Friday, November 16, 2012

Media folly of all kinds

Prof Kishwar has done a great job in profoundly analyzing the facts about Gujarat's Chief Minister Modi's recent speech in the State of Himachal Pradesh. It is worth to ponder over the below paras.

  • "If Modi’s concern for reducing women’s drudgery is genuine, if he has actually delivered piped gas to seven lakh rural households and intends to cover all the rest, if every household in rural Gujarat is getting round the clock power supply, his frivolous remark against Sunanda Tharoor is not enough to damn him for being anti-women. Mere lip sympathy for women won’t do. I prefer politicians who care for women’s well-being in concrete ways.
  • No politician dare marginalise the life concerns of the mass of our women as systematically as large sections of our media do, with their disproportionate attention to glamour dolls, film stars and the doings of the fashionable elite. It is easier to call monstrous politicians to account than media monsters."

Meaning that 'public policy'

Prof Ila has a very interesting piece on the ultimate impact and true use of Aadhaar in India. Read NIPFP study finds large returns from Aadhaar project

The FTI Team has also announced huge prize for public policy competition. 

Back to Marx and banking in 21st century. Read "Marx would have been proud of bankers".


Thursday, November 15, 2012

Of that "New Liberal Centre"

Here are some interesting readings. Though, a new set of debate is seems to be underway, yet, from Ramchandra Guha.




By the way, do not forget to read the comments on the first two pieces by Guha. It is very entertaining.

Friday, November 9, 2012

True to M K Gandhi

"India’s history books in the past sixty years have been written by Marxists, and Gandhi’s views have been distorted to fit in with the Marxist agenda. These books suppress Gandhi’s views on Marxism and socialism and instead present a sanitized version of history with Gandhi merely as a hero to be worshiped before invoking the doctrine of socialism. Instead of deifying Gandhi as a Mahatma and blindly worshiping him, Indians would do well to objectively examine his works and understand his political views." More here.

Wednesday, November 7, 2012

Capitalism = Insights

From A N Shroff memorial lecture delivered by Arun Maira on 9th October, 2012.


"Revisiting the role of India’s Planning Commission

When I joined the Planning Commission as a Member in 2009, one of the tasks the Prime Minister assigned to me was to determine what role the Planning Commission should play in 21st century India. I asked Montek Ahluwalia, the Deputy Chairman of the Planning Commission to give me a list of 20 persons to whom I should ask this question. He gave me a list of 20 respected citizens of the country. Some of them had worked in Government in very senior positions, in the Reserve Bank, in Parliament, some even in the Planning Commission in the past. And several others were respected industrialists of the country.

I asked each of these 20 leaders the following questions:
  • Is the Planning Commission playing a useful role for the country?
  • If not, is there another role that the Planning Commission could play in India’s progress?

The answer to the first question was unanimous. The Planning Commission was no longer making a significant contribution to the progress of the country. The country had changed. It was more decentralized politically and administratively. The private sector was playing an increasingly large role. The Indian economy was more connected with the international economy. For all these reasons, five year plans and budgets made by some experts in Delhi, which had then to be implemented by people all over the country, was an outmoded idea. 

However everyone, including the industrialists, said that the dynamic nature of changes in India and outside required a strategic group that, like a radar, could sense the forces that were causing change to happen and that could provide governments in the center and in the states, and private industry too, with insights into the forces shaping the future.

A More than Perfect Storm

I will now give you a picture of the forces shaping our future. I will also explain their effects on institutions of democracy, capitalism and government. I will use two images for you to visualize these forces and their implications. One, an image of a storm. The other, an image of a globe in stress.

First the image of the storm. Many of you may recollect the ‘Perfect Storm’ that Sebastian Junger described in his book. Not two, but three storm systems converged in the North Atlantic. This was unprecedented. No ship had been designed for such conditions. And no captain had the skills to steer a ship in such a ‘perfect’ storm.

As the 21st century unfolds, there are four strong winds blowing across the world and converging to create a more than perfect storm which is challenging captains of business and government institutions that are not designed for these conditions.

Free Markets and Capitalism
The first strong wind is the idea of free markets and capitalism. This is not a new idea. Often attributed to Adam Smith, it has been around for at least 200 years."

Friday, November 2, 2012

Back to Normal!!

