Tuesday, December 14, 2010

Occupations pass just like


Dr.Manmohan Singh said in the following words before the Hiren Mukherjee Memorial Lecture 2010 by Professor Jagdish Bhagwati

  • “Jagdish has since earned for himself an enviable place in the world of economics. As a trade theorist he is in a class of his own. He has not only influenced international trade theory and become a familiar name in every economics classroom across the world, but he has also helped shape trade policy. He is among the architects of the World Trade Organisation, and continues to guide it. 
  • He and Padma were pioneers among economists who questioned the efficacy of the Licence-Permit Control Raj. Their highly influential book became the beacon for policy reform in India . He was among the first to study the phenomenon of ‘brain drain’ and identify its benefits for our economy. 
  • Today we in India are experiencing the benefits of the reverse flow of income, investment and expertise from the global Indian diaspora. The problem of ‘brain drain’ has been converted happily into the opportunity of “brain gain”. We are drawing on the global “brain bank” of people of Indian origin world wide. Jagdish Bhagwati is one of the shining stars of that community of global Indians. 
  • Professor Bhagwati is a true patriot, a loyal son of our Motherland and a truly liberal and secular Indian. Over the years I have greatly benefited from his expertise and his incisive analysis of the Indian and the state of world economy. He has combined his commitment to academic rigour and discipline with an equally passionate commitment to popular education. He has sought to engage his critics and win them over with his persuasive intellectual skills and his gracious charm and good humour. You will be witness to both his wit and wisdom. 
  • I have been a proud member of our Parliament for nearly two decades now. It is not often that I have had the opportunity to welcome a college-mate of such great distinction to these august premises. Today ladies and gentlemen I am truly delighted to have this unique opportunity and honour! I thank you.” 


The full text of lecture is here and excerpts published in the IE is here

Let’s STOP lip services to the electors


Hope you understand what I mean in title of this post!! Particularly at this juncture.

The following is from a speech by the Prime Minister of India:


  • Let me also take this opportunity to reaffirm our Government's commitment to providing an enabling environment conducive to the growth of the corporate sector in our country. We wish to provide a level playing field for private businesses, free from fear or favour. I am aware of the nervousness in some sections of the corporate sector arising out of the powers conferred upon Governmental authorities to tap phones for protecting national security and preventing tax evasion and money laundering. While these powers are needed in the world that we live in, they have to be exercised with utmost care and under well defined rules, procedures and mechanisms so that they are not misused. We must also look for solutions through technology to prevent access of telephone conversation to systems outside the institutional framework of government. Legal mechanisms already exist and they are in place. They need to be strengthened for more effective enforcement.

  
  • Businesses, by their very definition, need to be profitable. But the manner in which they use natural resources and the extent to which they are sensitive to the needs and aspirations of the common man is also critical to their own long-term survival and growth. Market activity that concentrates wealth without empowering the poor and the deprived is also unacceptable ethically. I am sure our business leaders are aware that business practices of some corporate houses have recently come under intense public scrutiny for their perceived ethical deficit. 

Make that 0.01 percent by end of few centuries later!!


From In-Chin Closer by Sudheendra Kulkarni

  • My inspiration in this effort comes from one ancient Indian sage, Buddha, and two modern Indian sages: Mahatma Gandhi and Tagore. Gandhiji wrote in 1942: “As a friend of China, I long for the day when a free India and a free China will cooperate together in friendship and brotherhood for their own good and for the good of Asia and the world.” Gurudev’s words, spoken at the opening of ‘Cheena Bhavan’ in Shantiniketan in 1937, are my guide and command. “(There is) an ancient pledge implicit in our past…The pledge to maintain the intercourse of culture and friendship between our people and the people of China, an intercourse whose foundations were laid centuries ago by our ancestors with infinite patience and sacrifice.”

    • I also draw inspiration from those eminent Chinese who understood India’s true greatness. Amongst them was Prof. Tan Yun-shan, Tagore’s comrade-in-arms in founding ‘Cheena Bhavan’. He wrote: “Riding on the white horse I head / Towards the path trodden by old sages;/Something I hold close to my chest:/My great ambition yet to manifest./Gone are the Tripitakas into antiquity,/Supplementaries are needed for posterity./Who is ready to undertake the task/To make moderns better than men of the past?” 

