Tuesday, February 8, 2011

Raghuram Rajan on Economics crisis



 He writes in his blog: 
  • these expectations could have been distorted by ideology – it is hard to get into the past minds of economists. But there is a better reason to be skeptical of explanations relying on ideology. As a group, neither behavioral economists, who think that market efficiency is a joke, nor progressive economists, who distrust free markets, predicted the crisis. 

  • Like medicine, economics has become highly compartmentalized – macroeconomists typically do not pay attention to what financial economists or real-estate economists study, and vice versa. Yet, in order to see the crisis coming, you had to know something about each of these areas, just like it takes a good general practitioner to recognize an exotic disease. Because the profession rewards only careful, well-supported, but necessarily narrow analysis, few economists try to span sub-fields.

Monday, February 7, 2011

Economically illiterate jholawalas


  • As someone who grew up in that era of central planning, licences and permits, I consider it my duty to describe what a shabby, sad, hopeless place India used to be. The economy grew at barely 3 per cent (a figure derided as the Hindu rate of growth) so most Indians lived in absolute poverty. Millions in our poorer states worked as slaves under the euphemism ‘bonded labour’. There was a miniscule middle class and even the richest Indians lived poorly by the standards of the world. 

  • The only people who had easy access to the shoddy products of our controlled economy were politicians and bureaucrats. From their fine bungalows in Lutyens’ Delhi, they controlled quotas and permits as if all of India was their private estate. The rest of us lived with shortages of everything. Sugar, milk, bread, cooking oil, domestic gas, electricity, water and almost everything else was always in short supply. It is not that Indian entrepreneurs were incapable of producing adequate supplies of these things but that government policies ordained that they dare not without a permit or a license. This was based on the flawed economic principle that government factories would produce everything India needed. These factories were run in sloppy fashion by careless officials so an uncontrolled private sector would have put a quick end to them. This is why the private sector had to be licenced and controlled. So successful were these controls that our biggest businessmen could regularly be seen begging for licenses in the smelly corridors of Delhi’s Bhawans. 

  • The people who should be most worried are the well-meaning but economically illiterate jholawalas who constitute Sonia Gandhi’s National Advisory Council. Under their guidance, she has emerged as the Lady Bountiful of Dr. Manmohan Singh’s government handing out jobs to the rural unemployed, forest land to tribal people and free food if the NAC’s latest scheme goes through. All these freebies have been made possible by the fact that the Indian economy, thanks to the enterprise of its private sector, has been growing at a remarkable pace. If Indian businessmen decide that they would be better off investing in some friendlier country, then we could go rapidly back to the way we used to be. So if anyone needs to heed the Prime Minister’s warning, it is Sonia Gandhi especially since many of the interfering ministers claim to be acting in her name. 

(From Back to the licence raj? by Tavleen Singh)

Saturday, February 5, 2011

Bastard Keynesianism!!



I indeed wanted to post after the celebration of 75 year old Keynes book on General Theory. The damages done by this book is now history.

Moreover, Ann Pettifor writes in Blooomberg: 
  • This “bastard Keynesianism,” as British economist Joan Robinson called it, subverted and continues to block the Keynesian revolution both in vision and in method. Monetarists were concerned with the quantity of money. Keynes’s overwhelming concern was with the rate of interest on money. He argued that monetary policy should always support the private and public economy, stimulate it, and prevent recession. 
The Austrian school of economics main concerns is unlimited money creation and artificial creation of interest rate. So biting the money with extremely low interest rate is the culprit for economics crisis.

Friday, February 4, 2011

O for Obama vs O for ostrich

Dividendnomics


From Nitin’s new fortnightly column in DNA: 
  • Dilip Rao, a blogger at Law and Other Things, found a Freakonomics-like correlation between birth rates and terrorism in some states. He notes that a spurt in birth rates in the early 1970s in Punjab and Jammu & Kashmir meant that there was a youth bulge available in the 1980s to answer the separatists’ call. We can trace back the rise of terrorist violence in these states to Operation Blue Star or the rigged 1987 state election, we can prove that Pakistan used these conflicts to conduct proxy war, but Heinsohn goes to the extreme to argue that the cause itself is immaterial - if there is a youth bulge, it will be accompanied by violence. 

  • While these studies do not indicate or claim a definitive causal link, the data are sufficient for us to regard youth bulge violence as a long-term risk to national security. Going by the National Commission on Population’s projections to the year 2026, Uttar Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh and Delhi will experience a net increase in young people. The 15-24 cohort will grow in Bihar, Assam, Haryana, Uttarakhand, Jammu & Kashmir, Maharashtra, Jharkhand, and Gujarat. States that cannot both reduce grievances and create enough opportunities are likely to get into trouble. 

  • The best way to minimise grievances is not by pandering to them individually, but by delivering overall good governance. The politics of entitlement that the UPA government seeks to make respectable under the veneer of “inclusive growth” breeds more grievances for every entitlement. These are already expressed through the idiom of competitive intolerance and coercive violence. While they must be rolled back, those politically opposed to the Congress must do so without themselves creating and appealing to grievances.

Thursday, February 3, 2011

K.Subrahmanyam-nation lost a pillar of versatile strategist


During a book release function I had an opportunity to meet him and his wife in the mid of 2010. His talk was very interesting as he spoke about his career and the march of India’s strategic affairs. His talk is really memorable to me.

