Tuesday, September 17, 2013

Laws of Indian languages

"In 1949 Dr BR Ambedkar had moved a constitutional amendment to make Sanskrit India’s official language replacing Hindi. Not only the leaders from Tamil Nadu supported the move but Mr Naziruddin Ahmed, a Muslim League member from West Bengal also signed it. It’s another story how Hindi finally got the status but the episode amplifies how leaders of a nascent, independent India thought about Sanskrit." More here.

"Say Vanakkam to Tamil and it will be instantly translated as a Vande Mataram to Mother India."

Monday, September 9, 2013

India-"genuine union"

"in Mahatma Gandhi we had our Lincoln; in B.R. Ambedkar, our King. Nehru made better speeches than either but, in hindsight, fell short in both political grandeur and moral stature.". Mre here.

"Our stupidity is entirely self-inflicted. Our state thinks of the poor as objects of charity, as if they have no agency of their own."

"Bharati’s Kuyil Paattu doesn’t offer lessons. It’s simply a remarkable illustration of the poet’s private voice."

Indian right-wing- "spectacularly self-defeating"

Dr.Anantha has very interesting article in the Mint on Indian liberals and their stand on right-wing arguments on public policy in India. 

While in the piece he quotes a very interesting para from a recent article by Dr.Mehta, before placing his arguments. That para is really worth to read, re-read and ponder. Here is that para:

  • “The problem with much of the right-of-centre economic discourse in India is threefold. First, it does not have much of a sense of history. Has any modern society evolved without robust welfare protection? … Second, the right was caught in its own bad faith. On one hand, it wanted to critique entitlements and rights per se, on the other hand, it wanted to embrace direct cash transfers as an alternative. So in the end its arguments against redistribution ended up sounding more like lawyerly bad faith than a principled position… The right has not managed to link its purely economic arguments with an effective moral framework. Third, there was a spectacularly self-defeating political language that smacked of elitism... It is cute to call the bill a vote security bill... But what are we saying in saying this? That politicians responding to what they think voters will go for is a bad thing? ... If the left can be accused of sometimes doing the poor harm in the name of speaking for them, the right can match it by its subtle show of contempt for the ordinary voter. The right will need to change its game considerably.”

A bit from Dr.Anantha's piece:
  • "India’s current finance minister, when he was in the Tamil Maanila Congress, used to write a column inThuglak, a Tamil political fortnightly, explaining market economics to Tamil readers. He ceased making the case for liberal economics long ago. Another reformer took the nom de plume Kautilya and used to educate the readers of the periodical India Today on liberal economics and pro-market policymaking. Now, in the UPA government, he helped shut down mining with his environment laws and now he threatens to stop the future of manufacturing in India with his land acquisition law."
On both the cases, I completely agree!

Friday, September 6, 2013

Professor Ronald Coase, passed away at 102

Dr.Ronald Coase, was perhaps the only economics professor who lived such a long years upto 102 rather its more than a 101 economics. He passed away on September 2, 2013. He won the Nobel Memorial Prize for Economics in the year 1991 for his work on "for his discovery and clarification of the significance of transaction costs and property rights for the institutional structure and functioning of the economy".

I am a long admirer of his work on property rights. Prof Coase was also admirer of Prof F A Hayek's idea of choices in currencies and against of monopoly legal tender. 

Read this paper titled "Other things equal: the so called coase theorem".

His very opening line of his Nobel lecture was very candid. He begun by saying:

  • "In my long life I have known some great economists but I have never counted myself among their number nor walked in their company. I have made no innovations in high theory. My contribution to economics has been to urge the inclusion in our analysis of features of the economic system so obvious that,..."

"in a 60-year career he wrote only about a dozen significant papers and used little or no mathematics, yet his impact on his discipline was profound."

Here are some obituaries links:

The life and legacy of Ronald Coase
Ronald Coase : 1910 – 2013
RONALD COASE AND THE MISUSE OF ECONOMICS

Nobelist Who Studied Corporations
Remembering Ronald Coase
Ronald Coase has died, but his individualist dogma is everywhere

Wednesday, September 4, 2013

New parrot and its feathers

I read almost everything possible about Professor Raghuram Rajan, the new RBI Governor in the Indian media of all kinds.

I have also followed his popular writings on Indian monetary system for about a decade. I strongly believe that he can do better job and further the reform process initiated by monetary stalwarts like Dr.C.Rangarajan during his period in the RBI.

When Prof Rajan came to India for joining in Indian government, there was news item which says "Raghuram Rajan fit in quite comfortably at the University of Chicago. Like other free-marketers, the Indian-born economist and professor at Chicago’s Booth School of Business was inspired by Friedrich Hayek, the Austrian thinker." More here.

An Indian economist said recently that "There is little doubt that however objective an economist may try to be, his ideology is shaped by his own experiences and environment. For example, Friedrich Hayek strongly believed that Keynesian monetary stimulus can only lead to “roaring inflation”.

A bit from his recent works:


"the idea of eliminating all testing, and offering all students a social pass is a disastrous idea"

"Why not stay with the devil you know…Of course, those who are truly disillusioned"

"Economic theory suggests governments in the periphery cannot control the real exchange rate by fixing the nominal rate."

"how much of God’s work he is doing goes awry"

More you can find his works from here.

Niranjan in Mint has very good reaction over Prof.Rajana's statement on taking over RBI today. The firstpost also has detail musing about his speech.

Monday, August 19, 2013

A Man with Words

I always loved to read and ponder the autobiography or biography of any person in this world. The most loved part of the (auto)biography is related to their early life in outside school as well as their failures in work life after becoming an adult.

Here is a one by Kalam himself from his new book.

So far, I read (auto)biography of Kalam, Rajaji, K.Kamaraj, Swami Sivananda, Gandhi, Vivekananda,Subramania Bharati etc.

Thursday, August 1, 2013

State, Democracy and Development

The following is a concluding para from my latest article published in the Yojana magazine in "Web Exclusives".
  • "One of the most enduring questions is what makes nations have more inclusive democracy. An evolved democracy tends to be truly inclusive, offering highest possible freedom in the three main elements of democracy: society, polity and economy. Therefore, more inclusiveness means more democracy and more freedom in the economy (private property right, free enterprises, less state control, freedom of contract etc.), society (individual freedom to associate, equal opportunity to all etc.) and polity (transparency in election, accountability from elected representatives etc.). Indeed, India had the opportunity to have all these three pillars when it became a Republic in 1950, but unfortunately the economic freedom was curtailed. Fortunately due to external compulsions, India has a better and freer economy since 1991, though much more is required. If India makes its political, social and economic pillars strong enough by granting them the highest freedom possible, the path to attaining a mature and highly evolved democracy would be short and smooth." 

Tuesday, July 30, 2013

Indian Economists and Economics

Dr.Ashok V Desai has written a great article on how some of the great economists studied, worked and made impact on Indian economics over the years. Every one who is interested in Indian economics should read the article.

Prof Panagariya has also given us very timely interview in IE, wherein he says very perceptively that "From the beginning, the Left has been pretty strong in India, intellectually. The kind of Right that exists in other parts of the world, like Thatcherite or Reaganite, doesn't even exist in our system. All of us are by that measure left-of-centre."