scoring 67-90 marks out of 100 marks. None of the cities were categorized as green. Cities in the red category are those that need immediate remedial action to address negative public health and environmental outcomes.

Monday, June 21, 2010

Slum redevelopment

Gulzar Natarajan writes:

  • Even from purely economic considerations, it is inefficient to allot property rights to slum dwellers occupying small plots in valuable locations. Such fragmented titles come in the way of unlocking the full value of this prime real estate; it ends up inhibiting socially beneficial economic activity.

  • In these circumstances, the most realistic solution to slum development appears to be constructing in situ multi-storeyed housing on such encroachments. This will also ensure achievement of one of the primary objectives of all slum development programmes: providing dwelling units to the urban poor.