Wednesday, January 22, 2014
Thursday, January 9, 2014
Professor Bhagwati's Poor Economics!
During the debate on Sen vs Bhagwati, I uttered to a friend that I am not big fan of Professor Bhagwati. I could not give him a good solid reference, but here goes:
For all those Indian liberals especially my generation I wanted to inform them what Prof.Bhagwati said about Prof B R Shenoy (1905-1978). While reviewing Shenoy's book (Indian economic policy, 1968) in the Economic Journal in 1969 (Vol. 79, No. 315 (Sep).
Prof Bhagwati said:
"his overall view of Indian economic policies is flawed seriously by his antipathy to planning per se"
Bhagwati also did not agree on Shenoy's criticism about foreign aid.
This is what Bhagwati said about Shenoy on foreign aid:
"his unfortunate tendency to condemn foreign aid (which he shrewdly sees as making the expansion of the public sector relatively more rapid and easy) for the wrong reasons."
Some people argues that Prof.Bhagwati might be too young and have changed his views about Shenoy in later years but that seems not very clear. When Bhagwati wrote the above lines, he was about 35 year old and was educated in England and USA. It seems to be that he was like any other typical persons who had views of mainstream economists.
For all those Indian liberals especially my generation I wanted to inform them what Prof.Bhagwati said about Prof B R Shenoy (1905-1978). While reviewing Shenoy's book (Indian economic policy, 1968) in the Economic Journal in 1969 (Vol. 79, No. 315 (Sep).
Prof Bhagwati said:
"his overall view of Indian economic policies is flawed seriously by his antipathy to planning per se"
Bhagwati also did not agree on Shenoy's criticism about foreign aid.
This is what Bhagwati said about Shenoy on foreign aid:
"his unfortunate tendency to condemn foreign aid (which he shrewdly sees as making the expansion of the public sector relatively more rapid and easy) for the wrong reasons."
Some people argues that Prof.Bhagwati might be too young and have changed his views about Shenoy in later years but that seems not very clear. When Bhagwati wrote the above lines, he was about 35 year old and was educated in England and USA. It seems to be that he was like any other typical persons who had views of mainstream economists.
What I wanted to say is that we should not forget
these facts while crediting for his good old ideas of advocating for globalization, liberalization, free trade
etc. Even he changes his views about Shenoy, it is still important for me to judge him his economic thoughts. We
know he was one of economic adviser to Indira Gandhi in the 60s. "Mrs.
Gandhi followed the advice of her economic advisers, including Bhagwati, and
devalued the currency, with all its attendant complications".
Another point is that while Bibek Debroy accuses Manmohan Singh for coining the
Garibi Hatao slogan for Indira Gandhi, why not for Bhagwati for his role in
devaluing the rupee in Indira Gandhi's government?
Wednesday, January 1, 2014
Happy New Year 2014
Dear Friends,
Wish you all a very happy new year.
Let's begin the journey in a new year. The day went extremely great and much more happier than I was in the early morning. Thanks to friends and fellow citizens of India and the world for making the day better.
The biggest good news for this year is the launch of THE NEW ECONOMIST, International Journal of Global Economists. This journal is published from Chennai. I have a small role in helping to make it and have also contributed two articles. One on higher education and other one on skilling youth in India. Hope this new venture grow more and more brings some concrete changes in the peoples mind about the missed ideas of all kinds economic, social and political etc.
The year 2014 is going to be as interesting as the year went in 2009, 2004, 1998 and so on. I am sure you got it. I am talking about the elections in April or May and the fate of the big beasts which have been crying like wolfs.
The year 2014 is unlikely to record the repeat of the NGOs big shows for public policy drama in the national capital, all in the name of social causes.
The year 2014 is going to be as unpredictable as in the past as far as the Indian economy is concerned. But the economists and analysts strive to make all kinds of predicts to make headline news. That become a norm now.
Here are some good reading on the opening account of first blog post in 2014.
Tuesday, December 31, 2013
Goodbye 2013
Thank you all for your kind support and being part of the Hayek Order blog.
I will try and post more and more blog posts often in 2014.
It’s time, to say
goodbye to the year 2013, as always, the year 2013 was both good and bad to me
both personally and professionally. But personally, the year was more bad than
good! Professionally it is actually other way around. Anyway, it’s ending
finally.
Wish you all happy new year, may the almighty and the nature give you a good health, peace and prosperity in new year.
I sincerely hope to do some good work in 2014. Some new and interesting assignments have already landed!
