Friday, July 17, 2009

AICTE bribery and arrests

When I read this article I remember myself and my true friend Jayakamal went to Aravali Institute of Management in 2004 to attend an international convention. Jai had presented a great paper on population we also met Prof Varun Arya. The rest is history!

Utterly we need debate on nitty-gritty

N.K Singh is former civil servant in GOI and is now a Rajya Sabha MP and former Member, Planning Commission and present State Planning Commission, Government of Bihar.

In an article he writes “Kautilya is in fashion once again. While Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee has quoted extensively from his sayings, he may have forgotten to quote an important one: “A king with depleted treasury will eat into the vitality of both citizens and country people.”

And further “Independent analysts like T.N. Srinivasan have suggested that attributing the current economic slowdown to exogenous global factors is somewhat misleading as the deceleration had started before the onset of the crisis.”

Infact, T. N has a article in today’s Business Line in which he further stress that the “Economic Survey in its Chapter 2 elaborates on these challenges and includes a policy agenda with many diverse items and a superficial, and not an in-depth, analysis of the growth slowdown. Without an in-depth analysis, it is impossible to suggest policies to meet the first challenge of the FM.”

On children economy Rohini Nilekani has a article in the Mint and she suggest that “We need to refocus sharply on improving the lives of young children. The horrendous numbers hold a mirror to us that something more is going on, something that goes beyond economics. It tells us that the dialogue needs to shift to a debate on values—those slightly embarrassing, seemingly namby-pamby things that have no traditional place in a financial newspaper.”

More importantly she ask “why do we seem to care so little about the inalienable rights of the child to a childhood of love and joy and good health and good education? How does a society of adults become accountable for the treatment of its youngest citizens?”

The apathy in Indian education system further explained in another article by economist Bibek Debroy. He writes “In 1787, Thomas Jefferson wrote to James Madison, “A bill of rights is what the people are entitled to against every government on earth, general or particular; and what no just government should refuse, or rest on inferences.”

At least to me it is not surprise whenever somebody asks “Why don’t students go there? There are (in 2006) 355 universities and 18,064 colleges. The National Assessment and Accreditation Council (NAAC) rated 140 (out of 355) universities and 3,492 (out of 18,064) colleges. Only 9 per cent of colleges and 31 per cent of universities were grade “A”. The rest were junk grade. Is it any wonder 150,000 Indian students head overseas and get beaten up? ”

There is no such thing as profit but only future costs

“The National Policy on Education of 1986 has not been reviewed or revised after 1992, nor do policy pronouncements take into account the reality of liberalised India; even today, when matters of policy are debated, we pull out the same old experts who have been around for the last 30 years. Surely, it is time we charted a new course?”

Thursday, July 16, 2009

India's PHD research is rubbish

“Shekhar Gupta: PHD scholars for instance, where so much depends on your supervisor. So much of India's PHD research is rubbish because you just repeat what your supervisor believes in. See this is the mind-set we have to change.

Shekhar Gupta: I will tell you, there is a PHD given in the university in U.P with the title, Hindi Sahitya mein Lotte ka Mahitve or the importance of the Lotta in Hindi literature. Somebody has passed it. We have just cheapened our research, our PHDs, our higher education.”

Can we afford to ride a snail?

Obviously all we can say is a BIG no but only some people can surely say a silly YES who are those? Find out the answer but it is pathetic.

When I was in university a professor who travelled Europe told me that in the Indian Railway only monkey can claim and the people who traveled in the Indian railway knows.

Mr Barun Roy has good article in the Business Standard.

