Tuesday, January 19, 2010

The State Invented Urban Poverty

On Saturday (16th January 2010) I have attended a lecture (The Urban Lecture Serious) organized by Centre for Policy Research (CPR), New Delhi along with Janaagraha Centre for Citizenship and Democracy (JCCD), Bangalore. The topic was on "Indian Urbanisation in a Global Perspective" by Prof. Edward L Glaeser, Fred and Fleanor Glimp Professor of Economics, Harvard University.

Prof. Ed Glaeser gave his talk on “An Urban Future”

In sum, the lecture was attended by a well attended with first hand experience of urbanization.

First the representative of JCCD has presented a brief about what they do in their Centre. It was said that the REED Programme has achieved a wide spectrum in terms of research and advocacy programms. The full form of REED stands:

  • R-Regional Perspective
  • E-Empowering Government (local bodies etc)
  • E-Enabling Government (local bodies etc) and citizen
  • D-Direct Accountability

And then Prof. Ed Glaeser gave a talk mainly on the broader aspects of the following:

  • Evaluation of urban arena in US
  • Death of distance and decline of costing moving goods
  • Traditional State functions
  • People living in the urban cities in poverty are not bad thing!
  • Urban role in civilization (exporting of goods, cloth cities, food cities)
  • The gift of urban density
  • Idea oriented cities and importing of ideas (Athens imported of ideas from Greek, Baghdad imported of ideas from India etc)
  • The most skilled cities in US
  • Urban intercontinental gateways
  • What is good and bad about urban poverty?
  • The role of Economics and Choice in urban poverty
  • Urban governance, etc

Prof.Abhijit Banerjee pointed out in a study in Udaipur district of Rajasthan the round trip and short term migrant were found a significantly higher than the permanent migrant.

It was also said that the new two wheelers have revolutionized the Indian scenario of urbanization especially after the liberalization.

There were many more discussion on the contemporary issues of urbanization in India and the globe.

There were many interesting questions also which are not studied in the experience of US urbanization.

However, what is discussed is the difference of rural economy contribution to urban economy and vice-versa. It includes both building both physical and social infrastructure development.

At the end everybody in some or other way felt that the ultimate culprit in the urban poverty is The State failure of policy.

Monday, January 18, 2010

Edification, yet to work well

The former chairman of UGC and VC of Pune University writes:

  • Peter Drucker says, “Plans are only good intentions unless they immediately generate into hard work”.
  • The human resource development (HRD) ministry now has come out with a figure of Rs 1.71 lakh crore for five years.
  • We must realise that it is just not the provision for money that is going to make implementation easy. Each state would have to initiate several systemic reforms. Th ese include establishing the correct teacher-to-student ra tio (1:30), putting curriculum and examination reforms in place, creating a work plan for comprehensive and continuous evaluation, introducing new delivery methods and setting up school management committees with representation of all stakeholders.
  • Governments, state and central, must realise that these reforms cannot happen overnight by using a magic wand. It requires enormous efforts and commitment at several levels, right from the panchayat to taluka to district to state level. We need to work out the best way to redistribute existing teachers among urban and rural schools and assess how many new teachers need to be recruited to achieve this golden ratio.

Almost held up!

A former finance secretary and economic adviser to the Prime Minister S. Narayan writes in the Mint:

  • “We need foresight and strategy to devise a role for our country in these fast changing times. But I do not see anyone in the government in charge of long-term strategy, neither are there any reasoned commentaries in the media. Perhaps we have lost the habit of thinking long term”

I am not sure whether he is really asking this question to his reader, as he himself writes “in these fast changing times”. It seems to be he is looking half filled glass than half emty one!

Ronald Coase on Markets, Firms and Property Rights


Not less than a 99 year old economist Ronald Coase (Clifton R. Musser Professor Emeritus of Economics at the University of Chicago Law School) addressed to the conference on November 23, 2009.


(via http://antidismal.blogspot.com)

INTERVIEW WITH GARY BECKER


This is the fourth in a series of interviews with Chicago School economists. Read “After the Blowup,” John Cassidy’s story on Chicago economists and the financial crisis.


Hey Intellectual, can you hear me, the lay man from the knowledge society?

There is serious of excerpts from a latest book “Intellectual and Society” by Prof Thomas Sowell. This is a third book he has published in a year.

The below are the excerpts:

  1. How Data On Income Distribution Are Misunderstood And Misapplied
  2. How Media Misuse Income Data To Match Their Preconceptions
  3. How Intelligentsia Ignore The Risks Of Investing Data With Moral Angst
  4. What Intellectuals Don't Know About The Poor As Consumers
  5. Running A Business Is Simple; Ask Any Uninitiated Intellectual

Wednesday, January 13, 2010

“kya kare, chalta hai” no no.. you can not eat the cake of social-sector schemes too

An NGO CEO writes about the NGO’s politics and bureaucracy in Indian society, of course it purely private!!