    • …the Chinese Premier, one of the few philosopher-statesmen in the world today, has said: “Friendliness accounts for 99.99 per cent of the 2,200-year-old Sino-Indian exchanges and misunderstanding merely 0.01 per cent. It’s high time we buried that 0.01 per cent and re-established the 99.99 per cent.”

    The rotting of word “liberals”


    From The scared dragon by Meghnad Desai

    • The Indian Constitution is a great document which affirms India’s deep-rooted commitment to the liberal democratic tradition. This tradition guided India’s unarmed independence struggle against the British. Indeed, Gandhiji and Nehru and much of the Congress leadership had imbibed these values when they had been in Britain. A fundamental critique of British Imperialism ever since the days of Dadabhai Naoroji was that the regime was ‘un-British’, that is untrue to its own core values. 
    • It is embarrassing to many people to admit that the notion of human rights is a Western import. But little in India’s past prepares us for the notion of equal rights among all people. The tolerance of Ashoka or Akbar or the justice of Jahangir are all things to be proud of, but these depend on individual idiosyncracies. Indian society as a whole never admitted to equality; Shudras and Dalits were never equal in India nor did Muslim rulers follow the tenets of Islam and treat all as equal. 
    • The truth is that the colonial experience enriched India in terms of imbibing liberal democratic values even as it exploited its economy. Over the sixty-three years of independence, India has overcome the negatives of colonialism and is now thriving as an economy. What it needs to preserve is the positive heritage of liberal democratic values. If India loses that, it will be just another frightened dictatorship like China.


    From Reducing corruption to Twitter by Taveen Singh
    • We need to be more critical of this nonsensical stalling of Parliament over the demand for a joint parliamentary committee. It is a terrific way to divert attention from the real issue, which is that the reason why corruption has reached such unimaginable proportions in recent years is because the licence raj has not yet been fully dismantled.
    • We are lucky that because there was a feeble sort of private sector in existence, despite decades of Nehruvian socialism, we did not end up facing what Russia did after the collapse of the Soviet Union. Our high officials could have ended up as oligarchs, as happened in Russia, but because there were real industrialists around, it was they who saw the opportunities that came after the economic reforms began and grabbed them. What our high officials ensured was that they did not give everything away for free and they ensured this by deliberate obfuscation in areas of policy.  
    • We need transparent and clear rules that would guarantee that nobody setting up an airline or a cell phone company can influence policy changes or reduce competition. This is what we should be talking about instead of twittering on and on about scams in this silly way.


    It appears to me that all these above words are merely poured due to the frustrations generated by The State through its operations in the affaires of citizens of India.

    How strange is no strange


    That is how it sounds in the latest column in To The Manner Born:

    • The truth is that India is perhaps the rudest country when it comes to making its rules. We don’t like outsiders. Unless they come with money, fame or status. Even then we tolerate them till we have a use for them. For example, we are almost subserviently polite to diplomats. Why? We think in the long run they will help us jump the line when we apply for a visa. Ditto bureaucrats. Or politicians. Or industrialists. But will we let our Gujarati heiress marry a Punjabi investment banker? Only if they threaten to run away and cause embarrassment. Otherwise we would prefer to keep things within the baraadari.


    • What is even more reprehensible is that the more educated the class of Indian the more logical their disdain. They can argue a sane person into believing that it is a sin to accept difference. And that they are merely carrying out their dharma/karma by keeping their community free of impurities. Most young people are so convinced that they buy the logic that an arranged marriage is the only way to find happiness. Love has been thrown out of the window.


    • A few years ago Mumbai was labelled as India’s rudest city but the truth is we are perhaps the most liberal of all Indian metros. In Mumbai we are kind to strangers. We talk to them in bars, we invite them to our homes. We even let our most beautiful girls marry them. Many of Mumbai’s top models are married to or living with their foreign partners. Each one of these men is an Indophile and has contributed to the city’s cosmopolitan culture. I guess we are polite enough to live up to our reputation of being a “melting pot”. Too bad the rest of India ignores its perpetual slogan of unity in diversity.


    Kool, well said

    The Joke of the Year 2010

    Saturday, December 11, 2010

    After Obama’s and Sarkozy’s its now Wen to speak


    Natwar Singh’s My Books of the Year



    At present I am reading the much awaited (at least to me) book of this year- Makers of Modern India by Guha.

    I fully share the same feeling that Natwar has on the “The exclusion of Vallabhai Patel ” in the book.

