Wednesday, September 14, 2011

Government has never been central to out lfie

That is all.

Here is must read article published in today's Financial Express with many insights from Gurcharan Das.


Monday, September 12, 2011

No Big Surprise


Here is leading Dalit intellectual's criticism on my Ambedkar's article (Pdf). This is one criticism I have waited for long to kick off the lies and misunderstanding of Ambedkar's free market ideas. Of course, it was not big surprise to me.

In my view it is he who counts as completely misunderstood Dailt. It is the disgrace to the Dalit community. Of course, it is the disgrace to the writings of Dr Ambedkar who stood most of the time while analyzing economics outside the ideology of any particular.

Here I stop.

Rests you know, if you have some time, please go through the relevant literature available in the internet. 

Thursday, September 8, 2011

Men at work, Don’t disturb Economists!!


A veteran liberal politician Jaswant Singh wrote on Arun Shourie in the Indian Express-Financial Express which has published a collection views focusing last 20 years and next 20 years of Indian economy.

The following lines are greatest among I read on economists of this sunny world in policy making. Singh wrote:
  • The policy I took in the Finance Ministry was that we must put money in the hands of the citizen and give him the encouragement to save and also spend. I am extremely suspicious of economists. I toyed with the idea of putting up outside my office a placard saying ‘Men at work, economists please stay away’. My officers persuaded me not to. But I did persuade my colleagues in the Finance Ministry of getting out of the habit of saying no. We, I told them, are not a new version of Dr No made famous in a James Bond movie. Instead, we are in the business of improving the general mood of the country through our policies and actions. During my time, we worked out a resolution of the L&T issue from Grasim. The process worked beautifully. There were so many of those (p.23).
He is writing a book on our greatest liberal Rajaji, I can't wait for long!!!

Tuesday, September 6, 2011

New from the Takshashila


  1. September Issue of Pragati "Gandhi won't Return" (pdf)
  2. Demystifying India-China Trade Possibilities Should India sign a free-trade agreement with China? by V Anantha Nageswaran & Ritwick Ghosh, Policy Brief September 2011 (PDF)

'India's decentralized principalities have been merged into one bureaucratic morass'

Thanks to Sauvik! Excerpts from The Daily Bell article:


  • This is the conclusion to the article, and while it sounds reasonable, it seems to us that the assumptions on which the article is built are not necessarily accurate. For one thing, the article glosses over the fairly Draconian authoritarianism of the anti-corruption movement.
  • For another, the article assumes that the current Indian vitality is the result of inexorable cultural and entrepreneurial shift. We would argue this is entirely incorrect. India's resurgence is driven by central banking money printing and may not be seen as a natural expression of industry and society.
  • It is extremely important that the progress of the BRICS be placed in perspective. Brazil, China, India, even Russia, all have aggressive central banking policies. China and India, especially, have economies that are obviously being stimulated by excessive money printing. Both countries have a problem with price inflation as a result.
  • Progress built on printing money from nothing is ephemeral. In America and Europe, thanks to the debasement of money and the vast resources it grants (temporarily) to government, economies can seem quite healthy  one moment and then ill the next.
  • Money printing hollows out economies. It distorts business and job growth. It makes people feel wealthier than they are in reality. In both China and India, economic implosions will eventually take place. It cannot be otherwise, because central bank money stimulation inevitably leads to an exaggerated business cycle and subsequent busts.
  • For this fundamental reason in particular, the Wall Street Journal article is flawed. India has not necessarily experienced a resurgence of business and market creativity. It is simply going through the same cycle of monetary stimulation that the European PIGS and America went through recently.
  • Such monetary stimulation inevitably leaves behind ruined and fractured societies. In the case of India, the anti-corruption movement will likely make things worse, as it is in no way an expression of ancient Indian culture, which was decentralized and extraordinarily tolerant.
  • The India of today, based on reports having to do with the anti-corruption movement, would seem to be inheriting the worst parts of Western socioeconomic systems. India's decentralized principalities have been merged into one bureaucratic morass.
  • Money printing, in fact, is fooling the Indians into believing their economy is far stronger than it is – and also increasing the corruption of the bureaucracy. The anti-corruption movement is providing the Indian middle class with a simplistic approach to dealing with such problems.
  • The real issue of the way the West has organized Indian society from the top down, starting with central banking stimulation, are not being addressed. The solution is seen as one of authoritarianism rather than a reconfiguration of India's basic institutions.

