Wednesday, January 6, 2010

“Hills Road 6 form student wins Nobel Prize.”

Venkatraman Ramakrishnan said in his interview to Indian Express Walk The Talk:

Shekhar Gupta: Science is a good beginning. I’m happy to say that about myself — I’m from a generation of musicians forced to study science.
  • Venkatraman Ramakrishnan: My feeling is that even if you are not a scientist you really should have a certain minimum education in science because we live in a highly technical society. How do you know that the right decisions are being made by your government or people around you? We talk about pollution or global warming. How can you even judge if these things are meaningful or not? If you have a fundamental background in science even at the high school level, it does help you come to grips with the problem instead of taking someone’s word for it.

RTI (Response to Intervention)

Jerry Kohn on RTI (Response to Intervention) and School!!

Some excerpts:

  • As for learning, most adults I know have forgotten most of the subjects they allegedly learned in school (even those they got A’s and B’s in), and what they do remember is usually politically correct nonsense.
  • Unfortunately, it seems the only thing students actually do remember from their government-provided education is the government’s propaganda.
  • We teachers tell ourselves that we are preparing our students for adult life, but nothing about our schools even remotely resembles mature adult life. At school, students are segregated by age and ordered about all day given little choice in what they do, when they do it or how they do it.
  • As for the failures, we teachers generally blame the failures on bad parenting or on social and economic ills we, of course, played no part in creating. Schools take credit but never accept responsibility.
  • Instead, students must learn to evaluate their own success and failure and to adjust their efforts and direction accordingly. Finally, schools must end the practice of age segregation. School must afford children the opportunity to interact with and learn from people of all ages and not just spend time with their age-group peers and adult authority figures. In short, schools must be a secure microcosm of the real world where children are afforded rights while still being held accountable for their actions.
  • Our public schools are long past sick, and they are incapable of reform. They have become brain-eating, spirit-killing zombies operating not for the benefit of their students but for the benefit of those who work in them and those who profit by doing business with them. The big teacher’s unions, educational bureaucrats, education professors, teacher colleges, textbook publishers, and educational testing companies all profit from the status quo.

Intellectuals and Society

Sowell on his new book Intellectuals and Society:

From I

“….during the 20th century, it is hard to escape the conclusion that intellectuals have on balance made the world a worse and more dangerous place. Scarcely a mass-murdering dictator of the 20th century was without his supporters, admirers, or apologists among the leading intellectuals — not only within his own country, but in foreign democracies, where intellectuals were free to say whatever they wanted.”

From II

“Intellectuals and their followers have often been overly impressed by the fact that intellectuals tend, on average, to have more knowledge than other individuals in their society. What they have overlooked is that intellectuals have far less knowledge than the total knowledge possessed by the millions of other people whom they disdain and whose decisions they seek to override.

We have had to learn the consequences of elite preemption the hard way-- and many of us have yet to learn that lesson. ”

Tuesday, December 29, 2009

The levels of public engagement

C.V. Madhukar writes

“Many existing “think tanks” appear to be more focussed on producing research output
than in engaging more widely with policy makers. For a number of professionals in various walks of life, politics has been anathema all these years.”

Tuesday, December 15, 2009

More on The revealed Samuelson!

T C A on “Paul Samuelson, RIP”

Teachings of Paul

Michael M. Weinstein on The foremost academic economist of the 20th century

Hayek on Hayek


Nothing I expected more than this on Hayek!!

Monday, December 14, 2009

Paid votes vs paid politics by Chandra


Many new debates have been kick started after the recent general election and many state elections in India. Among them was paid advertisement of politicians to raise there voice as a politician or to prove a point. One such case here is showing a new age. P. Kodanda Rama Rao, who is with Loksatta Party, Warangal said in an Outlook issue of 21 December 2009.


He said:


“I was worried readers weren’t even aware I was in the fray. To prove a point, I called a reporter in Ennadu and paid 50,000. I got three half-page features highlighting my worth as a politician.” (Page.32).

There are many many such cases read the piece on “News you can abuse”.

Paul A. Samuelson, Economist, Dies

Paul A. Samuelson, Economist, Dies at 94

Saturday, December 12, 2009

Is there any correlation between The Beautiful Mind and The beautiful Tree?


Watch latest interview of Prof John Nash here

The Beautiful Tree By James Tooley

Bluffing playing

T C A on:

“..Darshan Singh Pheruman who fasted till he died for a political demand which was not conceded. On August 15, 1969 Darshan Singh, demanding that Chandigarh and some other areas also go to Punjab after the creation of Haryana in 1966, went on a fast unto death inside the Amritsar Jail. The Centre did not budge. On 27th October, 1969, he died.”

Indian Education umbrella may seem ludicrous!

Devesh Kapur writes:

“It was recently reported that a UGC study covering 14 central universities found that 42 per cent of posts at the level of professor, 29 per cent at the reader level and 34 per cent at the lecturer level are lying vacant.”