    Natwar writes:

    • Makers of Modern India by Ramachandra Guha provides the excitement of history. His selection of the “Makers” will not be universally accepted but neither can it be lightly dismissed. The exclusion of Vallabhai Patel is bewildering, as is the inclusion of Hamid Dalawi. He gives his reasons for doing so, but these are not entirely convincing. In his prologue, he states what India means to him — “the most interesting country in the world”. 

    The Margazhi Festival


    Growth of crooks beside The State


    In 1921, Mahatma Gandhi wrote in Young India: “The best use we can make of this government is to ignore its existence and to isolate it as much as possible from our life, believing that contact with it is corrupting and degrading”. The Mahatma said this of the British government in India then. It is ironical that today the government elected by “we, the people of India” deserves this treatment.

    Tap on freedom



    It was Professor hen software company Satyam went on hit the crisis.

    Now Surjit Bhalla is now voice –on phone tapping issues in similar tone.

    • …what right did the Indian government have, or for that matter any government, to tap an individual’s phone on the mere pretext of suspicion of income tax evasion? The government will argue, and correctly, that tax evasion is a criminal offence. But given the way our system works, or any country, do we want to give tax administrators the authority to tap our phones?  
    • In the US, evidence obtained via wire-tapping is not admissible in the courts.  
    • In order to wire-tap, the government in the US has to go to a federal judge and obtain permission. And this permission is granted only in rare cases and when there is threat to life and public security. A simple and easily manufactured allegation of income tax evasion just does not cut any ice. Either in the US or in any halfway decent civilised  society. So why isn’t our civil society and/or industrialists protesting the arbitrary and extreme powers that the Indian state is able to manufacture at will? We are protesting that our privacy was violated, but not the instruments that made such intrusion possible? There are many other instances of government and politicians (besides the daily offerings of new corruption and scams) playing short and dirty with individual enterprise and freedom. Take the microfinance “problem”.  
    • Intellectuals, and bureaucrats and politicians — the same kind that allow wire-tapping for as “cheap” and widespread an offence as income tax evasion (remember that for legal purposes an income tax offence is the same as have you ever cheated on your spouse?!) It is alleged by the so-called do-gooder politicians that microfinance is bad because it allows people to profit on the backs of the poor — before you know it, they will claim that microfinance is bad because it allows for the sexual exploitation of poor women.

    Boliticos: Dirty learning or dirtily doing?


    From Shekhar Gupta’s Dirty Business:

    • Those running the three main chambers — CII, FICCI and Assocham — would never admit it, but their power is now at its lowest point since 1991. The prime minister rarely, if ever, talks to corporate India. Government representation at the CII-World Economic Forum annual showpiece, the India Economic Summit, has rapidly declined over the UPA’s six years. In fact, the edition last month was the poorest of all. The prime minister of course gave it a pass; Pranab Mukherjee made a brief visit to speak in his stead, and then most of the top ministers stayed away. This year’s summit had probably the poorest levels of interest ever, sometimes presenting empty halls to reasonably serious panels. Similarly, under the UPA, official Indian representation at Davos has steadily declined. At the January 2011 Davos conference India is again the theme, for a rare second time in five years; and yet CII and the World Economic Forum are struggling to get senior ministers to represent the government. It is a strange paradox: 
    • And this when almost everyone, from Raghuram Rajan to The Economist to Newsweek rank crony capitalism as the biggest threat to the India story. 
    • India’s new billionaires come not from conventional manufacturing, IT or finance businesses, but from infrastructure, real estate and mining, where the state — and politicians — still hold arbitrary powers and, therefore, arbitrage. One land deal can produce more money than a dozen top members of India Inc, so why bother about them any more? This is the economic reason why corporate India feels so lost now. The political reason is simple. It is rooted in the Congress party’s faulty reading of the 2004 verdict as being against the BJP’s India Shining, and therefore against anything and anybody that represents that “fraudulent” idea. The logic being: poor farmers vote us to power, not fund managers. The question we need to ask is: what goodies can you take to the poor farmer, what rights to food, jobs, education, loan waivers if corporate India is not giving you growth, taxes, fiscal space, millions of new jobs? The top leadership of the Congress has to rectify this. It cannot take growth for granted. Particularly not when, disillusioned with policy flip-flops and fearful of a new backlash from New Delhi’s dreaded and now rejuvenated Bhavans, the biggest and finest Indian entrepreneurs are now moving their investments overseas. Tata now has nearly 60 per cent of his turnover overseas; almost all of Mukesh Ambani’s big investments over the next decade ($12 billion) are committed to America. Aditya Birla, Anand Mahindra, Essar, Bharti, are all looking outwards. It would be perilously complacent to mistake this flight of capital for globalisation of Indian enterprise. This is more a case of traditional corporates voting with their feet while the new billionaires of the crony capitalism of land-natural resources-politics get entrenched, hand-in-glove with the many Rajas of our scary new politics.

