Monday, October 10, 2011

Blinking links

Swapan Dasgupta: "Everyone loves a good poverty business" India except the poverty stricken on poor human being.
  • "It certainly didn’t need a familiarity with complex econometric models and either Keynes or Hayek to realize that the Planning Commission’s extrapolation from the Suresh Tendulkar method of poverty measurement was just another example of economists living in a make-believe wonderland. The wise men of Yojana Bhavan had once again demonstrated to the public’s satisfaction that after lies and damned lies comes statistics."
Gurcharan Das on, "Duty or revenge":
  • On a sweltering afternoon on September 29, 2011, principal district judge S. Kumarguru began to hand out sentences. There was a hushed silence in the packed courtroom in Dharmapuri, Tamil Nadu. He began at 3.30 pm but could not finish until 4.40 pm because he had to read aloud the names of 215 government officials. Among those convicted were 126 forest officials, 84 policemen and five revenue officials. Seventeen were convicted of rape and they were sentenced from seven to 17 years; others received from one to three years on counts of torture, unlawful restraint, looting and misuse of office. Had 54 of the accused not died in meantime, the sentencing would have taken longer.
  • Early on June 20, 1992, four teams of government officials descended on the adivasi hamlet of Vachathi, near Sathyamangalam forest, also home to the dreaded brigand Veerappan. They assembled the villagers beneath a neem tree and let loose a reign of terror as they searched for smuggled sandalwood. They picked up 18 teenage girls and dragged them into the forest, where they raped them repeatedly. They only brought them back at 9 pm.
  • Claiming a haul of sandalwood from the riverbed, the officials then put 133 villagers in jail. How does the human mind begin to cope with this soul-numbing news? My first reaction was horror at the rape of teenage girls by men in uniform. Second, was a feeling of relief and catharsis when punishment was meted out to powerful men. The third emotion was outrage at those who allowed the case to drag for 19 years. Then questions arose in my mind. How could this happen in the first place? And was this not as serious an act of corruption as the 2G scam? And why was the nation quiet?

Saturday, October 8, 2011

Education programm at The Takshashila Institution

Don’t count on it

Karl Marx’s malady

This news item in The Economics says that Steve Jobs realized that "Thomas Edison did a lot more to improve the world than Karl Marx and Neem Karoli Baba (the guru he was seeking, who died before they could meet) put together" 


I remember two things after reading this news item:


A recent interesting article "Marx to Market" by Peter Coy. The opening para of article is worth to ponder over:

  • Society generally moves on from its mistakes. Doctors no longer drain blood from patients. Aviators don’t try to fly by strapping wings to their arms. Nobody still thinks that slavery is a good idea. Karl Marx, though, appears to be an exception to the rule of live and learn. Marx’s most famous predictions failed; there has been no dictatorship of the proletariat, nor has the state withered away. His followers included some of the 20th century’s worst mass murderers: Lenin, Stalin, Mao, Pol Pot. Yet the gloomy, combative philosopher seems to find adherents in each new generation of tyrants and dreamers.
I strongly recommend to read the full article.

The other thing I remember is that in the great article "No History of Ideas, Please, We're Economists", Mark Blaug said:

  • “How can we possibly forget, or even pretend to forget, modern economics when we read Karl Marx? Why did the poor fellow try to attribute the value of the product to a single input, labor, without knowing anything about marginal productivity? One might well talk to a psychoanalyst about one’s childhood while pretending that amnesia occurred at puberty.”

Free market is good for dalits


Milind Kamble, chairman of Dalit India Chambers of Commerce and Industries said: 


  • Casteand capital can't coexist: "Capitalism dismantles rural societies and feudalism. Capitalism dismantles traditions and traditional cultures. Capitalism produces urban societies, democracy and modernity. India's caste system thrived and survived on agrarianism and traditional culture. Caste is losing its grip over dalits because India is industrializing, urbanizing and modernizing. Dalit capitalism will accelerate that process and will accord a human face to Indian capitalism. Caste and capital can't coexist. One has to give way to the other." 


