Saturday, February 28, 2009

Right to property moves right direction!

There is a news in the TOI which state that:

  • “The Supreme Court on Friday issued notice to the Centre on a PIL, which said that the purpose for which right to property was relegated to a mere statutory right in the late 1970s is no longer relevant. 
  • The PIL seeking restoration of the right to property in the third chapter of the Constitution, which enumerates the fundamental rights enjoyed by every citizen, argued that it was made a statutory right in 1978 to abolish large land holdings with zamindars and rich and their distribution among landless peasants.  
  • Salve told a Bench comprising Chief Justice K G Balakrishnan and Justice P Sathasivam that the situation was grave and needed urgent remedial action. 
  • The Bench issued notice to the Union law ministry seeking its response to the PIL, which challenged the constitutional validity of the 44th Constitutional Amendment, 1978, on the ground that it was violative of the basic structure of the Constitution. 
  • The petition, filed through advocate Gopal Shankaranarayanan, stated that in the recent past acquisition of agricultural land depriving poor farmers of their only means of livelihood has given credence to the necessity for a fresh debate on making right to property as a fundamental right again. 
  • Though the 1978 constitutional amendment was to permit government to acquire land for public purpose without being dragged to courts by big zamindars, the alteration of the status of the right to property never intended to harm small landholders, the petition stated”. 

Friday, February 27, 2009

Coimbatore will overtake Kolkata.

LAVEESH BHANDARI who co-authored this report on West Bengal says “When every parameter shows a relative decline, when the malaise is overarching, when accounts of government-run firms are not completed for many decades (yes, decades!)”, 

See other post here

Because it has none in the informal sector

T. C. A. prescriptions for healing economy:

  • “What is truly extraordinary is that the one thing that the government, as the largest buyer of goods and services can and must do, it is not doing. That is to place orders for steel, cement, computers, software, trucks, cars — you name it. Just fill the order books, if necessary with a proviso for later delivery, and see how the mood changes.
  • It is puzzling why this simple solution can’t be implemented. Instead of all this grandstanding, all that the different ministries had and have to do is to just get on with buying whatever they were going to buy this year and next year”.

This kind thinking has already implemented in the six pay commission by embossing the informal sector where the majority of people dwells. 

Just is the growth rate of different sector in the Q3 (October-December) 2008-09. The manufacturing and agriculture and allied sectors were shown negative growth but the community, social, and personal services were shown as high as 17.3%! 

Of course, people who are in the formal sector will defiantly do “orders for steel, cement, computers, software, trucks, cars”…..etc.

JNU Professor Dipankar Gupta Illusion

Can the left locked JNU professor DIPANKAR GUPTA disprove West Bengal which he did so energetically in Gujarat?



William Easterly on Asia's growth

Professor William Easterly has good post in his blog Aid Watch

The Left symptoms are key diseases in West Bengal and in India

There is a news on new report by two Indian economists at Indicus Analytics which state that: 

  • “In the early 1960s, West Bengal was one of the more successful states in India. What happened since the 1960s. One answer is the Left Front government and its policies. Even in instances of central schemes like NREGA and RTI, the delivery mechanism is not there at all,” Mr Debroy said releasing the report. The Left has been claiming NREGA was an outcome of its pressure on the UPA. West Bengal’s per capita GDP was Rs 29,457 which made it 18th in the country, he said.  
  • In 2005-06, only 27.9% of West Bengal’s households had access to safe drinking water. In Maharashtra, this figure was 78.4% and in Tamil Nadu 84.2%. “In a state often called the intellectual capital of India, the school dropout rate was 78.03%... Only Bihar, Nagaland, Meghalaya and Sikkim fare worse,” it said.  
  • While for India, 10.1% of households were rich, 54% middle class and 35.9% poor, for West Bengal 5.6% were rich, 41% middle class and 53.4% poor. This time, the finger will have to point inwards. The report quoted NSS data to say that in 2004-05, 47.3% of Bengal’s poor had no subsidy card while 43.3% of non-poor had BPL or Antyodya Anna Yojana cards. “This doesn’t say much about a government that is supposed to work in the name of the poor,” the report said.  

