Showing posts with label Peter Bauer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Peter Bauer. Show all posts

Friday, December 14, 2012

P T Bauer vs Nehru

"P.T. Bauer (London School of Economics) demurred. For all else, planning had become an article of faith."

A bit more to muse through from the above piece by Prof Varshney:

  • Central planning, clearly, did not achieve that goal. In the three decades of rigid planning, India’s economic growth rate was abysmally low — and its poverty rate remained unchanged. Should Nehru, then, be castigated for India’s economic failures until the onset of the 1980s? Could India have adopted a post-1991 style economic policy framework in 1950?
  • These questions require nuanced reasoning. We need to ask whether economists and intellectuals, not simply Nehru, trusted markets in the 1950s. What ideas were available to economic policy makers at that time?

Saturday, December 5, 2009

Economic Development and religion or traditions

“……religion or traditions, which apply only to particular circumstances of nations, are often discounted as being least important in economics. These variables, which cannot be measured in quantifiable terms, may have a totally unexpected impact in the final analysis.”

From Marginal Revolution:

Davide Cantoni (who by the way is on the job market, from Harvard) reports:

Many theories, most famously Max Weber's essay on the 'Protestant ethic,' have hypothesized that Protestantism should have favored economic development. With their considerable religious heterogeneity and stability of denominational affiliations until the 19th century, the German Lands of the Holy Roman Empire present an ideal testing ground for this hypothesis. Using population figures in a dataset comprising 276 cities in the years 1300-1900, I find no effects of Protestantism on economic growth. The finding is robust to the inclusion of a variety of controls, and does not appear to depend on data selection or small sample size. In addition, Protestantism has no effect when interacted with other likely determinants of economic development. I also analyze the endogeneity of religious choice; instrumental variables estimates of the effects of Protestantism are similar to the OLS results.

The full paper, and other work by Cantoni, is here. I believe this is the most thorough statistical test of the Weberian hypothesis to date.

More on “Peter Bauer and the Economics of Prosperity”

Peter Bauer and the Economics of Prosperity James A. Dorn, Barun S. Mitra (EDS.) Hard-bound Book (6¼" x 9¼") : Pages : 192 2009 Edition : ISBN - 978-81-7188-665-4 Price : INR 595 / US $ 16.95

ABOUT THE BOOK :
  • Peter Bauer was an unlikely revolutionary, yet he inspired a revolution in development economics. In an environment dominated by a poverty of clear economic thought, Bauer built his theories of economic prosperity. He fought to free the poor from the tyranny of poverty. With the recent spread of anti-market, anti-trade, and anti-migration movements in many parts of the world, it is important that we take a fresh look at the way Bauer exposed the fallacies behind these protest movements. He showed them to be anti-poor and anti-people, and to be exacerbating global poverty. This volume is an attempt towards helping in introducing the ideas of Peter Bauer to a new generation of readers.

ABOUT THE EDITORS :
  • James A. Dorn is Vice President for Academic Affairs at the Cato Institute and Editor of the Cato Journal. He is a China specialist and a regular contributor to Caijing (online), China’s leading business and finance magazine. His articles have also appeared in the Financial Times, Asian Wall Street Journal, South China Morning Post, and Australian Financial Review. He has taught at Fudan University in Shanghai and is currently Professor of Economics at Towson University in Maryland.
  • Barun S. Mitra is the Director of Liberty Institute, an independent think tank based in New Delhi, which is engaged in public policy research and advocacy with the aim of promoting economic and political freedoms. He is an engineer by training, and writes on a wide range of developmental, economic, environmental and technological issues. He has been published in a number of national and international newspapers and journals. He received the Julian L. Simon Award for his contribution in explaining the role of market economics in harnessing human ingenuity and creativity, leading to improvement in economic well-being and environmental quality. He is a member of the Mont Pelerin Society.
CONTENTS IN DETAIL :

Foreword
Acknowledgements
Editors/Contributors
Preface
Remembering Peter Bauer
— James A. Dorn
Peter T. Bauer: A Brief Biography
— Ralph Harris

Part 1 Development, Freedom and Prosperity
1. Reflection on Peter Bauer’s Contributions to Development Economics — Milton Friedman and Thomas Sowell 37
2. Peter Bauer: An Unusual Applied Economist
— Basil Yamey
3. How Does Development Happen?
— Amartya Sen
4. P.T. Bauer’s Market-Liberal Vision
— James A. Dorn
5. The Market, Yes; Demos, No
— James M. Buchanan
6. Human Attitudes and Economic Growth
— Israel M. Kirzner