  • “India's cargo trains run at 19-30 km an hour, they run at 120 km in China - and the difference is only growing.
  • Thank God there’s Rabindranath Tagore, so Mamata Banerjee could quote him to spice up her 2009-10 railway budget speech. And thank God there’s China, so we can compare notes and check out how good her fare really is. And what we find is that it is old fast-food cooked anew, instantly palatable but a potential killer.
  • In a growing economy, can we afford to ride a snail? We need a railway system that’s fast, dynamic, and expanding. We don’t have one and won’t have it till the time non-stop trains continue to be the best we can think of. Will they run fast? Faster than India’s current fastest, the Rajdhani and the Shatabdi expresses, whose average speed is no more than 80 km per hour? If they don’t run fast, they won’t make much of a difference. In a country where any train that runs at 55 km per hour or more is called super-fast, we’ll only have a few more. In plainer language, only a few more gimmicks.
  • How fast are our goods trains? No more than 19 km to 30 km per hour in different part of the country. In eight years from now, when some 3,000 km of dedicated freight corridors ( forming only a tiny segment of our total network) are expected to be in service, a few of them could — just could — be running at 100 km an hour. Some benchmark indeed for 2020 India!
  • Look at China. After six reviews and continuous upgrading, the average speed on the Chinese railways has shot up to 200 km per hour from 55 km per hour in 1997. There will be 35 high-speed routes by 2012, with trains running at between 200 km and 350 km per hour. At least 50,000 km of dedicated high-speed passenger railways will be on the ground by 2020. Thus, existing tracks will be freed up for cargo trains, whose average speed is already 120 km per hour.
  • The difference between the two countries is even more glaring when it comes to new construction. Mamata Banerjee’s budget provides for only 250 km of new lines in the current fiscal year. The provisions for the previous two years were for 350 km and 155 km of new lines, respectively. Is that enough for a country whose economy is expected to grow by 8-9 per cent a year and which wants a fair geographical distribution of growth? We’ve gone through almost two decades of economic reforms, but our route length has grown from 62,367 km in 1990 to only about 63,350 km now. Do you call that progress? Can we go on flogging a limited network without sacrificing speed and efficiency and adding to congestion? More than 75 per cent of India’s railway goods-traffic moves on about 20,000 km of fully saturated, over-utilised, and low-capacity lines. One day, it will simply choke.
  • In China, on the other hand, over 2,500 km of new lines were built in 2008 and another 3,450 km will be built in 2009. The new goal is to add 6,000 km of new tracks every year till 2020. China’s network currently stands at 80,750 km, making it the third-largest in the world after the US and Russia. By 2020, it will have hit 120,000 km, of which 50 per cent will be double-tracked and 60 per cent electrified. What will India have by then?
  • Network expansion has naturally meant more business for the Chinese railways. They have three times the number of wagons India has — 600,000 against 200,000 — and moved 3.3 billion tonnes of cargo last year, against India’s 833 million tonnes. What is India’s target for 2009-10? No more than 882 million tonnes. For a vast and growing economy like India’s, it’s nothing but a joke.
  • The other difference is that the Chinese know the value of time. We don’t. Beijing’s 126-acre West station, commissioned in 1996 and said to be the largest in Asia, was built in three years. Work on the 1,318-km. Beijing-to-Shanghai high-speed railway, a brand new line meant to cut travel time between the two cities from 14 hours to five — mark that — began in April 2008 and is to be completed by 2013. What’s our schedule, say, for making 50 of our stations ‘world class’? We don’t know. The budget doesn’t say anything on that. The budget debate has revealed that many past promises have remained unfulfilled so far.
  • So, you may draw your own conclusions. Mamata says it’s a continuous process, whatever that means. And, as the previous railway minister, Lalu Prasad, admits, not all promises are meant to be implemented. Thus, while China goes on to cover the entire country with high-speed trains to bolster its economic growth, we are happy to tinker with whatever we have, much like a child playing with his toy-train set, adjusting it here and there and deriving pleasure from it. It’s a game we play, rolling out new promises to hide old failures, with no sync with the real economy.”

A Personal Inequity

It is worth to read Sowell's article.

A Personal Inequity by Thomas Sowell

Tuesday, July 14, 2009

Sometimes, when I hear about "disparities" and "inequities," I think of a disparity that applied directly to me-- the disparity in basketball ability between myself and Michael Jordan.


When I was in school, I was so awful in basketball that the class coach wouldn't even let me try out for softball, at which I was actually pretty good.