Thursday, February 26, 2009

Crisis almost in all level

On 12 February 2009 Mr Shankar Acharya wrote a article in the Business Standard saying “In the field of financial economics I can think of no other Asian who combines serious policy experience with academic rigour so effectively”. Yes he praised Andrew Sheng who delivered Third K B Lall Memorial Lecture on “From Asian to Global Financial Crisis” at ICRIER in Delhi recently. 

The lecture has almost all usual citing and verbatim etc. at least   what was interesting to me was his concluding part as Sheng writes “The three key functions of financial sector are to protect property rights, reduce transaction costs and have high transparency. These are Western concepts that were not understood well within the Asian experience”.

see other post here

The more famous the expert, the less accurate his or her..........tended to be.

Fox once smelled my body as I was sleeping in our farming when I was a ten year boy. However I was terrible scared but we had a great dog named ‘Johnny’ to save me from that bad smell? But what is relevant today yes there is a point. 

Liking and disliking certain things become a kind of institution to act with time if one is mature to listen, learn and live with it. This comes to my mind when I was reading an interview which is more like bubble bust in expert thinking forget the processing of thinking. See below:   

First from Philip Tetlock interview

  • “Ironically, the more famous the expert, the less accurate his or her predictions tended to be. 
  • What makes some forecasters better than others?
  • The most important factor was not how much education or experience the experts had but how they thought. You know the famous line that [philosopher] Isaiah Berlin borrowed from a Greek poet, "The fox knows many things, but the hedgehog knows one big thing"? The better forecasters were like Berlin's foxes: self-critical, eclectic thinkers who were willing to update their beliefs when faced with contrary evidence, were doubtful of grand schemes and were rather modest about their predictive ability. The less successful forecasters were like hedgehogs: They tended to have one big, beautiful idea that they loved to stretch, sometimes to the breaking point. They tended to be articulate and very persuasive as to why their idea explained everything. The media often love hedgehogs.
  • How can we nonexperts test our own hunches?
  • Listen to yourself talk to yourself. If you're being swept away with enthusiasm for some particular course of action, take a deep breath and ask: Can I see anything wrong with this? And if you can't, start worrying; you are about to go over a cliff.”

Before this interview I was of course reading an another experts interview who is the only hero in Tamil Nadu perhaps in India with honest if the law  degree with which he attempts for making comments!

Just see one comment (though it was in 2005):

  • “So, the time is right but the person over there is wrong again. By wrong person, I mean Sonia Gandhi [Images], who is the real authority, the real power. So, there is a wrong person there. One can rest assured that it will be wrongly administrated. I will not welcome an Emergency if this government imposes it. But if a person like Vajpayee or Advani, real nationalists- not necessarily them but someone like them- does it at some point of time, I will welcome it. That's my present mood. I want to be honest when I give my opinion”. 

Who cannot wait for Higher Education?

“Democracies rarely address problems unless a full-blown crisis erupts; higher education is now in such a crisis and a young India urgently awaits. We cannot fail them”.

Governments often think and Plan for ‘Poor’ but it tax too much

At least folks now realised that they can not fool poor people anymore by taxing lavishly. See what Vijay Kelkar says: 

  • “Consumers pay the tax on final goods and services purchased. In terms of the national economic identity, therefore, a tax is levied on that part of value added which is consumed. Exports are “zero-rated’ as in competitive international markets you cannot export taxes!  
  • One of the most important factors adversely affecting our competitiveness is the present indirect tax system. 
  • High import tariffs, excises and turnover tax on domestic goods and services have enormous cascading effects, leading to a distorted structure of production, consumption and exports.
  • The existing tax system introduces myriad distortions which favour some goods and services at the expense of others. Manufacturing sector is so highly taxed that India is an outlier in terms of taxation”. 

