Tuesday, April 14, 2009

Birth of Banyan Tree in Asia

The Economist

London based The Economist has come out a separate column for Asian Economies to track the change in it but confused where it stand in the world as it saying goes “There has also been confusion about quite where Asia is.” 

Further it says “So why Banyan? A dearth of pan-Asian images speaks volumes, but the banyan tree serves better than most, for it or similar trees are found somewhere in most Asian countries. The banyan spans Asia’s spirituality and its entrepreneurialism. The Bodhi tree, under which Buddha attained enlightenment, was a banyan by another name. Gujarati merchants conducted business under it, and the Portuguese lent their name, banyan, to the tree. It stuck.”

Dr Ambedkar and Military Headquarters of War (MHOW)

Well, today is the birthday of Dr B R Ambedkar who was responsible for the drafting of Indian Constitution. If any one wanted to make a sense of one subject like economics or Indian Constitution as a single matter of entity he/she needs to have a lucid understanding of the subject’s concepts and implication in practicality both in national prospective and a world view.

Obviously, people celebrate a person or an idea etc when they like or dislike their life and works. 

Dr Ambedkar was born in MHOW, now in Madhya Pradesh. I happened to study my basic research work in the institute which was established on his name. I visited several times his home there is a Muslim masque beside his home. MP government is trying to make his home into a temple like a Buddha statute type, since he had been converted to Buddhism and they are trying to do the same. 

I was taught a subject called Dr B R Ambedkar thoughts and contemporary issues in society. The whole course work was pass/fail oriented but every bit of his idea was covered in a more intensive caste biased, one side view, deliberately rejecting other side of the coin etc. 

 What I was not taught I learned from a library in the institute. The institute library is not biased it has all kind of books including the liberalism! 

I happened to pick up the liberal ideas and concluded my argument with Prof and friends in our debate that “if a person converts from one religion to another he or she could never feel that he or she is born with the one in which they were born naturally”. For economic benefit anyone can convert to other religions and it was accepted by my friends and Prof in the institute. 

The below are some of the Ambedkar ideas which are relevant even toady. 

He said in the Assembly on 15 November, 1948: 

  • “(H)ow the society should be organized in its social and economic side are matters which must be decided by the people themselves according to time and circumstances. It cannot be laid down in the Constitution itself, because that is destroying democracy altogether… It is perfectly possible today, for the majority people to hold that the socialist organization of society is better than the capitalist... But it would be perfectly possible for thinking people to devise some other form...which might be better than the socialist organization of today or of tomorrow.” 

[Source: Constituent Assembly Debates, Vol. VIII, pp.401-402] 

  • He asked: “On 26th January 1950, India will be an independent country. What would happen to her independence?” 
  • He said: “What perturbs me greatly is the fact that not only India has once before lost her independence, but she lost it by the infidelity and treachery of some of her own people.” His anxiety was deepened by the fact that “in addition to our old enemies in the form of castes and creeds we are going to have many political parties with diverse and opposing political creeds.” 
  • He queried: “Will Indians place the country above their creed or will they place creed above country” and answered: “This much is certain that if the parties place creed above country, our independence will be put in jeopardy a second time and probably be lost for ever. This eventuality we must all resolutely guard against. We must be determined to defend our independence with the last drop of our blood.” 
  • His second thought was about the future of democracy. “There was a time when India was studded with republics, and even where there were monarchies, they were either elected or limited. They were never absolute.” 
  • He was emphatic that “We must make our political democracy a social democracy as well. Political democracy cannot last unless there lies at the base of it social democracy.” He asserted that “liberty cannot be divorced from equality, equality cannot be divorced from liberty. Nor can liberty and equality be divorced from fraternity. Without equality, liberty would produce the supremacy of the few over the many. Equality without liberty would kill individual initiative. Without fraternity, liberty and equality could not become a natural course of things.” 
  • “The United States has no caste problem. In India there are castes. The castes are anti-national. In the first place because they bring about separation in social life. They are anti-national also because they generate jealousy and antipathy between caste and caste. But we must overcome all these difficulties if we wish to become a nation in reality. For fraternity can be a fact only when there is a nation. Without fraternity equality and liberty will be no deeper than coats of paint.” 
  • He pointed out the complete absence of two things in Indian society. “One of these is equality. On the social plane, we have in India a society based on the principle of graded inequality which means elevation for some and degradation for others. On the economic plane, we have a society in which there are some who have immense wealth as against many who live in abject poverty. …. In politics, we will have equality and in social and economic life we will have inequality. In politics we will be recognizing the principle of one man one vote and one vote one value. In our social and economic life, we shall, by reason of our social and economic structure, continue to deny the principle of one man one value.” 
  • He suggested that “the sooner room is made for the realization of their aspiration, the better for the few, the better for the country, the better for the maintenance of its independence and the better for the continuance of its democratic structure. This can only be done by the establishment of equality and fraternity in all spheres of life.” 

