Friday, January 14, 2011

A case against income tax-now in India!!!

Of the 2 trillion rupees ($44 billion) net direct tax collected by the end of Dec. 2010, the personal income tax contribution was just over750 billion rupees ($16 billion). Now that’s a huge number and one would assume that our country needs such a large sum of money to sponsor the rapid urbanisation and infrastructural development. Well yes, it does but that’t not where these 750 billion go! Instead, as I mentioned earlier, they go in plugging holes – you and I pay our hard-earned money to keep alive the mismanaged, loss-making government enterprises! We pay for our government’s incompetence. Simple as that. We pay to make good the over 45 billion rupees loss of Air India, over 400 billion rupees loss of public sector petroleum companies andover 350 billion rupees loss incurred by the power sector among others.

For more read here (Indian Liberals.org).

Reading the ASER 2010

What is the relevant of India’s Right of Children to Free And Compulsory Education Act, 2009? When we have the out of school children which is of the order of 3.5 percent (rural) in the age group of 6-14 years, the out of schools children is simply children who are in the age group of 6-14 are not in any schools run by both government and private.

Rural: In 2010, 26.0% of all boys (age 6-14) were enrolled in private school and 22.3% of all girls (age 6-14) were enrolled in private school.

Read more here.

Business of fear and favours

Rediscovering the mercantilism

Arvind Subramanian writes:

  • A second lesson stems from one crucial difference between the two episodes of Chinese mercantilism. Back in the early 1800s, China was mercantilist and closed. The paradox is that today China is mercantilist but highly open. China’s surplus in the earlier episode was a consequence of unquenchable foreign demand for China’s tea combined with a closed-door policy that virtually extinguished Chinese demand for foreign products. Put simply, China exported a fair amount and imported very little. Today, China exports a lot, exports a lot more than it imports, but it also imports a lot. 

  • Taking account of China’s size and the regularity that large countries tend to trade less than small countries, China is an exceptionally big importer and trader. My calculations suggest that the degree of China’s openness, measured in terms of trade outcomes, is far greater than anything achieved by the United States in the post-war period and resembles the levels of openness achieved by the United Kingdom at the height of empire. 

  • So, one reading, perhaps overly optimistic and naive, is that a China that moves away from mercantilism will be a China that is an exceptionally large and fair trader with strong stakes in maintaining an open trading and financial system. Post-World War II, the United States fashioned such a system out of enlightened self-interest. In contrast, China’s stake in openness might be less enlightened but more direct and important because its rise to prosperity, on which is predicated the legitimacy of its government, will depend upon an open system.

The government is the problem, not the solution bank

Bibek on....... the MGNREGA is already distorting the labour market. The way it has been constructed, it was probably deliberately intended to do so.

Aruna Roy on: The government will not have any moral authority to implement the Minimum Wages Act when it is itself a defaulter. It also opens the door to any other legislation over-riding the minimum wage and creating conditions of forced labour.

Thursday, January 13, 2011

Best at 100



Micro farming the farmers

  • Who is the real culprit? Is it the government's neglect of the agrarian economy, the lending practices of microfinance institutions, liberalisation or globalisation? 
  • A large number of studies conducted by social scientists across the country point to the following: there is no single culprit. Crop failure, debt burden, loss in non-agriculture activities and failure of borewells have as often been found to be associated with households with suicides as are person-specific factors such as alcoholism, gambling, property disputes and factors that point towards social problems such as burden of dowry, caste issues and other related social problems.  
  • Clearly, to blame suicide among farmers on largely external factors such as liberalisation and globalisation misses a major part of the story.  

  • Almost all the burden of the risk, e.g., crop failure due to draught or excessive rains, falls on farmers.
  • Instead of creating institutions that allow farmers to hedge their risk, politicians have opted for short cuts that provide instant votes, but not long-terms solutions that rescue farmers from the clutches of landlords, cooperatives, microfinance institutions and reduce risks on account of crop failures.  

Excerpts from Neeraj Kaushal’s Article.

Not reforming is a bad idea

“China’s New Confucianism.”

