Showing posts with label Rights of Free Market Economics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rights of Free Market Economics. Show all posts

Monday, April 13, 2020

Tomorrow is 129th Birth Anniversary of Dr.B.R.Ambedkar

Tomorrow is 129th Birth Anniversary of Dr.B.R.Ambedkar
Leaders in the past and present time have misused the life and works of Ambedkar for the individual's vested interests, petty polity which Ambedkar clearly explained through his many works not to do ever..
the biggest sin is hero worship in the name of non believing this god or other....
more than that few even went to the extent to say, Ambedkar never said anything about free market economics or wealth creation with minimum state.... its sad some are in Jail now!!
The following are my tribute to B R Ambedkar's free market economic thoughts..... so far none could substantially disagree because i did not distorted the history like few others.

Indeed, few dalit capitalists have actually cherish over my works on Ambedkar!!

Tuesday, November 12, 2019

Free Market Economist Prof B.R. Shenoy and German Socialism

The thirty years After Fall of The Berlin Wall is now a major debate around the world. The main comparison being made by many are on socialism vs capitalism, the free market capitalism. It is interesting that the Indian free market economist Prof B.R.Shenoy's article has been widely referred on the east Germany vs western Germany.  Prof Shenoy wrote a article titled "East and West Berlin: A Study in Free vs. Controlled Economy" on August 15, 1960 issue of The Indian Libertarian.

The following are some excerpts of article referred by different writers on the eve of thirty years Fall of The Berlin Wall:


From Rep. French Hill: 30 years after the fall of the Berlin Wall, America can't repeat East Germany's mistakes


An economist from India, B.R. Shenoy, had a first-hand look at the difference between the east and the west. In a 1960 article, Shenoy documented, “The main thoroughfares of West Berlin are near jammed with prosperous looking automobile traffic, the German make of cars, big and small, being much in evidence. ... The departmental stores in West Berlin are cramming with wearing apparel, other personal effects and a multiplicity of household equipment, temptingly displayed.”
Like my visits to East Berlin in 1986, Shenoy continues, “Food shops in East Berlin exhibit cheap articles in indifferent wrappers or containers and the prices for comparable items, despite the poor quality, are noticeably higher than in West Berlin. ... Visiting East Berlin gives the impression of visiting a prison camp.”

From "30 Years After The Fall Of The Berlin Wall, Socialism Is Staging A Comeback"

B.R. Shenoy, a prominent economist in India, noticed the significant differences of the two economic models in the divided city of Berlin in as early as 1960. He observed that in West Berlin, “Rebuilding is virtually complete…The main thoroughfares of West Berlin are near jammed with prosperous looking automobile traffic, the German make of cars, big and small… The departmental stores in West Berlin are cramming with wearing apparel, other personal effects and a multiplicity of household equipment, temptingly displayed.” 

In contrast, when Shenoy went to East Berlin, he saw “a good part of the destruction still remains; twisted iron, broken walls and heaped up rubble are common enough sights… Buses and trams dominate the thoroughfares in East Berlin; other automobiles, generally old and small cars, are in much smaller numbers than in West Berlin… The food shops in East Berlin exhibit cheap articles in indifferent wrappers or containers and the prices for comparable items, despite the poor quality, are noticeably higher than in West Berlin.”
Interestingly, if we leave the specification of location in this paragraph blank, what Sheony observed could have been replaced by any socialist countries mirroring the same scene, whether of China in the 1970s, or Venezuela in 2010. Socialism consistently produces similar devastating results, no matter where it has been attempted.
Shenoy wasn’t the only one who noticed the drastically distinct economic situations of East and West Germany in 1960. People in East Germany were aware of their poverty and political oppression, in contrast to the freedom and prosperity their families and friends enjoyed in West Germany since as early as the 1950s. East Germans wanted out.

Wednesday, July 10, 2019

BR Shenoy - A Prophet Without Honour?



Prof BR Shenoy - A Prophet Without Honour? in his own country!


Prof Subodh R Shenoy who is a son of Indian free market economist Prof B R Shenoy who thundered the socialist planned economy of early 50, 60 and 70s.

Prof Subodh interestingly explains in this video produced by free market and public policy institute in India, Centre for Civil Society, New Delhi.

Several years ago I had published a long essay about Prof B R Shenoy's works in Mises Institute's Blog.

Tuesday, April 1, 2014

Interesting reading

The 80 year old Economic Freedom lover S.V Raju shares many things on the birth and death of Swatantra Party (SP) in India. SP was the largest opposition party in the Lok Sabha in 1967 with 44 MPs. It won about 256 assembly seats in various States. The party ruled in states like Gujarat and Rajasthan. The article also talks about other old men who were with SP and now with NCP, etc (Open Magazine page:42-44, April 7,2014).