Looking at the prevailing politico economics of India at the moment, its really disturbing in many ways. The hardcore liberals are once again disintegrating themselves and moving apart to join other parties hands. And others are in silence as usual in the past. These are bad signal for youth in India who have seen the fruits of economic reforms and globalization etc. I will try my best and do good works in my own way.
Here are my major publications in
2013:
English articles
1.State, Democracy and Development:
Institutional Perspectives, Yojana Magazine (Web Exclusives), August, 2013
2. Aspirations of emerging giants,Pragati:
The Indian National Interest Review, June, 2013
3. History of Indian economic
thought: the forgotten subject, Pragati: The Indian National
Interest Review, March, 2013
Tamil Articles (on
National Food Security Act, Amartya Sen vs Bhagwati, free market economic
thoughts of B R Ambedkar, Manmohan Singh's UPA in line with Indire Gandhi
govt.):
Other unedited blog post articles at CPPR.
Monday, December 30, 2013
Year End Posts
Another year is ending and almost a last day is left. The year gone is filled with full of changes with all kinds including many negative change! And I liked them! But the understanding gone in to it is not measurable and only the future will tell me the really use of it in life and work.
Nevertheless here are some good reading, though nothing new is discovered. The fools piece on Reimagining India is really stupid one!
Nevertheless here are some good reading, though nothing new is discovered. The fools piece on Reimagining India is really stupid one!
Intractable, vulnerable and contestable by Subir Gokaran
The year of #outrage by Veena
India can win the gold game by S Gurumurthy
Why I’m not on social media by Akar Patel
Thursday, December 26, 2013
Thursday, December 12, 2013
Children of Reforms of INDIA
The current mood of Indian public is believed to be the focus of three letters: G-A-Y. and
elites of Delhi who in turn manipulate every thought, idea and design about India.....................?
Let's read something else!
How the children of reforms affect electoral politics
"...Indian politics is riddled with stupidity, dynastic succession, public corruption, insane populism, crude factionalism, blatant pandering, naked dishonesty, extreme selfishness, myopia and other repulsive features." More here.
Tuesday, December 10, 2013
Friday, December 6, 2013
The Lose of Africa's greatest Madipa-Nelson Mandela
Some good reading on the passing away of the greatest human being ever to see this disguised apartheid world. He once said “I consider myself neither morally nor legally obliged to obey laws made by a parliament in which I am not represented.”
Disguised apartheid is morally indefensible
The Universal deficit
Saturday, November 30, 2013
Monday, November 25, 2013
Thursday, November 21, 2013
Monday, November 18, 2013
Professor CNR Rao
Professor CNR Rao is rightly in news for right time and context. Here are some good articles on his role in science in India and the world.
Tribute to a master alchemist by R. A. MASHELKAR
Sunday, November 17, 2013
It's all about Sci-Spo-Ele-Pol
It's all about science and sports in India More than the election time politics.
I am very happy that Prof Rao spoke openly and we need more such outspoken persons in all field. I think we have enough in economics and politics.
There is a news item which says that:
I never liked the cricket. But it is very interesting to read Sachin Tendulkar's speech.
An interesting piece by good friend titled "Should Governments hand out civilian honors?"
A bit from Tavleen Singh's article in IE:
I am very happy that Prof Rao spoke openly and we need more such outspoken persons in all field. I think we have enough in economics and politics.
There is a news item which says that:
- Bharat Ratna awardee and eminent scientist CNR Rao today had an angry outburst as he called politicians "idiots" for giving them "so little".
- "....Why the hell these idiots these politicians have given so little for us. Inspite of that we scientists have done something," Rao said, losing his cool.
I never liked the cricket. But it is very interesting to read Sachin Tendulkar's speech.
An interesting piece by good friend titled "Should Governments hand out civilian honors?"
A bit from Tavleen Singh's article in IE:
- "A vision in which electricity and clean water will be basic rights and not favours from government. A vision in which poverty alleviation is given as much weight, in the formulation of economic policies, as creating a rich and prosperous India." More here.
Thursday, November 14, 2013
Must read
Respected pradhan mantriji by Jaithirth Rao
Origins of Pseudo Secularism in Nehru Patel Rift by Arvind Kumar
Not just a matter of rats by Chandra Bhan Prasad
An Appreciation of B R Shenoy, Economist by Sandeep Prakash
The spirit of the NPA by Ajay Shah
The divide that never was by Vidya
Congress beyond dynasty by Ramachandra Guha
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)