Monday, September 5, 2011

Make sense

Shankkar Aiyar writes:

  • India is doubtless the home of paradoxes. It has arguably the largest number of banks and the lowest level of financial inclusion. The RBI informs us that there are 33 foreign banks, 21 private sector banks, seven new private sector banks, 20 nationalised banks, six banks of SBI and its associates…not to mention a host of cooperative institutions. And yet over 50 per cent of the households find themselves outside the formal banking and financial system, and 73 per cent of farmers have no access to formal credit. Is it then the claim of the government that new banks and indeed corporate houses will deliver what the existing pantheon of 80 banks and over 1,000 cooperative institutions are struggling to achieve?
  • The very obvious need is for more branches or access to banking services. If financial inclusion is the stated objective, why has the policy shut out public institutions like the Life Insurance Corporation and India Posts which have been clamouring for banking licences? Indeed, if there is one organisation which can deliver access, geographical reach and inclusion, it is the India Posts which has over 155,000 offices of which 1,39,000 are spread across rural India. Yet, India Post has been shut out of the process of expanding banking and delivering financial inclusion.
It makes sense to argue like this but the services delivery is terribly poor in post offices. I have experienced all kinds of non senses in vising post offices for years. Unless, the post office system takes help of technological development it cannot provide any kind of services with cost effective.

Demo-cursing!

From friend Nitin Pai's article published in the The Atlantic:

  • The mainstream political parties missed the plot entirely. The Indian National Congress-led United Progressive Alliance (UPA) coalition government, which first came to power in 2004, set back the process of economic liberalization, by stalling on economic reforms, ostensibly in the name of the "common man." This led to cronyism on the top -- the last decade saw the expansion of family-held conglomerates rather than the start-up successes of the '90s. It also led to rampant corruption in sectors of the economy that were untouched by reforms. The Congress and its allies purchased electoral mileage by introducing entitlements for the rural poor, but Middle India was too rich to be bought off and too poor to be sold to. The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), which demonstrated a reformist outlook when it led a coalition government at the turn of century, has since become loath to challenge the Congress party's economic idiom, even after this approach failed it in the 2009 elections.

Friday, September 2, 2011

Michhami Dukkadam to you all

 That is what Gujarat CM say's to all. "Michhami Dukkadam means i ask forgiveness for any hurt i may have caused you by thoughts, words or actions, knowingly or unknowingly."


What I liked very much from his article is the below lines:

  • When i was a student i really loved celebrating Teacher's Day. Students were given a chance to become teachers for a single day. We observed our teachers and their way of teaching. This chance observance gave us an insight into building our future lives. 
  • After becoming chief minister, i had two desires. I located some 25 of my childhood friends and called them to my house. The second strong desire i had was to call all my teachers to my home and show my love to them and acknowledge their contribution in shaping my life. I got that chance on November 17, 2005 during my book Kelave te Kelavani's release function, where i called all my teachers. I publicly bowed to them in deference for being my tutors once. On this function, a 90-year-old teacher of mine along with over 35 others gave me their blessings which deeply touched me. 

Thursday, September 1, 2011

My latest article in Yojana Magazine!

Here is my latest article (with my friend Saravanan) on 'Growth Trends in Service Sector in India' which has been published in the Yojana (Planning) magazine in the September Issue, 2011.

"Yojana is a monthly devoted to socio-economic issues and started its publication in 1957 with Mr. Khuswant Singh as its Chief Editor. The magazine is now published in 13 languages viz. English, Hindi, Urdu, Punjabi, Marathi, Gujarati, Bengali, Assamese, Telugu, Tamil, Kannada, Malayalam and Oriya."

Here is gist of the article. It has interesting analysis covering last sixty years growth trends of service sector. It also looks at the sub-sectors growth within service sector of India. One of the key findings is that Indian economy has moved (income wise) directly from agriculture to services sector rather then the usual textbook method or the way the developed world experienced like agricultural to industry (or manufacturing) and then to services oriented economy. This is something that many people take no notice or ignores without understanding the structural changes that has taken place.