Sunday, March 27, 2011

Threesomes


Among others, one has to be careful with three persons in the world, particularly, what these three persons say in their capacity, and act about it. These are the law maker, central banker, and more importantly economist working with law maker, central bank and the government.

Some time the economist who is working with the government say uncommon thing but the media always ignores because that is important to them!

The current Chief Economic Adviser in the Ministry of Finance said “one uncommon thing” in an interview to Indian Express but it seems that the persons who were there in the interaction could not notice what the Adviser said. The Adviser said:

“..an economy cannot have more than one money-creating authority.”

It is simple as well as a complex to understand. About the “money creating authority”, understanding in theory in one thing and thinking about applicability is another thing. Did any one asked him why not? No one!! But what is worth to ponder is the following:
Is there a country in the world, where there is ‘more than one creating authority?’ Close to home whether India had ever such system in her history?
I am certainly sure to answer these questions in near future!!

Thursday, March 24, 2011

A(mbedkar) means D(alit) not C(apitalism)-WHY?


Friends,

I am unable to post often in this blog (which I loved) due to many responsibility landed on me, my apology for that!!

This is the 10th year living with the word Economics than my life!! I had great opportunity to study the history of Indian economic thought subject during my B A and M. A Degrees (both in Economics) I am thrilled to dig out more than many economic historian did for many their life time!! I have also met many great economists and people.

I am now more inclined to think that most of them did what they thought is right but ended up producing not only  wrong ideas, but very dangerous ideas, some are even doing right now, to whom the Indian society think a big thinker, but the reality seems to be otherwise.

So, what I am trying to convey you is that I will be posting very limited post hereafter. But will write more on what I have read in the past 10 years on various issues for publications by different agencies.

One of them is the Ambedkar’s economics, is there anything like that? Of course what he wrote during his early career as well as during his higher education is the one which I call it as Ambedkar Economics. More essentially, the core principles on which he had worked of course after deep thinking through it.

 What went wrong with his ideas were mostly the people who took or understood wrongly is the long trend continues which have become stone-age myth now, but not that easy to break! But let me try!!

One peculiar things happens with Ambedkar free market economics is that the people who call themselves as follower of Ambedkar actually ended up misusing his writings, mis-quoting etc.

The current situation is such that the movement you say the word Ambedkar, suddenly people will think that he was Dalit icon etc, I have no problem with that. My problem with them is the word Capitalism which he cherished very much but denied saying he did not utter anything!! for hell reasons which is not quite known!!   

My question is let’s repeat the title of this post WHY A(mbedkar) means D(alit) not C(apitalism)

So, thanks for being patient!!! 

Monday, March 21, 2011

No Planning, please

Chinese Democracy


Nitin Pai has a nice piece in today’s BS exploring the possibility of China becoming a democracy, but it seems to be unlikely to change its attitude towards India even it become. Remember that in this blog I have posted in this January what Prof Kishore Mahbubani said in his address in New Delhi that Chinese Government is studying the democratic models around the world.

He writes: 
  • It is harder for democracies to doggedly pursue the quest for power. As we know too well, there is often a disconnect between what is popular and what is necessary. Democracies are left with the complex, time-consuming task of reconciling this difference, often at the cost of losing opportunities to maximise national power. Authoritarian states, on the other hand, are less inhibited.

Thursday, March 10, 2011

Finally at Mises Institute!!!


I have not able to post any update on this blog for quite some time. The reason is simply that my research paper on liberalism and free banking ideas of Dr. B.R Ambedkar has been selected for the presentation in the Austrian Scholars Conference 2011.

I am now here to present my paper. It was great challenge for me to finally reach the Mises Institute for the Conference. Many great people have helped me in every single thing to make it this trip successful. This is my first visit to United States of America. Indeed, I am greatly thankful to all those who have helped me. I will write in detail about their individual name when I am back from the Conference.

Thursday, February 24, 2011

“corroded the moral fibre”




The people of India did not heard this, could you repeat, please?

Hello, the road to Ambedkar’s vision of Bank management is too far away


Wednesday, February 23, 2011

All road to "Swiss" but misses the point!!



  • That leaks make news is well known. More sensitive the leaks more shocking the news. The alleged ‘apology’ of L K Advani to Sonia Gandhi to the Bharatiya Janata Party task force on black money abroad saying that she held secret Swiss bank accounts was indeed a stunner. The leak shocked the BJP to grief, surprised the Congress to joy, and bewildered the media to splits. A plain reading of Advani’s letter shows that he has not regretted for the task force report mentioning Sonia’s name at all. Yet, thanks to the media spin, the whole country believes he has.
  • Here is the story of the ‘regret’. The task force of the BJP consisting of four specialists — Ajit Doval, a  security expert, Prof Vaidyanathan, a  financial expert, Mahesh Jethmalani, a  senior lawyer and myself, an experienced chartered accountant — had submitted a meticulous report, running to almost 100 pages, on the black money stashed away abroad. Citing two unbiased sources, the task force report had said that Sonia Gandhi family reportedly held huge funds in Swiss banks. This should have made big national news; but it did not. Why?
(From article by S.Gurumurthy)

Excuse me please my NAME is Capital ‘C, & S, of course M!!


