Wednesday, December 22, 2010

From Prof.Jagdish Bhagwati Blog!!

Yes, he now blogs @ The American Interest

First, while authoritarianism can accelerate reforms, it can also be a serious handicap. Years ago, when both Mao and Zhou Enlai were alive, Padma Desai, the Columbia University expert on Russia, was asked about China’s future growth prospects. She answered: it depends on whether Mao dies first or Zhao dies first – her point being that in a top-heavy system, growth paths can become unpredictable, and thus subject to volatility.

From his post on India or China?

Being an economist is worth like anything, but GOLD!!


In my friends group everybody has studied management or science related subject. I am the only one who has studied economics. So, most of the time, when we start debating this or that in social developmental issues and when it comes the functions of economic systems all them will say everything but not the truth. And that is where they all realize that they have wasted their time in their subject. Because the particular country’s economic system affects all spheres of economy. So what is the point here? Nothing directly, read It’s Better Being an Economist (But Don’t Tell Anyone) 

Struggle to make worth of life in youngage


  • As is evident in NYRS 2009, about 48% of all literate youth indicated that they supported it, while 35% were against caste-based reservations. While 54% of SC, 50% of ST and 47% of OBC are in favour of the current system, 43% of the general castes back it.
  • The youth are also often prone to violence. Frustration is a key driver of this increasingly marked attribute and it arises from unfulfilled aspirations. The major reasons for frustration in today’s youth are unemployment, injustice and corruption. What rubs salt on this wound is a sense of victimhood to the forces of unemployment, injustice and corruption. Their impressionable minds are hemmed in from all sides by glamorous objects and options that most cannot possess.


From Rajesh Shukla's Young, employed and Unhappy".

Eightfold “Scorching corruption like fire”

  • Reminiscent of the eightfold path of the Buddha (right thinking, right view, right intention, right speech, right action, right livelihood, right effort and right possessions), the President of the Indian National Congress, Ms Sonia Gandhi, has also come out with an eightfold path (fast-tracking of corruption cases against big shots in politics and administration, abolition of the Central and State Governments' discretionary powers of any kind, state funding of elections, transparency in public procurement, adoption of public interest as the sole criterion for leasing/auctioning of public assets, protection to whistleblowers, avoidance of vulgar displays of wealth and waste, and adherence to simplicity, restraint and austerity “as our chosen way”) to fight corruption to the finish. 
  • We, the people, delight in the fact that there is not one political establishment which, while seeking our votes during elections, has not solemnly promised to unearth and bring to book the corrupt and the crooked. Actually, the tradition goes back to the period before Independence, when the Congress vowed to hang the black marketers, profiteers and the fleecers of the people from the nearest lamp post.

Paper subsidy

  
Gulzar Natarajan on issuing of voucher for vocational training;

  • The government can issue vocational training vouchers to prospective students, selected through defined criteria, with some basic qualification. The course-independent vouchers will subsidize a part of the training expenses including tuition fees and boarding charges. A basic subsidy can be announced each year, which would be reimbursed to the institutes on production of the vouchers. The institutes could offer a variety of vocational courses, letting students choose on the market signals. They would compete to offer courses and attract students.
  • The vouchers issued can be linked with the recipient’s Aadhaar number to simplify administration and reimbursements, prevent leakages, and ensure portability. The trained students should then be linked to NEP. In other words, leveraging the potential of NSDC through vouchers, and linking it with NEP can be a big step towards addressing what is arguably India’s biggest economic challenge.


Tuesday, December 21, 2010

Hope never move, but change

According to the Pew Research Centre, some 87% of Chinese, 50% of Brazilians and 45% of Indians think their country is going in the right direction, whereas 31% of Britons, 30% of Americans and 26% of the French do. Companies, meanwhile, are investing in “emerging markets” and sidelining the developed world. “Go east, young man” looks set to become the rallying cry of the 21st century.

We are truly unique in many ways BUT WHAT IS THE USE OF IT WHEN WE HAVE MAJORITY OF THEM WITH NO FOOD


Thanks to my friend Ghanshyam for bringing in my knowledge about an article titled The Art of Remaining Poor by Avik Chattopadhyay. It’s a must read one.

