Monday, April 11, 2011

Faith in capitalism



Which countries are most in favour of the free market?

FAITH in the free market is at a low in the world's biggest free-market economy. In 2010, 59% of Americans asked by GlobeScan, a polling firm, agreed "strongly" or "somewhat" that the free market was the best system for the world's future. This has fallen sharply from 80% when the question was first asked in 2002. And among poorer Americans under $20,000, faith in capitalism fell from 76% to 44% in just one year. Of the 25 countries polled, support for the free market is now greatest in Germany, just ahead of Brazil and communist China, both of which have seen strong growth in recent years. Indians are less enthusiastic despite recent gains in growth. Italy shows a surprising fondness for markets for a place that is uncompetitive in many sectors. In France under a third of people believe that the free market is the best option, down from 42% in 2002. 


Thursday, April 7, 2011

The State makes sure, that order uncut


In this mid’s of agitation and crisis of reality check in Indian politics Prof Mehta writes:

  • No agitation focuses on sensible, manageable reform of representative institutions; all agitative energies are premised on bypassing them. 
  • To many of us, this proposal seems like the way we approached educational reform: if BA is not good quality, introduce MA; since MA does not work, have MPhil; since we can’t trust our PhDs, have a further NET exam, endlessly deferring to new institutions at the top of the food chain without attending to basics.  
More interestingly he says: 
  • The demand that a Jan Lokpal Bill be drafted jointly by the government and a self-appointed committee of public virtue is absurd. Most of us sharply disagree with elected government on matters even more important than corruption. But no matter how cogent our arguments, it does not give us the right to say that our virtue entitles us to dictate policy to a representative process.
In fact, the Indian Express editorial says:
  • “The only tiny hope that Hazare and other supporters of the Jan Lokpal draft hold out against this overwhelmingly likely possibility is that the individual at the head will be selected by a committee that will be partly non-governmental in organisation. For example, it will include all Indian Nobel Laureates, and the two most recent winners of the Ramon Magsaysay Awards — hardly a substitute for real electoral accountability. This sort of thinking among the privileged members of civil society, a belief that they alone can speak for “the people” and elected representatives cannot, is dangerous.” 

Hayek Street in Italy

Saturday, April 2, 2011

Back to M.K.G(andhi)



I would never call M.K Gandhi as a Mahatma for my own reasons!!

One more new book on Gandhi has been out now in America. And it is not surprise when States in India bans the book before its release! and that is too where Gandhi was born.

The below are the review or comments one should read on the new book on Gandhi. 
  1. A Different Gandhi by Anita Desai
  2. Don't ban book: Bapu grandson by Rajmohan Gandhi,
  3. New Book Raises Question: Was Gandhi Gay by Tripti Lahiri
  4. Among the Hagiographers by Andrew Roberts
  5. What They Said: Gandhi Book Ban by Krishna Pokharel

Letter to common good


“Teachers must be free to be spontaneous, and to deal with each student as a unique individual.

The human element has been crushed by decades of bureaucratic reform — by required protocols, by endless forms, by dread of legal proceedings for daily discipline and by rigid metrics forcing teachers to “teach to the test.”

Reformers have tried to compel competence by cramming bureaucracy down teachers’ throats, when the only hope of inspiring students is to let teachers be themselves, and form personal bonds.”

See here for more. 

No “Vande Mataram” please, but “Chak de”

India’ property rights index

Parth Shah of CCS discuses the improvement of property rights index in the new report:  
  • One may argue as to how could political stability in India might have declined, as the government at the Centre as well as ruling regimes in states are comparatively more stable than earlier years. It is because the index does not measure only stay of the governments in office, but all sorts of disruptive movements like naxal and Telangana, explained Dr Parth J Shah, president of the Centre for Civil Society, partner of Property Rights Alliance in India for this index.
  • He said there are incidents of human rights violation in J&K and north eastern parts of the country. Besides, special and arbitrary powers are given to army through the Armed Forces Special Powers Act (AFSPA)in Jammu and Kashmir.
  • As expected, the report says that judicial independence is slightly on the rise in India. Without naming court's interventions in alleged scams in spectrum allocation for 2G and commonwealth games, Shah said there are instances of the judiciary challenging the executive in recent times in India.
  • In physical property rights, India scored 6.6 points in 2011 index, same as in 2010. However, Indian system of keeping records relating to physical property are too archaic. Even the last major land survey was conducted during British times.
  • “So far as property rights are concerned, the poor continue to fight the battle against forceful acquisition of their land by either the government or private parties. This remains a point of serious concern for India even as we achieve high rates of growth every year” Shah said.

