Tuesday, February 1, 2011

Make that republic institutions work for resource-poor people


Mr. Arun Maira wrote on 26th January, 2011 that: 
  • One school of thought proposes that the quality of public services will improve by handing them to the private sector, which, with its focus on efficiency and profits, will cut out the waste. The same school of thought also believes that environmental damage is caused by a “tragedy of the commons” when no one “owns” the water, the forests, and the atmosphere. It believes that creation of private property rights (including tradable rights to pollute the atmosphere) will induce human beings to behave more responsibly. 

  • The basic premise of this school is that a market in which self-interested persons can trade, will always produce good outcomes. It believes that institutions for progress must be founded on principles of private property rights and competition.

  • Institutions are the wheels on which the cart of progress moves. The need to tune up government is evident. And the need to redesign market-and-property based institutions to meet challenges of inclusion and sustainability is evident too: in increasing public interest in new concepts of business accountability, social entrepreneurship, producer companies, and so on.

Of course, in India everything takes a little longer


That is what Prof. Raghuram Rajan says on the issues of ranging from managing overall economic growth to UID, education, fiscal balance, job creation, social delivery vs public delivery, and of course “Thinking that India will remain a country where more than 60 per cent of people will remain in agriculture is just a pipe dream.”

Output maters in social sectors as inputs matters in agriculture



  • The recently released Annual Survey of Education Report serves as an important reminder of India’s greatest challenge: converting increased financial outlays to improved development outcomes. Since 2004, India’s education budget has more than doubled, increasing from Rs 152,947 crore in 2004-05 to Rs. 372,813 crore in 2009-10. For the same period, ASER has tracked learning outcomes — and found that learning levels have remained depressingly stagnant. Nearly half the children in Standard 5 are still unable to read a Standard 2 text.

  • This outcome failure is not unique to education; nearly every social sector suffers the same fate. What explains the status quo?

Money and all that..


Martin Amis said in a interview to ET that

….money. We all know it's evil. That it's dirty. In myth, money is also associated with rubbish and excrement. There is something essentially dirty about money. And yet, we have not been able to restrain it and here it is. 

“benign neglect” vs “ironic reversal”


Prof Jagdish Bhagwati on Globalisation marches on 
  • The fear of globalisation, however, began historically in the East, not the West. After World War II, the West dismantled barriers to trade and investment flows, and worked to eliminate exchange controls and move to currency convertibility. What was sometimes called the liberal international economic order was the order of the day, and it was embraced by public opinion as well. 
  • By contrast, the East generally embraced the fearful view that, as the Chilean sociologist Oswaldo Sunkel put it, integration into the international economy would lead to disintegration of the national economy. Many intellectuals shared this dark anti-globalisation vision, and policymakers in much of the East were not far behind. 
  • Indeed, the West accepted the view that globalisation would result (as with trade) in mutual gain, embracing what I called in 1997 the notion of “benign neglect”. In the case of foreign investment and aid flows, the West went further, viewing them as being motivated by altruism, or “benign intent”, whereas the East regarded globalisation in a world of poor and rich nations as implying “malign impact”. In some analyses, malign impact turned into a more sinister “malign intent”. Thus, foreign aid was regarded as a plot to trap poor nations in a neo-colonial embrace. 
  • What happened next was what I have called an “ironic reversal”. As the benefits of globalisation became manifest, and the damage wrought by autarkic policies also became evident, policymakers in the East began to appreciate that their anti-globalisation stance had been a mistake. 
  • But then fear of globalisation moved to the West. The East had feared that it could not gain from trade with the West, which had superior infrastructure and human capital; now, the West had come to fear that it would lose from trade with the East, which had abundant, cheap labour. The longstanding stagnation in wages for unskilled labour was attributed to low-cost, labour-intensive imports, ignoring the corollary that western workers’ consumption of labour-intensive Asian goods offset the effect on real wages. 
  • To take another example, the East worried about a “brain drain” of professionals to the West, where opportunities seemed to be more plentiful. Today, the West is witnessing anti-globalisation opposition from members of professional groups, who fear the loss of their jobs to foreign counterparts. 
  • Rudyard Kipling famously wrote in The Ballad of East and West: “Oh, East is East, and West is West, and never the twain shall meet.” Given the ironic reversal of globalisation fears, Kipling is still right: convergence has continued to elude East and West. 
  • The current crisis did not create the debate about globalisation now heard in the West; it only made it slightly more salient. Yet the crisis may be tilting western policy outcomes in favour of globalisation. For example, on trade, therehasbeenaremarkablecommitmenttoefforts—largelysuccessful—to avoid significant backsliding into protectionism. Moreover, the G20 leaders have continued to express the need to conclude the Doha Round of multilateral trade liberalisation negotiations. 