The quality of the education is terrible in India

In the Globalpost Shailaja Neelakantan writes “India has become a philanthropist nation, rather than a poor supplicant looking for handouts”. 

And further she asks and it is relevant: 

  • “a few dissident voices have begun to ask why so much Indian money was being pumped into the U.S. higher education system when India's own is in far more desperate need of cash. "It is strange that they are not doing it in India," said Sam Pitroda, chairman of the National Knowledge Commission, an advisory body that is looking into higher education reform here”. 

 In fact it is true that:

  • “the Tata family has contributed a lot to Indian higher education. Several higher education institutions were started with the help of the Sir Dorabji Tata Trust that was established in 1932. The private, top-ranked Indian School of Business in southern India has also received generous contributions from Indians here and abroad. And the renowned Indian Institutes of Technology — the biggest beneficiaries — have received millions of dollars from their graduates living here and in the U.S., including from Nilekani.
  • But the impact of this philanthropy has been limited because it has directed funds to institutions that already operate at an elite level. Graduates like giving to the technology institutes because they have more autonomy than other public institutions in India, and therefore have more control — with more openness — over how donations are spent. Fundraising experts and some Indian donors who give to their American alma maters say prospective donors here believe that any money given to a typical public university in India would be frittered away — because the entire higher education system in India is poorly managed — or siphoned off by corrupt officials”.

Wednesday, February 25, 2009

49(O) No Vote moves

As today’s TOI editorial report that the “The Supreme Court has now decided that the right to cast a negative vote should be taken up by a five-judge constitution bench. While delivering a judgment on a PIL, a two-judge bench felt the matter was important enough to be heard by a constitution bench. This is welcome. 

The Election Commission has already given its support to the demand for a negative vote. It has asked for an amendment to existing laws to enable a voter to "reject all the candidates, if he chooses to do", while maintaining secrecy of the ballot. This would mean putting a `None of the above' option in electronic voting machines, which shouldn't be too difficult. Unsurprisingly, most political parties are against this move. But if the right to cast negative votes can shake up political parties and make them nominate better candidates, it would have served its purpose”. 

But it may be sad that the Delhi based Liberty Institute reject this move. In fact it feels this move will “plague our democratic system”. 

In fact in this case there is a NGO in Tamil Nadu whose single objective is “Oh Podu” (“cast the vote”).

Conversions have created resentment and social disharmony: Tamil Nadu and Andhra Pradesh top in foreign aid

If any one say that the “conversions have created resentment and social disharmony in their wake” in Indian society. Perhaps it is true in the case of Tamil Nadu and Andhra Pradesh. Take “the Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act (FCRA), available on the website of the Union Home Ministry. During 2005-06, Rs 7,877 crore was received by way of foreign donations to various NGOs, up from Rs 5,105 crore in 2003-04. Tamil Nadu (Rs 1,610 crore) and Andhra Pradesh (Rs 1,011 crore) were among the highest recipients. The highest foreign donors were Gospel Fellowship Trust USA (Rs 229 crore), Gospel for Asia (Rs 137 crore), Foundation Vincent E Ferrer, Spain (Rs 104.23 crores) and Christian Aid, UK (Rs 80.16 crores). The largest recipients were World Vision (Rs 256 crore), Caritas India (Rs 193 crore), Rural Development Trust Andhra Pradesh (Rs 127 crore), Churches Auxiliary for Social Action (Rs. 95.88 crores) and Gospel For Asia (Rs. 58.29 crore). The funds received by some of these organisations have trebled or quadrupled in just three years since the formation of the UPA Government. 

If the official Christian population in India is barely 3 per cent, why do Christian NGOs receive the largest share of foreign funds? From Christian organisations that are known to support evangelism in many Asian countries? 

In my travels in Karnataka, my home state, I have seen significant conversions to Christianity having taken place in recent years wherever World Vision and other foreign-funded NGOs started their charitable activities. Kannada newspapers in the past few weeks have carried graphic accounts of how proselytisation is packaged with charity, especially targeting vulnerable sections of society” (Sudheendra Kulkarni “Conversations with foreign-funded charity”). 

