Wednesday, September 28, 2011
Tuesday, September 27, 2011
Consultants for Courts in Jharkhand
There is a news which says;
"Jharkhand High Court has moved to appoint 24 professionally qualified court managers — armed with B-school degrees in management and IT systems — to reduce the tottering backlog of cases."
"Jharkhand High Court has moved to appoint 24 professionally qualified court managers — armed with B-school degrees in management and IT systems — to reduce the tottering backlog of cases."
Monday, September 26, 2011
CPI
Do you know, how Communist Party of India (CPI) lies?
Here is an example:
"Vajpayee’s NDA appointed a committee under Aditya Birla to recommend reforms in higher education in 2009"
Let me say what I heard about the writer of the above line-D Raja. He is my district in Tamil Nadu, in the north western part of the State. He was a middleman for disputes cases, yes all kinds of cases. Mostly he got huge money from farmers by playing middleman in doing all kinds of odd jobs between the high officials of district collector and the farmers.
Secondly, during my visit to Kolkata early this year in one of the function organised by some local group reportedly circulated some notices that under the 2G spectrum it was D. Raja who looted all that thousands of crorers and not the A Raja! Whatever may be the mistake, the story is aptly fitting.
Here is an example:
"Vajpayee’s NDA appointed a committee under Aditya Birla to recommend reforms in higher education in 2009"
Let me say what I heard about the writer of the above line-D Raja. He is my district in Tamil Nadu, in the north western part of the State. He was a middleman for disputes cases, yes all kinds of cases. Mostly he got huge money from farmers by playing middleman in doing all kinds of odd jobs between the high officials of district collector and the farmers.
Secondly, during my visit to Kolkata early this year in one of the function organised by some local group reportedly circulated some notices that under the 2G spectrum it was D. Raja who looted all that thousands of crorers and not the A Raja! Whatever may be the mistake, the story is aptly fitting.
Saturday, September 24, 2011
Property or Poverty
T N Ninan writes: "The poverty industry has its own rackets, and if public money is to really go to the poor, we need realistic definitions based on proper data."
Labels:
Indian Economy,
Poverty,
Private Property Rights,
T.N Ninan
Friday, September 23, 2011
Old mind
In this high-tech age. When so many things are in public domain to have better view on it. Many take escape root to be on wrong side. That is how it has been happening with the Planning Commission figure mentioned in its reply to the apex court in India.
To my surprise, I was on a discussion in telephonic-call from London!! I was trying to tell them what Sunil Jain has greatly pointed out in his column today in the FE. Finally, they-the London wallas could not get it!! and kept on and on asking how does that matter. Yes, it does matter a big way.
To my surprise, I was on a discussion in telephonic-call from London!! I was trying to tell them what Sunil Jain has greatly pointed out in his column today in the FE. Finally, they-the London wallas could not get it!! and kept on and on asking how does that matter. Yes, it does matter a big way.
Without the body
Sufferings are as universe as the happiness in the human life. It's not just that I discovered from the book "Does he know a mother's heart How suffering Refutes Religions" by Arun Shourie. But the fact that if any one try to understand his/her actions of at least past few years, one can surely get the answers nearly for the sufferings. but always questions remain questions.
Wednesday, September 21, 2011
Refuting the sufferings of gods child
“The secret to writing 26 books is to be unemployed from time to time,” quipped Arun Shourie, author, journalist, scholar and politician, releasing Does He Know a Mother’s Heart? - his 26th book."
It only sounds modest when Arun himself says" “I am not a creative writer. I am lawyer, and all my books are arguments for the prosecution, whether it is on Ambedkar or on suffering.”
I just received the copy of this book, was curious to read this book as I read his other book worshiping false god.
It only sounds modest when Arun himself says" “I am not a creative writer. I am lawyer, and all my books are arguments for the prosecution, whether it is on Ambedkar or on suffering.”
I just received the copy of this book, was curious to read this book as I read his other book worshiping false god.
Foolish governments, smart women
The title of this post is the beautiful chapter in the great slim book "India Unincorporated" by Professor R Vaidyanathan.
SOme blinking Links:
The another round of crisis is already underway either by the actions of Indian government or by the actions of other countries especially the USA and the EU. More here.