Some excerpts: 

  • During the election campaigning in Bihar in October this year Rahul Gandhi, the heir apparent of the Indian National Congress proudly claimed, "Aapki Congress party gareebon ki party hai, aapki party hai." ["Your Congress party is the party of the poor, your party."] 
  • After 63 years of an independence that was hard fought, such a statement made with a sense of pride seemed pathetic to me. 
  • While it mirrors the reality we live in, it demonstrates the 63 years of deliberate, orchestrated and cruel deprivation of a sixth of the world's population. It reeks of the sheer apathy and shamelessness of those that the man and woman on the street look upon as redeemers. It talks of the thick skin all of us have developed…our leaders, administrators, planners, implementers and benefactors. Otherwise, someone in the crowd should have stood up and hurled a chappal in utter disgust. Or some editor would have used the pen [or keyboard] to prise open some very bare and basic questions. 
  • According to a report on Asian economic powers, in 1947 India's per capita income was at $439 while South Korea stood at $770. In 50 years India stood at $1,818 and South Korea at $13,317! So, what went wrong with us? What stunted our development and prosperity? Our population? The British rule? The multi-party democracy? The world powers conspiring against us? The 'socialist' operating principles? Over reliance on agriculture? Faulty planning? What, exactly what? Nothing. Actually nothing went wrong. Everything is according to plan. Right from the time Mr. Nehru justified that some of the poorest parts of country were the ones ruled longest by the British and systematically de-industrialised in the 190 years of subjugation, we have planned for poverty as integral to our socio-economic-political superstructure. 
  • We have used 'socialism' as a term under which we have perpetrated protectionism, patronage and favouritism. 
  • We conjure up programmes like the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Generation Act that make millions of villagers slaves of projects that are alien to them and displace them rather than help them lead improve upon what they do best — farming, animal husbandry, dairy and handicrafts....... 
  • Mr. Gandhi would have felt ashamed thinking of those words, leave alone gallantly using them, not once but 16 times while doing the rounds of Bihar!

One thing many PhD students have in common is dissatisfaction


That is a line from another piece in the Economist. A bit from the piece:

  • ...Martin Luther nailed 95 theses to the door of a church in Wittenberg. In those days a thesis was simply a position one wanted to argue. Luther, an Augustinian friar, asserted that Christians could not buy their way to heaven. Today a doctoral thesis is both an idea and an account of a period of original research. Writing one is the aim of the hundreds of thousands of students who embark on a doctorate of philosophy (PhD) every year. 
  • One thing many PhD students have in common is dissatisfaction. Some describe their work as “slave labour”. Seven-day weeks, ten-hour days, low pay and uncertain prospects are widespread. You know you are a graduate student, goes one quip, when your office is better decorated than your home and you have a favourite flavour of instant noodle. “It isn’t graduate school itself that is discouraging,” says one student, who confesses to rather enjoying the hunt for free pizza. “What’s discouraging is realising the end point has been yanked out of reach.” 
  • But universities have discovered that PhD students are cheap, highly motivated and disposable labour. 
  • Brilliant, well-trained minds can go to waste when fashions change.

Let’s change



The genius of The Nature of the Firm turns 100


As I have posted here the Economist now has a piece (Why do firms exist? Ronald Coase, the author of “The Nature of the Firm” (1937), turns 100 on December 29th) on the grand giant firm theory revolutionary figure: Professor Ronald Coase who is going to turn 100 year by next week.

Few excerpts from the piece:

  • Today most people live in a market economy, and central planning is remembered as the greatest economic disaster of the 20th century. Yet most people also spend their working lives in centrally planned bureaucracies called firms.
  • The man who restored the pin factory to its rightful place at the heart of economic theory celebrates his 100th birthday on December 29th. The economics profession was slow to recognise Ronald Coase’s genius. He first expounded his thinking about the firm in a lecture in Dundee in 1932, when he was just 21 years old. Nobody much listened. He published “The Nature of the Firm” five years later. It went largely unread. 
  • But Mr Coase laboured on regardless: a second seminal article on “The Problem of Social Cost” laid the intellectual foundations of the deregulation revolution of the 1980s. Eventually, Mr Coase acquired an army of followers, such as Oliver Williamson, who fleshed out his ideas. In 1991, aged 80, he was awarded a Nobel prize. Far from resting on his laurels, Mr Coase will publish a new book in 2011, with Ning Wang of Arizona State University, on “How China Became Capitalist”. 
  • How much light does “The Nature of the Firm” throw on today’s corporate landscape? The young Mr Coase first grew interested in the workings of firms when he travelled around America’s industrial heartland on a scholarship in 1931-32. He abandoned his textbooks and asked businessmen why they did what they did. He has long chided his fellow economists for scrawling hieroglyphics on blackboards rather than looking at what it actually takes to run a business. So it seems reasonable to test his ideas by the same empirical standards. 
  • Mr Coase’s theory continues to explain some of the most puzzling problems in modern business. Take the rise of vast and highly diversified business groups in the emerging world, such as India’s Tata group and Turkey’s Koc Holding. Many Western observers dismiss these as relics of a primitive form of capitalism. But they make perfect sense when you consider the transaction costs of going to the market. Where trust in established institutions is scarce, it makes sense for companies to stretch their brands over many industries. And where capital and labour markets are inefficient, it makes equal sense for companies to allocate their own capital and train their own loyalists.