Inflation is often by product of The State actions


Mr Raj Jain writes: 
  • Ironically, high commodity prices do not benefit the producers — the farmers — because of outdated Agricultural Produce Marketing Committee (APMC) laws. The APMC Act stipulates that farmers can only sell their produce to licensed commission agents. The Act perpetuates the monopoly of around 4,000 traders across the country. These traders, often with strong local political clout, further sell the farmers’ produce to shopkeepers, after which it reaches the consumer at inflated prices. 

However, his suggestion on “Farmers should be educated on best agricultural practices” is absurd on many grounds.

I have my own experiences in going to Marketing Committee back to my home town. It is the organized criminal practices being allowed to exist in this republic. I have seen (for many years) farmers who received payments after several months after selling their goods through the Marketing Committee. Even many traders operate with or without licenses by paying bribes to the authority whose role is to implement this nanny law called APMC Act.

One has to listen to these farmers who often come through the potholes of no roads in villages.

The best way is to create competitive environment in trading with farmers, provided there should be a around the clock of Lifeline for addressing complains of farmers. There is nothing exist at present. Even if you want to make a complaint you have to travel several miles to make a one. The telecom revolution is yet to create any good news to these aspects.  

One has to ponder how massive shifts taken place in the input costs for farming. Often the big industries receive subsidies in the name of farmers and their community.

Monday, January 31, 2011

Three beautiful books


This is the first time in my life received three beautiful books in January (2011) month. First (received on January 1st) one on “Institutional Theory of Poverty: A General Theory of Change from Poverty to Plenty” by Prof. Vedagiri Shanmugasundaram. It is a must read one. Few lines from his this book is worth to validate my likeness (don't forget to read the last line in the below points): 
  • Many errors in reasoning left the economist blindly trailing one or other of the hypotheses… 
  • The blind adherence of Keynesian deficit financing by Dr. VK.R.V Rao and his associates preferred their advice to Pandit Jawarhalal Nehru thus “Buckets of cement in Bhankra Nangal were better than of gold in the Reserve Bank of India vaults” 
  • The brilliant brains in the bureaucracy were put to work in wrong directions and much of the blame attributable to those in authority and policy making….. Bureaucracy to my mind is more sinned against than sinned. 
  • Keynesian fiscal extra veganza or model builders who are oblivious of important limitations which the centralized planned economy is unable to overcome.. 
  • ……the blunders of socialism in early decades 
  • Bureaucrats have kept the experts under their thumb, and politicians in their turn have sent the bureaucrats on wrong scent. The consequence is domestic poverty of ideas under the illusion of planning.  
  • Poverty is real. It is deliberately caused, and purposefully maintained. 

The second book (received on 10th) is “The New Asian Hemisphere: The Irresistible Shift of Global Power to the East” by Professor Kishore Mahbubani. I have already posted about the book here.

And the third book (received on 21st) is “Remaking India: One Country, One Destiny” by Arun Maira.

 I am currently reading this book and will post few things about the book and perhaps need of writing it!

Back to blog!!


I had another great opportunity to present my paper here and meet few interesting people also. I was also away from the NET world so I could not post anything that I think is important for this blog.

Some good news:

Prof.Ken is very kind to include my few words in his For News of Jonathan Gullible and the Philosophy of Liberty. You can see me by scrolling down!!!!

The other good news is that we have new Seminar:

The Mises-Hayek-Shenoy Seminar
Economics Beyond Keynes and Friedman
February 9-10, 2011
New Delhi

If any one of you interested to participate please do write to me, or to vipin.veetil@gmail.com andghanshyamsharma1985@gmail.com

Tuesday, January 25, 2011

Who spoke what is letter matter, than what they did in decision making?


The new Food Minister of India tells, I spoke to this and that, but correctly admits that the NREGA is a crook which kills the labour productivity.

From his interview with ET: 
  • In my younger days the question was scarcity. In Kerala very often we got rice only one time of the year. For the rest of the time we had to manage with things like tapioca. From that period of scarcity now there is availability. No one questions the availability. 
  • Then comes the question of purchasing capacity. Purchasing capacity has increased, especially after the NREGA. Recently I went to Tamil Nadu. In one of the villages, sugarcane farmers said they are not getting agricultural labour because of NREGA. Kerala doesn’t have enough rubber tappers.  

To be sure, inflation has increased after the NREGA, subsidies, unlimited money printing, etc

Monday, January 24, 2011

Mutiny of our native astrologers

10 things I really hate about R-Day

If you read this story I am certainly sure that you will be disappointed!! But you have to do just only one thing remember is the political junkies love of scam!!!