  • It is sad that at the end of 2009, almost 25 years later, the Deputy Chairman of the Planning Commission reiterates that Rajiv Gandhi was right — indicating that over the last 25 years there has been a constant siphoning off of huge amounts of money meant to be spent for the benefit of the poorest of the poor.
  • By most reports, the NREGA scheme has been the most successful of government schemes — what that means is perhaps, not 50 per cent, but a lower amount is being siphoned off. Let’s face it, the scheme is dependent on the Block Development Officer and the sarpanch to identify and confirm the beneficiary before payment is disbursed; what are the checks and balances in place to ensure that a nexus between these two does not lead to siphoning off of funds to non-beneficiary accounts? The BDO post is reportedly being auctioned off for as much as 5 crores these days, giving lucrative police station house officer postings stiff competition.
  • A worthwhile exercise for the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) would be to undertake a state-wide exercise to identify the number of NGOs that are founded by politicians or bureaucrats or through family members or fronts. Ideally, identify where (say) more than 0.5 per cent of the sanctioned funds for any one scheme in a state were sanctioned and then identify the organisations that received the funds. Then depending on the findings, to investigate those organisations where politicians or bureaucrats were involved to see how the funds were spent/disbursed, or at least to show the data on their website for others to study how the funds were actually spent. If these large amounts are being siphoned off it would need people in power to initially authorise the projects to the NGO, and then to sanction the payment to them — which could be fictitious.
  • The shocking truth is that approximately 60 per cent of the central schemes are sanctioned directly to NGOs and social organisations, where the CAG has no purview for an audit (because these funds do not pass through the consolidated fund of the respective state)!
  • The CAG reports go to the Public Accounts Committee (PAC), which have been known to stall or delay action on these reports. PAC meetings are held in camera. Why hold them secretly? The public should be engaged in the PAC process — when did they receive the CAG report? When and how did they act on it? The need is for transparency here.
  • After years of a public perception that there was a nexus between politicians, bureaucrats and corporates that was responsible for the major corruption in our country, perhaps the new nexus between politicians, bureaucrats and the social sector will reveal corruption at an even bigger level.

There is no such thing as Healthcare as Human Right!

Read New paper released by International Policy Network

The Multitudes of facts

Robert J. Samuelson writes in the Washingtonpost:

  • Being optimistic, Americans commit suicide at fairly low rates, 10.2 for every 100,000 people in 2004, less than the 11.9 average for all industrial countries or Japan's 20.3 and France's 15.1. Food is cheaper here than almost anywhere else. In 2007, only about 6.9 percent of U.S. consumer spending went for food at home; Germans spent more (11.4 percent), as did Italians (14.5 percent) and Mexicans (24.2 percent). On the other hand, low food prices may contribute to Americans' obesity. In 2006, about 34 percent of U.S. adults were judged obese, triple France's rate (10.5 percent) and four times that of Switzerland (7.7 percent).
  • The United States may be the birthplace of feminism, but that's not obvious from global figures. In 2009, women were 16.8 percent of the U.S. House of Representatives. In other national legislatures, women did better. For Canada, the comparable figure was 22.1 percent; for the Netherlands, 41.3 percent. The United States was nearly on a par with Uzbekistan's 17.5 percent.
  • Considering today's economic slump, America may seem a land where progress has died. Not so. The Stat Abstract offers many counterexamples. Crime is one.
    Two decades ago, governments seemed helpless against a rising tide of murders, assaults and drug deals. Then crime began to subside. From 1993 to 2007, murders dropped from 25,000 to 17,000 and robberies from 660,000 to 445,000. Crime rates per 100,000 declined more, because the population rose 16 percent over the same period. There is no consensus as to why. Possibilities include better policing techniques and tougher sentencing (the incarcerated population doubled from 1.15 million in 1990 to 2.29 million in 2007). But crime still remains serious, especially for the young: In 2007, 18 percent of high school students reported carrying a weapon sometime in the previous year.
  • There are other signs of progress. Smoking continues to decline, from 25.3 percent of adults in 1990 to 19.7 percent in 2007. Five-year survival rates for cancer are up: from 62.4 percent in 1990-92 to 69.1 percent in 1999-2005 for whites; and from 48.2 percent to 59.4 percent for blacks. Voting is also up; the 57.1 percent turnout in 2008 was the highest since 1968. Garbage per person has stabilized; it was 4.5 pounds per day in 1990 and 4.6 pounds in 2007. Among young adults (18 to 29), Internet usage is virtually universal: 92 percent in 2009, up from 72 percent in 2000.
  • But bad news abounds, too. In 2007, nearly two-fifths of all U.S. births were to unmarried women, double the share in 1980. Since 1970, the student-teacher ratio in schools has declined dramatically, from 22 to 1 to 15 to 1 in 2007, with little effect on test results. The share of children under the federal poverty line in 2007 (17.6 percent) was virtually the same as in 1980 (17.9 percent).
  • Almost one-quarter of elementary and high school students are immigrants or have immigrant parents. In 2007, the average American spent 1,613 hours watching TV, the equivalent of 67 days. From 1980 to 2007, the number of pickup trucks, vans and SUVs almost quadrupled, to 101.5 million, while the number of cars rose only 12 percent, to 135.9 million.
  • And sex? The Stat Abstract has that, too. Among men ages 15 to 44, the median number of sexual partners in their lifetimes is 5.4. Almost a quarter of men (22.6 percent) say they've had 15 or more partners. Among women, the median number of partners is 3.3, and almost a tenth (9.2 percent) say they've had 15 or more partners.

