Wednesday, October 19, 2011

A line of thought

Ponder over this lines from Professor Mehta's article in the Indian Express:


"...The terms of the social contract have to be rewritten. Capitalism has to justify itself in terms of social gains, and democracy in terms of empowerment. But at the moment no one quite understands what all of this might mean."

A K Ramanujan essay

So, there is a huge wolf cry over the removal of a great essay by late great poet and professor A K Ramanujan.

The below are the original essays.

1 (extract) 2 (full essay)

Some links on controversial essay.

1, 2 3

Tuesday, October 18, 2011

From an article published on Oct 16, 2002 in FE

Full article is here.

  • It is indeed sad that most Indian economists still believe in the Keynesian analysis that recessions are caused by insufficiency of demand and that the solution is a fiscal stimulus. Indian economists — barring Brahmananda and perhaps Surjit Bhalla — are totally oblivious to the Austrian business cycle theory, best articulated by Hayek. According to Hayek, recessions are brought about by excess supply, which is brought about by overinvestment. Each boom contains the seeds of the subsequent recession and each recession, the seeds of the subsequent boom. Readers would do well to study the above-mentioned Economist special issue which succinctly explains the Hayekian analysis (pages 8-9).
  • Hayek argues that if central banks hold interest rates below the equilibrium rate (that is, the rate at which the supply of savings equals the demand for investment funds), credit and investment would rise too rapidly and there would be a shortage of savings. Cheap credit and inflated profit expectations cause overinvestment and malinvestment in the wrong kind of sectors. Eventually, the mismatch between savings and investment can be resolved only by a rise in interest rates, making some investments unprofitable. Excess capacity will reduce profits and lead to investment collapses, ushering in a recession. As excess capacity is cut, profits rise and investment eventually recovers.
  • According to this analysis, the only way to prevent the turn of the cycle is to inject more credit which becomes unsustainable. A recession is not only inevitable, but necessary to correct the imbalance between saving and investment. The Economist argues that recent business cycles in the US and Japan have typical Hayekian features. The right policy response is to raise interest rate well before the boom spins into a downturn. But if inflation is low, central banks are reluctant to raise interest rates and as the cost of capital is way below the expected return, there is a surge in credit and investment to unsustainable levels. It is overinvestment which causes the return on capital to decline. The Hayekian analysis would point to the repeated easing of interest rates to be wrong as it merely delays the correction of past excesses.
  • Sir John Hicks,as far back as 1966, argued that developing countries typically fit into the Hayekian overinvestment mode. A recession is necessary to work off an imbalance between too much investment and too little saving. The moral is that injecting created money and lowering interest rates only delays the cleansing process. The output losses would be much less if central banks prevent the boom from reaching unsustainable levels by a timely increase in interest rates when growth rate and investment goes into an unsustainable upswing. Monetary policy is most effective when it cools the overheating; it is totally impotent during the downturn of activity. Lowering interest rates would be ineffective and only delay the adjustment.

I too missed the great economist: Sudhir Jayantilal Mulji (1938-2005)


Few days ago I somehow got a link by reading through an article on Indian economy. I once really thought about the ideas or the way Mulji wrote this article which I posted here yesterday. That is a different story.

Later I read about this man who was so close to the Indian classical liberal community. But no one ever told me about this man in my interaction with any of the so called living Indian classical liberals, let alone we all learns from the genius of GOOGLE!!!

I keep telling my readers and friends who utter a word on Indian classical liberals that they (Indian classical liberals) do not believe in the words-unity in diversity.

Here is my bit of reading and knowing about this great man Mulji. I am sure you will enjoy reading his articles, it is really fun and he brings the tradition of history of Indian economic thoughts into the present day political economics that is what amazes me.

CCS President Dr Parth Shah wrote “I remember my last conversation with him about our first seminar on Austrian Economics that we are planning in late August. He was very keen to participate in it and debate the ideas with youngsters at the seminar. He reminded me several times during the conversation to make sure that he got his invite. I know the economics students at the Seminar would have benefited tremendously from his theoretical insights and extensive understanding of the real world. We all will miss it now.”

I had attended the Austrian Economics Seminar. I too missed this great man!

According to Shankar Acharya “During his early Bombay years, Sudhir also served as secretary to the Maharashtra wing of the Swatantra party, a responsibility quite consistent with his liberal, market-friendly views.”


Mulji on Kayek:

  • For as with (Friedrich A) Hayek and Kahn on policies of unemployment, wrong signals may lead to bad policies. The story is that during the period of sustained unemployment Kahn asked Hayek the question: "Is it your view that if I went out tomorrow and bought a new overcoat, it would increase unemployment?" Hayek: "Yes, but it would take a very long mathematical argument to explain why." Read full article here. See here at Mises blog whether Hayek said such a thing!!
Some beautiful tributes
  1. Sudhir Mulji-Keynesian columnist and businessman by Paul Levy
  2. Afull and varied life by Shankar Acharya
  3. CCS/Newspapers 

Mulji’s articles (many of his works is interesting, but never assume in one go that he was a lover of Keynes!! though his writings may appear).
  1. Revaluing the yuan
  2. Why deficit finance works
  3. Empowerment vs regulation
  4.  A Keynesian election
  5. Deficit-induced investment
  6. Inflows & exchange fluctuations
  7. From deficit to surplus
  8. Under-valuation or volatility?
  9. External reserves: A Keynesian angle
  10.  Has Keynesism failed? (response to Kaushik Das!!!)
  11. Has the euro failed?
  12. On functional finance (must read)
  13. Mid-term appraisal of the Plan
  14. Concepts of unemployment

 His views: 1, 

There are several other articles which I have not mentioned here.

