Friday, August 14, 2009

Teachings of Prof S Ambirajan: “Clout intact by pandering”

When I was a student of undergraduate in Economics at Gurunanak College, in Chennai I heard Prof S Ambirajan’s writings but never gave thought, after all we were students! Infact one of my teacher who taught me was PhD student under the Supervision of Prof Ambirajan when he was the head of Economics Department in University of Madras.

But over a period of time he has been a forgotten man within me, though often I use to search who are all counted as liberals in India.

Many thanks to Sauvik for giving me Prof Ambirajan’s book “Classical Political Economy And British Policy In India” this book was published as Series of Cambridge South Asian Studies.

I’m enjoying reading, it has great ideas infact the following excerpts will help you to imagine some extant on his understanding.

Excerpts from his article published in The Hindu in 2001:

  • “India attained freedom: ``since the Indianisation of the Viceroy's Council, the once prized efficiency of the ICS and the Government, at any rate of the administrative side, has largely disappeared……. there is adequate evidence of the steady decline in the efficiency of governance now when the entire administrative system is unquestionably Indian.
  • Public expenditure by itself is not harmful and is actually necessary. However it has damaging consequences depending on what is spent and how, and where the revenue is generated. The ripple effect of public expenditure can affect the economy's performance by destroying the productive and encouraging the wasteful elements of the governing system.
  • The remedy should rest in leaving as little as possible of the nation's resources in the hands of our ruling class.
  • Take for example the Human Resources Development Ministry which is one of the most bloated spending Ministries of the Central Government. The work of the Ministry of Education since its beginning has been incredibly dismal. In spite of the goal set by our founding fathers in our Constitution that all children will be provided free and compulsory education till the age of 14, after more than five decades, India has more illiterates than the total Indian population in 1947. In every area where the Ministry's footprints are seen - secondary education, higher education, scientific research, technical education, distant education, and so one can only notice colossal failure. It can be safely concluded that in its main job of widening the knowledge base in the country, the Ministry has achieved little.
  • If the vast monies poured into the Ministry did nothing to create a well educated India, what has it achieved? The agenda of the Ministry of Education (later christened Ministry of Human Resource Development) seems to be purely decorative, and it has always exerted itself to build a powerful empire to dispense favours. In the name of preserving culture and encouraging higher scholarship, numerous departments, centres, commissions, academies, councils, and institutes have been created to accommodate ideological positions and favoured individuals not to mention developing personality cults. Most of these institutions have evolved into self-perpetuating parasitical bodies, and the Ministry itself by ruthlessly acquiring control over educational funding has erected a highly centralised system. The Ministry's function is like the Mughal Mansabdari system where fiefs were created for favoured courtiers. The history of the Ministry seems nothing but a history of the constant struggle among coteries and groups to capture positions of power. And the Ministers who preside over this vast incubus have always played the game of favourites. It was religion as in the case of the first Minister, Abul Kalam Azad, who packed the Ministry with Muslims provoking a commentator in the irreverent Shankar's Weekly to define the Ministry as ``Pan-Islamic Brotherhood''! Narasimha Rao and Bommai preferred people from their regions for key appointments. The two professor Ministers, Nurul Hasan and M. M. Joshi, stuck to ideological soul mates for heading fiefdoms under their control, Marxists and Hindutvawadis respectively. Mr. Geethakrishnan, the Ministry of HRD is ready for your attention!”

Indeed, I am very much excited to say that I have got another great paper of Prof Ambirajan which he wrote in 1997 this paper was in B.B. Price edited book “Ancient Economic Thought”.

Actually I have collected a bunch of papers/article by Prof Ambirajan.

All I can say is thanks to Sauvik for his giving me Prof Ambirajan book.

Can Dr Singh do a Robert Peel?

T C A on Import:

  • It will, instead, try to trap domestic supplies at home by banning exports. Indeed, this is why the UPA-I pumped in Rs 87,000 crore into farmers’ pockets last year through the increase in minimum support prices. It won the election as a result.
  • But if the politicians continue to see it in this way, and do nothing about rising food prices, we could have food riots soon. The time has come to stop worrying only — note, only — about the producer and start worrying about the consumer also. About 70 per cent of net buyers of food are abjectly poor and live in the rural areas, so there is a moral dimension as well.
  • The Government thinks food subsidies are an answer. In a limited way, they are. But the final answer lies in increasing supply now, and not waiting for productivity to increase at some distant date. And there is only one way to do this: Import.
  • In a way, therefore, the Prime Minister has to do what a British Prime Minister, Robert Peel, did exactly 150 years ago — he repealed that infamous corn laws that had been enacted in 1815 to protect British corn prices against cheap imports from America.
  • This import ban had caused millions to become poorer even as their incomes rose because of industrialisation.
  • In the years after the repeal of the corn laws, that is between 1850 and 1900, food prices in Britain fell continuously, as did the land under corn. Import dependence went from only 2 per cent in 1830 to 75 per cent by the end of the century. That had other adverse consequences, mainly for India and China, but food in Britain became cheap.