Friday, January 8, 2010

Disco Dance Tonight: For Sanyasins Only: No Economists allowed to move their legs!!

Prof. Jagdish Bhagwati writes:

  • ……..Indian policy framework had degenerated into an unproductive, even counterproductive, set of policy choices that had produced the abysmal growth rate of approximately 3.5 per cent per annum over nearly a quarter of a century. The slow growth of the Indian economy had also undermined the assault on poverty that had been our central objective since planning began in 1951. It is only common sense that a stagnant economy cannot pull people out from poverty through job creation, even though a growing economy may still not create enough jobs. So, when we failed to grow, we also failed to make a serious dent on poverty.

On 1991 crisis:

  • ……….the fact that thoughtful Indians had finally understood that we just could not go on the way we had, that change was necessary.

    On The States Failed Policies :
  • But Prime Minister Manmohan Singh told me that an important part had also been played by the diaspora. He told me that, when he was spearheading the reforms as the finance minister, Prime Minister Narasimha Rao had lent his full support largely because many members of his own family, who were abroad, had told him that India’s policies made no sense and that they had diminished our standing in the world. Coming from his own family’s immediate experience abroad, the message carried great salience and cemented the resolve of the prime minister to pull India out of the rut into which it had fallen.
    Indeed, the policy-making elites were finally shocked into the reforms by two factors that acted like a pincer movement against the status quo.
  • First, these elites increasingly experienced, at first hand when they went abroad, the disjunction between their sense of India’s ancient culture and glory and their realisation that our foolish economic policies had led to a situation where few took us seriously. The worst kind of psychological situation is where you have a superiority complex and an inferior status!
  • …….they lived often in countries where our policies would have been laughed out of court. I recall writing an op-ed in the New York Times when Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi was coming to the United States and I had mentioned how he represented a force for change and how the licensing system had been softened to allow for product diversification. The editor asked me what that meant; and I explained how the Indian licensing system had gone so far as to insist on specifying whether one produced knives or forks! The editor was incredulous: how could anyone think that good planning meant that one could not diversify production without permission? I, a member of the diaspora, did mention this at the time to several friends in the Indian government, to their chagrin. Indeed, over time, the flood of such stories coming from the diaspora helped lay the groundwork for the abolition of the senseless licensing restrictions on capacity creation, product diversification, on import competition, that became part of the liberal reforms.

The State to end education inspector raj

“We want to end the inspector raj that has governed the functioning of the AICTE,” human resource development minister Kapil Sibal said at a briefing where the policy shifts were announced.

Hope for creating more freedom

Friedrich A. Hayek wrote in the Contemporary Review of London, April 1938: “The link between classical liberalism and present-day Socialism — often still misnamed liberalism — is undoubtedly the belief that the consummation of individual freedom requires relief from the most pressing economic cares. If this seems attainable only at the price of restricting freedom in economic activity, then that price must be paid; and it may be conceded that most of those who want to restrict private initiative in economic life do so in the hope of creating more freedom in spheres which they value higher.”

Intellectuals and Society

In an interview Prof. Thomas Sowell talks from his latest book Intellectuals and Society: Chapter 4 of 5

Thursday, January 7, 2010

What is of note of Indian Economy?

According to economist Mr. Debroy:

….at Ficci and the newly-appointed Chief Economic Advisor spoke there. This is what he reportedly said and it is best to put this within quotes. “In 1975, India first achieved 9% gross domestic product (GDP) growth due to the nationalisation of banks and opening of a large number of branches in rural areas, which led to the highest rate of savings and investment that made up 13% of the GDP.”

Inspiration vs Aspiration

Rama Bijapurkar writes:

  • If my generation paid the price of the socialist ideology, then this generation is bearing the cross of the free market, survival of the fittest, keep up with the Joneses society that we are becoming.
  • What do they see as the big problem that this country has to deal with? It is poverty and unemployment (27% votes each), while only 4% chose illiteracy and lack of education, 3% terrorism and 6% corruption.