Tuesday, May 31, 2011

We want to pay them!!

Rapping Economics: Keynes vs Hayek


From Financial Express editorial: 
  • It’s unsurprising that What’s the Difference, a classic from legend of rap Dr Dre’s The Chronic 2001, has well over 2 million YouTube hits. Rap is big, and Dr Dre’s is the sort of rap we all expect. But 2.3 million hits for EconStories.tv, with its rap battle between JM Keynes and FA Hayek! No, the biggest economic influences of the 20th century haven’t come back to life to test themselves against Eminem. 

  • Despite the videos’ Hayekian bias, given the creators’ Austrian views, the videos portray the work of both theorists accurately. Whilst the first looks at their analysis of what causes the boom and bust cycle (Hayek: blame low interest rates; Keynes: Nahhh, it’s the animal spirits), the second examines their purported philosophical underpinnings in the context of continued global economic sluggishness. A testament to the power of creativity in spreading understanding, it is a shame that the Aadhaar enrolment drive in Punjab, as reported in Indian Express recently, wasn’t able to use its creative plans to spread word of the enrolment drive, as EconStories could with economic theory. It is a valuable lesson for us all to learn: capturing imagination is the key to learning and understanding.

Dalits affairs on capitalism

Here is my piece in today’s Wall Street Journal (Asia) which argues for the free market ideas of B.R.Ambedkar. It also talks about his views on English, urbanization etc.

Monday, May 30, 2011

“You don't want the IAS running the country. At the end of the day we want politicians to run this country.”


The Rediff interviewed Prof.Mehta some time back in two parts. If you have not read it, I would urge you to do now!! First Part and Second Part.     

He said: 
  • “Now you have the National Advisory Council on one track and the finance ministry on another track; the planning commission is on a different route and the Prime Minister's Office is on another track.”


Saturday, May 28, 2011

Cash them out!!

Guy has great piece explaining the truth about the cash transfer to abject poor, read its interseting. He also rejects Jean Dreze's argument. 

Friday, May 27, 2011

Talk at SHALA!!


The SHALA is almost near!! 

See the scheduled speakers list from here!

Please do watch live webcast of the event!!

Check out the speakers timing here. 

Bastard Ambedkarites!!

Mind you, that is not my words!

Please see here!! for understanding WHY DALIT MOVEMENT   FAILED IN INDIA?


Thursday, May 26, 2011

"Ambedkar is one of our key antidotes."


Mr.Bal has very interesting article on “The Absence of Ambedkar”, in which he writes: 
  • This is no surprise, while there is widespread public admiration for Ambedkar in India, there is little or no appreciation of his ideas.  Even the public admiration is quite often a façade, with the caste elite in India reserving their contempt for the privacy of their homes much as they would their anti-Muslim sentiments. As a result of a few government presses and new publishers such as Navayana, Ambedkar’s own writings are now accessible to those willing to make the effort but we are still far from a good biography of the man or a critical engagement with his ideas. 

  • Ambedkar matters at least as much as Jawaharlal Nehru, and far more than Gandhi, in understanding contemporary India.


Wednesday, May 25, 2011

Make market forces work


From the article “Leave It To The Market” by Dilip Modi
  • However, the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, gives sweeping legal powers to the government or its authorised agencies to acquire almost any private land or property provided such acquisition is for "public purpose". Invariably this route is adopted. This is also known as 'eminent domain', regarded as an inherent right of the state to take private property for public use. It is legal in many countries, including the US, UK and France. 
  • The problem lies in interpretation of the term "public purpose". Unfortunately the Act does not define the term. So interpretation was left to the courts. The Supreme Court in 1971 took a very wide view of the term in the case Jage Ram vs the State of Haryana. Yet it did not provide any definition and left it to the state governments to define and thus (mis)interpret the term. Strangely the judgment was delivered when 'right to private property' was still a fundamental right. Subsequent apex court judgments further widened the scope of interpretation. 
  • The economics behind eminent domain and thus the interpretation of the term public purpose assume that the state would always act in the public interest and, therefore, any taking of private property would be to provide certain "public goods" that otherwise would not be provided by the markets. 
  • Lighthouses or clean air are typical examples. One or several ships can use the light at the same moment. Yet no single ship owner would build the lighthouse. The government needs to build it - in other words, provide public goods as the market will not provide them automatically. 
  • This clearly implies the Act's provisions should only be used when the government itself is to provide infrastructure facilities (public good). They should not be used for land acquisition for private investments, whatever the benefits. For such transactions, the market must play out. The government should not undermine market processes. 

Tuesday, May 24, 2011

‘The ideal way to bridge the skill gap is to privatise the education system’

Prowess of ancient (south)India

Monday, May 23, 2011

What a tribute to UPA Government!!


 Please give no judgment after reading the below article/argument!! 

Silly names like politburo or (No)useful ginger group

The communist turned economist Mr.Meghnad Desai writes: 
  • The general-secretary can do no wrong. Nor does he ever resign; in the USSR, purge was the only way out but never resignation.

This is true in case of Mr.Prakash Karat who is a General Secretary of the Communist Party of India (Marxist). Under his leadership, he ensured one GOOD thing for our country is to simply sink his party in all the electoral battle contested. Who can do such as nice thing to us!

Mr.Desai further said: 
  • Communist parties do not allow free and open democratic debate about their failings. They use words like ‘rectification’ which ordinary mortals never do. The very word implies its opposite. 
  • The basic problem is an understanding of how capitalism works. Leninism was predicated on the bet that capitalism is in a terminal crisis and will collapse before long. Instead, the Leninist State in the USSR collapsed before capitalism did. The fact that capitalism has its ups and downs, that it fosters inequality and that it creates insecurity, is all true. But the cure is not to wait for its demise even by giving a push but to see how it can be regulated and cured. Each generation has to face the task anew since capitalism is capable of immense innovation and change. Even poor people like the casino aspect of capitalism because that is better than regimented poverty which is what Communism offered them. 
  • The Left in India needs a wide and open debate. They have a lot of sympathisers who can help. I recall that in the 1950s, the Communist party used to be in the vanguard in critiquing old and outdated religious superstitions……..What we have is a repetition of old anti-colonial, anti-imperialistic rhetoric with no new economic thought.
I actually wrote the title of this post as "there is nothing called democratic in communism!".

Saturday, May 21, 2011

Growing restrictions on personal liberty and increase in state power


Prof.Deepak Lal writes:

  • In dealing with the undeniable state-sponsored Pakistani terrorism in India, a similar policy is relevant. The only long-term solution is to change the Pakistan army’s calculus that it can succeed in destroying India (or its economy) through its jihadi agents. As this tiger it has unleashed, increasingly turns( as it has) against its sponsors, and the growing distance between its citizens in a stagnant and those in the booming Indian economy becomes apparent to its people (as is happening), the ‘rent seeking’ soldiers might at last realise that it is in their interests to complete the deal, which Musharaff nearly completed with Dr Manmohan Singh. Meanwhile, intelligence remains vital in apprehending and forestalling ISI-sponsored terrorists. But this is not done through heavy handed suppression of civil liberties. When,with information from Western intelligence agencies, about the co-ordinates of suspicious boats moving to Bombay, along with mobile numbers of some terrorists, Indian intelligence failed to forestall the 26/11 attacks, it is absurd to believe that they can forestall future terrorist plots by preventing my 70-year-old American wife from coming back to India, a month after she had left our New Delhi home.