It is also its cure


  • I fancy myself a humble person. One evening, I sought confirmation of my humility from my daughter and granddaughter. I asked them if they all thought that I was humble. My granddaughter, Naina, who is known for her brashness, replied: “You must be joking! You love flattery. All these ladies who send you kebabs, kheer, cakes and flowers, give you enormous pleasure and inflate your ego. And the man who lays it on thick and keeps giving you vintage Scotch, flatters you as if you were a minor prophet.” As if this were not enough, my daughter, Mala, added; “When you are dazzling your audience with your wit, you expect them to say nice things about you. And when they fall silent, you feel bored and ask them to go. How can you call yourself humble?”

Read the full article you will find even more interesting things.

Tips from Nobel laureate-Venkatraman Ramakrishnan


Top to bottom

  • “There is no magic formula for winning the Nobel Prize” 
  • “If India wins a single Nobel Prize it does not mean Indian science is okay” 
  • “Don’t work on anything that you’re not interested in — day-to-day science is extremely tedious,” 
  • “If you don’t gossip about the problem, then you’re not really interested in it. It’s (got to be) something you can’t help talking about. The problem has to be bugging you when you have a coffee” 
  • “Also aim to go to the best place for your work,” 
  • “You can change fields with humility, 
  • “It’s a paradox that the biggest benefits of science to humanity have come from the fundamental science problems”


What one did not say has already been said about another Nobel Laureate in Economics science:

“And unlike that imposter Amartya Sen, this is the real deal. Ladies & Gentlemen, Professor Dixit”

Clean up or perish should be the message

 Mr.Rekhy is one of the finest human beings. I had brief opportunity to work with him some years ago.

From Good governance creates value By Richard Rekhy


  • While liberalisation paved the way for India’s success story, the cue was picked up by the corporate world and it is private enterprise and corporate leadership that has steered India towards this growth. Corporate India understands the importance of governance. Well-governed companies have always got better valuations and have inspired other entrepreneurs to follow in their footsteps. Maybe, it is time for corporate India to lead the way and infuse the country with good governance practices. Clean up or perish should be the message. Companies sho­uld make it clear through policy and action that there is zero tolerance to fraud and corruption. Let us not blame the eco system of this country for fraud and corruption to exist and thrive. There are many examples of ethical and well- governed companies in India that we can learn from.

  • Governance is a state of mind, it does not need rules and regulations. While regulation and law can assist governance, the place we in India have to get to is where we follow governance in every walk of life; and ethics penetrate the heart and soul of every action that we take. As we end the year 2010, let us hope that India will move towards a culture of good governance and that the government will recognise that it will fail in its mission to build India into an economic powerhouse unless it lays down a strong foundation of ethics and values and de­monstrates that through action. What we need is enforcement and examples of the guilty being given appropriate punishment for their crimes.

Middle ground is no ground

From Minding their own business by P. Vaidyanathan Iyer

  • It is an unfortunate fact that bureaucrats are not sector experts, and hence, not the right fit. They are instead trained to be good administrators. The brighter among them manage to grasp the issues within a few months, but in this age of rapid change and innovation, the government can no longer afford to give regulators the luxury of time. 


So what is the solution, yes there is no other solution in the short period say at least next 15 years. But think of the following:

  • It may not be that difficult to get academics, but they carry with them the baggage of too much theory and too little practical experience. For private sector stars, money is not the only driver. It is also the prestige attached to such seats. Besides offering decent compensation — which could be a middle ground between staid public sector salaries and lucrative private sector packages, the government must create an environment that allows them to function independently and effectively. The esteem value can go up only when the government goes that extra mile to give private sector achievers an impression that their expertise will be respected and made good use of. Perhaps we are not there yet.

Yatha praja thatha raja