Friends thanks for bearing with me! I got married on 18th of last month. Hence, no post for long period. Not many things happening in India in terms of new good economic policy making. Anti-corruption movement wallas taking up self-stage for granted partly believing that the voters are their side or for that matter the funding parties.

Though, there were many interesting readings in the past two weeks. Here some of them.



IAC should go beyond corruption by Prof P V Indiresan




Thursday, October 11, 2012

"public sector as untouchable holy cows"

Professor Raghuraman Rajan says:

"State ownership in many areas no longer serves the public interest, and the only reason it continues is because it serves the many vested interests that benefit from the status quo – the public sector workers who have cushy undemanding safe jobs, the unions who enjoy the power, the occasional corrupt executive who rakes in bribes, and the minister who enjoys the patronage." Full speech is here.

Sunday, October 7, 2012

Some links

Last two days, I participated in the first Regional Conference on "Reforms for Citizen Centric Governance" held in Hyderabad. There are many new innovations taking place at State level in terms of improving the services delivery. 

Interesting readings:


Fasten your seatbelts by Nitin Pai




What Reform, Mr PM? by S Gurumurthy


Tuesday, October 2, 2012

MGR's Mango Man!

Indian economist MGR has written a wonderful piece. It is always interesting to ponder on the following paragraphs:
  • …the aam aadmi is not just the mango man who sells the delicious fruit but someone special that every political party in the country is concerned about and seeks to represent. I had to also mention that, ironically, while all political parties seek to represent him and profess to bleed for him, no one actually cares for him. Although most often he himself does not know that he is the centre of their universe and is a subject of representation, he is too confused to know what he really wants. Perhaps, he would like to be left alone, but every political party knows what is good for him and he has no business to seek anything else.
  • I am yet to find a politician who would want to raise more money from taxes. It is also hard to find a politician who would want to reduce expenditures. While in our private lives we all would like to save huge sums to bequeath wealth to our progeny, we do not care if the government borrows large amounts of money year after year and leaves a huge debt burden to the future generation. We do not realise that today’s borrowing is tomorrow’s taxes. Perhaps, most Indians do not know that every Indian today carries a debt burden of R46,000, which will have to be paid back by way of higher taxes in the next few years.
  • The only way to shore it up is to undertake reforms that will bring in more foreign investment. In addition, in the case of retail trade, lack of competition has led the neighbourhood shopkeeper charging at least what is printed as MRP, which, unfortunately, has no relationship with the cost of production. The only way to minimise exploitation is to increase competition. 
  • There is no alternative for the country but to reform, and reform can be painful. The past sins of controls will catch up to increase the travails of the aam aadmi. We still have a number of prices determined by government fiat and, as and when they are decontrolled, the prices will rise to haunt him. If you don’t allow the markets to determine the prices, you will create more problems. 

Wednesday, September 26, 2012

Shibboleths of Indian economic orthodoxy

This article gives a very good case study for how to do a make over.

Very interesting comment from new chief economic adviser. 

He says I'm not going to give any number because I don't think it's an useful exercise...While I was the IMF's chief economist, the one thing that we were always wrong on is projection of growth."

Monday, September 24, 2012

Line of trucks

As Gurucharan Das writes in India Grows At Night:

“Rajaji (C Rajagopalachari)…was the first to describe Nehru’s socialist economy as a ‘licence-permit-quota raj’ in the late 1950s. When a reporter suggested that corruption had increased because Indians, not the British, were ruling, Rajaji had quickly retorted that corruption was less a matter of culture and more about economic incentives. Socialist controls sent out the wrong signals to human beings on how to behave. Yes, culture mattered but culture would quickly change if the incentives changed.”

Bloomed vs Doomed


Shankar Aiyar rightly asks a serious of questions which needs to be pondered:

  • There was, however, no explanation on why the economy was in a crisis. The Prime Minister says an “unsustainable increase in government expenditure vis-a-vis government income” would lead to “steep rise in prices and loss of confidence in our economy” as indeed had happened in 1991. The question is did this happen overnight? How did we get here? And who let this happen? Was the writing on the wall in Greek? 
Razeen Sally on Asianeconomies and its need for “Limited government—a strong but small state that performs its core functions well—and free markets at home and free trade abroad: These are the ingredients for a new Asian century.”