" if reservations are to be expanded, political parties should begin with quotas in their own leadership."

An unconventional take on the Partition

"There is right now no shortage of ideological grandstanding but little analytical insight on inequality in India" "....inequality came down during the socialist planning era while it began to increase after liberalization"

Wednesday, January 22, 2014

B.R.Ambedkar, the Greatest Free Market Economist of India

From my first article for the Centre Right India (CRI):

  • Socialist myth: when people do talk about his economics, but it is about his opposition to capitalism and socialist leanings. This is a myth forwarded by dalits to further their own agenda.In fact, Ambedkar did not oppose free-markets but was himself an advocate of free-markets!!
  • Dalit politics: his economics is ignored by the mainstream and misrepresented by the dalits community because it is contrary to the socialist politics in India.
  • True free-market capitalist: those who know about his economics downplay it but he was free-market economist even before Austrian Economists like F.A.Hayek, etc.
  • Significance of Ambedkar’s economics today: in the heyday of economic reforms in India, we need to rediscover the Ambedkar’s economics, especially his ideas of free-market principles, to empower the dalits and raise them from deep ignorance.

Tuesday, June 11, 2013

Capitalism, Caste and Society (CCS)

Here is a very interesting interview with two powerful, yet persuasive minds working on mission to do something concretely with the idea of Capitalism, Caste and Society. And thus they say "'Capitalism is changing caste much faster than any human being. Dalits should look at capitalism as a crusader against caste". A bit from the interview:

"What has happened during the past 50 or 60 years is that the state's welfare measures or methods or reservations got slightly misunderstood and also slightly misused by the "victims".

...10 per cent of MSMEs registered with the Government of India are Dalit-owned, which is about 1,64,000 across the country. 

...the silencer in the Tata Nano is produced by a Dalit entrepreneur.

Affirmative action has given Dalits a launch pad. A launch pad is a launch pad. You need that to take off. Ambedkar gave you the launch pad. Now don't run on the launch pad, take off.

Because of economic reforms, globalisation, you can't produce everything under one roof. You will have to outsource work. Most of the Dalit entrepreneurs of today are beneficiaries of outsourcing.

Along with globalisation came Adam Smith to challenge Manu. So that's why for the first time, money has become bigger than caste.

there is an economic process, that capitalism is changing caste much faster than any human being. Therefore, in capitalism versus caste, there is a battle going on and Dalits should look at capitalism as a crusader against caste.

what man failed to do, capitalism is doing. Let us go with capitalism that is changing caste faster than your reforms

People who are working on poverty have a better life than people like us, because if you work on poverty, then you fly. You work on poverty, you live in five-star hotels. If you work on poverty, you are in touch with big foreign funding agencies. So, talking poverty makes you strong, makes you rich.

The inspiration behind DICCI is the economic thought of Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar. The second is the black capitalism in America."

Tuesday, May 28, 2013

Ambedkar's free market ideas in Tamil

Here is my Tamil article on B R Ambedkar's free market economics. This article may be the first one to talk about Ambedkar's free market ideas in Tamil magazine. The English version appeared in various publications. See here 1, 2 and 3.

Wednesday, May 1, 2013

Interesting reading

Why Indian economy slowed? 

Dr. Bhim Rao Ambedkar had cautioned us in his speech on November 4, 1948, delivered in the Constituent Assembly that: “The form of the administration must be appropriate to and in the same sense as the form of the Constitution ... [It] is perfectly possible to pervert the Constitution, without changing its form by merely changing the form of the administration and to make it inconsistent and opposed to the spirit of the Constitution … Constitutional morality is not a natural sentiment. It has to be cultivated. We must realise that our people have yet to learn it.” More here.


"A laissez faire economy is characterized by the absence of non-market pressures such as taxes, subsidies, tariffs, though the very definition of a free market economy has been the subject of vociferous debate. In a free market/economy, individuals are free to contract, where the only regulations, in theory, would be to safeguard against coercion and theft. Certain economists have postulated that competition would thrive in a free market economy, perhaps even through a praxeological approach. However, given the different theoretical models of free-market economies and the opposing practical reality(ies); class differences, income inequities and the resultant dominating powers do allow for a powerful class to emerge and skew market conditions through monopolies and the abuse of dominant positions." More here.

Sunday, March 31, 2013

Interesting reading

Saturday, March 2, 2013

Two great men passed away in different world


Today I wanted to write about two great men recently passed away in two different world. Both passed away last month. Both are strong believer of free market principles like limited government, rule of law, private property right etc. Both are great teachers in their own field. One taught economics and other man taught engineering subjects. I am talking about Prof P V Indiresan and Prof Armen A Alchian.

