- New socialism in Uttar Pradesh of India
- The world of Masanis: Minoo Masani, as we all know, began his political career with strong socialist leanings, only to abandon it in the wake of communist totalitarianism. He then became among the early champions of the Swatantra Party (India’s only true liberal party ever), opposing tooth and nail Jawaharlal Nehru’s socialist policies. He finally settled with the anti-Indira Gandhi post-Emergency coalition, only to be finally disillusioned with active politics. His personal life was no less troubled, spanning relationships with various women, which did not end with his third marriage (to Shakuntala, the author’s mother).
- A shoebox of ashes;
- "My father's role as the founder leader of Swatantra Party, India's first serious parliamentary Opposition, is well known; and it is ironical that our present Prime Minister Manmohan Singh acknowledges Minoo Masani as his main ideological inspiration, rather than Pandit Nehru," the London-based Zareer writes.
The Indira wave-Excerpted with permission from Penguin Books India from And All is Said: Memoir of a Home Divided by Zareer Masani
- Dangerous lies by Tavleen Singh: Ms Roy was among a handful of privileged Indians who inhabited a tiny oasis of prosperity in an ocean of desperate poverty. She taught aerobics at the Taj Palace in Delhi and made forgettable films with silly names. As one of the people in her aerobics class, I had opportunity to converse with Ms Roy often and remember her as being astoundingly apolitical. She appears to have developed her whole political philosophy after becoming a celebrated novelist (ex-novelist?) and has a very limited understanding of economic and political issues.
Sunday, April 8, 2012
Interesting readings
Labels:
Indian States,
Indira Gandhi,
Minoo Masani,
Socialism,
Swatantra Party
Up to, what I am
Due to frequent travel I could not post anything for almost eight days. On first of April I went to Daman and Diu via Mumbai for a conference. By road I went to Daman from Mumbai. The road was excellent.
On turning, a great offer has landed on my hand to participate in the book discussion at Sikkim Central University, Gangtok, Sikkim. After a while, I accepted the offer especially given the importance of the book which was planned to discuss. The book for which I was invited to discuss in the panel was The Concise Oxford Companion to Economics in India edited by Prof Kaushik Basu and Dr Annemie Maertens.
This book discussion was part of the Sikkim University's important event i.e. 3rd Spring Lecture on "Nehru's Vision of India" delivered by Prof Mushirul Hasan. Good or bad, I had the chance of meeting him earlier. In 2011, he had chaired a session in the Global Conclave for Young Scholars in India on Education organised by NUEPA New Delhi, where I had presented a research paper on technical and vocational education in British India between 1700-1947.
There were three people in my panel; me and one (assistant professor) each from the Delhi University and Sikkim University.
The visit to Gangtok for this book discussion was really interesting and I enjoyed fully. Perhaps I may rewrite my comments on the book into a brief article for Pragati.
On turning, a great offer has landed on my hand to participate in the book discussion at Sikkim Central University, Gangtok, Sikkim. After a while, I accepted the offer especially given the importance of the book which was planned to discuss. The book for which I was invited to discuss in the panel was The Concise Oxford Companion to Economics in India edited by Prof Kaushik Basu and Dr Annemie Maertens.
This book discussion was part of the Sikkim University's important event i.e. 3rd Spring Lecture on "Nehru's Vision of India" delivered by Prof Mushirul Hasan. Good or bad, I had the chance of meeting him earlier. In 2011, he had chaired a session in the Global Conclave for Young Scholars in India on Education organised by NUEPA New Delhi, where I had presented a research paper on technical and vocational education in British India between 1700-1947.
There were three people in my panel; me and one (assistant professor) each from the Delhi University and Sikkim University.
The visit to Gangtok for this book discussion was really interesting and I enjoyed fully. Perhaps I may rewrite my comments on the book into a brief article for Pragati.
Saturday, March 31, 2012
M K Gandhi, Patel and Modi Land
My recent visit was very fruitful. However, I could not come to a point to offer a sort of comments or observation here in this blog about the relationship between Gujarat Chief Minister Mr Narendra Modi and the clash among Hindu Muslim. But one thing is sure for the doing business in Gujarat the governance improvement is unbelievable.
Whatever may happened in the past whether it is a earthquake or clash between Muslims and Hindus in Gujarat. The story about the land of wealth creation is here to rule out. This wonderful essay about the raise of Gujarat Chief Minister Shri Narendra Modi Ji.
Here is anther old article about Mr Modi in The Atlantic.
Given the facts about the life of Mr Modi and his conviction at least I am not surprised to see this news "Mr. Modi was the third Gujarati to make it to the cover of the prestigious magazine after Mahatma Gandhi and Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel."