I was more than forty years old before I ever got the ball through the basket. It wasn't during a game. The basket was in my brother's backyard and I was just shooting-- unopposed-- from practically right under the basket. The only pressure on me was that my little nephew was watching.


After making that one basket, I never took a basketball in my hands again. I retired at my peak.

Think about it: Michael Jordan made millions of dollars because of having a talent that was totally denied to me. Through no fault of my own, I had to spend years studying economics, in order to make a living.


Economics is not nearly as much fun as basketball and doesn't pay nearly as much money either. We are talking inequity big time.


Most discussions of "disparities" and "inequities" are a prelude to coming up with some "solution" that the government can impose, winning politicians some votes in the process. How could the disparity between Michael Jordan and me be solved?


We could change the rules of basketball, in order to try to equalize the outcomes. Michael Jordan could be required to make all his two-point shots from beyond the three-point line, with five players opposing him and no one on his side. A three-point shot could require him to stand under the basket on the opposite side of the court and shoot from there.


Meanwhile, I could make two-point shots from a spot half the distance from the foul line to the basket, and of course without any other players on the court to distract me. Any shots I might make from back at the foul line would count as three-pointers.


Even under these conditions, you would be better off betting your money on Michael Jordan. But, conceivably at least, we might change the rules some more to make the results come out less lopsided, in order to create "social justice."


The problem with trying to equalize is that you can usually only equalize downward. If the government were to spend some of its stimulus money trying to raise my basketball ability level to that of Michael Jordan, it would be an even bigger waste of money than most of the other things that Washington does.


So the only way to try to equalize that has any chance at all would be to try to bring Michael Jordan down to my level, whether by drastic rule changes or by making him play with one hand tied behind his back, or whatever.

The problem with this approach, as with many other attempts at equalization, is that it undermines the very activity involved. Basketball would be a much less interesting game if it was played under rules designed to produce equality of outcomes.


Attendance would fall off to the point where neither Michael Jordan nor anyone else could make a living playing the game.


The same principle applies elsewhere. If you are going to try to equalize the chances of women getting jobs as firefighters, for example, then you are going to have to lower the physical requirements of height, weight and upper body strength.

That means that you are going to have more firefighters who are not capable of carrying an unconscious person out of a burning building.


If you are going to have these lower physical requirements be the same for both women and men, that means that you are not only going to have women who are not capable of carrying someone out of a burning building, you are also going to have men who are likewise incapable of carrying someone to safety.


Most activities do not exist for the sake of equality. They exist to serve their own purposes-- and those purposes are undermined, sometimes fatally, when equality becomes the goal.


Nor would a politician encouraging me to feel resentful toward Michael Jordan do any good. If I had such resentments, they would do me more harm than they would do Michael Jordan. They would make me feel bad-- and could make me miss seeing some great basketball.


Monday, July 13, 2009

Cost of lives


There needs to be careful observation- No more socialist nest please

The world has changed and the India has changed through the free market ideas.

No more blind faith in statesim and socialism these poverty stricken ‘isms’ have gone though, not completely.

Time and again the socialist economists give wrong signal which is not at all sure in their mind, in way it is bogus. And its not surprise when Mr Abhijit Banerjee says that:

  • “…there aren't many other possibilities of tailor-made goods for the poor…
  • i haven't really come across compelling examples of products designed for the poor.”

Now, take the second line it is completely nonsense and he forget to observe carefully.

Today, the poor gets cheaper products from shampoo to school education (private) much better than a decade ago. Let’s take in detail some of them:

  • The 50 paisa shampoo is an example,
  • The one rupee washing powder is an example,
  • The 500 rupees Mobile phone is an example,
  • The one rupee water packet is an example,
  • The 10 rupee chota recharge is an example,
  • The poor people sent their children near to their home for education and pay 50-100 rupee per month is an example,

Now, you count…………..

He should change the centre (which he heads at MIT) into Prosperity Action Lab instead Poverty Action Lab. In way these groups are collectivist.