"Put the three together and you get the logical conclusion that the government’s heavy role in the sector has been only to distort pricing. Its involvement has neither resulted in energy availability for the consumer nor a friendly climate for investors"
SOme blinking Links:
The another round of crisis is already underway either by the actions of Indian government or by the actions of other countries especially the USA and the EU. More here.
"Put the three together and you get the logical conclusion that the government’s heavy role in the sector has been only to distort pricing. Its involvement has neither resulted in energy availability for the consumer nor a friendly climate for investors"
Monday, September 19, 2011
Reading Hayek
From Sylvia Nasar article here: Nasar, a former New York Times economics reporter and the author of “A Beautiful Mind,”
Reading Hayek
- En route to the Bretton Woods conference, on the Queen Mary, Keynes had lounged in his deck chair devouring, among other books, “The Road to Serfdom” -- written by Friedrich Hayek at Keynes’s old college in Cambridge.
- Although just 40, Hayek too was feeling his age, and was troubled by deafness and a sense of uselessness. His emigre status had shut him out of any active role in Britain’s fight against fascism.
- During World War I, he had been a corporal in the Austro- Hungarian army and, in the cold, dark, hungry years that followed, a university student in Vienna. A moderate socialist who was repelled by his family’s enthusiasm for German imperialism and anti-Semitism, Hayek grew disillusioned with central planning when he witnessed the new Austrian state and hyperinflation destroy the middle class’s faith in democracy.
- Keynes had been Hayek’s hero since “The Economic Consequences of the Peace” was published in German in 1920. But like many young men who seek immortality in economics, Hayek launched his career by attacking the reigning king, beginning when he was an impecunious graduate student on a Rockefeller fellowship at New York University. When he met the great man in person at a conference in London, in 1927, he picked a fight about interest rates. And when he started Vienna’s first economic forecasting institute, Hayek ridiculed the confidence of Keynes and Irving Fisher that the next recession, whenever it came, would be mild, thanks to managed money and the Federal Reserve. In February 1929, in his monthly forecast newsletter, he predicted instead that the American boom would result in a crash.
Great Depression Debate
- This strategy succeeded brilliantly, snagging Hayek an invitation to Beatrice and Sidney Webb’s London School of Economics, which a group of young Turks were itching to turn into a libertarian antipode of interventionist Cambridge, where Keynes’s disciples were. With Hayek on the LSE team, young economists everywhere followed the furious debate that ensued with the passion and partisanship of soccer fans.
- As the Depression deepened, Hayek held that it was “due to monetary mismanagement and state intervention operating in a milieu in which the essential strength of capitalism had already been sapped by war and by policy.” Overinvestment during the boom -- not underinvestment, as Keynes contended -- had produced the slump. Consequently, what was needed was “time to effect a permanent cure.”
- “The creation of artificial demand,” Hayek argued, would only lead to another burst of inflation and another downturn. Like most American economists -- as well as President Herbert Hooverand his political rival, Roosevelt -- Hayek opposed going off the gold standard, and favored spending cuts and tax increases to balance the budget. Give the economy time to heal.
- When “nature’s cure” failed to end the Great Depression, Hayek’s star hurtled to earth. As Beatrice Webb wrote in her diary of Hayek and his allies in 1936, “They and their credo are sidetracked, without influence or even relevance to the present state of the world.” According to Nicholas Wapshott’s new book about the Keynes-Hayek disagreement, Hayek was so discouraged that he essentially gave up economics and turned instead to philosophy.
Blinking links
school talk is often just an oblique way of hinting at pedigree
Basic knowledge of economics has become a prerequisite to enter any sector of the economy
"Last year I wrote, “... the seas east of Singapore hold the key to the lands west of the Indus.” I should have added that the rules made on the banks of the Yamuna hold the keys to those seas."
Basic knowledge of economics has become a prerequisite to enter any sector of the economy
"Last year I wrote, “... the seas east of Singapore hold the key to the lands west of the Indus.” I should have added that the rules made on the banks of the Yamuna hold the keys to those seas."
Sunday, September 18, 2011
Saturday, September 17, 2011
Amendments History of Private Property Right
I post here the full article for record:
Land acquisition and right to property by Sudhanshu Ranjan
"Right to property has seen various mutations, in effect, granting more powers to the State to acquire for ‘public purposes'
The issue of land acquisition by the State and the compensation paid to the owner has been a cause of turmoil in recent times. The problem, however, is not new. This is borne out by the repeated amendments that have been made to the ‘right to property'.