Part 2 Migration, Foreign Aid and Poverty
7. Migration, Globalisation and the Spirit of Peter Bauer
— Daniel T. Griswold
8. A Voice for the Poor
— The Economist
9. A Titan Passes Away
— Swaminathan S. Anklesaria Aiyar
10. A True Friend of the World’s Poor
— Sauvik Chakraverti
11. Peter Bauer and the Third World
— Anthony Daniels
12. P.T. Bauer on the Population Question
— Nicholas Eberstadt

Part 3 Bauer on the Economics of Prosperity
13. Economic Control or Economic Development?
— P.T. Bauer
14. Indian Economy Policy and Development
— Peter T. Bauer
15. B.R. Shenoy: Stature and Impact
— Peter Bauer
16. The Disregard of Reality
— Peter Bauer

Index
CONTRIBUTORS:

  • Swaminathan S. Anklesaria Aiyar is consulting editor of The Economic Times newspaper in India, and research fellow at the Cato Institute in Washington DC. He writes the popular weekly column ‘Swaminomics’ in the Sunday Times, India.
  • Peter T. Bauer was Professor Emeritus of Economics at the London School of Economics, University of London, and a Fellow of the British Academy.
  • James M. Buchanan is Distinguished Professor Emeritus of Economics at George Mason University and the 1986 recipient of the Alfred Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences
  • Sauvik Chakraverti is the senior assistant editor of The Economic Times newspaper in Delhi.
  • Anthony Daniels is a medical doctor and is the author of From Zanzibar to Timbuktu. He writes for The Spectator, as Theodore Dalrymple, and is a contributing editor of The City Journal of New York. This article is adapted from his dinner address at “A Conference in Tribute to Peter Bauer” hosted by the James Madison Program, Princeton University, May 7, 2004
  • Nicholas Eberstadt is the Henry Wendt Scholar in Political Economy at the American Enterprise Institute. An earlier version of this article appeared in The Public Interest (Eber stadt 2005).
  • Milton Friedman was a Senior Research Fellow at the Hoover Institution and the 1976 recipient of the Alfred Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences. Thomas Sowell is the Rose and Milton Friedman Senior Fellow on Public Policy at the Hoover Institution.
  • Daniel T. Griswold is Associate Director of the Center for Trade Policy Studies at the Cato Institute in Washington and author of the recent Cato study, ‘Willing Workers: Fixing the Problem of Illegal Mexican Migration to the USA.’ He has authored numerous studies on international trade and globalisation.
  • Ralph Harris was the founder president of the Institute of Economic Affairs, London. He was made a life peer as Baron Harris of High Cross, of Tottenham in the County of Greater London.
  • Israel M. Kirzner is Professor Emeritus of Economics at New York University.
  • Amartya Sen is Lamont University Professor and Professor of Economics and Philosophy at Harvard University, former Master of Trinity College, Cambridge, and the 1998 recipient of the Alfred Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences.
  • Thomas Sowell is the Rose and Milton Friedman Senior Fellow on Public Policy at the Hoover Institution, Stanford University, USA. He has published over two dozen books, among them Basic Economics: A common sense guide to economics (Third edition, 2007), Conflict of Vision (Revised edition, 2007), Affirmative Action Around the World: An Empirical Study (2004), Conquests and Cultures: An International History (1998), and Ethnic America: A history (1981).
  • Basil Yamey is Emeritus Professor of Economics at the London School of Economics and Political Science and a Fellow of the British Academy.

Friday, December 4, 2009

The Art of living of Bauer's ideas

(Academic Foundation, New Delhi Rs 595 pp192 )


There is a fair enough review by Roudra Bhattacharya about a new edited book (Peter Bauer and the Economics of Prosperity by James A Dorn and Barun S Mitra) on the great development economist late Peter Bauer.


Roudra writes:


“This book is able to successfully encapsulate Bauer's elaborate works of over five decades. Among his various ideas, an area where Bauer has voiced his strong opinion is the freedom of labour migration. This, he believes, is a key factor for the development of the world's economically backward regions.


Bauer, who strongly opposed Government regulation in most areas of commerce, felt that the Government should remain a political institution and refrain from making economic decisions for the people. The Government's job, he believed, was limited to safeguarding the rights of its citizens and strengthening the system of justice for the upholding of contracts.