USAHOME-UL!

Friday, Jan. 21, 1966

THE HOMOSEXUAL IN AMERICA


Saturday, July 11, 2009

No Regrets Have I

That was a rendering of the Tamil composition of C. Rajagopalachari a great liberalist. For record I am reproducing the full poem below:

Kurai Onrum Illai (No Regrets Have I)

No regrets have I

My lord,
None.
Lord of the Written Word,
My light, my sight,
My very eyes
No regrets,
None.
Though you stand
Where I behold you not
My light, my very eyes,
Protector of all earthlings
I know you sustain me
Lord of the Venkata Hill so pure
You meet my hunger, my thirst
My hope, my prayer
You keep me from harm,
Lord of the Sparkling Gems,
I need naught else
Father of the Seven Hills,
Naught else.

* * *

You stand — do you not? —
Veiled by a screen
Only the learned can part
For they are the learned
Which I am not
But no, no regrets have I.
Crowning this hill
You stand as rock
Giver of Boons
Immutable God
Father to these hills
No regrets have I
Govinda !

* * *

In this benighted Age of ours
Lord —
The worst of all the Four —
You have entered
The sanctum
A shaft of granite
Where though I see you not
No regrets have I.
Boulder of strength
With the Ocean,
Heaving on your breast,
Of the purest compassion —
My Mother,
My very own, who grants
Anything I ask of her
Can I possibly have regrets?
The two of you, I know,
Stand there for me
Eternally
No regrets have I my Govinda
None, none whatsoever
Govinda! Govinda!
Govinda! Govinda!

An abettor of the free market and not a usurper of the market

A 12th grade student argues that “The Indian population remains one that needs to be taken care of. It is simply not ready to be left alone in the wild yet”

But there is no way to agree his point in this generation and in future. But having recent experience we all have to agree some or other what the other student says.

“Government is no substitute to free markets. All the same, free markets, as recent events demonstrate, can't do without government (which corrects market failures). So the big question is not of government versus free markets. Nor is it about "how much" state intervention but of "what kind." This is as true for the Indian economy as any other!”

See here for full article debate in WSJ

Dog eat dog. Darwinism of the waiting line

Daniel Asa Rose says “There are 85,000 people biding their time, most of them on thrice-weekly dialysis that leaves them with an enervated excuse for a life the rest of the time. More than 4,500 of them died last year waiting. On average, that’s 13 people dying each day awaiting a kidney.”

The government is making criminals of all of us

There is a great article on winenomics and by Shoba Narayan. I am posting the full article here for record.

Behind every successful oenophile is a bootlegger

Thu, Jul 9 2009. 8:37 PM IST

Indian wine is an orphan with an image problem. Unlike liquor, wine lacks a lobby. Wine lovers can protest all they want but there is no concerted effort by any coalition to make wine accessible to the masses

A recent headline on the Indian Wine Academy website caught my eye. “Death knell in Delhi for fine wine,” said an article by Subhash Arora, president of the academy and the Delhi Wine Club. While the jargon about transfer permits and “not being gazetted” can make your head swim, the fact is that the Delhi government has increased the excise duty on wines to 150-200%, making it, according to Arora, the second worst state in India in this regard, after Maharashtra.

This is a shame. More and more urban Indians are drinking wine, and I would argue, they should. Wine is as nice a social lubricant as the single malts my erstwhile editor swears by. Better, I would argue, for wine is good for you. The problem is that Indian wine is an orphan with an image problem. Unlike liquor, wine lacks a lobby. Wine lovers can protest all they want but there is no concerted effort by any coalition to make wine accessible to the masses.

We Bangaloreans take our tipple seriously. Whether it is a corporate launch on the lawns of the Taj West End, lunch at the Rogue Elephant, coffee at Koshy’s or drinks at Caperberry, the talk inevitably comes around to two things: rants against the 11.30pm closure of pubs and the state of Indian wines. Admittedly, this is a small, self-selected group, and some of this harks back to Bangalore’s “pub culture”, in which drinking was viewed with a benign, non-judgemental eye.

