Showing posts with label Joseph E Stiglitz. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Joseph E Stiglitz. Show all posts

Friday, October 22, 2010

Neo-liberal economists find new battlefront


There is war of debate is going on about the stimulus packages with respect to many issues like unemployment etc. It’s quite interesting to read and ponder how the "so called experts reacts".


I am posting the full debate below for record (dont' forget to read the Prof Lal's comments):

Neo-liberal economists find new battlefront

Michael Janda reported this story on Thursday, October 21, 2010 12:44:02

ELEANOR HALL: While many have criticised the scale of Britain's spending cuts one of the world's most powerful economic groups has praised the move to slash public debt, urging other nations to follow the UK's lead.


The Mont Pelerin Society held its biennial global meeting in Sydney and launched a stinging attack on the stimulus policies used to fight the global financial crisis.

The society's president professor Deepak Lal spoke to business reporter Michael Janda.

MICHAEL JANDA: Unbeknownst to most Australians one of the world's most powerful economic groups has recently visited our shores.

The Mont Pelerin Society was started just after World War II by Nobel Prize winner Friedrich von Hayek in an effort to fight back against communism, socialism and the Keynesian welfare state.

DEEPAK LAL: The society is literally there to promote the ideals of liberty - economic and political. The society has had, I can't remember - eight, nine Nobel Prize winners.

MICHAEL JANDA: That's the society's president professor Deepak Lal, a development economist from the University of California in Los Angeles.

And while its fight against communism largely ended in the early 1990s the society sees new battlefronts. One is the looming competition for economic supremacy between a free-market India and a state-controlled China.

DEEPAK LAL: China for 1500 years has been a tightly controlled bureaucratic authoritarian state. India for 2,000 years has been a completely anarchic society. Governments have never succeeded in doing anything.

And so as a result in India you've got civil society which actually manages to do all the things governments can't do. And that's its great strength.

In China if something happens to the state there will be another big band because the legitimacy that Chinese Communist Party which is the current dynasty, if that is eroded you could have chaos.

MICHAEL JANDA: Professor Lal says Australia should be careful not to over-commit to China.

DEEPAK LAL: If you're taking bets on the long-run, 20, 30 years, then clearly India is a better bet in my view, yeah.

MICHAEL JANDA: Another is the fight to quickly roll back the stimulus that most developed nations pumped into their economies during the financial crisis. And Professor Lal says the society is having some success.

DEEPAK LAL: The trouble is many other Western countries over the years have built up huge entitlement economies - welfare states in which you know they create politically determined income streams for all sorts of people.

And these then lead to a debt crisis. And this means that just trying to use the old Keynesian method, spending more, in fact makes this problem worse. And Britain for instance has bitten the bullet. It now decides, it's decided quite rightly the only way to deal with this is to reduce public debt levels.

MICHAEL JANDA: The society has a history of success, influencing the economic policies of conservative leaders such as Ronald Reagan and Margaret Thatcher in the 1980s.

A look at the guests at last week's conference shows the influence it has in Australia with former prime minister John Howard one of the key note speakers.

A key function of the society is attacking government intervention in financial markets and the economists who advocate it such as Nobel Prize winner Joseph Stiglitz.

DEEPAK LAL: Joe Stiglitz is a very smart theorist but he's got no sense as far as public policy is concerned. They've had all this stimulus and what has happened? Unemployment is still very high, no sign of it coming down. So they're going to try this next thing, print money.

MICHAEL JANDA: Professor Frank Stilwell who teaches political economy at Sydney University says the power of the Mont Pelerin Society to influence government policy shouldn't be underestimated.

FRANK STILWELL: Kevin Rudd at the time of the global financial crisis announced here the end of neoliberalism. But frankly a couple of years on it doesn't look like that. The neoliberals are resurgent.

And the meeting of the Mont Pelerin Society is I think part of that process whereby the right wing economists get themselves reorganised for a new assault on this Keynesian response to the crisis.

MICHAEL JANDA: And he's banded together with some other left-wing Australian economists to mount an irreverent challenge to free market economics through the Monty Pelican Society.

FRANK STILWELL: The name is of course ironic. But it's a serious attempt to provide a counter to these neoliberal views, stressing the need for governments to take responsibility for a more secure and a more equitable society.

MICHAEL JANDA: I'm guessing it's not quite as well funded and doesn't hold its meetings at the Hilton Hotel?

FRANK STILWELL: (Laughs) Absolutely no funding at all. And the small meetings are held periodically in a public place.

ELEANOR HALL: That's Sydney University professor Frank Stilwell ending that report by Michael Janda.