(Source: Excerpts from P. P. Rao article in the Tribune)

Community Currencies…….

Jamal Mecklai book review throws some new coins “there is a very interesting section on the QQ, a new Chinese coin created by online marketers, which has already moved into the real world. The second is a brief mention of Community Currencies, which, in many senses, are a reactionary response to globalisation.”

Madras Institute of Sciences (MIS)..

RAMACHANDRA GUHA quotes a letter written to Swami Vivekananda by Jamsetji Tata on November 23, 1898. The below is the letter: 

Dear Swami Vivekanand, 

I trust you remember me as a fellow-traveller in your voyage from Japan to Chicago [in 1893]. I very much recall at this moment your views on the growth of the ascetic spirit in India and the duty, not of destroying, but of diverting it into useful channels.

I recall these ideas in connection with my scheme of a Research Institute for India, of which you have doubtless heard or read. It seems to me that no better use can be made of the ascetic spirit than the establishment of monasteries or residential halls for men dominated by this spirit, where they should live with ordinary decency and devote their lives to the cultivation of sciences — natural and humanistic. I am of opinion that if such a crusade in favour of an asceticism of this kind were undertaken by a competent leader, it would greatly help asceticism in science, and the good name of our common country, and I know not who would make a more fitting general of such a campaign [than] Vivekanand. So you think you would care to apply yourself to the Mission of galvanizing into life our ancient traditions in this respect? Perhaps, you had better begin with a fiery pamphlet rousing our people in this matter? I should cheerfully repay all the expenses of publication. 

With kind regards

I am dear Swami

Yours faithfully

Jamsetji N. Tata 

But what Mr Guha says now is “Some of its Directors have been brilliant; others, merely capable.” It is nonsense to say “merely capable”. It seems to me that he has understood human nature and their environment where the person born, lived, his/her family etc. Everything is matter in a person life and works. 

However, now the populist Tamil DMK parties said in its LS election manifesto that “establishing an Indian Institute of science (IISc) in Chennai”. 

Of course, DMK is not a Tata to fund the institution if anything it cost for establishment the money will be theft from people of this state/country. 

Fund Candidate not Parties!!!

Yes the idea of “Fund Candidate not Parties” is not an issue in this election, but it is a matter of time. 

Former Chief Justice of the High Court of Delhi Rajindar Sachar says “A straightforward, honest, equitable solution is to ban the corporate funding of political parties, as in the US and the UK. Clean politics mandates this as a minimum prerequisite for all political parties. Let the electorate demand that the manifestos of the parties include such a provision. Let them give a straight answer immediately.” 

He also gives a brief history of how corporate funding ruled out:

  • “It is beyond doubt that contributions by companies are given not because of any ideological reason but as a device to be in the good books of the ruling party. Thus, between 1966 and 1969, as many as 75 companies paid down Rs 1.87 crore out of which Rs 144 lakh was given to the ruling party. The ruling Congress party in 1967 alone received Rs 87 lakh. 
  • Perception and reality have not changed. Thus we find that in 2003-2004 the BJP got Rs 90 crore as against the Congress’s Rs 65 crore. The peak of the BJP was Rs 155 crore in 2004-05, down to Rs 137 crore in 2007-08. The rise in the share of the Congress during this period was phenomenal, starting from 2002-03 at Rs 53 crore, upswinging to Rs 265 crore in 2007-08. More significant, the corporate-political nexus is illustrated by corporate donation to the BSP of Ms Mayawati rising in 2002-03 from Rs 10.9 crore to Rs 55.6 crore in 2007-08. Does one need more proof of invidious entry of the corporate sector in our body-politic and of the dangerous consequences.”

Stigmatized Power/muddled ideas are the “central concern of economists” in India…

Yes that’s how it seems to be in India as for as macroeconomics is concerns. Most of the macro economists in India are not interested to look what economists like Hayek and others said. 

It is not surprise when Mr Bery write “the developed countries (some of whom then were not much richer in the 1930s than the middle-income countries of Asia today), interest in saving was largely stimulated by the work of John Maynard Keynes and his attempt to understand the sources of the Great Depression. As he famously observed, in an economy closed to international trade and capital movements, overall economic activity adjusts to equate desired saving with desired investment. 