    I do not know how many of you read the Self-Marxist Mr.Aiyar’s 1997 article. If not do read it now. Of course the motive writing of all these stories, yet merely stories have their own motives and purposes. I am posting some excerpts (it’s a must read one!!) from his article:

    • We now have a tricameral legislature: the Lok Sabha, the Rajya Sabha and the Confederation of Indian Industry. So it was entirely proper for Inder Kumar Gujral to have sought a vote of confidence from the CII before submitting himself to the House of the People. He was merely acknowledging the growing role of the business lobby in determining the nation's destiny.

    • The business politicos (or boliticos, if I may coin a term), like their counterparts in the real game of politics, are a divided lot. They hide their identity behind a welter of acronyms leaving the layman (that is, you and me, dear reader) a little perplexed about who they are, what they stand for, and what distinguishes the one from the other.
    • There are three main business lobbies: CII, ASSOCHAM and FICCI. You know what CII stands for. ASSOCHAM is the Associated Chambers of Commerce, and FICCI is the Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry.
    • What distinguishes one from the other is not that one is a confederation, the other no more than a federation, and the third a mere association. The rift runs deeper. CII speaks English, ASSOCHAM Indish while FICCI speaks Marwari. (ASSOCHAM also speaks ZEEndi).
    • CII went to Harvard; ASSOCHAM stayed at home; FICCI believes degrees are superfluous since accounts are to be carried not digitally but in the head.
    • CII uses state-of-the-art computers; ASSOCHAM uses state-of-the-mart typewriters; FICCI makes do with khatas.
    • CII wears designer suits; ASSOCHAM wears patriotic bandgalas; FICCI wears dhotis, tucking most of it, like their accounts, out of sight.
    • FICCI is Indian in origin. ASSOCHAM was British until the Brits went away. And CII has completed the voyage begun by Christopher Columbus in 1492. Five hundred years late, the Americans have found, through the CII, the route to India -- or, at least, the route to CII.
    • As a 60s socialist, I learned to see the CIA's hand in everything. As a 90s socialist, I am learning to see the CII's hand in everything. CIA stands for Central Intelligence Agency. CII stands for Chidambaram's India Inc.
    • What unites all three is that they believe the business of business is the business of the nation. CII is downright ashamed of the state of the nation. FICCI funded the freedom struggle and is vaguely proud of it. ASSOCHAM is still making up its mind.
    • Therefore, it is the CII which is the favoured son of the first finance minister we have ever had who is ashamed of his nation. Our twice-born finance minister chose the very month in which India should have been (but was not) celebrating the first Asian Relations Conference convention in New Delhi (March, 1947) to announce his life ambition of making India Asian!
    • Hacks being hacks, and as such made up, for the most part, of chaps who failed to get clerical jobs at FICCI, perhaps misheard ASEAN as Asian -- I don't know. At any rate, CII applauds the finance minister's decision to make India Asian or ASEAN, whatever, so long as he does not persist with the foolishness of keeping India Indian. They have no use for 5,000 years of identity. What they are looking for is cash in the till. And they have got themselves a finance minister who says he's gonna give it to them.
    • Oh! he will, attaboy, he will. For, after all, he went to Harvard.
    • "And how will he?" you, as a non-member of CII, ask.

    Fortunately, an unfinished story

    Some excerpts from this year's Nobel Prize (Literature) Lecture by Mario Vargas Llosa.

    • Reading changed dreams into life and life into dreams and placed the universe of literature within reach of the boy I once was.

    • I have been able to devote most of my time to the passion, the vice, the marvel of writing, creating a parallel life where we can take refuge against adversity, one that makes the extraordinary natural and the natural extraordinary, that dissipates chaos, beautifies ugliness, eternalizes the moment, and turns death into a passing spectacle.

    • Flaubert taught me that talent is unyielding discipline and long patience.