Tuesday, September 15, 2009

A rich harvest to parched plains…and plans

An eminent liberal Professor Jagdish Bhagwati argues in his article in the Business Standard that the capitalism causes prosperity provided appropriate policy reform. What is ‘appropriate’ is however a broad question one has to grasp the history of economic system and understand that what is appropriate given the condition of ideas and diagnosis. The book “In Defense of Globalization” is certainly one to start.

Some interesting paragraphs:

  • “This is none other than my Columbia colleague Joe Stiglitz. He made a much-cited claim that the current crisis was for capitalism (and markets) the equivalent of the collapse of the Berlin Wall. Now, we know that all analogies are imperfect. But this one is particularly fatuous.
  • When the Berlin Wall collapsed, we saw the intellectual bankruptcy of both the authoritarian politics of communism and the economics of extensive, almost universal, ownership of the means of production and of central planning. We saw a wasteland.
  • After the liberal economic reforms, they did register accelerated growth rates; and finally this did pull up nearly 500 million above the poverty line during the last twenty years. However grim the current crisis has been, it cannot be used to deny and destroy this elemental truth.
  • But has the fate of the poor in the rich countries been less comforting? The labour unions such as the AFL-CIO in the US are convinced that trade with the poor countries has produced paupers in the rich countries by depressing real wages. But this dire conclusion is unsupported by empirical analysis. My own analysis, dating back at least a decade (and extended in my 2004 Oxford book, In Defense of Globalization), argued that, if anything, the fall in wages which labour-saving technical change and other domestic institutional factors would have brought about, had been moderated by trade with the poor countries. This benign conclusion has been re-asserted by Robert Lawrence of Harvard’s Kennedy School in recent years.
  • But the critics also argue that the crisis spells the end of “market fundamentalism”. But the presumption from which these critics start is that we were in the pragmatic centre and have moved to the market fundamentalist right, letting markets rip and rip us apart. But this is totally wrong for much of the world, certainly for the developing countries. Many of the developing countries had been into “anti-market fundamentalism” — there was extreme hostility towards markets and much knee-jerk interventionism such that Adam Smith’s Invisible Hand was nowhere to be seen. When they realised that this model was not working and had cost them dearly, they moved to the pragmatic centre. So, the reality is that we shifted in recent years, not from pragmatism to market fundamentalism as Stiglitz and Soros would have us believe, but from anti-market fundamentalism to the centre.
  • None of these reformers cared, however, what Bretton Woods institutions, or Washington more generally, thought and felt. Washington Consensus is therefore little more than Washington Conceit, spread by Western media at first and then by the anti-market fundamentalists and the anti-globalists who find that the phrase, and the anti-Americanism which it invokes, gets them greater mileage than the content of their critique actually merits.”

Also read Hasan Suroor piece on “How Margaret Thatcher pleaded with Gorbachev not to let the Berlin Wall fall”

Thursday, September 10, 2009

Random note: Private property and The State

The following note was taken during my visit to National Institute of Rural Development (NIRD) library, for presenting my paper in its Foundation Day Seminar in 2006. The paper was peer reviewed one and was also paid a lump sum as Honorarium for the paper!

The State by Anthony de Jasay

“Young Marx- He spoke of the ‘general secular contradiction between the political State and civil society’, and contended that ‘when the political State…comes violently into being of civil society…... it can and must proceed to the abolition of religion, to the destruction of religion: but only in the same way as it proceeds to the abolition of private property (by imposing a maximum, by confiscation, by progressive taxation) and the abolition of life (by the guillotine) (K Marx, The Jewish Question, Early writings, 1975, pp.220, 222, 226).

  • For Marx State as essentially as instrument then Engels, Lenin
  • For Hobbes it keeps the peace
  • For Locke it upholds the natural right to liberty and property
  • For Rousseau it realise the general will
  • For Bentham and Mill it is the vehicle of improving social arrangements
  • For today’s liberals it overcomes the incapacity of private interests spontaneously to co-operate
  • Collectively proposed public goods of order, defence, clean aid, paved streets and universal education.

For ‘non market choice’ or public choice school, the interaction of private choices through the instrument of the State is liable to overproduce public goods and fail in other way to attain prepared outcomes (as one of the founders of this school puts it, welfare economics is about market failures, public choice theory is about government failures) (James M Buchanan, The Limits of Liberty, 1975, ch.10).

People who have been to rely on the State never learn the art of Self-reliance nor acquire the habits of civil action.

State action may or may not achieve its intended effect. “Civil society governs itself”

The ‘Origin of the State is conquest’ and the ‘origin of the State is the Social Contract’ are not two rival explanations.

“Social Contract”

Robert L Carneiro, ‘A Theory of the Origin of the State’ in JD Jennings and E . Hoebel (eds),

The origin of capitalist ownership is that ‘finders are keepers’. Possession to ownership; to good title to property, independently of its particularities, of who the title- holders may be and also of the use he may or may not make of the property.