Also read “Caste and the Market Economy” by Sauvik Chakraverti

  • “I suggest Dalit leaders get interested in the Economics of prosperity. We urban liberals dream not just of making India prosperous; we dream of making India obscenely rich.
  • The Dalits will gain enormously from open markets, economic freedom and urbanisation. As they claim, in their respective economic niches, a greater share of a rapidly growing pie, and as they mingle with caste anonymity in bustling metropolises, they will find the old caste equations disappearing.”


Chetan Bhagat writes:
  • “I have nothing against commercialisation of education. Commerce and business are a good thing. However, when it comes to education, it needs a sense of ethics and quality. Good people must be incentivised to open colleges. Say, by a simple policy fix like allowing private institutes to make a profit……………. These private colleges have played the role of providing students with a chance to earn a degree of their choice. There is nothing wrong in this. It fact, it is even good that the private sector is playing a role in educating our students.”

Wednesday, October 5, 2011

Blinking links


Gandhi was wrong, says London mayor



It is ironic to see comments like the one from no less than a person who attach with compassionate capitalist.

Yes I am talking about Mr Narayana Murthy. He said during a address recently that: 

"Thanks to the coaching classes today, the quality of students entering IITs has gone lower and lower." 
  

Tuesday, October 4, 2011

Economics of language

Jobs is no Edison!

Economics in the Next Ten Years?

From Economic Principles:

  • A young economist, or an economics journalist interested in what the young are working on, could do a lot worse than reading through, as I did the other day, 55 very short papers written by distinguished economists describing the large questions they think are likely to dominate the next generation of research in their respective fields.
  • They are among 252 papers by experts in various disciplines who responded to an invitation by the National Science Foundation’s Directorate for the Social, Behavioral and Economic Sciences  to describe “grand challenge questions” that transcend near-term funding cycles, questions which therefore might benefit from investment in infrastructure.

Reading history of Indian economics

Arvind Kumar & Arun Narendhranath have written a 7 part series of articles on Indian economic history covering a range of issues in the last sixty years.


A bit from the concluding part:

  • "The government must respect the rights of the people by getting off the fiat currency regime and allowing the unregulated use of any commodity including gold as the currency. In addition, it must shutter the Reserve Bank and stop interfering in the interest rate market. Such steps together with curbs on the fractional reserve banking system will lead to a stable economy with a stable currency."
I strongly recommend to read all the seven part articles from here. It is worth reading them and of course will have to ponder over a few issues/policy suggestions.

But never think that those ideas/suggestions are not from our our country!!

Monday, October 3, 2011

India's malinvestments

The below paragraphs are the concluding part of my friend G P Manish's argumentative article on India's three Plan periods.
  • "Most economists have concluded that the institution of planning in India increased the rate of growth of GDP and therefore led to a marked improvement in economic performance. However, the analysis here shows that despite the impressive growth rates of GDP and GDP per capita during this period, the planners’ efforts caused stagnation in the output of the two goods consumed by the masses—cotton cloth and food grain. The growth in availability per capita of both of these goods was far less than the growth rate of GDP per capita in this period. It follows, therefore, that the masses’ living standard did not improve significantly. Nor did it improve in the following period. The per capita availability of cotton cloth fell from 14.23 sq. meters per annum in 1970–71 to 14.05 sq. meters in 1980–81...."
  • The vast amount of resources invested in the heavy and basic industries were malinvested. A great deal of capital was invested in producing capital goods and industrial intermediate goods at home that could have been procured from abroad at much lower cost. The bulk of these goods proved to be uncompetitive on the world market. Furthermore, as predicted by the argument of the impossibility of economic calculation under central planning, the forced industrialization was characterized by economic irrationalities—phenomena that never would have occurred in a marketbased system with an operational profit-and-loss mechanism. Thus, many of the capital goods produced were either in excess of domestic requirements or could not be utilized because of the lack of adequate supplies of complementary production factors, and their designs marked them as inefficient and obsolete even by developingcountry standards. Most important, all of this investment in the economy’s “commanding heights” failed in its primary purpose of increasing the future output of consumer goods and agricultural commodities."

What Do Economists Contribute?

