Saturday, January 30, 2010

The real common man

So we are ending first month of 2010= minus two zeros means 21th century!

The very next month is budget month, hardly a person in this 21th century to do a simple exercise like what Nani Palkhivala did.

Read this article.

Who are unfortunate student and why?

An academic turned CEO writes in today’s ET that in the present crisis of deemed universities, he states that the student studying in these deemed universities are “unfortunate”.

And then he says:

  • “Unscrupulous educators in cahoots with inept and corrupt elements among the regulators, reduced an idea of deemed universities — an idea originally intended to accord an enabling auxiliary educational status to those institutions that had the highest standards expected of a university, but were in fact not universities — to create a large number of ragtag band of educational mafia exploiting thousands of innocent students, and giving the very idea of deemed universities a bad name.
  • Unfortunately, over time as the educational and infrastructural standards of even the regular universities went into severe decline , it provided a fertile ground for many dodgy institutions to prey on unsuspecting youth desperate for quality education, imagining paying more money is akin to receiving superior education. While the minister’s action against some of the deemed universities may be a good start, there are any numbers of other ‘entrepreneurial institutions’ that may also need a closer scrutiny.”

Thursday, January 28, 2010

The real mess is in our University Education System

Prof.P. V. INDIRESAN writes:

  • Some deemed universities have also been sponsored by the government, whose credentials are at best doubtful.
  • On a personal note, my wife was a UGC nominee to enquire into the accreditation of a college in Rajasthan. That college had given degrees in chemistry for several years without having a single teacher to teach that subject. The labs had been condemned as unfit and had not been repaired. The person who received her in the morning had vanished by the evening because he had been transferred to a “better” college and he wanted to join before the order could be revised — by political pressure. That university remains accredited; that college “functions”.
  • Some years ago, a colleague of mine went as Vice-chancellor of a state university and found that it was giving more than 10 times the Ph.Ds produced by IIT Kanpur. He tried his best to bring some discipline but failed; he had to quit. In fact, in many states, the universities have no powers to decide whether to accept a college or not; that is decided by the minister.

Saturday, January 23, 2010

Exactly how nubile?


We need Mallu, Maadu, Sindhi and Sardarji jokes about our Constitution;

Shoba Narayan writes that we need make the:

  • “….Constitution accessible, we not only help India’s future citizens know their rights and responsibilities, we also teach both the elite and the common man not to take its blessings for granted. The lofty ideals of the Indian republic are worth fighting for. They just need to trickle down from scholars to schoolchildren; from libraries to lounge bars; from educational institutions to no-name addas. The “Constitution is a living document”, as the government of India’s website says. Simplifying and popularizing it will mean no disrespect. Rather, it will lay the foundation for the people to understand and enact its tenets more faithfully than we are now doing.
  • This is not hard to do. Karadi Tales can do a sing-along version of India’s first principles. Amar Chitra Katha can create an illustrated story of how our Constitution came to be. Pratham Books can commission a Constitution for Children series, fraught as it is with colourful characters set against a dramatic backdrop. Rajkumar Hirani could get over his 3 Idiots and write the Munna Bhai equivalent for the Constitution. Just as bumbling Munna contemporized the Mahatma’s message, a wise-cracking, fast-talking Koli fisherwoman can enact Gandhiji’s dream of an “untouchable woman president” on the big screen and popularize the tenets of this republic. We need Mallu, Maadu, Sindhi and Sardarji jokes about our Constitution; we need to get Robert and Mona Darling to banter about its issues; we need ad jingles that skew its message; we need saas-bahu serials that invoke its lines; we need college debates and reality shows based on it. We need our Constitution to speak to us. All it takes is a few celebrities to get the ball rolling. Instead of tatkal twittering and then blaming the media for taking his message out of context, minister Tharoor (who, I personally think, has had enough of being minister) can tweet about the Constitution rather than his calendar. Chetan Bhagat can write about the state of our republic after his 2 States. Our rich heritage of folk songs and street theatre can be used to make this important historical document come alive for its citizens.
  • Consider Article 16, which talks about equality of opportunity. The rap version would be, “Yo Bro. You wanna job. You gotta job. Equal opportunity but social justice. Peace, man.” The rap version of Article 19 can dispense with the “notwithstanding” and other legal but necessary jargon and emphasize the basic rights of free speech, assembly, association and movement. For example, the folk version could be a catchy Asha Bhosle tune about a nation of talkers who move within the motherland and love to get together. Or some version thereof.”

Friday, January 22, 2010

Wednesday, January 20, 2010

Climate-politics

UN climate chief admits mistake on Himalayan glaciers warning

IPCC imperialism on Indian glaciers

Still heating up

Need accountable Economic System

We all agree that we need right kind of economic system. But what is right system is not known to a single. Therefore, given the options we chose one of them and hang on it till someone else overtake (almost automatically) but there is a lot of ‘if’ and ‘buts’ in between. It is also important to understand these systems functions. Best of my sense of understanding of economic system, is to make accountable for their actions. In other words, the system which makes every one accountable tends to promote freedom at nobody’s price.