This insight, together with the implication that government must intervene when desired investment falls, desired saving increases and credit markets fail (all of which are true of the United States today) lies at the heart of today's call for global fiscal stimulus.” 

What are you talking about? Now it is recognized by every one that the crisis were deepened in United States because of dried up ‘savings’ in other words US consumer used all or most of their earning and saved nothing or less. 

What about the wrong direction of government during boom period. Did private institutions have intervened or do they have any incentive to do so for corrective mechanism?

Monday, April 13, 2009

Bureaucrats Charity works very well under the table……….

K Shivakumar quote’s Nani Palkhivala in an article in BS which is like anything but how terrible our government bureaucrats Nani said: 

Two things strike the student of Indian income-tax law with trepidation and amazement — the precipitate and chronic tinkering with the law by bureaucrats who are the unacknowledged legislators of India, and the anaesthetised patience of the Indian public. The poor of India endure inhuman conditions which would lead to a bloody revolution in any other country. The rich endure foolish laws and unending amendments which benefit none except the legal and accountancy professions, and instinctively prefer to circumvent the law than to fight for its repeal.”

All lips service is OK, but show me the reforms…

Yes, we have to ask ourselves first that did Dr Singh has done anything on education reform meaningfully? 

Shiv Visvanathan, writes “…. what is wonderful about Singh is his concern and compassion, the fact that he listens. He is not a gladiator. He appears gentle, even thoughtful. This does not mean he lacks courage, merely the bravado that goes with it. 

This is why Singh’s response dubbed as uncharacteristic was unfortunate. He succumbed to the false politics of masculinity evoked by the word security. He is not a Modi or an Advani infusing a militaristic sensibility into civilian life. 

One would argue that he should stay this way, avoiding jingoism, machismo or the rituals of a clichéd masculinity. India’s response to terror and violence has not mimicked it. In this lies our sanity. ”  

Let’s not make ourselves fool!

In search of the a real “Doyen”!

Delhi School of Economics Prof Pulin B Nayak writes in today’s ET that “Prof Chelliah was decidedly different. Nor did he have any propensity towards or time for political sloganeering. He wanted to employ the body of academic knowledge in the era of post-Keynesian macroeconomic and fiscal policy making to make a difference to the human condition in his home country. But for this it was vital that he must return home.”  

Except the tax reform he is not able to site a single research paper which breaks the usual thoughts of other Indian economists. I never heard (I am may be mistaken) of telling anyone that Prof Chelliah was a great Indian reform team! Even when he was alive forget about now. 

I respect him a lot as a human being but I am unable to take any of his ideas/suggestions. Of course he was not outside of socialist economists as Mr Nayak writes “He wanted to employ the body of academic knowledge in the era of post-Keynesian macroeconomic”s. 

Further, Mr Nayak says quite unconvincingly that “The only thing that ever mattered was the academic merit of an individual, regardless of region, linguistic background, sex, religion or caste.”  I guess, he perhaps never heard of what one of greatest 20th century economists and economics Nobel laureate F A Hayek said “Differences in wealth, education, tradition, religion, language or race may today become the cause of differential treatment on the pretext of a pretended principle of social justice or of public necessity. Once such discrimination is recognised as legitimate, all the safeguards of individual freedom of the liberal tradition are gone”.

Thursday, April 9, 2009

Three tales to tango-Outliers- Tiger -Ideas

Well, we have just passed three months in the year 2009 and now the spring has come once again. Many are thinking how the “Green shoots of spring are all very appealing but will they really spread and grow into a solid recovery?” (Spring fever). 

I had good time to read books that was published in 2008. Two are from Indian authors one went to win The Man Booker Prize. 

Imagining India: Ideas for the New Century by Nandan M. Nilekani, and 

The White Tiger by Aravind Adiga 

Outliers by Malcolm Gladwell 

All three are well written with consciences.   

Nandan’s book is well searched and thought out book especially I enjoyed his lucid coverage of language issues in India. 

For me the Adiga book is a great history of Indian Economic Thought as he rightly emphasised the brutalism of the great Indian Socialist darkness India and emergence of lights. As Freakonomics author STEPHEN J. DUBNER says if your read White Tiger “you learn a great deal about modern India”. 

Gladwell’s book is a full of insights with paradise of imagination. It thrills me like when I traveled first time in plane from New Delhi to Srinagar for an international conference. 

DAVID BROOKS said in his review in NYT “It leads to resilience, the ability to persevere with an idea even when all the influences in the world say it can’t be done. A common story among entrepreneurs is that people told them they were too stupid to do something, and they set out to prove the jerks wrong.