Thursday, October 13, 2011

Eclipse-India, China and USA

Day before yesterday, I attended a Session on new book "Eclipse: Living in the Shadow of China’s Economic Dominance" by Arvind Subramanian. It was organised by CPR and you can see the panelists from here.


YOu know, an author talking means- always if and buts, so what then why not, how does that matter to India so on and on!


As always in the past, Montek did not read the book, despite that spoke for no less than a panelist!! nodded the Chair. The other co-panelist said he had read the book and made few remarks, yes you guess it is all if and buts!. 


The book is very slim. Swami had sort of reviewed this book in the Economic Times.


The full book is freely available here, though you cannot print it!!


Though, no connection, but read and think about it "One-Dollar Bribes for India Licenses Contribute to World's Deadliest Roads"

Economists rarely blame fellow-economists for the bad advice they gave.

Wednesday, October 12, 2011

IS not is Kambara!!

A few days ago was listing the All India Radio after very long time. It was news time. I hear one interesting thing which led me to write here. It is the interview of Mr Chandrashekhara Kambara who is according to Wikipedia:

In one of his interview he said:

  • Age has not hampered my creativity, be it poetry or plays. In fact, I am planning to write a satire on forest brigand late Veerappan, who wielded a lot of clout in the political world. Many Kannada newspapers have requested me to write columns. But I refused as I am someone who uses a lot of metaphors. Newspaper style is dull and does not suit my temperament which is why I have not accepted offers to write columns.

Hope some of you might have read free market economist Sauvik's article on Veerappan (Veerappan as respectable businessman).

I am really looking forward the satire on veerappan!!!

Beyond RED

Yesterday I read a new book called "Beyond RED an apostate on communism" by Kesavan Nair who was a practicing communist in the State of Kerala for long time.

This very slim book is not only thoroughly analyses and rejects all communists theory and practice but also shows through scientific analysis how the communists are DEAD against the very people.

The full book is available from here in the authors blog. The book was first published in the Malayalam language, however, the English version is as author says is rebirth of what is written originally in Malayalam.

This article reviews the English version of the book. It is enough to say that "P. Kesavan Nair closely analyses the nihility and blunders of Marxism through his book Marxism Communism".


It is a must read book. However there are few wrong notional analysis in the book, i consider it is the flop side of the book. 

Nobels-political prizes

The today's Indian Express editorial says:

  • The Nobel prizes, we are sure, incorporate political signals. The literature prize rewards political consciences: Dario Fo to the left, Mario Vargas Llosa to the right, Günter Grass to the centre. And, of course, Harold Pinter, the eternal dissident. Peace has been even more obvious: Pinter-like European disdain for George W. Bush was expressed though awarding political alternatives — Carter, Gore, Obama. The surest sign, perhaps, that economics is far from being a pure science is that its award, too, is invariably seen as political. Amartya Sen’s prize marked the move towards an inclusive development economics, and the rise of the Indian growth model. Edmund Phelps’ 2006 prize was seen as a warning to triumphalist free-marketeers; and Paul Krugman’s seemed to have obvious political overtones. So how should we judge this year’s award, to Christopher Sims of Princeton and Thomas Sargent of NYU?
And further
  • Although they unquestionably deserve the prize, the question remains: why now? As Europe teeters on the brink, has the Committee passed up the opportunity to make a statement about the solution?
  • It may well have not. Sargent’s most memorable paper is from 1981, on the futility of trying to control inflation through monetary policy. In today’s high-inflation times, as central banks worldwide struggle with their mandates, that’s hardly apolitical. And Sims’ work focused for years on trying to make sense of simple Keynesian models; he ended up concluding that it underestimated the links between fiscal and monetary policy, the degree to which they are inextricably twinned through the government’s budget constraint — precisely the error that has landed the European project in such trouble. That’s a relief: the prizes are not, after all, completely apolitical. They wouldn’t be as much fun if they were.

Monday, October 10, 2011

The Shala at Chennai!!

I had great experience in participating at the Shala event at Pune in this May.

What I liked about Shala event even more is the fact that the people talked about things at not easy things but important to understand them especially in today's dynamic political economy situations.

At Pune, I was given a great chance to speak on my research of digging into the free market ideas from our very founders of modern India. There is even more interesting ideas coming out soon from my research!!

The Takshashila Institution has just announced another Shala event in Chennai early next month.

Those of you are interested to participate in the event can register yourself. There is no fee charged for this event. In my view, The Takshashila Institution has many committed people for reforming the ills of systemic issues in our country.

Let's join together to make this event happen like our own!!

NG-means nuked gundas

Senior BJP leader says:


Ravish Tiwari: Your NDA government is held responsible by some for converting the Public Distribution System from universal to a targeted one. What is your stand on NREGA and schemes like targeted PDS?

I was the chairman of the Public Accounts Committee in this Parliament for a while and I examined NREGA. I found that NREGA is not a success story, it is a disaster story. It is simply a hand-out and not always to the deserving. A great deal of this money goes to the village sarpanch. NREGA is a criminal wastage of money.

Failure is again a thing

Dr. Atanu Dey argues in his Indian Express article that "The failure of the Indian education system must count as the Indian government’s greatest failure. Over 90 per cent of students drop out of school by the 12th grade; only 6 per cent go on to tertiary education, to cite just one dismal statistic. We have to understand that the failure is primarily due to flawed policies that the government has consistently imposed on the education sector. Aakash, like its predecessor, the “$10 laptop”, is just another distraction — but a very costly distraction."