Manis mantra: “uninterrupted and uninterruptible dialogue”



  • Should the Pakistan government assist the Indian government in this manner to return to the negotiating table, then the first task would be to consolidate the gains of the 13-year old Composite Dialogue. Irrespective of whether progress on the back-channel is acknowledged or not, the official position of the two governments has grown so much closer to each other's than ever before that even by returning to the front table and taking up each component of the Composite Dialogue, including, above all, issues related to Jammu & Kashmir, we could dramatically alter the atmosphere in which to pursue the outstanding matters.

  • In such a changed atmosphere, it would be essential to immediately move to the next phase of what I hope and pray will be an “uninterrupted and uninterruptible” dialogue. Let me place before you, in outline, what I envisage as the essential elements to be structured into an “uninterrupted and uninterruptible” dialogue: One, the venue must be such that neither India nor Pakistan can forestall the dialogue from taking place. Following the example of the supervision of the armistice in Korea at Panmunjom for more than half a century, such a venue might best be the Wagah-Attari border, where the table is laid across the border, so that the Pakistan delegation does not have to leave Pakistan to attend the dialogue and the Indians do not have to leave India to attend.

  • Two, as in the case of the talks at the Hotel Majestic in Paris which brought the U.S.-Vietnam war to an end, there must be a fixed periodicity at which the two sides shall necessarily meet. In the Hotel Majestic case, the two sides met every Thursday, whether or not they had anything to say to each other. Indeed, even through the worst of what were called the “Christmas bombings” — when more bombs were rained on Vietnam than by both sides in the Second World War — the Thursday meetings were not disrupted. In a similar manner, we need to inure the India-Pakistan dialogue from disruption of any kind in this manner.
(From Way forward in India-Pakistan relations by Mr.Mani Shankar Aiyar)

Poor, weak: man or woman?


That is what it seems after the Sunday column by Tavleen Singh in IE: 
  • It is important to remember when we wring our hands over Dr Manmohan Singh’s timidity that he has a boss and that Sonia Gandhi has the most enviable political job in the world. She has immense power without any accountability. Everything that goes wrong is blamed on poor old Dr Manmohan Singh who after a long and illustrious career in government will now end up being remembered as the man who failed to improve governance at a time when India needs it more than anything else.
  • If we had a semblance of modern governance, we could overtake our old rival China in less than two decades. 

I terribly hate the words “overtake our old rival” because when we ‘overtaken’ we always leave behind someone!!

Nevertheless, get on: 
  • A meaningful Cabinet change would have been to scrap the ministry of Human Resource Development altogether. 
  •  Since the last general election we have seen the National Advisory Council take more decisions than the Government of India. It is to Soniaji’s private Cabinet that we owe almost every major policy decision taken in the past two years. This is why it is probably a waste of time criticising the Prime Minister’s feeble attempts to stir the dead roots of his government with a reshuffle.

Old man with old mind


Rather even polluted mind!! Isn’t it?

I mean Mr. Narayana Murthy says:

"He (Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose) would have continued and perhaps would have accelerated our efforts to control population through fair and transparent method".

However, Mr.Murthy is very right in saying that:

"India would have embraced modern methods of scientific agriculture and made us food surplus year on year. India would have embraced industrialisation better and become more export oriented than relying on import substitution which has led to all kinds of problems,"

Thursday, January 20, 2011

Liberals in UPA government

Sauvik has already commented on what Niranjan wrote: 
  • The motives behind the schemes to provide guaranteed jobs and food cannot be questioned. But the road to hell is often paved with good intentions. These schemes will push up food prices and also harm public finances.
What is even more interesting and in fact exuberantly feeling comes, when Niranjan used the words “outstanding economic liberals in government”. However, the meaning of liberals here may slightly vary from the understanding of the word “liberals” as such. Is there any one in the present UPA government? Of course I am aware of whom he refers!!
  • No reforms have been rolled back and economic policy is nowhere as interventionist as it was during the Indira Gandhi years, but it is quite clear that the UPA political leadership does not have a deep commitment to economic reforms despite having some outstanding economic liberals in government.
  • First, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh put his foot down and rejected the ridiculous suggestion by the influential National Advisory Council (NAC) that wages paid for work on the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme should be on a par with the minimum wages in each state, a move that would raise rural wages without any commensurate increase in productivity as well as put an immense strain on government finances. Second, a committee on food security set up by the Prime Minister and headed by economist C. Rangarajan rejected the NAC proposal that three out of every four families should be covered by the proposed right to food law.