Thursday, April 14, 2011

My speech at Mises Institute (March 12th, 2011)

The following is the speech prepared for my paper presentation but I could not present in this order but certainly the whole presentation is based on these aspects.


Let me begin by thanking Mises Institute for giving me this great opportunity to present my paper in the Austrian Scholars Conference 2011.

I would also like to thank people who have not only constantly encouraged me along and but also helped in getting financial support for my trip.

I would like to name at least three of them:

Mr. Nitin Pai, who is a Founder of the Takshashila Institution and Editor of Pragati—The Indian National Interest Review. A emerging independent free market think tank in India

Dr.Atanu Dey who is a libertarian economist and he blog at Deeshaa.org

Last but not lest, Dr.Parth J Shah who is a Founder, President of Centre for Civil Society, New Delhi, India

I would also like to mention that the only economist who writes about the Austrian Economics in India in the letter and spirit of Mises is Sauvik Chakraverti!!!

In August of 2005 Dr.Parth Shah had organized an Austrian Economics Seminar in New Delhi, India

I was thrilled to know what is all about Austrian Economics and what is interesting to me in it and who were the Austrian economists in India?

Before that I knew very little about Austrian Economics from the F A Hayek’s Book The Road to Serfdom. Essentially it was a quote in a Statistics Textbook by a Bengali author from this book.

It was during this time I was also doing my Master of Philosophy degree in social sciences in the Institution named after Ambedkar at Mhow in Western India.

Also in my whole class of 30 students none of them had interest in studying the Ambedkar’s works in economics. So I ended up doing something on Special Economic Zones.

So who is Ambedkar?

He was 14th child to his parents. He father was in army in the East India Company.

Ambedkar came to America almost close to 100 years (99) before me to study for his Masters and PhD in Economics from Columbia University.

Ambedkar was fortunate to get a scholarship to study in America. After that he went to England to receive D.Sc in Economics from LSE and a Law Degree from London University.

He later become the First Minister of Law after Independence in the Nehru’ Cabinet. Though he did ask for Ministry of Planning!! But he was denied!!

So what he is known for now and not so known for?


Ambedkar is now widely known for



-As a Father of Indian Constitution
-As a icon of certain community (dalit)
-As a First Law Minister in the Independent Indian Government  
-His hard argument with M.K Gandhi
-His conversion to Buddhism

Misunderstood views of Ambedkar on


-Socialism,
-Marxism
-Centralized planning
-Against too much bureaucracy
-on establishment of Reserve Bank of India (RBI)

Ambedkar’s neglected thoughts

-Free banking
-Gold standard
-Individual liberty and freedom
-His argument against Keynes views on gold exchange standard
-His understanding of Carl Menger’s works
-Knowledge problem/Decentralized planning

Ambedkar, the forgotten free-market economis


Finally, my article has been out now, let’s clear all the myths about Ambedkar being portraying as against free market economics and soul believer of socialism etc.

Please find my article on Ambedkar A champion of the free market in the April 2011 Issue of Pragati The Indian National Interest Review.

I request all of you should see the PDF version of the full issue of Pragati (PDF).

I take this opportunity to thank all my friends and supporters for making my full paper presentation at the Austrian Scholars Conference 2011 organised by the Mises Institute, Auburn, USA

Particularly, I would like to thank Mr.Nitin Pai, Dr.Atanu Dey (Please do see 1, 2, and 3), and Dr.Parth J Shah. 

Monday, April 11, 2011

Profitable Education


Mr.Manish Sabarwal of Teamlease Services writes: 
  • Rabindranath Tagore has a wonderful story called Kartar Bhooth where the perceived static wishes of a dead leader make life difficult and kill innovation. The ghost of non-profit in education has similar consequences: 90% of education capacity created since 1991 has been for-profit but in the guise of non-profit because of legislation. This regulatory cholesterol reduces the ability of professionals like teachers to attract third-party capital for entrepreneurship. 
  • More dangerously, it rewards regulatory arbitrage abilities and, consequently, most education entrepreneurs today are land mafia, criminals or politicians. This low-quality private sector capacity creation becomes a self-reinforcing argument against legitimising a professionally-managed, well-regulated and quality-minded for-profit private sector. But the most expensive school is no school and the primary case for private sector is not quality but capacity and cost. We should not care whether a school is government, not-for-profit, not-for-loss, for-less profit or for-profit. All that matters is a good school or a bad school. Let biodiversity explode. 

Prices and costs cuts by that polity lines


Agricultural scientist M S Swaminathan told in his interview with BS soon after the budget and the appointment of new chairman if CACP:

The new chairman of Commission for Agriculture Costs and Prices Ashok Gulati is a non-bureaucrat too. But his views contradict yours. He favours markets driving farmers’ incomes, while you say farmers should be given a 50 per cent profit and cost of production as a minimum support price.