Wednesday, January 12, 2011

India and Human Action by Ludwig von Mises

Years ago when I heard first time about the Professor Mises book Human Action, I wondered what Mises would have thought and probably said about India when he was writing this book. It is not surprise as the book runs about thousand pages. In the form a article I have now compiled the essential from the book Human Action to see what Mises actually wrote on India, M.K.Gandhi, Indian businessmen, British India, landlords etc.

It is quite amazing to read all those views which are very lucidly expressed and of course make you muse. The most interesting are the below seven paragraphs. Yes only the SEVEN WOUNDERS!! My favourate one is the FIRST and the SEVENTH WOUNDER!!

Mises wrote: 
  1. Mahatma Gandhi disavowed his whole philosophy when he entered a modern hospital to be treated for appendicitis (p.85). 
  2. A comparatively insignificant number of Britons could rule many hundred millions of Indians because the Indian princes and aristocratic landowners looked upon British rule as a means for the preservation of their privileges and supplied it with the support which the generally acknowledged ideology of India gave to their own supremacy. England’s Indian empire was firm as long as public opinion approved of the traditional social order (p.190).   
  3. In the long run it is impossible to withhold the better arms from the members of the majority. Not the equipment of their armed forces, but ideological factors safeguarded the British in India (p.191). 
  4. If capitalist entrepreneurs had not succeeded Lord Clive and Warren Hastings, British rule in India might one day have become such an insignificant historical reminiscence as are the one hundred and fifty years of Turkish rule in Hungary (p.650). 
  5. The poverty of Asia and other backward countries is due to the same causes which made conditions unsatisfactory in the early periods of Western capitalism (p.747-748). 
  6. Mere technological knowledge is of no use if the capital needed is lacking. Indian businessmen are familiar with American ways of production. What prevents them from adopting the American methods is not the lowness of Indian wages, but lack of capital (p.774). 
  7. Indian nationalists take pleasure in speaking of traditional Hindu democracy! (p.842-843).

Scrap the Right to Education Act (RTE)

The Right to Education Act comes when there is no issue of enrollment but huge drop-out ratio. What it makes mockery of school education in this chaotic democracy is for the private schools and that is too by law!! Read the article and ponder what else more one need for scraping this RTE!!

Some excerpts:
  • It is said that one of most damaging virtues of George W Bush was his steadiness; he believed the same thing on Wednesday that he believed on Monday - no matter what happened on Tuesday. Unfortunately, the well-meaning or self-interested people - these are the only two kinds pushing for swifter implementation of the Right to Education Act (RTE) - seem to share this dangerous steadiness despite new information. 

  • As a company at the exit gate of the education system - we have hired somebody every five minutes for five years but only 5% of the kids who came to us for a job - we see and suffer the tragic consequences of India's education emergency. True impact in public policy – unlike election campaigns - does not lie in poetry but in plumbing.  

  • RTE makes it impossible for education entrepreneurs to compete on price since many states propose to regulate fees and uncertainty has paused the Cambrian explosion of energy in school entrepreneurship. This means lower capacity and lower competition. And that means schools don't have clients, but hostages. 

  • Third as enrolment ratios cross 100% it fights yesterday's war of quantity and fails to focus on quality and learning outcomes. We don't need more cooks in the kitchen but a different recipe. RTE not only fails this test but poisons the ecosystem by sabotaging other ways to get India educated.

Tuesday, January 11, 2011

Information vs resources


Read the below two articles before start reading the article on Ask and you shall be killed.

I really do not know how many of you have already read the Hayek’s one of the most important works the Why I Am Not a Conservative (published in The Constitution of Liberty (Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1960). 
  • Before I consider the main points on which the liberal attitude is sharply opposed to the conservative one, I ought to stress that there is much that the liberal might with advantage have learned from the work of some conservative thinkers. To their loving and reverential study of the value of grown institutions we owe (at least outside the field of economics) some profound insights which are real contributions to our understanding of a free society. However reactionary in politics such figures as Coleridge, Bonald, De Maistre, Justus Möser, or Donoso Cortès may have been, they did show an understanding of the meaning of spontaneously grown institutions such as language, law, morals, and conventions that anticipated modern scientific approaches and from which the liberals might have profited. But the admiration of the conservatives for free growth generally applies only to the past. They typically lack the courage to welcome the same undesigned change from which new tools of human endeavors will emerge.