That is the introduction chapter from Daniel B. Klein in a beautifully collected articles of eminent economists.
In his own words:
  • "The essays gathered here speak of the choices economists make. Which subjects to write on, which premises to follow, which authorities to appeal to, which methods to use, which tones to assume, which audiences to address, which challenges to respond to, which social purposes to serve: all these choices are made each time an economist acts as an economist. Are economists today, in making their individual choices, led to promote ends of human betterment? Most of the present authors suspect that much choosing by economists is not for the better. 
  • Economists are quick to find flaws in markets, governments, and other institutions. Yet they rarely aim their flaw-finding at their own professional institutions (not publicly, anyway). In such matters, their public attitude is rather like their attitude toward their children: acceptance without critical examination. Some economists harbor doubts about normal professional practice and standards, doubts confined to private thought and discreet conversations. A few, such as Arjo Klamer, David Colander, Thomas Mayer, Deirdre McCloskey, and Lawrence Summers express their doubts publicly.
  • The impetus for the present volume stems from the belief that academic institutions are failing and that they take a dim view of certain research activities which do advance the sound practice of political economy. If so, economists might find that pressures to pursue academic work divert them from contributing to the art and science of political economy."

Idea of choices in currency-Ambedkar, Hayek and Ron Paul

Ron Paul on Hayek and Competition in Currency:


  • Hayek concluded “Denationalization of Money” by calling for what he termed “a Free Money Movement comparable to the Free Trade Movement of the 19th century.” He came to the view that the gold standard was not the solution, though it was “the only tolerably safe system” if the management of money were going to be the preserve of the government.


  • The Free Competition in Currency Act got an early hearing in Congress this month in the House Subcommittee on Monetary Policy. The hearing wasn’t widely attended, but there was testimony by the president of the Foundation for the Advancement of Monetary Education, Lawrence Parks, and by a professor at George Mason University, Lawrence White, who talked about how FedEx and UPS’s private competition with the Post Office has brought benefits to American consumers. He extended the analogy to money.


  • It’s too bad Hayek couldn’t have been at the hearings. He viewed the denationalization of money as the “cure” for “recurrent waves of depression and unemployment that have been represented as an inherent and deadly defect of capitalism.” In other words, as a cure for ills like the current crisis. How Hayek, who once called for a global debate on socialism versus capitalism, would have thrilled to the moment, pausing only for the occasional pinch of his favorite snuff.

Saturday, October 1, 2011

Wild dreams

Ok let me ask "what can we reasonably expect the level of our economic life to be a hundred years hence? What are the economic possibilities for our grandchildren?"


These are not my questions my dear!


Of course, I did not say this "in the long run, we are all dead", did I say this.


By this time you might have guessed the wild dreams of Lord Keynes!! Those questions were all asked by Lord Keynes in 1930s.


Yes Lord Keynes wrote a article in 1930 tattled "Economic Possibilities for Our Grandchildren"  


How does that matter in blog Hayek Order: of course it matters.


Note what Lord Keynes wrote in this essay:

  • "he commencement of the modern age was already known to man at the dawn of history. Language, fire, the same domestic animals which we have to-day, wheat, barley, the vine and the olive, the plough, the wheel, the oar, the sail, leather, linen and cloth, bricks and pots, gold and silver, copper, tin, and lead-and iron was added to the list before 1000 B.C.-banking, statecraft, mathematics, astronomy, and religion. There is no record of when we first possessed these things."

No State had helped to produce these things, yet they were spontaneous order or natural order like the Professor F A Hayek pioneered.


And further, he notes that:


"From the sixteenth century, with a cumulative crescendo after the eighteenth, the great age of science and technical inventions began, which since the beginning of the nineteenth century has been in full flood--coal, steam, electricity, petrol, steel, rubber, cotton, the chemical industries, automatic machinery and the methods of mass production, wireless, printing, Newton, Darwin, and Einstein, and thousands of other things and men too famous and familiar to catalogue."


And lastly.


"If economists could manage to get themselves thought of as humble, competent people, on a level with dentists, that would be splendid!"


From Hayek's own words:


" However reactionary in politics such figures as Coleridge, Bonald, De Maistre, Justus Möser, or Donoso Cortès may have been, they did show an understanding of the meaning of spontaneously grown institutions such as language, law, morals, and conventions that anticipated modern scientific approaches and from which the liberals might have profited. "

Proof does not matter in policy