Showing posts with label Knowledge Paths. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Knowledge Paths. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 27, 2012

"The source of confusion here is that there was a Good Hayek and a Bad Hayek"

Prof Solo has very interesting book review article in NTR on Professor F A Hayek: A bit from it:

  • "The source of confusion here is that there was a Good Hayek and a Bad Hayek. The Good Hayek was a serious scholar who was particularly interested in the role of knowledge in the economy (and in the rest of society). Since knowledge—about technological possibilities, about citizens’ preferences, about the interconnections of these, about still more—is inevitably and thoroughly decentralized, the centralization of decisions is bound to generate errors and then fail to correct them. The consequences for society can be calamitous, as the history of central planning confirms. That is where markets come in. All economists know that a system of competitive markets is a remarkably efficient way to aggregate all that knowledge while preserving decentralization.
  • But the Good Hayek also knew that unrestricted laissez-faire is unworkable. It has serious defects: successful actors reach for monopoly power, and some of them succeed in grasping it; better-informed actors can exploit the relatively ignorant, creating an inefficiency in the process; the resulting distribution of income may be grossly unequal and widely perceived as intolerably unfair; industrial market economies have been vulnerable to excessively long episodes of unemployment and underutilized capacity, not accidentally but intrinsically; environmental damage is encouraged as a way of reducing private costs—the list is long. Half of Angus Burgin’s book is about the Good Hayek’s attempts to formulate and to propagate a modified version of laissez-faire that would work better and meet his standards for a liberal society. (Hayek and his friends were never able to settle on a name for this kind of society: “liberal” in the European tradition was associated with bad old Manchester liberalism, and neither “neo-liberal” nor “libertarian” seemed to be satisfactory.)"

Monday, August 22, 2011

Too many 'Bills'


Mahesh Bhatt said something very interesting one has to ponder: 

  • "I am an imperfect person with an imperfect view of the world – couldn't that hold true for everyone else, including Anna?"

And 

  • “Anna's bill is just as impractical and dangerous as the government's bill. The nation must question Anna's bill as much as the government's. The bill proposes to create a power that is dangerous. Democracy must destabilise power, not augur it in the wrong hands. I get abused online by Anna's supporters so badly when I criticise his agenda. Arre bhai, just because I am not with you, does it mean I am against you?”

Monday, June 6, 2011

Land and knowledge problem


Vipin has great piece in today's Mint on land and knowledge problem where he says "It is economically inefficient and politically tyrannical to force all farmers to accept identical contracts."

Monday, December 6, 2010

India can learn from Israel by adapting bitzua, chutzpah, rosh gadol and davka


But our pundits will raise their finger that why should we k***f learn!!


R. Gopalakrishnan’s articles are always not only entertaining but are also more insightful with useful (useless) information. Consider his today’s article in ET. Of course, it is interesting in many ways not because it’s on innovation I say but because of its twisted analysis on the India’s yesterday year’s un-devisable monopoly innovation strategy, simply I mean the license raj or buffed quota raj.


  • Israel is an incredibly innovative nation. It ranks the highest in the world in the per-capita number of patents filed. A partner at A&G Partners, which specialises in building bridges between Israel and Asia, says that even her hairdresser has a patent on an exact algorithm for deducing the right hair shade! A good 22% of the Nobel Prize winners are Jewish; among women who have been awarded the Nobel Prize, 38% are Jewish. These are amazing statistics, considering that the number of Jews on the planet peaked at 18 million before World War II, and today, number only about 12 million.

  • Dr R A Mashelkar often says that India should be permanently angry. The country demonstrated during the Green Revolution the same davka and rosh gadol when the US suspended the PL 480 shipments.

  • India has produced DCD icons, who practised being daringly-creative and disciplined: Vallabhai Patel and C Subramaniam in public life, Ratan Tata and E Sreedharan in industry and infrastructure, and Raghunath Mashelkar and M S Swaminathan in science and technology.

  • Our academic curriculum in management and our national folklore in innovation should progressively shift the fulcrum of focus to this fourth C of channelisation: which involves learning how to create an Innovation Engine to plan and execute risky ideas, which may not get nurtured naturally in the Performance Engine.