  • A complex economy is something no person or institution can understand. But it can generate a sustainable order, with a rational allocation of resources, as individuals respond to their own circumstances and make choices as consumers and entrepreneurs, signaling the subjective value that they place on goods and capital stock through the price mechanism: One of Hayek’s most original contributions to economic theory is the insight that economic systems are based primarily on information rather than resources. To plan an outcome and to direct economic inputs and outputs toward this outcome is to stifle the emergence of a spontaneous, democratic response to the needs of the individuals who make up the community—a response that will necessarily have winners and losers, but that will not privilege the vision or depend on the limited information of a governing elite, and that will encourage further experimentation. The responsibility of a government that fosters individual freedom is to set up transparent and impartial rules so that the legal reaction to personal choices can be predicted for all, regardless of social station; to tolerate no privileged access to the law; to provide security; and to protect contracts and private property, so long as doing so does not conflict with the very small set of social assumptions on which there truly is broad consensus (arguably, Hayek’s suggestion that government should be responsible for a minimum standard of living would have fit into this consensus when Road was published.).

The local resources vs local problems

Elinor Ostrom, who won the Nobel Prize for Economics in 2009, says in her interview with DNA:

One of the major theses of your work is that beyond market and state, it is the communities that can manage things.

At different scales. We have ignored enabling local communities to manage water, forests and pasture lands.

You are not an economist in the traditional sense as it is understood in the last 50 years.
My official degree is in political science with a minor in economics. I am very much influenced by Douglass C North, Vernon Smith, James Buchanan, and Amartya Sen.

One of the issues in Indian agriculture is whether farmers should be given free power.

I don’t think anyone should be given free power. Overuse of power is a very great threat, a major threat to us all.

Even if it is meant as an incentive in a sector like agriculture, which is supposed to require some help?

No. I think they should be paying for water and power because you want them to use it efficiently.

Cartoonomics or Federonomics

Amity Shlaes writes: 
  • John Maynard Keynes and Milton Friedman preached different philosophies but shared one thing: a withering contempt for students who couldn't keep up with the rest in a seminar. There is a lively debate about whether Friedman himself would have supported QE2. I believe not. But the Friedmanian emphasis on monetary policy helped to make Ben Bernanke's QE2 possible. 

  • The seminar culture carried over to the salon of general economic discussion. Journalists don't clarify. Instead, they become graduate students, journeymen who pander to the masters, professional economists. No one dares to suggest that if high-end theory is so difficult to understand it may not be the best theory. No one dares admit he is less than 100% sure, to quote Mr. Bernanke in his recent 60 Minutes appearance. To talk in anything other than Keynesian or monetarist terms is to ensure you'll be shut out of the salon. 

  • Hence the cartoon. This medium calls the academics' bluff. Cartoons do not even aspire to the salon. What a cartoon video says, in effect, is: "I don't care if I'm called stupid; I'm a cartoon. What I care about is trying to discuss the economy in plain English." Readers and viewers are so relieved to be free of the obligation to appear erudite that they turn to the cartoon in droves. The same phenomenon has produced another unlikely economic messenger: a rap video. A mock rap debate between John Maynard "Let-the-Spending-Soar" Keynes and the Austrian School economist Friedrich "Too-Much-Aggregation" von Hayek has received 1.7 million hits on YouTube.

China has emerged, more than India

Says Professor Rana Mitter,

Today, as funding for science in the West falls victim to budget cuts and government spending restraints, the Chinese are now at the cutting edge of technology in many areas. Chinese work on solar energy is widely regarded as world-beating. The Chinese space programme has already produced its first astronauts, and few would be surprised if China were to place a man or woman on the moon within the next decade.

The authorities have also sought to clean up the nature of Chinese academic culture. Many journals which publish shoddy or plagiarised work will be shut down. Many other journals have begun to publish in English, on the grounds that this is the only significant international scientific language. For the next few years, then, there is no reason that Chinese scientific research should not forge ahead even while freedom of discussion on political matters remains restricted. 


Read the full article here.