Also read “Why UGC should go federal” this is piece by one my teacher!

Dreams never die

Charles Krauthammer on “The new socialism” and environmentalism

A bit from his piece:

  • “With socialism dead, the gigantic heist is now proposed as a sacred service of the newest religion: environmentalism.
  • The idea of essentially taxing hardworking citizens of the democracies to fill the treasuries of Third World kleptocracies went nowhere, thanks mainly to Ronald Reagan and Margaret Thatcher (and the debt crisis of the early '80s). They put a stake through the enterprise.
  • This naked assertion of vast executive power in the name of the environment is the perfect fulfillment of the prediction of Czech President (and economist) Vaclav Klaus that environmentalism is becoming the new socialism, i.e., the totemic ideal in the name of which government seizes the commanding heights of the economy and society.”

Friday, December 11, 2009

The demands for Vidarbha, Gorkhaland, Harit Pradesh, Kongu Nadu,

Ramachandra Guha has piece explaining the need of new State in Andhra. He also urge for forming new States Reorganisation Commission (SRC):


Some excerpts:

  • ‘The people of Telangana find themselves in an unenviable state. Their fellow countrymen outside the State of Andhra Pradesh, are unable to understand, much less appreciate, the significance of the revolt in Telangana’.
  • ‘The moment Telangana elected representatives dehypnotise themselves from the lure and pressure of the Andhra political bosses, and fall in line with the aspirations of their electors, the movement will reach its natural culmination’.
  • K. Chandrasekhar Rao, embodied the sentiments of millions of people. Since he was more obscure, and the prime minister of the day more powerful, it took his death (after 58 days without food) and the intensification of the street protests for the Centre to concede the new state. This then led to protests by Kannada, Marathi, and Malayalam speakers, in response to which a States Reorganisation Commission (SRC) was created, which, in 1956, officially mandated the principle of linguistic states.
  • In retrospect, it is clear that this reorganisation consolidated national unity, such that India did not go the way of Pakistan and Sri Lanka, which had to suffer bloody civil wars because of the unwillingness to grant linguistic autonomy. However, our nation-state is comparatively young, and still evolving. It now faces a second generation of challenges, these pertaining to the regional imbalances in social and economic development. A new SRC should be constituted, which would look dispassionately into the demands for Vidarbha, Gorkhaland, Harit Pradesh, Kongu Nadu, and other such. Its mandate should also include the granting of real financial and political autonomy to panchayats and municipalities.
  • To do its task fairly and honourably, a new SRC must draw its members not from political parties but from the law, the academy, and the social sector. The members of the first SRC were the jurist Fazl Ali, the author and diplomat K.M. Panikkar, and the social worker H.N. Kunzru. India today has a comparable set of distinguished and independent-minded people. Some names for a fresh SRC I might suggest are the jurist Fali Nariman, the economist Jean Dreze, the sociologist André Béteille, and the social worker Ela Bhatt — but there would be others, too.
  • Meanwhile, expect Jaswant Singh to put aside his pen, thus to answer his constituents’ demand that he make Gorkhaland the sole object of his attentions. Ajit Singh may also be stirred out of his present lethargy to lead the movement for Harit Pradesh. As for Rao, he certainly knows the parallels with the movement in the 1950s for a separate Andhra. Potti Sriramulu’s fast was conducted in Madras; because he lived there, and because he wanted Madras to be the capital of Andhra Pradesh. In the event, Sriramulu’s supporters got their state but not that city. Rao’s greatest fear now must be that history would repeat itself in toto, such that they have their Telangana, but without Hyderabad.

The road to Climate Change is death mark


Don't let the climate doubters fool you

Thursday, December 10, 2009

A forgotten national leader!

Today is the 131st birth anniversary of Chakravarthi Rajagopalachari, affectionately called as Rajaji.

A year ago B.R.Haran wrote:

"It is an irony that the Chief Minister, who has been a hardcore adversary of Brahmins and who has been criticising and abusing them till the day before yesterday, has made a u-turn yesterday and said that he was never against Brahmins! Apart from his claims of giving paltry ‘financial’ assistances to Brahmin scholars, can he show a single good thing, which he has done for the Brahmin community in the capacity of Chief Minister during his five terms? When he can introduce the ‘1 kg rice-1 Rupee’ scheme on Anna’s birth anniversary, why couldn’t he introduce ‘prohibition’ on Rajaji’s birth anniversary? If not prohibition, why not a few ‘vocational’ courses in schools?

Similar to the Dravidian parties, the Congress party has also not bothered to celebrate Rajaji’s birth anniversary. The days are not far off for this ‘one-family’ party to forget Gandhi too! If the present day political parties prefer to ignore the leaders of the past, then it will not demean those great leaders, but it means that these parties are only insulting themselves!"