Prof Arvind on:
  • Larry Summers, the recently departed Chairman of US President Barack Obama’s National Economic Council, posed the following question before his trip to India last November: “What is the self-perception of the Congress as a political party?” In fact, this broad question provokes three specific ones in the domain of economics. Is the Congress the party of Jagdish Bhagwati or Amartya Sen; Nehru or Indira Gandhi; or Aruna Roy or Nandan Nilekani?

I highly recommend to read the full article here.

Chinese Confucius via India’s confusion Conferred by government fiats


From a article by Mr.Shreekant Sambrani on fishing the NREGA:
  • The great Chinese sage Confucius said that he gave a hungry man a piece of fish which took care of his hunger for a day. Teaching him how to fish would have taken care of his hunger for life. Poverty alleviation has two dimensions: its manifestation and its causation. Relief activities, feeding programmes and curative medicine address the manifest symptoms of poverty. They are akin to giving the Confucian hungry man a piece of fish. Augmenting assets to enhance their productivity, education and skills training to improve employability on a sustained basis, and preventive medicine together with added nutrition to increase vitality, all attack the factors that cause poverty in the first place and attempt to break the poverty trap. They teach the man how to fish and, hopefully, provide him a fishing tackle. 

  • A Keynesian perpetual employment model of digging ditches and filling them up (or its modern Indian equivalent of rebuilding kutcha roads washed away after the monsoon year after year) may provide relief indefinitely, but does not address the root cause of the problem. Rural connectivity accounted for 40% of the NREGS activities until 2009. Having to undertake drought relief year after every drought year means that there is no drought-proofing worth the name. 
  • NREGS is as yet in the nature of an entitlement. Conferred by government fiats, it could create dependencies and sycophantism. Power gained through economic means, be it higher income from productive activities or greater control over local developmental expenditure, is far more lasting and elevating. The ultimate test of effectiveness of NREGS is that it is no longer needed. That would be a true tribute to the valiant fire-fighter Mr Kanga 40 years on. 

  • You see those hills?” Jamshed Kanga, an illustrious IAS officer, then divisional commissioner, Pune, asked the noted development economist John Lewis who was visiting him in 1972, pointing to the barren Sahyadri range behind his office. “I will break every one of those if necessary, but will not let a single person starve.” It was the worst drought in the history of independent India, with a monsoon deficit of 25% from the normal. Maharashtra and Gujarat were the worst sufferers. Kanga was true to his word. Massive relief works, mostly of the nature he had indicated, warded off starvation.

Amartya Sen’s nod to the licence-permit raj


Prof. Arvind Panagariya politely says that the acclaimed leftist economist Prof.Sen favours the growth killer "licence-permit raj" even now!!.

Some excerpt: 
  • Sen leaves the impression that growth is at best a sideshow when it comes to the well- being of the poor. He essentially ignores the direct contribution growth makes to the creation of income and employment for the poor when he states: “The central point to seize is that while economic growth is an important boon for enhancing living conditions, its reach depends greatly on what we do with the fruits of growth. To be sure, there are large numbers of people for whom growth alone does just fine, since they are already privileged and need no social assistance.” Thus, contrary to the evidence that growth directly benefits the poor, Sen emphasises the accrual of such benefits only to those “already privileged” with the benefits to the poor depending principally on how what the government does with the “fruits of growth” . Why does it matter whether you choose to see growth as central to improving the wellbeing of the poor or as a sideshow ? Because the policies you would advocate critically depend on this choice. Bhagwati, who sees growth as central, has long advocated policy reforms that enhance growth prospects while also recommending increased expenditures on antipoverty programmes. 
  • Sen, who sees growth as a sideshow, has rarely spoken in favour of promarket reforms, implicitly giving a nod to the licence-permit raj, which denied higher incomes and better employment opportunities to the poor. All politicians now recognise the centrality of growth in generating revenues to finance expenditures on health, education and employment programmes in a poor country like India. Because India started extremely poor at Independence and also grew very slowly for nearly four decades, successive governments failed to muster enough revenues to finance expenditures on these sectors. As a concrete example, Article 45 of the directive principles of state policy in the Constitution had required free compulsory primary education . But despite repeated attempts throughout, the goal remained unfulfilled until 2010 when accelerated growth finally yielded sufficient revenues to permit the implementation of the right to education as a fundamental right. 
The article published by Prof Sen in The Hindu is here.

Tuesday, February 22, 2011

Anywhere but nowhere


SG writes:

……the Congress has nobody worthwhile, the BJP has imploded, the third front is dead, and Mayawati, arre baap re baap... There was a time when the same class was fascinated with Musharraf: so smart, so with it, so confident, what swagger, so articulate, so much “like” us. More important, so unlike our smelly, pot-bellied, crotch-scratching politicians who mostly do not know how to dress or speak English. You know where he ended up as millions of brave Pakistanis took to the streets to protect their democratic rights and their judiciary.

The literary traditions in India

Friday, February 18, 2011

How to analyze the public polices?


I have been thinking a freakonomics way of looking at things and how to analyze the public polices in general and the policy decisions taken by the politicians, bureaucrats, dominant private companies, corporate in particular. One may look at their behavioural pattern in private and personal life. In fact, one can very easily think of this particular method of thinking in healthcare and education that has been provided to their children, relatives etc. because most of these people sent their children to private schools and invariably argue for public schools for poorer children. Similar, for the abysmal healthcare centres for the poor and quality private healthcare for their personal.

The big problem is that where we get the data or information? Even if you prepare a questionnaires will these interest group accept and provide necessary information?

Is there any study in the world looking at this sort of analysis?