The proposed new law on land acquisition, which may be placed in Parliament soon, would virtually re-open the legal debate on the right to property, where the courts and Parliament have been at loggerheads.
The power of eminent domain — the legal capacity of the State to acquire the private property of individuals for public purposes— has been recognised as an essential attribute of a sovereign State.
The Supreme Court, however, held in Kameshwar Singh v. State of Bihar (1951) that though this power is recognised, Constitutional provisions define safeguards subject to which the right may be exercised. The State has, in turn, sought to spell out exceptions to the right to property from time to time. What we see today is a situation where eminent domain has been exercised on dubious grounds.
Statute changes
Article 31 of the Constitution made the right to property a fundamental right, which clearly stated that no person would be deprived of his property save by authority of law, and it would not be acquired save for a public purpose, and most crucially, it provided for the payment of adequate compensation.
Article 31 was amended six times before it was repealed. In its place there were a number of Constititional Amendments, essentially circumscribing the right to property.
The Fourth Amendment to the Constitution stated that acquisition of property cannot be challenged on grounds of adequacy of compensation. The six amendments to Article 31A were aimed at enhancing the power of the State.
The Fourth Amendment restated more precisely the power of the State for compulsory acquisition and requisition of private property, and distinguished it from cases where State caused “deprivation of property”. The Seventeenth Amendment further restricted the fundamental right to property. The concept of “estate” was expanded to overcome the Supreme Court's decisions and those of the Kerala High Court. Ryotwari estates were specifically included in Article 31A, even as the Supreme Court held in Karimbil Kunhikonam v. State of Kerala that ryotwari estates did not fall within the ambit of Article 31A. At the same time, the State was restrained from acquiring any self-cultivated land within the ceiling fixed by law till compensation not less than the market value was paid.
DIFFERING VIEWS
Many of these changes were placed under the Ninth Schedule, rendering them immune to judicial review.
The confrontation between the court and Parliament veered around the right to property. When the court persisted in its interpretation of the word “compensation”, Parliament substituted it with the word “amount” in the Constitution (Twenty-Fifth Amendment) Act, 1971. During Nehru's time, 17 amendments to the Constitution were effected.
The controversial ones were those which restricted judicial review in respect of the right to property.
The propertied class was worried and challenged the validity of those amendments on the grounds that they attacked the fundamental rights.
The issue was whether Parliament could use the power of amendment to deprive the people of fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution.
Article 13 (2) says that the State shall make no law that takes away or abridges the fundamental rights. The question is whether Constitutional amendments are “law” or not.
In a landmark judgement in 1967 the Supreme Court in I. C. Golaknath v. State of Punjab held that a Constitutional amendment effected under Article 368 was a “law” within the purview of Article 13(2). The case called into question the inclusion of the Punjab Security of Land Tenures Act, 1953, in the Ninth Schedule, the court observing that the First, Fourth and Seventeenth Amendments themselves were unconstitutional as they precluded judicial review of laws relating to property.
The inclusion of the Mysore Land Reforms Act (10 of 1962 as amended by Act 14 of 1965) was assailed on the same grounds.
A Constitution Bench of 11 judges heard it and the court decided by a majority of 6:5 that none of the fundamental rights could be taken away or even abridged.In 2007, the Supreme Court held that laws placed under the Ninth Schedule after April 1973 would be open to review.
Current context
The recent agitations of farmers against land acquisition and compensation stem from the fact that the State governments have been behaving like property dealers. In Uttar Pradesh, land acquired at the rate of Rs. 880 per square metre was sold to builders at the rate of Rs 4,800 and an additional Rs 2,600 was allegedly paid ‘below the table'. If farmers sell directly to builders they could have earned more.
The Land Acquisition Act, 1894, provides for taking private property for public purposes, the eminent domain principle. In 1984, this Act was amended radically, providing that compensation once announced by the government cannot be reduced as could be done under the 1894 Act, and that compensation is to be provided at projected market rate.
Besides, it provided for ‘solatium compensation' for psychological injury caused because of displacement.
Now, another Land Acquisition Bill is likely to introduced in the next session of Parliament.
A just formula of compensation has to be worked out, and the buyer must be forced to return the land to the seller if it is not developed within a reasonable time span."
(The author is a Senior TV journalist and columnist.) (This article was published on June 14, 2011 in The Business Line)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)