Particularly, what he had mentioned was as Ritu Sarin wrote in January 9, 2000: 
  • Interestingly, none other than Dr K. Subrahmanyam, presently convenor of the National Security Council Advisory Board (NSCAB) was on the hijacked plane in 1984 and was a key witness for the prosecution. And just as Pakistan is insinuating that the hijack of IC-814 is the handiwork of the Research and Analysis Wing (RAW) and that there was an agency official on board, Jain's judgement shows that after the 1984 hijacking, a similar canard was raised against Subrahmanyam. Six of the seven hijackers had told the Ajmer court that it was K. Subrahmanyam who (to quote the judge), ``planned the entire hijacking to supervise and examinethe nuclear installations of Pakistan.''

  • The judge, of course, dismissed such There are other similarities between the two hijackings, separated by a period of 15 years.  


Unlike today’s seasoned economists, experts, etc Dr.K Subrahmanyam turned down Padma Bhushan in 1999 and believed that bureaucrats and journalists should not accept any award from the government because they are more liable to be favoured. 

Nitin has already posted one of his interview with KS sir. C Uday Bhaskar has nice obituary in ET.  Professor Sanjay Subrahmanyam is the son of KS.

From the BS Report:
  • He is survived by his wife, Sulochana, a Tamil scholar, and three sons, S Vijay Kumar (secretary, mines, Govt of India), S Jaishankar (India’s ambassador to China) and Sanjay Subrahmanyam (a distinguished historian).
The IDSA page is here and according to ToI He was suffering from cancer and diabetes but his end came after a heart attack, family sources said. 

Wednesday, February 2, 2011

Liberal at fiasco or fiscal



Mr Venu writes with political hunches in coming Budget:
  • At a more macro level, Pranab Mukherjee is under severe pressure to consolidate the rising fiscal deficit as a means to lower inflationary expectations. The RBI, in its monetary policy statement last fortnight, has clearly pointed to high inflation as the main risk to growth and has called upon the Centre to use its fiscal instruments to complement the central bank’s effort to lower inflation expectations.
  • Pranab Mukherjee had delivered liberal doses of fiscal stimuli in the previous two budgets as the world economy remained shaky post the global financial crisis. One of the key outcomes of the liberal fiscal and monetary policies pursued around the world since 2009 is high inflation, which emerging economies, particularly, are grappling with. So clearly it is time for some roll-back of both monetary and fiscal boosters in emerging economies. India cannot escape that process, as inflation is the biggest tax on the poor. 

But there is hardly anyone, who can say boldly the current FM is liberal nor his past  Budgets were liberal in tone. 

MFIs and Money

Getting polluted for power


It sounds big when Mr.Kiran asks: 
  • Why, the writers might enquire, is technology not being used to ensure an efficient and transparent transfer of funds to the beneficiaries, as also to streamline the public distribution system for food grain? Why is our world-beating IT industry's expertise not being more extensively used to first reengineer and then make cost-effective the systems and processes connected with governance, healthcare, law enforcement, traffic management, etc?  

But the reason of his mind goes all the way to square one which is nothing but the absolute power hunter in the business cum politics in local and global. See what he said in the same column: 
  • The letter might reiterate the collective aspiration of a happy, healthy, caring and compassionate society, with equality of opportunity and social justice. It would ask whether present policies are attuned to this goal, and urge that the right to good health and right to food be enacted as laws, along with a universal right to livelihood (as a progression from right to work). It would condemn the illegal campaign of intimidation against human rights activists, demand the release of Binayak Sen and an end to state-sponsored, private, armed gangsters who are only spurring an escalating cycle of violence. 

Tuesday, February 1, 2011

Taxation is coercive-morally

That is what I said to one of my new friend in 2006. At that time and now he works with NGOs. We had long debate about this simple logic. I told him that we the people of this country elect representatives every five years to the place called Parliament and make our life, liberty and property protective but that dos't not happen. I simply told to my friend that the Elected Representative have no right to VOTE on behalf of the people for Taxing our hard earned money by all means and all grounds especially and (more importantly) Morally. He kept on asking me, how to think in practical life about this idea. I told him that we need to take away the power from the so called Representative of People and States from the Parliament by law to tax. He still ponder on it!! I still believe it by virtue of natural law or an order!!


Read:

  • Democracy sucks.
  • Unions hurt more than they help.
  • Campaign spending is political speech.
  • Economic inequality does not undermine democracy or democracy’s role in establishing and protecting equal liberty.
  • Economic rights are as important as political and civil rights, and should be just as vigilantly protected, even if  that leads to huge inequalities, which do not, by the way, threaten democracy or the value of political and civil rights.
  • Taxation is coercive but imprisoning the guy who nicked your lawn gnome isn’t.                        

The same India with news stars

Easy to build but hard to operate

Blessing with cursing


The principal of St Stephen’s College, New Delhi Mr.Valsan Thampu writing (It’s not about the brand) in the Indian Express says that: 
  • As against the 12,000 applications for 400 seats in 2007, there were 28,000 in 2010. Perhaps we should be proud? Perhaps not! 

In case he is proud, what is the purpose? When he deprives thousands of students by simply denying admission to the institutions by simply not expanding the number of seats available with teachers and other facilities!!!!!

The night the light went out…but blinking

Free market: When government discretion and tariffs are sold on the market.


Even more says Prof Mehta that:

  • Since language is an inherently social enterprise we will all have to contribute to the reconstruction of our language. But how can one possibly make sense of our times, when words and institutions lose all their meaning? In uttering them, we conjure up merely unmeaning shadows of their former referents. 

But the language with the same letters needs to be painted, and perhaps the spirit is different!!