Gulati’s appointment is as grave an error of judgement on the part of the government as the appointment of the CVC. It does not bode well for agriculture and, more so, for farmers. The pro-US interests have the upper hand in the government and the pity is that they don’t understand the human aspect of agriculture.

Faith in capitalism



Which countries are most in favour of the free market?

FAITH in the free market is at a low in the world's biggest free-market economy. In 2010, 59% of Americans asked by GlobeScan, a polling firm, agreed "strongly" or "somewhat" that the free market was the best system for the world's future. This has fallen sharply from 80% when the question was first asked in 2002. And among poorer Americans under $20,000, faith in capitalism fell from 76% to 44% in just one year. Of the 25 countries polled, support for the free market is now greatest in Germany, just ahead of Brazil and communist China, both of which have seen strong growth in recent years. Indians are less enthusiastic despite recent gains in growth. Italy shows a surprising fondness for markets for a place that is uncompetitive in many sectors. In France under a third of people believe that the free market is the best option, down from 42% in 2002. 


Thursday, April 7, 2011

The State makes sure, that order uncut


In this mid’s of agitation and crisis of reality check in Indian politics Prof Mehta writes:

  • No agitation focuses on sensible, manageable reform of representative institutions; all agitative energies are premised on bypassing them. 
  • To many of us, this proposal seems like the way we approached educational reform: if BA is not good quality, introduce MA; since MA does not work, have MPhil; since we can’t trust our PhDs, have a further NET exam, endlessly deferring to new institutions at the top of the food chain without attending to basics.  
More interestingly he says: 
  • The demand that a Jan Lokpal Bill be drafted jointly by the government and a self-appointed committee of public virtue is absurd. Most of us sharply disagree with elected government on matters even more important than corruption. But no matter how cogent our arguments, it does not give us the right to say that our virtue entitles us to dictate policy to a representative process.
In fact, the Indian Express editorial says:
  • “The only tiny hope that Hazare and other supporters of the Jan Lokpal draft hold out against this overwhelmingly likely possibility is that the individual at the head will be selected by a committee that will be partly non-governmental in organisation. For example, it will include all Indian Nobel Laureates, and the two most recent winners of the Ramon Magsaysay Awards — hardly a substitute for real electoral accountability. This sort of thinking among the privileged members of civil society, a belief that they alone can speak for “the people” and elected representatives cannot, is dangerous.” 

Hayek Street in Italy

Saturday, April 2, 2011

Back to M.K.G(andhi)



I would never call M.K Gandhi as a Mahatma for my own reasons!!

One more new book on Gandhi has been out now in America. And it is not surprise when States in India bans the book before its release! and that is too where Gandhi was born.

The below are the review or comments one should read on the new book on Gandhi. 
  1. A Different Gandhi by Anita Desai
  2. Don't ban book: Bapu grandson by Rajmohan Gandhi,
  3. New Book Raises Question: Was Gandhi Gay by Tripti Lahiri
  4. Among the Hagiographers by Andrew Roberts
  5. What They Said: Gandhi Book Ban by Krishna Pokharel

Letter to common good


“Teachers must be free to be spontaneous, and to deal with each student as a unique individual.

The human element has been crushed by decades of bureaucratic reform — by required protocols, by endless forms, by dread of legal proceedings for daily discipline and by rigid metrics forcing teachers to “teach to the test.”

Reformers have tried to compel competence by cramming bureaucracy down teachers’ throats, when the only hope of inspiring students is to let teachers be themselves, and form personal bonds.”

See here for more. 

No “Vande Mataram” please, but “Chak de”

India’ property rights index

Parth Shah of CCS discuses the improvement of property rights index in the new report:  
  • One may argue as to how could political stability in India might have declined, as the government at the Centre as well as ruling regimes in states are comparatively more stable than earlier years. It is because the index does not measure only stay of the governments in office, but all sorts of disruptive movements like naxal and Telangana, explained Dr Parth J Shah, president of the Centre for Civil Society, partner of Property Rights Alliance in India for this index.
  • He said there are incidents of human rights violation in J&K and north eastern parts of the country. Besides, special and arbitrary powers are given to army through the Armed Forces Special Powers Act (AFSPA)in Jammu and Kashmir.
  • As expected, the report says that judicial independence is slightly on the rise in India. Without naming court's interventions in alleged scams in spectrum allocation for 2G and commonwealth games, Shah said there are instances of the judiciary challenging the executive in recent times in India.
  • In physical property rights, India scored 6.6 points in 2011 index, same as in 2010. However, Indian system of keeping records relating to physical property are too archaic. Even the last major land survey was conducted during British times.
  • “So far as property rights are concerned, the poor continue to fight the battle against forceful acquisition of their land by either the government or private parties. This remains a point of serious concern for India even as we achieve high rates of growth every year” Shah said.