Professor P V Indiresan who passed away on 24th February, 2013 in Pune where he was about to chair a Session on " the Election Commission’s technical committee meet on electronic voting machines."

When I first heard the news I was terribly saddened. Though I was in office at that time and could not do anything except to simple sit down  and pray for his peace. Two things connects me. First, I have been reading his articles at least since 2002 and secondly, I had the opportunity to meet him in 2012 and freely discuss things that interest us. He wrote his last India 2020 column in The Business Line on 22nd February, 2013. 

I am sure he would have written a great piece on this year budget if he were to alive today. His column use to appear on Saturday. You can read all his BL columns here. He also written regular columns in The Hindu newspaper long ago, some are available in the website but one need to do some technical search to get the article. He has also written a column in The Indian Express. The most interesting thing about Prof Indiresan is that he could easily yet lucidly about economics even the economists in India cannot think of such ideas. I am referring to his articles on differential interest rates of RBI.

Here are news item/articles on his passing away:


Very recently only I was introduced to Prof Armen Alchian. Good friend Vipin gifted me the two volume of collected works of Prof Alchian by gently saying "Alchian is equally important economist as Prof F A Hayek was" on decoding the private property right and many other issues. Here are some good links to get quick understanding about his works. See 1,2,3,4.

Thursday, January 10, 2013

Professor James M. Buchanan, no more

The most liked line from his work is this: “My task has been to ‘uneducate’ the economists.”

"James M. Buchanan, who died Wednesday at age 93, was one of history's greatest economists. Though he won the Nobel Prize in 1986, Jim at heart was always a farm boy from Tennessee—an old-fashioned, hardworking American who disdained unearned privileges as well as deeply distrusting the promises of politicians and the passions of collectives." More here. 

"As Buchanan put it in “Liberty, Market and the State” (1986), politics is “a process within which individuals, with separate and potentially differing interests and values, interact for the purpose of securing individually valued benefits of cooperative effort.” More here.

  • "Buchanan believed that government is necessary to produce public goods (mainly security, but a few others too), hence politics as exchange. The problem in this sort of exchange is that the majority (or perhaps a minority, like bureaucrats) will be tempted to exploit the rest of the population. Rational individuals will want to protect themselves against this danger with a unanimous, if only implicit, social contract that constitutionally limits what the state can do. We must, as the subtitle of The Limits of Liberty indicates, stand “between anarchy and Leviathan.”

Tuesday, November 27, 2012

"The source of confusion here is that there was a Good Hayek and a Bad Hayek"

Prof Solo has very interesting book review article in NTR on Professor F A Hayek: A bit from it:

  • "The source of confusion here is that there was a Good Hayek and a Bad Hayek. The Good Hayek was a serious scholar who was particularly interested in the role of knowledge in the economy (and in the rest of society). Since knowledge—about technological possibilities, about citizens’ preferences, about the interconnections of these, about still more—is inevitably and thoroughly decentralized, the centralization of decisions is bound to generate errors and then fail to correct them. The consequences for society can be calamitous, as the history of central planning confirms. That is where markets come in. All economists know that a system of competitive markets is a remarkably efficient way to aggregate all that knowledge while preserving decentralization.
  • But the Good Hayek also knew that unrestricted laissez-faire is unworkable. It has serious defects: successful actors reach for monopoly power, and some of them succeed in grasping it; better-informed actors can exploit the relatively ignorant, creating an inefficiency in the process; the resulting distribution of income may be grossly unequal and widely perceived as intolerably unfair; industrial market economies have been vulnerable to excessively long episodes of unemployment and underutilized capacity, not accidentally but intrinsically; environmental damage is encouraged as a way of reducing private costs—the list is long. Half of Angus Burgin’s book is about the Good Hayek’s attempts to formulate and to propagate a modified version of laissez-faire that would work better and meet his standards for a liberal society. (Hayek and his friends were never able to settle on a name for this kind of society: “liberal” in the European tradition was associated with bad old Manchester liberalism, and neither “neo-liberal” nor “libertarian” seemed to be satisfactory.)"

Wednesday, November 7, 2012

Capitalism = Insights

From A N Shroff memorial lecture delivered by Arun Maira on 9th October, 2012.


"Revisiting the role of India’s Planning Commission

When I joined the Planning Commission as a Member in 2009, one of the tasks the Prime Minister assigned to me was to determine what role the Planning Commission should play in 21st century India. I asked Montek Ahluwalia, the Deputy Chairman of the Planning Commission to give me a list of 20 persons to whom I should ask this question. He gave me a list of 20 respected citizens of the country. Some of them had worked in Government in very senior positions, in the Reserve Bank, in Parliament, some even in the Planning Commission in the past. And several others were respected industrialists of the country.

I asked each of these 20 leaders the following questions:
  • Is the Planning Commission playing a useful role for the country?
  • If not, is there another role that the Planning Commission could play in India’s progress?