All decisions relating to the movement of people and trade are best left to the dynamics of the market. Particularly, the free migration of people across nations, he said, ensures a steady source of labour for all regions of the world, while keeping labour costs in check.”

Wednesday, July 1, 2009

Homework: Simple truths that are often development economists forgot

Recently Mr Niranjan Rajadhyaksha wrote in the Mint:

  • “It reminds me of the critique of development economics by Peter Thomas Bauer where people were treated as “lifeless bricks to be moved around by some master builder”. That attitude has not changed.
    We usually assume that such desperately poor people are helpless in the face of rock-bottom incomes. But Daryl Collins, Jonathan Morduch, Stuart Rutherford and Orlanda Ruthven show in their book that the poor families whose finances they tracked make ends meet. They actually buy food, send children to school, pay medical costs, etc. They do so by using financial tools that help them borrow, save, deal with risks and smoothen cash flows.
  • The poor show surprising sophistication when dealing with finances. “…we came to understand that money management is, for the poor, a fundamental and well understood part of everyday life,” the four authors say in the introduction.
  • The other example of a research venture that does not treat the poor as lifeless bricks to be moved around is the World Bank’s Moving Out of Povertyproject. I have read only the Indian part of the findings, written by Deepa Narayan, Binayak Sen and Katy Hall. They have studied cases of families from four Indian states—Andhra Pradesh, Assam, Uttar Pradesh and West Bengal—which have moved out of poverty between 1995 and 2005.
  • The researchers collected the life stories of 30,000 women and men in 300 villages. The 50,000 pages of notes have been used along with the standard statistical tools used in development research. While the overall findings of this research cannot be encapsulated in a few lines here, one important thing that comes across is that the poor are hard-working, show initiative and aspire to a better life. For example, 77% of the people spoken to say their children would lead better lives. Or there are other ground-level insights that need attention: Most people fall back into poverty because of health-related expenses or social shocks such as family breakdown. Other researchers have shown that the cost of funerals in AIDS-afflicted countries such as Angola is a huge burden on the poor.
  • One of the authors of this study, Narayan, even told The Times of India in an interview: “People want a free-market economy. But they need the skills to connect with it. The government machinery needs to treat the poor with dignity and respect. This is something that they value a lot. The people also desired free and fair elections and honest leaders as it helps in empowering them.”
  • The problem with most debates about poverty is that they are ridden with clichés and do not take the real experiences of the poor on board. So, on the one hand, we see the state trample over the rights of the poor and, on the other, you have governments handing out doles to protect their images as protectors of the poor.
  • But what both Portfolios of the Poor and Moving Out of Poverty in India show is that the poor need neither contempt not pity. They have a remarkable understanding of their problems and are also quite comfortable with modern finance.
  • Bauer himself was a great believer in direct observation. His studies on the rise of cash crops in countries such as Malaysia and Ghana involved a lot of field work. He showed that farmers in these countries were quite able to take the long view and plant cash crops that took years before they yielded any revenues; they responded to price signals; they had an instinctive understanding of risk.
  • These are simple truths that are too often forgotten by development economists and policymakers because of their enduring fascination with statistical neatness.”

Mr Raghuram Rajan said in his interview to ET NOW that “It’s very important that we start with the notion that we want the poor to be able to handle their finances better. ……The poor often have some cash savings, but they put those savings in places that aren’t that effective. “

It seems to me to be that he wanted some sort of centralized system to regulate or control mechanism that is not going to address the issue.

Wednesday, June 24, 2009

People want a free-market economy

Niranjan Rajadhyaksha has a very good piece in today’s mint. The following are some of forgotten facts in development economics in India. 

  • “The poor are either ignored or patronized, crushed or pitied. Few seem to believe that these people are capable of helping themselves if they are given the right opportunities. It reminds me of the critique of development economics by Peter Thomas Bauer where people were treated as “lifeless bricks to be moved around by some master builder”. That attitude has not changed. 
  • Bauer himself was a great believer in direct observation. His studies on the rise of cash crops in countries such as Malaysia and Ghana involved a lot of field work. He showed that farmers in these countries were quite able to take the long view and plant cash crops that took years before they yielded any revenues; they responded to price signals; they had an instinctive understanding of risk. 
  • The poor show surprising sophistication when dealing with finances. “…we came to understand that money management is, for the poor, a fundamental and well understood part of everyday life,” the four authors say in the introduction.”