Bangaloreans—like the Goans—know how to hold a drink. All of which is ironic preamble to the fact that the one thing Bangalore lacks is decent wine at reasonable prices. Some local wines are good. Others, as epicurean Stanley Pinto says, “aren’t fit to strip paint with”. Pinto runs the Bangalore Black Tie—a group of foodies who dress in tuxedos and gowns and dine out once a month at city restaurants—and I am a member.

Last year, the local government imposed a “special additional fee” on not just imported wines but also non-Karnataka wines. This means that if I have to drink a Nashik wine, I have to cough up Rs300 more than you folks sitting in Mumbai. This means that a Yellow Tail Shiraz that sells for $5 (around Rs250) in the US costs three times as much here. Members of the Bangalore Wine Club have been up in arms over these price hikes, calling for a boycott of the local Grover Wines because Kapil Grover is part of the Karnataka Wine Board, which recommended taxing non-Karnataka wines. From the point of view of the Karnataka wineries, however, these price hikes are a tit-for-tat measure against the Maharashtra government and its seven-year-old protectionist policies. Last year, Karnataka returned the favour, at twice the rate that Maharashtra had imposed, and we, as consumers, suffered.

There are ways around this that mostly have to do with travelling abroad. Bringing the allowed two bottles of wine and then some when you come back from overseas trips is a good, if expensive, way to sustain your wine habit. But what if you don’t go abroad that much? I buy my wine at my neighbourhood store, Thom’s, where it is stored poorly. When I spend Rs1,500 on a wine and it turns out to be so-so, I cannot tell if it is the wine or the storage. Some say that the state’s godowns, where wines are stored between vineyards and retailers, are “criminally unprofessional”, that most wines are destroyed before they arrive at stores.

So I called Alok Chandra, co-founder of the Bangalore Wine Club, with one simple question: How can one get decent wine at reasonable prices in India and more specifically, Bangalore?

“Go to your friendly neighbourhood smuggler,” he retorted.

Say what? Did he really want to be quoted saying that, I asked.

“Why not?” said Chandra. “The government is making criminals of all of us.”

Pinto not only agreed with Chandra, he offered to give me the telephone numbers of three smugglers who would deliver French, Italian, Chilean and Australian wines to my home, at prices that “cock a snook at the idiot authorities”.

The problem is that the authorities don’t care. They sell about 5,000 cases of wine a year and 10 times that amount of liquor. Wine is—and is perceived as—elitist. Wine drinkers are a minority in India, and perceived as a wealthy one at that. So “tax the buster” seems to be the government’s approach.

Chandra buys his wines at Spar supermarket and Metro. Pinto suggested Peekay Wines at Crawford Market, Mumbai. I bought a Chateau d’Ori Merlot and Sauvignon Blanc for Rs322 each—lower than the Rs400 I pay for Kinwah, a new Karnataka winery. I also got the Tiger Hills Chardonnay I had been wanting for Rs520. Since they had a two-for-one offer on Vin Voulet, I got two bottles of red. All were satisfactory. All are finished. I am back to square one.

There is a glimmer of hope on the horizon. Two months ago, the Maharashtra government proposed to bring down the excise duty on out-of-state wines if Karnataka would reciprocate. Apparently, Karnataka didn’t reciprocate, for Delhi too has now raised the excise tax on wines.

Look, I know all this wine talk sounds pretentious at some level. I mean, who cares? It’s only wine, not world peace or the budget, you can say. Okay. Let me make a somewhat complicated argument. If state governments lower taxes, then wine will be accessible to more people and not just the elite. Perhaps this will make the man who drinks toddy or illicit arrack reach for wine instead. He will get his kick—and I know I am stretching here—except it will be healthier.

Shoba Narayan recently had a terrific 2005 Chilean Montes Alpha Cabernet Sauvignon at Italia restaurant in Bangalore. Write to her at thegoodlife@livemint.com

Article is here

  • There is also news for importing used cars in India.