Sunday, March 27, 2011

Threesomes


Among others, one has to be careful with three persons in the world, particularly, what these three persons say in their capacity, and act about it. These are the law maker, central banker, and more importantly economist working with law maker, central bank and the government.

Some time the economist who is working with the government say uncommon thing but the media always ignores because that is important to them!

The current Chief Economic Adviser in the Ministry of Finance said “one uncommon thing” in an interview to Indian Express but it seems that the persons who were there in the interaction could not notice what the Adviser said. The Adviser said:

“..an economy cannot have more than one money-creating authority.”

It is simple as well as a complex to understand. About the “money creating authority”, understanding in theory in one thing and thinking about applicability is another thing. Did any one asked him why not? No one!! But what is worth to ponder is the following:
Is there a country in the world, where there is ‘more than one creating authority?’ Close to home whether India had ever such system in her history?
I am certainly sure to answer these questions in near future!!

Thursday, March 24, 2011

A(mbedkar) means D(alit) not C(apitalism)-WHY?


Friends,

I am unable to post often in this blog (which I loved) due to many responsibility landed on me, my apology for that!!

This is the 10th year living with the word Economics than my life!! I had great opportunity to study the history of Indian economic thought subject during my B A and M. A Degrees (both in Economics) I am thrilled to dig out more than many economic historian did for many their life time!! I have also met many great economists and people.

I am now more inclined to think that most of them did what they thought is right but ended up producing not only  wrong ideas, but very dangerous ideas, some are even doing right now, to whom the Indian society think a big thinker, but the reality seems to be otherwise.

So, what I am trying to convey you is that I will be posting very limited post hereafter. But will write more on what I have read in the past 10 years on various issues for publications by different agencies.

One of them is the Ambedkar’s economics, is there anything like that? Of course what he wrote during his early career as well as during his higher education is the one which I call it as Ambedkar Economics. More essentially, the core principles on which he had worked of course after deep thinking through it.

 What went wrong with his ideas were mostly the people who took or understood wrongly is the long trend continues which have become stone-age myth now, but not that easy to break! But let me try!!

One peculiar things happens with Ambedkar free market economics is that the people who call themselves as follower of Ambedkar actually ended up misusing his writings, mis-quoting etc.

The current situation is such that the movement you say the word Ambedkar, suddenly people will think that he was Dalit icon etc, I have no problem with that. My problem with them is the word Capitalism which he cherished very much but denied saying he did not utter anything!! for hell reasons which is not quite known!!   

My question is let’s repeat the title of this post WHY A(mbedkar) means D(alit) not C(apitalism)

So, thanks for being patient!!! 

Monday, March 21, 2011

No Planning, please

Chinese Democracy


Nitin Pai has a nice piece in today’s BS exploring the possibility of China becoming a democracy, but it seems to be unlikely to change its attitude towards India even it become. Remember that in this blog I have posted in this January what Prof Kishore Mahbubani said in his address in New Delhi that Chinese Government is studying the democratic models around the world.

He writes: 
  • It is harder for democracies to doggedly pursue the quest for power. As we know too well, there is often a disconnect between what is popular and what is necessary. Democracies are left with the complex, time-consuming task of reconciling this difference, often at the cost of losing opportunities to maximise national power. Authoritarian states, on the other hand, are less inhibited.

Thursday, March 10, 2011

Finally at Mises Institute!!!


I have not able to post any update on this blog for quite some time. The reason is simply that my research paper on liberalism and free banking ideas of Dr. B.R Ambedkar has been selected for the presentation in the Austrian Scholars Conference 2011.

I am now here to present my paper. It was great challenge for me to finally reach the Mises Institute for the Conference. Many great people have helped me in every single thing to make it this trip successful. This is my first visit to United States of America. Indeed, I am greatly thankful to all those who have helped me. I will write in detail about their individual name when I am back from the Conference.