Indiauncut bloger Amit Verma wrote in his first Novel My Friend Sancho:
“Humans as a species would not exist if not for extremely improbable things happening consistently over millennia……….we are all products of accidental events- and after they happen, we look back at them as if they were inevitable, constructing narrative where none exist.”, p.211.
In one day, the little boy’s of my land lord asked me What is government? Before I answer that question I asked them what their teachers have taught. Their answer was ‘nothing’. Then I asked what they have read in the Text Book. They have showed me the following text from the book-Social Science- Social and Political Life-1, Chapter-3, page 27:
“What is Government?
Government sought to protect rights of unorganized workers
Govt, fixes price of onions, says no shortage in market
Detailed plan to tackle floods soon, says government
Supreme Court can have five more Judges: Govt.
Govt for revamping coal and power sector
Over 15,000 villages declared scarcity hit by government……”
I am not surprised to see the definition of ‘What is Government?’ in the Text Book of Class VI. Though, this Text Book was prepared by The National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT).
They were paused when I said that the definition of government is nothing but to ensure the life, liberty and property of the individual citizen of a country. And its role is to ensure people’s life, liberty and property through the civilized law and order system, morally matured defence system and equal opportunity to everyone. Then I went on to say there is a great amount of danger in government functions in India and elsewhere. Freedom is ruined and property is threatened.
"The travesty is the intellectual arrogance of the authors of climate-change models partially based on the problematic practice of reconstructing long-term prior climate changes. On such models we are supposed to wager trillions of dollars -- and substantially diminished freedom."
“why people fear the state. The rhetorical use of victims’ rights cannot obviate the fact that a state is a state only if it has a moral identity. The so-called “weak laws” have become a self-serving alibi for larger institutional failures of the state. There is also considerable comparative evidence of how draconian security laws add little to law-enforcement capability.
……..state is hoist on its own petard because it often overestimates the power of power.”
"Barun Mitra, however, had a different argument. He said it is growth which leads to a green and clean environment.
"Economic growth invariably creates energy efficiency and leads to a greener environment, while poverty makes people vulnerable," said Mitra.
"If we can get rid of poverty we can solve the problem," he added.
At this, Mitra reiterated his point and said, "Poor always pays the highest price in all casualties because of the fact that he is poor. The only way to deal with the poor issue is growth."
Mitra gave a new argument and claimed there has been nothing like climate change in the world.
"Science is not about answers, it is a quest, a search. The email-gate clearly establishes how corrupted the scientist community can be when they hand in glove with the political establishments," he emphasised."
They are no fools, and the professional practitioners of development and well-paid warriors against poverty are not as wise and all knowing as they might think they are
As I myself have experienced in the villages of Madhya Pradesh near Indore and wrote it here in this blog some time ago.
Here is a former IAS officer note back to his practice about in and out of his mind. In a way he become a Hayekain now!! Even more than that! Whether he knows or not?
Some excerpts from his piece in today’s Indian Express:
A good deal of money was spent (maybe there was a World Bank loan!), houses were built in an urban row-house pattern, and these were handed over to the tribals with much fanfare by political bigwigs who got a nice photo-op, and maybe even some genuine satisfaction at having done something good for these ‘ ignorant, poor people’.
Three months down the line, a team went to visit the place to see how the tribals had taken to the new life style. To its utter disbelief, the team found that the tribals still continued to live in their traditional thatch roof huts, and were using the newly built houses to keep their beloved livestock!
Buffaloes, cows and goats were happily munching their feed off cement floors, and the air was redolent with the unmistakable smell of dung and droppings. The tribal people just could not sleep in those brick and mortar houses, or use the strange toilets, or cook in the confined kitchens, and so what better use of the new houses than to utilise them to keep their precious cattle? The project, obviously, was not a success
…..development plans conceived and implemented without any real understanding of the people being ‘modernised’, and without any consultation with them.
ANECDOTE TWO: RURAL HOUSING IN EARTHQUAKE HIT GUJARAT, INDIA, CIRCA EARLY 2000’S.
We found that the newly built villages had small but neat two room houses of brick and mortar, with mosaic floors, electricity, and even an attached toilet. To me, it seemed that these would be rejected by the villagers the same way the tribals of Betul had rejected the houses built for them.
I asked myself, why this difference in attitude from that of the tribals of Betul, and realised that the main reason why there was no criticism or rejection by them of these new style houses was that the state government had, very wisely, followed a participative process, and had in fact left the planning of the new villages and houses largely to the NGOs and the end users, unlike in the case of Betul where all planning was done by outsiders who wanted to provide what they considered to be ‘good’ for the tribals to them.
What is really relevant is that the lesson is the same now as it was forty years ago, which is that only development initiatives which are done in consultation with the beneficiaries shall succeed, and where they feel that they are participants in development and not just recipients of charity. They are no fools, and the professional practitioners of development and well-paid warriors against poverty are not as wise and all knowing as they might think they are.
……..during the colonial period, a broad-based commercialization and a state that wanted to consolidate private property rights, led to a legal and market regime in which communities had to shed their isolation,
……….If we compare the complex of case laws in 2000 with that in 1850, it would seem that private rights have won the battle, but not without great economic and social cost.
………the Kings in precolonial India were expected to function within a moral order that included the notion of a social contract. The principle of the contract was to respect the juridical-economic-cultural autonomy of those collectives that supplied essential services for the state. All states are built upon alliances. There was no essential difference between Europe and India in this respect.