In today’s Mint Mr.Niranjan writes about what kind of free market system do we need to create a New (Indian) Economics?

  • The long-term effects on social attitudes are most severe on those individuals who are between 18 and 24 years during economic downturns—an impressionable age when attitudes towards life and society are being formed.
  • These insights raise an interesting question: Will individuals growing up in a long boom be part of a generation that is more sympathetic towards free markets, have lower risk aversion and believe that wealth is a result of hard work rather than luck?
  • This is a question that can have a deep impact on Indian society and politics in the decades ahead. We can take 1985 as the breakthrough year for the Indian economy, when the first reforms were introduced and the middle class started participating in the stock market. A quick look at India’s population pyramid shows that around three out of every four Indians were born after 1967, and thus came of age in a country that had broken out of the circle of endemic shortages and anaemic growth.
  • These young Indians below 45 years of age are likely to be more open to free markets, new technologies and risk-taking. We see it anecdotally around us, but then India is a complex place and there are large swathes of the country where the benefits of reforms are not that evident, even though higher growth has lifted millions out of poverty.
  • India’s long economic boom has the potential to change popular attitudes towards free markets and capitalism, but a lot will depend on what variant of capitalism takes root here. There are too many worrisome signs right now that we are moving towards an economy dominated by giant oligopolies that are nurtured by government policies, even as the old habit of handing over the management of public companies to the children of large business families continues merely because they have hit the DNA jackpot.

Knowledge is doomed to unfit

The State makes sense of regulation in time to time in a “Vague” way and it never know how much knowledge it has to make decision upon millions of individuals. In the process of decision making or policy making they completely lose (even if one society has wide consultations with respective stakeholders!) the humanity role in it. Invariable it has been that their aim is to achieve their own personal goals.

For a while the judiciary system were also sleeping on the forehead of The State’s regulation on the same polices for years. Though, there are movements in the society and we see it in every day life, so what, that is what people ask in every election after election.

The present education system is another awful system which makes muggy of human life, no mater whether one has entered the four wall of the class room or not.

Here are some cases:

Tuesday, January 19, 2010

ASER makes the difference….

Wilima Wadhwa writes:

  • The latest ASER (Annual Status of Education Report), an annual survey of learning facilitated by NGO Pratham, indicates that at the all-India level, private school enrolment increased from 16.3% in 2005 to around 22.6% in 2008—a rise of around 40%. In 2009, private school enrolment has marginally dropped to 21.8% in rural India.
  • Uttar Pradesh, Haryana, Punjab and Kerala where private school enrolment is as high as 40%, and on the other are Bihar and West Bengal with private school enrolment closer to 5%.
  • In 2009, in classes I-V, the percentage of children in government schools who could read at least at the class I level was 43.6%. The corresponding figure in private schools was 52.2%—a whopping 8.6 percentage points advantage.
  • Once we control for characteristics other than the type of school, the learning differential between government and private schools falls drastically from 8.6 percentage points to 2.9 percentage points— from 20% to a measly 5%.
  • In the case of English, the starting differential is greater and the narrowing a little less. The percentage of children in classes I-V who can read simple words (or more) in English is 26.5% compared with 44.2% in private schools—an advantage of 17.7 percentage points, or 67%.
  • Once we control for other factors, this differential falls to 10.8 percentage points, or 41%. Hence, around 40% of the observed differential in English learning levels between government and private schools can be attributed to other factors.
  • In the case of reading in the local language, in many cases most of the learning differentials disappear once other factors are controlled for—Uttarakhand, Chhattisgarh, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, Andhra Pradesh and Tamil Nadu. For Madhya Pradesh, the difference is actually reversed— once other factors are controlled for, government schools perform better than private schools. In Andhra Pradesh and Tamil Nadu, where government schools had higher learning levels to start with, the gap widens once other factors are taken into account.
  • In the case of English, in most states, the starting differentials are greater and the narrowing of the differentials smaller as was the case for all of India. However, there are still states such as Chhattisgarh and Madhya Pradesh where two-thirds of the learning difference is attributable to factors other than private schooling.