It leads to creativity. Individuals who can focus attention have the ability to hold a subject or problem in their mind long enough to see it anew. 

Gladwell’s social determinism is a useful corrective to the Homo economicus view of human nature.”

All three has a significant common focus on ‘entrepreneurship’ which is a industry born with human intuition or ethics. 

I will shortly post my reviews. But first I wanted to post a serious of posts on The White Tiger as he has covered a great amount of The Great Indian Socialist Darkness.

Dr Subroto Roy on Dr Raja Chelliah

He writes with a dimmed mind by remembering his meeting with Dr Raja that “The institute he founded appears to consist mostly of a name and some buildings and a lot of wasteful bureaucratic public expenditure as is typical of the new Dilli Raj of recent decades.   I recall a heated discussion with two of his successors there in the late 1990s in which they somehow attempted to say they were beyond Government of India control and could do as they pleased (which they had in fact proceeded to do).  Neither could be said to have been familiar with Indian public finance data at the degree of precision necessary to grasp  the fiscal problems Dr Chelliah had warned against.  Like the Planning Commission and similar sets of public buildings, it is all mostly a waste;   Delhi’s “think tanks” have been largely incapable of any real thought.” 

In fact the same point was already raised by another economist Suman Bery, who is also head of NCAER.

Kushal Neta, Nirnayak Sarkaar (Determined Leader, Decisive Government)

Gujarat’s Chief Minister Narendra Modi says in a interview to Rediff “Dr Manmohan Singh has not even visited all the states in the five years of his prime ministership, while Advaniji is a leader who has, at some point in time, spent a night in our 400 districts.”

Why I hate mathematics and econometric economics?

As I posted here today about my dislike of mathematics and econometric economics some reader may think I am wrong and hey what hell you are talking about; each subject has its own course of relevant. Some specialize this or that. Some also confuses both by injecting a serious of models which can be understood by a few people etc. by creating a journal for that few people! 

Paul Krugman won the 2008 The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel. My base for hating the mathematics and econometric economics is from his article published at MIT. Whether one like or dislike economics as a subject his article is worth to read. 

Some excerpts: 

"Marshallian" style of economic discourse: "(1) Use mathematics as a shorthand language, rather than as an engine of inquiry. (2) Keep to them till you have done. (3) Translate into English. (4) Then illustrate by examples that are important in real life. (5) Burn the mathematics. (6) If you can't succeed in 4, burn 3."

"Economic doctrine ... is not a body of concrete truth, but an engine for the discovery of concrete truth ..." (quoted in Sills and Merton, p. 150).

How are students and colleagues supposed to learn how to use this engine if you burn the evidence of the engine at work?

Krugman’s version of Marshall's rules:

“(1) Figure out what you think about an issue, working back and forth among verbal intuition, evidence, and as much math as you need. (2) Stay with it till you are done. (3) Publish the intuition, the math, and the evidence - all three - in an economics journal. (4) But also try to find a way of expressing the idea without the formal apparatus. (5) If you can, publish that where it can do the world some good.

In short, two cheers for formalism - but reserve the third for sophisticated informality”.

“the point of their education is to learn methods, not answers. And publication in professional journals is or at least should be a form of education: it is how economists teach each other about their work.” 

In fact liberal economist F A Hayek who also received The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel jointly in 1974.   

Hayek said something like this: “economics is a method”.

Who will become next Finance Minister of India?

T C A has some list, but there are several brutal men in the list. See them: 

“Satish Chandra Mishra: Mayawati’s Brahmin mascot. If she becomes PM, she may want him as FM. The civil service will be pleased. Acceptable face to all Manuwadis. 

Sitaram Yechury: He could become FM if the Left plays a prominent part in the next government. Less harmful to business than his boss. Talks sense more often. Easily tameable by the civil servants. 

Amar Singh: If Mulayam Singh has his way in the Yadav-Dalit group of UP-Bihar, he could be a contender. Good at handling money and finance, and an excellent negotiator. 

H. D. Kumaraswamy: Former CM of Karnataka, Daddy Deve Gowda may want him as FM if he himself can’t become PM. 

Naveen Patnaik: He may need a job soon, and would be acceptable to all parties. Depends on whom he makes a deal with.”

Bubbles Warding off……….

Christopher Lingle has valid point “For its part, the Obama team increased the climate of uncertainty to stampede the general public into accepting the stimulus package and the mushrooming deficit. While successful entrepreneurs can deal with uncertainty from market conditions and even thrive with it, uncertainty created by politicians tends to stifle business activity. And so, fear-mongering and negative remarks about the economy to spook the electorate into supporting his spending plans have undermined overall confidence.”