  • Coupled with the existing presence of the first three Cs of challenge-creativity-chaos , Indians can then aim to deliver and celebrate breakthrough innovations in the coming decades. The future for Indian innovation is bright.

Future is always ‘bright’ but the near future is ‘dismal’.

Wednesday, November 17, 2010

Simply Hayekian!!

In an interview to ET British Historian Mr. Simon Schama says:

Ideas and learning

  • ….we have become, in a difficult world, much more utilitarian about useful knowledge, with a very narrow range of what counts as useful…

  • Teachers have to be storytellers, in addition to teaching their students analysis and how to ask questions and that does take time.

Indian Revolution

You also said British students should study the rise of Empire in South Asia, why not the fall as well…


  • Of course, about that too. I was specially speaking of the 18th century. For some extraordinary reason, because of the way the British curriculum was designed, the entire 18th century is missing. And that’s the time when what Britain became was decided, Britain as an entrepreneurial innovator, as a ruthless commercial empire, and Britain still very surprisingly loses the part of the empire you would think would naturally fit with it, in the shape of the American colonies, and extraordinarily has an Indian presence which grows bigger and bigger.


  • It is very important to understand that because of what the Raj became, the ruthless exploitation of sovereignty, but it started as a different kind of ruthlessness. It started as a kind of commercial plunder without the strings of government, and it was because Bengal in particular was disintegrating, was becoming this centrifugal sink-hole in which neither the Mughals had power nor did the indigenous governors, and the British found that they had to actually control the revenue system if they were going to pay for their trades.

  • So it became backwards, they went into India backwards — which didn’t make them less imperialist. So, it’s a fantastic exercise in unintended consequences, what happened to British power in Bengal in particular. It’s a sort of thrilling, tragic, ferocious story. There’s this huge South Asian population in Britain, why wouldn’t this story be interesting to them as to pink people from Exeter and Liverpool? I was someone who did Indian history as an undergraduate, and loved it, I did the lay the 18th and early 19th century in India, after Warren Hastings, and nearly became an Indian historian. And I thought it very complicated and thrilling, and thought why not make it part of what kids are taught.

Monday, May 31, 2010

Random readings


1. Throwing light on knowledge- Ralph Waldo Emerson: “A man should learn to detect and watch that gleam of light which flashes across his mind from within.”

2. Humans: Why They Triumphed;

  • Yet all the ingredients of human success—tool making, big brains, culture, fire, even language—seem to have been in place half a million years before and nothing happened.
  • But the sophistication of the modern world lies not in individual intelligence or imagination. It is a collective enterprise. Nobody—literally nobody—knows how to make the pencil on my desk (as the economist Leonard Read once pointed out), let alone the computer on which I am writing. The knowledge of how to design, mine, fell, extract, synthesize, combine, manufacture and market these things is fragmented among thousands, sometimes millions of heads. Once human progress started, it was no longer limited by the size of human brains. Intelligence became collective and cumulative.

  • ideas are having sex with each other as never before.
  • The rate of cultural and economic progress depends on the rate at which ideas are having sex.
  • We tend to forget that trade and urbanization are the grand stimuli to invention, far more important than governments, money or individual genius.

Friday, January 8, 2010

Intellectuals and Society

In an interview Prof. Thomas Sowell talks from his latest book Intellectuals and Society: Chapter 4 of 5

Wednesday, July 16, 2008

Matrix of Ideas Transmission by Chandra

There is several ways to transmit the idea among human beings but no other method evolved on this earth except involving people.
"A teacher is the architect of future generation and hence the future of India depends upon the teacher to a great extent".
This article pity focused from student’s point of view. It reminds me several occasions where I encountered such absurd teachers, professors in class rooms in my school and college days.
There is also another article (Awakening a slumbering elephant: CCS in India) by respected free market economist in India is Dr Parth J Shah, President of the liberal think tank ‘Centre for Civil Society’ . He tells four different type of targeting the future generation to transmit the idea.
It really awake me to open the eye to imagine how one could march towards self sufficient of knowledge in a particular field or in institution or in society etc amazing when I realize the actions of ideas around the world played by human beings.

He engages reader quite well! Do read 7th article published in a book by IEA, London.