Whatever may happened in the past whether it is a earthquake or clash between Muslims and Hindus in Gujarat. The story about the land of wealth creation is here to rule out. This wonderful essay about the raise of Gujarat Chief Minister Shri Narendra Modi Ji.
Here is anther old article about Mr Modi in The Atlantic.
Given the facts about the life of Mr Modi and his conviction at least I am not surprised to see this news "Mr. Modi was the third Gujarati to make it to the cover of the prestigious magazine after Mahatma Gandhi and Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel."
Friday, March 30, 2012
Blogs that ******** for years
Increasingly i get a lot of request to suggest what I read in terms of blogs.
Here is my blog list:
1 Dr Dey-http://www.deeshaa.org/
2. Amit Varma-http://indiauncut.com/
3. Dr Ajay Shah-http://ajayshahblog. blogspot.com/
4. Rajesh Jain-http://emergic.org/
5. Gulzar -http://gulzar05.blogspot.com/
6 .Dr Anantha-http://tgs. nationalinterest.in/
7. Nitin-http://acorn. nationalinterest.in/
9. Dr Roy-http://independentindian. com/
11 Deepak-http://capitalmind.in/
12. Satya-http://prayatna.typepad. com/education/
13. sauvik-http://www. theantidoteblog.com/
14. Sanjeev-http://sabhlokcity. com/
transforming India Big Ideas for developed nation
The title of the post is a book by Dr Atanu Dey, a very aptly named one. It is very lucid way of looking at the complexity of economics of poor India. The entire book is freely available in pdf here. I had seen the earlier version of the book before the current print edition. Dr Dey has created a great website for the book to be more interactive and engaging.
Thursday, March 29, 2012
Squandered political capital
Interesting readings:
- Why I am quitting my job for earning wages under NREGA?
- Schooled into brands and brands into schooled
- Is it a reversion to command economy? Is it that you are reasserting the need for a socialist economy?
- Economist Lant Pritchett calls India a flailing state
- Ladies and gentlemen, it is time to place your bets
- Wizards economics
Tuesday, March 27, 2012
‘too many cooks spoil the broth’
BJP leader Jaswant Singh questions the ruling congress governments folly economic policies. It is worth taking note the below paragraphs:
- Is it a reversion to command economy? Is it that you are reasserting the need for a socialist economy? Are you placing the public sector banks back on the commanding heights of the economy? I am unable to discern that central purpose — not because I am deficient in understanding, but because I do hold that this very important document, which comes only once a year and is a statement of the fiscal policy of the government, is deficient in conveying what has happened and why has this happened.
- I personally feel there are far too many economists in this government. I believe that there are more economists infesting this government than any other government. Despite all these economists, all this is happening, raising a very serious question. You are surely familiar with the saying ‘too many cooks spoil the broth’. But, these ‘too many cooks’ are not simply ‘spoiling the broth’, Mr Finance Minister, they actually do not let the broth to be cooked. That is why, we suffer this deficiency.
This gentleman rightly point out that the:
- It is understandable that this government is following its socialist tendencies on spending, masked in the guise of 'coalition politics'. By not passing on actual prices into the economy - whether in power, oil and gas, coal (all energy), fertilisers, railways, etc -it is increasing the disequilibrium of this economy.
Prof Ila on With increased import duties on gold, we return to pre-liberalisation thinking
Sunday, March 25, 2012
Another vote motive
The imbecile is talking about striking balance of federalism in India. Why can't the Union Government better manage the national security first and leave all else to State Governments?
The DNA newspaper chief editor Mr Aditya says, rightly, that:
The DNA newspaper chief editor Mr Aditya says, rightly, that:
- "No governance means that citizens will be spared large social expenditures such as the farmers’ loan waiver or the proposed food security bill or other such plans which are basically meant to bribe a section of voters. No governance means that we will not suffer crony capitalism such as the gifting away of land or coal or gas or other natural resources to big industrialists in an opaque and suspect manner. No governance means less chance of a scam, now that everyone is breathing down the government’s neck, ready to whip out a draft CAG report when there’s a whiff of graft or pestering it for a Lokpal bill."
Saturday, March 24, 2012
Self-Talk at travel and land of M K Gandhi
If I was asked to go by sarker Airline I felt every time how I am going to manage the shoddy people who continues to behave "mai baab sarker" while serving the customer. This was greatly cooled by two beautiful kids (less than 6 year old) during my recent visit to Hyderabad. These kids were asking all kinds of nice questions.Another painstaking journey, yet again by sarkar airline today morning. Unlike my usual practice of self musing, I was not really musing myself on anything. In fact, I had forgotten the fact that I am coming after 6 years to the land of the great man who was born on this land and lifted the ignorance of world masses.