    • I discovered that there is hope even in the worst of circumstances, that living is worth the effort if only because without life we could not read or imagine stories

    • ….culture was a privilege of the few

    • But thanks to literature, to the consciousness it shapes, the desires and longings it inspires, and our disenchantment with reality when we return from the journey to a beautiful fantasy, civilization is now less cruel than when storytellers began to humanize life with their fables. We would be worse than we are without the good books we have read, more conformist, not as restless, more submissive, and the critical spirit, the engine of progress, would not even exist. Like writing, reading is a protest against the insufficiencies of life.

    • Literature creates a fraternity within human diversity and eclipses the frontiers erected among men and women by ignorance, ideologies, religions, languages, and stupidity.

    • Since every period has its horrors, ours is the age of fanatics, of suicide terrorists, an ancient species convinced that by killing they earn heaven, that the blood of innocents washes away collective affronts, corrects injustices, and imposes truth on false beliefs. Every day, all over the world, countless victims are sacrificed by those who feel they possess absolute truths. With the collapse of totalitarian empires, we believed that living together, peace, pluralism, and human rights would gain the ascendancy and the world would leave behind holocausts, genocides, invasions, and wars of extermination. None of that has occurred. New forms of barbarism flourish, incited by fanaticism, and with the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction, we cannot overlook the fact that any small faction of crazed redeemers may one day provoke a nuclear cataclysm. We have to thwart them, confront them, and defeat them. There aren’t many, although the tumult of their crimes resounds all over the planet and the nightmares they provoke overwhelm us with dread. We should not allow ourselves to be intimidated by those who want to snatch away the freedom we have been acquiring over the long course of civilization. Let us defend the liberal democracy that, with all its limitations, continues to signify political pluralism, coexistence, tolerance, human rights, respect for criticism, legality, free elections, alternation in power, everything that has been taking us out of a savage life and bringing us closer – though we will never attain it – to the beautiful, perfect life literature devises, the one we can deserve only by inventing, writing, and reading it. By confronting homicidal fanatics we defend our right to dream and to make our dreams reality.

    • It is regrettable that democratic governments, instead of setting an example by making common cause with those, like the Damas de Blanco in Cuba, the Venezuelan opposition, or Aung San Suu Kyi and Liu Xiaobo, who courageously confront the dictatorships they endure, often show themselves complaisant not with them but with their tormenters. Those valiant people, struggling for their freedom, are also struggling for ours.

    • Literature is a false representation of life that nevertheless helps us to understand life better, to orient ourselves in the labyrinth where we are born, pass by, and die. It compensates for the reverses and frustrations real life inflicts on us, and because of it we can decipher, at least partially, the hieroglyphic that existence tends to be for the great majority of human beings, principally those of us who generate more doubts than certainties and confess our perplexity before subjects like transcendence, individual and collective destiny, the soul, the sense or senselessness of history, the to and fro of rational knowledge.

    Thursday, December 9, 2010

    We cannot show charity at someone’s else expense!

    That is the last words from former Finance Minister of Punjab. Some excerpts from his article in The Tribune:

    • Let me say it once again that I am totally against bad subsidies as well as unconscionable expenditure and there is no change in my position on this issue. This of course includes bad subsidies as well as unconscionable expenditure.

    • Newspaper reports in the past had shown how certain ministers and even some people who were not even elected, were spending crores of rupees on their personal petrol expenditure and passing their bills to the government. Likewise, in certain cases the reimbursement of medical bills is amounting to several hundred crores.

    • Even security bills, for instance. While I could understand the need for tight security for the Chief Minister and one or two top functionaries, I saw no merit in every member of the government travelling with an elaborate cavalcade of vehicles and security paraphernalia -- all at the cost of the common man’s taxes. Similarly, I rubbed a lot of people the wrong way when I went after persistent tax defaulters.

    • During my tenure as the finance minister, I never recovered any travel expenditure I made. This was a personal choice and I did not expect my Cabinet colleagues to emulate it. But certainly, I felt that they could have spared the state an expenditure of several crores that came from flimsy foreign trips, unjustified security entourages, continuous upgradation of their official vehicles -- all at the cost of the exchequer.

    • ..I would just say- get rid of wasteful subsidies and unjustified expenditure by members of the government. Have as many subsidies as you want, but make sure they are required and most importantly ensure that there is sufficient resource mobilisation. We should have our money to provide subsidies. We cannot show charity at someone’s else expense!