In fact is true that Tamil Nadu (5139) and Andhra Pradesh (4768) have highest number of “associations registered under the Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act, 1976”.

Glories Centre for Civil Society, New Delhi

If any one thing that the Delhi based liberal think tank achieved in its more than a decade old in the public policy it is the “five specific professions of the informal sector - barbers, cycle rickshaw pullers, dhaba owners, meat shop owners and vegetable vendors”. 

These sectors have not been reformed and there is no reason why it has not both officially and privately. In fact it is nonsense that the governments never gave thought but the often cited Constitution of India gives somehow fair role to ensure basic right to trade among people. 

Of course, one may ask what the whole private sector role in reforming these sectors? 

One answer may these sectors are very small no milliners or billionaires so no firefight. But that is not true. The same red tape “sims” is prevailing in these sector for long time. 

I have been time and again widely experienced (personal interaction while in works) with these sectors across cites in India-Chennai, Delhi, Indore, Chandigarh, etc.

World financial crisis: State vs Market

Whether any argument is true or not often economists and experts try to escape by claiming two routes one is blaming politicians and the other one is government institutional system. But it is like wounded people try to look for first-aid. Simply that is the situation of government institutions and the politicians around the world. Of course there are others who look at things in radical way. But how these wounded are managing their role in the debate is altogether different issue. It is almost a mess now in the debate of who created world financial crisis, and every one will agree it is the US but how it has created? Different pundits look at it in different way. Some are here:

Swaminathan S Anklesaria Aiyar says:

  • “Political measures to subsidise ownership and discourage renting have contributed to terrible lending and borrowing practices that caused the current crisis. Instead of reforming these, the Obama Plan provides billions to subsidise those same terrible practices”. 

Deepak Lal writes:

  • “Obama is planning to enlarge. Walker also warned that the crisis could not be solved by growing out of the problem, eliminating earmarks, wiping out fraud, ending the Iraq war or cutting defence expenditures, restraining discretionary spending or letting the Bush tax cuts expire (US, GAO-07-389T, p.18). These are the very policies that Obama is hoping will reverse exploding future deficits. With projected reductions in military spending, it seems likely that the US, like its Roman predecessor, will find it difficult to maintain the sinews of the forces that have held the global order together. With no obvious alternative to provide this global public good, I fear the ensuing erosion of the global order, which is so essential for the processes of globalization to work, is likely to be the most serious long-term consequence of the global financial crisis.” 

Importantly, Percy S Mistry pointed out more like argumentative:

  • “It is obvious that we are reposing too much faith in governments. Because we are convinced that markets have failed, we assume that talking heads know better. They don’t. They just talk louder. As a result of flawed government actions, what was a liquidity problem has now become a solvency crisis with secondary and tertiary effects. In 2007-08 the size of bank insolvency kept increasing as governments fumbled. It has exploded as government actions turned what started out as an American financial crisis into a global economic crisis. Government failure has converted what might have been a short recession into a long depression. The assumption that, when markets and banks fail, governments will automatically succeed, is wrong. Evidence suggests that governments have failed even more; because of the nature of political (and legislative approval) processes, bureaucracy, inefficiency, and compromised delivery that is endemic in governments, more than in the private sector! What’s the evidence?” 
  • In the current scenario the public choice theorist are seems to be balanced but Mr Mistry says it does not “The fantastic sums mounting in the black hole of bank balance sheets are resulting in wet diapers, and screams for triggering the nuclear option: i.e. nationalising global banks! This is advocated by Greenspan (who, with Bush Jr., is more responsible than bankers for the mess we are in), senior members of the US, UK and EU parliaments, as well as ‘public choice’ academics. Based on experience with nationalised banks around the world over time, and the UK’s experience since August 2007, that proposition is insane; even if it is advocated as temporary, for nursing the banking system through intensive care!”