Quite surprisingly, how the time takes me to places where I have been put up today! I was not determined to write this blog from such a important place any time soon or my life time at all. Yes, I am writing this from the very place where the great Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi faced the trial of sedition in the Central Hall of the Government Circuit House at Ahmedabad on the 18th of March in 1922 under "section 124A of the Indian Penal Code" and and sentenced to six years' imprisonment. Read the full story from here. From today's context the relevant of sedition and need for reform.
Friday, March 23, 2012
Remember words of B R Ambedkar and M K Gandhi on 'Arms'
Great free market liberal economist B R Ambedkar said:
"To deny freedom of opportunity, to deny freedom to acquire knowledge, to deny the right to arms is a most cruel wrong. Its result to......... .and man."
- Communists pose the greatest threat to freedom and property rights. Communists also oppose the right to own arms which are necessary to defend oneself and one’s property.
- While Sri Lanka showed tremendous resolve and smashed the LTTE which described itself as a Marxist-Leninist outfit, Nepal meekly capitulated to the Maoists. In India, the Naxalite problem persists because home minister Chidambaram responds to bombings with warnings as though the Naxalites would tremble at the prospect of receiving a strongly worded letter of reprimand.
- Chidambaram also reveals remarkable political naiveté when he claims that poverty causes communist terrorism.
- Both the home ministry and the Election Commission display their incompetence by recognising the CPI(ML)-L as a political party despite the Naxalite group flouting the Representation of People’s Act.
- The constitution of the CPI(M) too uses inflammatory language and states its aim as “the establishment of the state of dictatorship of the proletariat.” It also calls for the recruitment of “militants” and prescribes a “revolutionary outlook” for its leadership.
- Carter and his Democratic Party actively interfere in global politics and lobby for the Marxist-Leninists in India, Nepal, Sri Lanka, East Timor and South Sudan, places where American churches collude with the communists. These communist terrorists can be defeated only by using arms.
- A few months back, the Madras High Court ruled that citizens had the right to use arms to defend themselves. This ruling should be welcomed as an armed populace will make India as peaceful as Switzerland which has a high rate of gun ownership. In an armed society, operations like the Mumbai terror attacks will last just a few minutes.
- Arms were easily accessible to Indians before the British disarmed the country. Even priests used firearms to protect temples.
- The people must once again arm themselves and remember Gandhi’s words on the ban on weapons, “Among the many misdeeds of the British rule in India, history will look upon the act of depriving a whole nation of arms, as the blackest.”
Planned chaos or planning for chaos
Indian Economist Bibek as I expected! says “I wish press releases by Planning Commission were better drafted." In fact, there is a lack of skill for drafting important communication with general public in India in public interest. See yourself the press release of PC, utterly...the very first para. This one was after damage.
Thursday, March 22, 2012
Blind spot is the real hurdle
From Saving India from the Keynesians by Shanmuganathan "Shan" Nagasundaram
- "While there would be impediments to implementation as cited above, the bigger stumbling block lies in the realization by the economic team as to why the above is the right thing to do. For a team that has paraded the NREGA as its flagship achievement, indulges in price controls as a way to manage inflation, has praised ministers for presenting socialistic budgets (for example, the railway budget, where passenger fares have not been revised for the last eight years and due to the burgeoning deficit, there has been a nominal increase in 2012), the intellectual blind spot is the real hurdle. With the repeated hyperbole in the mainstream media of Indian Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh being a "brilliant economist," and given that he has surrounded himself with advisers who are essentially welfare/Keynesian economists, salvation truly lies only within."
The scions of those dynasties
There is a consensus in academia both India and abroad about whether Nehru ruling was far more freer or his daughter's ruling as Prime Ministers of India. Most people agree that the former is factually correct and the later is incorrect. In fact, Indira's ruling ruined more than what it did for the country. The moot question I am underlining here is neither is true. Even learned people tend to make blind mistakes. I was told by several well known economists in India (whom I don't want name here) that until Nehru's period India was going on ''right path'', what they mean right path is only they knows how they define; but one thing clear to me when I discuss with them that these people simply are not aware of what Rajaji and others wrote about the kind of economic system we need in India and the long tradition of economic freedom. Half a century later we realized that we are ahead of terrible path!
With these words, let me quote to you from today's newspapers:
From ToI lead article: "Lecherous Kennedys. Dictatorial Nehru-Gandhis. Bushes on the warpath. We do not care. Let the dynasties live on. We will always give the next generation another chance." The wild game is here in this article is the India-US politics: Rahul Gandhi vs Mitt Romney
Bachi says something funny, yet cruel joke!. She says "Karl Marx may have had a considerably different take, but ever since UPA-1 decided to jettison the CPM, we have had to follow Groucho instead." Hold your breath! She goes to say "Welfare states know the dangers of poverty becoming a lifestyle choice. But when our politicians get into the act, it is more pernicious."
I do have a story may be slightly different from this one for my small writings.