"Economic Freedom, Human Freedom, Political Freedom"

"Economic Freedom, Human Freedom, Political Freedom"

by Milton Friedman

Delivered November 1, 1991

  • The United States today is more than 50% socialist in terms of the fraction of our resources that are controlled by the government. Fortunately, socialism is so inefficient that it does not control 50% of our lives. Fortunately, most of that is wasted. People worry about government waste; I don't. I just shudder at what would happen to freedom in this country if the government were efficient in spending our money. The really fascinating thing is that our private sector has been so effective, so efficient, that it has been able to produce a standard of life that is the envy of the rest of the world on the basis of less than half the resources available to all of us.
  • The major problems that face this country all derive from too much socialism. If you consider our educational system at the elementary and secondary level, government spending per pupil has more than tripled over the past thirty years in real terms after allowing for inflation, yet test scores keep declining, dropout rates are high, and functional illiteracy is widespread. Why should that be a surprise? Schooling at the elementary and secondary level is the largest socialist enterprise in the United States next to the military. Now why should we be better at socialism than the Russians? In fact, they ought to be better; they have had more practice at it. If you consider medical care, which is another major problem now, total spending on medical care has gone from 4% of the national income to 13%, and more than half of that increase has been in the form of government spending. Costs have multiplied and it is reasonably clear that output has not gone up in anything like the same ratio. Our automobile industry can produce all the cars anybody wants to drive and is prepared to pay for. They do not seem to have any difficulty, but our government cannot produce the roads for us to drive on. The aviation industry can produce the planes, the airlines can get the pilots, but the government somehow cannot provide the landing strips and the air traffic controllers. I challenge anybody to name a major problem in the United States that does not derive from excessive government.

The State Invented Urban Poverty

On Saturday (16th January 2010) I have attended a lecture (The Urban Lecture Serious) organized by Centre for Policy Research (CPR), New Delhi along with Janaagraha Centre for Citizenship and Democracy (JCCD), Bangalore. The topic was on "Indian Urbanisation in a Global Perspective" by Prof. Edward L Glaeser, Fred and Fleanor Glimp Professor of Economics, Harvard University.

Prof. Ed Glaeser gave his talk on “An Urban Future”

In sum, the lecture was attended by a well attended with first hand experience of urbanization.

First the representative of JCCD has presented a brief about what they do in their Centre. It was said that the REED Programme has achieved a wide spectrum in terms of research and advocacy programms. The full form of REED stands:

  • R-Regional Perspective
  • E-Empowering Government (local bodies etc)
  • E-Enabling Government (local bodies etc) and citizen
  • D-Direct Accountability

And then Prof. Ed Glaeser gave a talk mainly on the broader aspects of the following:

  • Evaluation of urban arena in US
  • Death of distance and decline of costing moving goods
  • Traditional State functions
  • People living in the urban cities in poverty are not bad thing!
  • Urban role in civilization (exporting of goods, cloth cities, food cities)
  • The gift of urban density
  • Idea oriented cities and importing of ideas (Athens imported of ideas from Greek, Baghdad imported of ideas from India etc)
  • The most skilled cities in US
  • Urban intercontinental gateways
  • What is good and bad about urban poverty?
  • The role of Economics and Choice in urban poverty
  • Urban governance, etc

Prof.Abhijit Banerjee pointed out in a study in Udaipur district of Rajasthan the round trip and short term migrant were found a significantly higher than the permanent migrant.

It was also said that the new two wheelers have revolutionized the Indian scenario of urbanization especially after the liberalization.

There were many more discussion on the contemporary issues of urbanization in India and the globe.

There were many interesting questions also which are not studied in the experience of US urbanization.

However, what is discussed is the difference of rural economy contribution to urban economy and vice-versa. It includes both building both physical and social infrastructure development.

At the end everybody in some or other way felt that the ultimate culprit in the urban poverty is The State failure of policy.

Monday, January 18, 2010

Edification, yet to work well

The former chairman of UGC and VC of Pune University writes:

  • Peter Drucker says, “Plans are only good intentions unless they immediately generate into hard work”.
  • The human resource development (HRD) ministry now has come out with a figure of Rs 1.71 lakh crore for five years.
  • We must realise that it is just not the provision for money that is going to make implementation easy. Each state would have to initiate several systemic reforms. Th ese include establishing the correct teacher-to-student ra tio (1:30), putting curriculum and examination reforms in place, creating a work plan for comprehensive and continuous evaluation, introducing new delivery methods and setting up school management committees with representation of all stakeholders.
  • Governments, state and central, must realise that these reforms cannot happen overnight by using a magic wand. It requires enormous efforts and commitment at several levels, right from the panchayat to taluka to district to state level. We need to work out the best way to redistribute existing teachers among urban and rural schools and assess how many new teachers need to be recruited to achieve this golden ratio.

Almost held up!

A former finance secretary and economic adviser to the Prime Minister S. Narayan writes in the Mint:

  • “We need foresight and strategy to devise a role for our country in these fast changing times. But I do not see anyone in the government in charge of long-term strategy, neither are there any reasoned commentaries in the media. Perhaps we have lost the habit of thinking long term”

I am not sure whether he is really asking this question to his reader, as he himself writes “in these fast changing times”. It seems to be he is looking half filled glass than half emty one!