Locke’s famous words “enough and as good”

Adam Smith- describes political economy as a branch of the ‘Science of a Statesman’ and ascribes to it in the role of two distinct objects: first to provide a plentiful revenue or subsistence for the people or more properly, to enable them to provide such a revenue or substance for themselves; and secondly, to supply the State or commonwealth with a revenue sufficient for the public services. It proposes, he says, to enrich both the people and the sovereign (The Wealth of Nations, Cannan’s Edition vol I, 395).

The following are from ‘Politics and Economics Papers in Political Economy by Lord Robbins’ 1963, Macmillan & Co, New York.

  • Keynes-in the end, the world is governed by ideas and by little else.
  • The world’s freedom and ‘order’ each appeal to our emotions.
  • ‘I desire freedom as an end in itself. I desire order as a means to freedom’
  • We decide to rely on private property as a basis of dispersed initiative and freedom, we must be prepared to tolerate the existence of some inequality arising from this source also.

Diffusion of property…

From Globalisation and Its Discontents by Joseph E. Stiglitz (2002)

  • I saw divisions were often made because of ideology and politics. I believe in privatization, if markets are competitive and efficient and lower’s prices for consumers.

Wednesday, March 18, 2009

Economics, town and untrained economists………

In the morning I read three articles the subject of article vary from financial crisis to urbanization and false theory of economists. 

First, in today’s ET Joseph E. Stiglitz has article in which he says that “Trickle-down economics almost never works” it comes after doing a significant damage which the present academic community fails to understand and give up the theory. 

Second, fight over whether macroeconomics was advanced or not after 1970s. Typically T. C. A. Srinivasa-Raghavan says by quoting Keynes who said in 1931 that “If economists could manage to get themselves thought of as humble, competent people on a level with dentists that would be splendid.” 

And “he is also intensely critical of the tendency introduced by engineers-turned-economists to look on the real world as a sort of machine where pressing the right buttons leads to predicable outcomes.”

 In case of India it includes Raghuram Rajan also. 

T. C. A. Srinivasa-Raghavan earlier criticized Raghuram Rajan report on financial sector reform saying “unfortunately, and thanks in a large measure to the data boys, especially those with engineering backgrounds, this has become a generalised problem in macroeconomic analysis and policy wonking. So even though they pour scorn on anecdotal evidence, the data boys have become guilty of the same methodological flaw. They confuse correlation with causality and use induction and deduction inter-changeably.” 

Third, in India many think Bibek Debroy is a liberal economist but some time seem to be a terribly Keynesian economist. He writes in today’s Financial Express “In the long run we are all dead.” Most people know this Keynes quote and most non-economists probably think it is from General Theory (1936). It is actually from A Tract on Monetary Reform (1923), written well before those troubled times. Given these troubled times, the subsequent sentence has relevance for the tribe of economists. “In the long run we are all dead. Economists set themselves too easy, too useless a task if in tempestuous seasons they can only tell us that when the storm is long past the ocean is flat again.”

Tuesday, December 23, 2008

Outlier economists

Joseph Stiglitz says in The Hindu “the crisis was predictable, and predicted. But unfortunately, mainstream economists, politicians, and policymakers ignored the warnings. We have much to learn from these failures, as well as those of the economy itself.”

For your information I was told that about 200 students from JNU were attended his recent lecture on the Tenth D. T. Lakdawala Memorial Lecture delivered on December 20, 2008, New Delhi !!.

 What a tragedy for this nation.

Friday, December 19, 2008

I do not 'get' Joseph Stiglitz

Mike Moffatt writes “I have read a number of his academic articles and followed his media appearances over the years and I cannot see for the life of me what other economists see in him. It is not an ideological thing - in the sense of understanding why they are well respected I get Hayek, I get Krugman, I get Prescott, I get Schumpeter, I get Veblen. I even get Gunnar Myrdal. But everytime I hear or read Stiglitz, I usually end up cringing”. 

Some of the comments posted in response to above post are worthwhile: 

Ben says Krugman is an idiot when it comes to economics. 

Marteen says I could not finish Stiglitz’s book, Globalization and its Discontents. After about a quarter through it I just had to put it down because it was like singing, “100 bottles of beer.” After get to 95 bottles of beer, it ceases to be enjoyable. It seemed that Stiglitz just went over the same theme again and again. 

Green says Unfortunatly Stiglitz has blurred the line between the social sciences- this is most definatly a mistake.

Tuesday, November 11, 2008

Stiglitz is No Mockery!

Joseph E Stiglitz says “America exported its deregulatory free market philosophy”.

It is blunder to accept anything and everything without the minding of the business of the business in our life from other persons or from other countries in the world. It is the same in the Stiglitz case too.