The answer to the first question was unanimous. The Planning Commission was no longer making a significant contribution to the progress of the country. The country had changed. It was more decentralized politically and administratively. The private sector was playing an increasingly large role. The Indian economy was more connected with the international economy. For all these reasons, five year plans and budgets made by some experts in Delhi, which had then to be implemented by people all over the country, was an outmoded idea. 

However everyone, including the industrialists, said that the dynamic nature of changes in India and outside required a strategic group that, like a radar, could sense the forces that were causing change to happen and that could provide governments in the center and in the states, and private industry too, with insights into the forces shaping the future.

A More than Perfect Storm

I will now give you a picture of the forces shaping our future. I will also explain their effects on institutions of democracy, capitalism and government. I will use two images for you to visualize these forces and their implications. One, an image of a storm. The other, an image of a globe in stress.

First the image of the storm. Many of you may recollect the ‘Perfect Storm’ that Sebastian Junger described in his book. Not two, but three storm systems converged in the North Atlantic. This was unprecedented. No ship had been designed for such conditions. And no captain had the skills to steer a ship in such a ‘perfect’ storm.

As the 21st century unfolds, there are four strong winds blowing across the world and converging to create a more than perfect storm which is challenging captains of business and government institutions that are not designed for these conditions.

Free Markets and Capitalism
The first strong wind is the idea of free markets and capitalism. This is not a new idea. Often attributed to Adam Smith, it has been around for at least 200 years."

Friday, September 7, 2012

Stunning self-correction

Sentence to ponder over (Fixerpreneurship by Shekhar Gupta):

  • If you draw a simple chart of the large companies that have lost the most value on the stock markets over the past three years, you’d notice that almost all of these were doing business on the same cusp of politics, finance and natural resources. To that extent, you have to admit that the market has been the first to sense the rot and has applied a stunning self-correction, severely punishing those responsible for it. Many of those who called themselves masters of the universe until just the other day, flaunting Bentleys, private jets, yachts, Swiss chalets and more, are now hiding from their bankers and shareholders and blaming the “system”. Obviously, there can be no sympathy for them or for their bankers. The small shareholder is always the victim of hype. So the markets, at least, have responded to this multi-layered crisis of governance.
Prof Ajay has very interesting post here discussing about the Indian capitalism and its wings of fire.

Sadanand Dhume point out that unlike India "Japan, South Korea and Singapore didn't start seriously expanding their social welfare programs before they were well into middle-income status—at which point growth had begun addressing the major woes."

Saturday, September 1, 2012

Of that ruining tales of Indian growth story

Some links:

Shankkar Aiyar quotes while analyzing the current political economy of India:

Voltaire said, “We never live; we are always in the expectation of living.”

Mark Twain said “invest in land as they don’t make it anymore”.

Free marketeers turn Marxists- At least, I am not surprised to see these free marketeers turning to Marxists. 

Very interesting thoughts on health economics. "Master the gold standard of strength training first.".

Monday, August 27, 2012

Of that interesting reading

In this worst of the best Session of parliamentary mess in India what can one expect to respect the ruler whom we elected knowingly or unknowingly. The answer is nothing. Stop reading the political economics columns for a while to really kind of ponder about what is happening behind the door. There is no many harsh statement on many things. It become a sort of habits that many people just say what they would not have said if they really thought through it with commonsense.

I am not the one who recommends every time when Narayan Ramachandran writes about anything that he think is good to tell others about it. But this article is really worth spending your time perhaps I strongly recommend any one who is interested in the subject of invisible hand or the markets in society. The piece is absolutely excellent.

Saturday, May 19, 2012

Pricing vs rationing


Last week, I met Prof Indiresan for a dinner chat. It was extremely interesting to meet him over a dinner. He discussed his ideas including why we should have different interest rate for poor and rich States or regions in India.
Here is a article by Prof P V Indiresan in BL:
  • "Professor Sandel asks “Is that right?” He then quotes Professor Thomas Sowell who said that there was nothing wrong; people get accustomed to a price, but there is nothing sacred about it. Sowell has a point. In India, bus fares are ten times lower than they are in the US, but car prices are cheaper in the US than they are in India. Which then is the right price?
  • Years ago, I told Professor Madhu Dandavate, then Minister of Railways, of the harm done by rent control in the city of Bombay. At that time, it was estimated that around a hundred thousand flats were locked up by their owners because — once rented — they had little chance of getting their property back. If only the controls were removed, those flats would have entered the market, thereby, reducing rents.
  • What is more, a hundred thousand less attractive flats would also enter the market and the process would go on until a hundred thousand families currently living on pavements would have moved to better residences. He did not refute my argument, but as a socialist he would not do anything about it."