Private school revolution in Bihar Perhaps I should mention what the spiritual guru Sri Sri Ravi Shankar said yesterday about government schools in India. He said "It's often seen that boys from government schools are into Naxalism and violence. Those from the private education system are not into these things. They move ahead with an ideal and teachers are responsible for it,"
Who said it is completely wrong to be "illiberal"
OK, let's ponder over this one para: "When we have carped a bit about the ethical wasteland our society seems to have become, we say “schools must teach values, that is the long-term solution”. It’s just another one of the kicks, which Shukla laconically observed."
With these words, let me quote to you from today's newspapers:
From ToI lead article: "Lecherous Kennedys. Dictatorial Nehru-Gandhis. Bushes on the warpath. We do not care. Let the dynasties live on. We will always give the next generation another chance." The wild game is here in this article is the India-US politics: Rahul Gandhi vs Mitt Romney
Bachi says something funny, yet cruel joke!. She says "Karl Marx may have had a considerably different take, but ever since UPA-1 decided to jettison the CPM, we have had to follow Groucho instead." Hold your breath! She goes to say "Welfare states know the dangers of poverty becoming a lifestyle choice. But when our politicians get into the act, it is more pernicious."
I do have a story may be slightly different from this one for my small writings.
Private school revolution in Bihar Perhaps I should mention what the spiritual guru Sri Sri Ravi Shankar said yesterday about government schools in India. He said "It's often seen that boys from government schools are into Naxalism and violence. Those from the private education system are not into these things. They move ahead with an ideal and teachers are responsible for it,"
Who said it is completely wrong to be "illiberal"
OK, let's ponder over this one para: "When we have carped a bit about the ethical wasteland our society seems to have become, we say “schools must teach values, that is the long-term solution”. It’s just another one of the kicks, which Shukla laconically observed."
Wednesday, March 21, 2012
Growth mania
Mostly today's Indian newspapers are talking about growth vs poverty.
While Indian Express expressed "Any public debate on poverty tends to blend reason and emotion." The ET says that economic growth helps in reducing poverty but interventionist scheme like NREGA is an important tool for that makes limited sense.
Prof Panagariya has a piece in ET which argues that Rajiv Gandhi had no political game of fame of his own in winning elections. All he used was the political game developed by his mother and grandfather.
Budgeted failure: The left people never try to see other side of the same coin as far as the freeing of gold import is concerned. Here is poor professor who argues for more restriction of gold import.
Liberal economist Dr Ashok V. Desai says: "The finance minister has chosen to tax gold. This in my view is stupid; gold is so easy to smuggle that taxing it will collect no revenue and revive gold smuggling."
Other readings
In India, History Literally Rots Away
India will be superpower
Writing on the wall
While Indian Express expressed "Any public debate on poverty tends to blend reason and emotion." The ET says that economic growth helps in reducing poverty but interventionist scheme like NREGA is an important tool for that makes limited sense.
Prof Panagariya has a piece in ET which argues that Rajiv Gandhi had no political game of fame of his own in winning elections. All he used was the political game developed by his mother and grandfather.
Budgeted failure: The left people never try to see other side of the same coin as far as the freeing of gold import is concerned. Here is poor professor who argues for more restriction of gold import.
Liberal economist Dr Ashok V. Desai says: "The finance minister has chosen to tax gold. This in my view is stupid; gold is so easy to smuggle that taxing it will collect no revenue and revive gold smuggling."
Other readings
In India, History Literally Rots Away
India will be superpower
Writing on the wall
Tuesday, March 20, 2012
Morning Readings
In today's Bare Talk column. Dr Ananth says that "On the international stage, the Group of 20 (G-20) is dead." And therefore the "only way the world can find a sustainable way to grow in future is to abandon the US intellectual framework that defined the post-World War II global economy. For that, the US economic and intellectual dominance have to be replaced with wisdom appropriate and relevant to developing nations with their own long civilizational histories. That, in turn, requires that developing nations stop fighting with one another, bury their differences and forge a durable alliance."
Instead of "who wants a federal front?" where is the "federal front"?
Many of you may not know, late Prof V K R V Rao's close relative is S L Rao. He says that:
Instead of "who wants a federal front?" where is the "federal front"?
Many of you may not know, late Prof V K R V Rao's close relative is S L Rao. He says that:
| "It is wrong to attribute the budget’s deficiencies only to coalition compulsions. The budget does do something right, especially on investment, but fails on many other fronts. It does not ensure growth or assure that inflation will remain under control. With general elections due in 2014, this is the last year that the United Progressive Alliance could take bold decisions. It has not taken them. This will ensure that the economy will be under stress and that the 2014 elections will be fought on economic grounds. And with a Congress that had let the country down badly on what was assumed to be its strength, namely economic management." |
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)