Thursday, August 13, 2009

Globalisation: sound and fury in Seattle

From Prof S Ambirajan article published in The Hindu, 2000:

  • “To make some sense of this process of globalisation which seems to have received the imprimatur from almost everyone, one must try to understand on what philosophical basis the edifice stands. Looking at the big names in economics supporting globalisation, the unlettered layman could easily believe that it is all based on esoteric but sound theories which lead us to the ultimate truth.
  • At its core is the orthodox economic reasoning of the neo- classical variety which believes in the following fundamental principles: (a) the way economies behave is solely dependent on the actions of individual economic agents who take decisions independently; (b) the individual is a rational actor taking all decisions carefully with self-interest in mind and (c) the actions and reactions of individual economic agents tend towards an equilibrium which brings benefits to everyone.
  • The institution of unfettered market enables the achievement of this desirable outcome because it is where uncoordinated but fully informed individuals - who though individually by themselves lack any power to influence - lead the economy to adjust at a desirable level.
  • Individuals cannot always take decisions solely in their own interest because of informational barriers and institutional compulsions. More often than not, key decisions are taken to suit not individuals but groups defined by criteria as varied as religion, caste, community, locality and gender. Freedom to take decisions is not evenly distributed but is determined by those who have the levers of political power. Often individuals and even groups become helpless spectators when key decisions that involve them are taken willy-nilly. Markets embedded as they are in a social milieu are seldom unfettered. Despite all the brouhaha about vanishing national boundaries, they are guarded zealously because the nation-states have not shown any intention to give up their power over their citizens.
  • Globalisation is a process of rearrangement of the world's resources between people and countries. In this process, there are winners and losers. While some countries as a whole may lose out and others gain, in general the losers and the winners are individuals and groups. Let us take two examples. In a study of foreign entry in the domestic banking market worldwide during 1988-95, three World Bank economists, Claessens, Demirguc-Kunt and Huizinga, have shown that in developing countries foreign banks as a rule have greater profits, higher interest margins and higher tax payments than do domestic banks. On the contrary, in industrial countries, it is the domestic banks which have the upper hand in terms of profits, interest margins and tax payments. Does this mean foreign entry in the domestic banking market is altogether harmful? They argue that it need not be so because the entry of foreign banks can make national banking markets more efficient by compelling the domestic banks to meet the competitive challenges with vigour. Take import of second- hand cars. How should we judge this policy? The beneficiaries in the short-run are the consumers and in the long-run, the second- hand exporting countries. The losers are the local manufacturers in the short-run and the importing countries in the long-run because the ultimate environmental effects of the disposal of old cars are borne by the importing countries.
  • Sad to say, we are not living in an ideal world because those who are powerful will always try to dominate the weak. What should be done? As the economist Albert Hirschman said in a different context: ``Do we exit or do we voice?''

Recently Niranjan Rajadhyaksha has written a piece on this ‘exit’ and ‘voice’ matters.

Illiteracy is of what?

That was the title of one of my paper which I had presented at a national seminar at BANISS!

That is what Prof S. Ambirajan also said while writing a book review that “A person who may not be able to sign his name in paper will nevertheless have a thorough grip over interest rates, profitability ratios, geometrical proportions and other such mathematical knowledge needed for both his economic relationships and constructional activities.”

Basic Newton’s laws of motion applied to a public issue

Ramesh Ramanathan has good piece on “unveiling of the statue of Tamil poet Thiruvalluvar” in Bangalore.

  • The “social conflicts can only happen through political processes. Politics is, therefore, not a bad word, but a term that we need to embrace more and more, as we begin to talk more openly about our conflicts, and seek their resolution. The Thiruvalluvar statue issue was not one that could have been resolved informally by two groups of people sitting and having tea and samosas—the underlying emotions ran deep, the conflicts had a genuine core which were exacerbated by other factors. The other examples I listed earlier also fall into the same category.”

Wednesday, August 12, 2009

INDIA 1950S: ANATOMY OF A DECADE

Prof. Dr. V. Shanmugasundaram gives a certificate to a girl student

That was the title FE carried a bunch of articles on last Sunday, these articles focuses on changes in the economy, policy, visions, etc during the period 1950-59.

Some excerpts from those articles:

From Prof Meghnad Desai article:

  • “India had, uniquely among the colonies, a 90-year background in modern industry by the year of Independence. It was the seventh largest industrial economy by volume of output. It had a large native entrepreneurial class and successful world class industries in cotton and jute textiles. It had railroads, steel, cement and pharmaceuticals.
  • Within two years of its launch, the Second Five Year Plan ran into trouble. There were not enough resources to finance either the restricted list of imports or even domestic savings to finance investment. The Sterling balances had been frittered away long ago, mainly helping Indian capitalists to buy up British owned firms. There was a foreign exchange crisis and drastic restrictions had to be imposed on who could spend what abroad. Permits and licenses were required to monitor who got what of the scarce resources. The Plan had to be pruned.
  • Luckily for India, in 1991 the economy crashed. It was a replay of the forex shortage of 1958. This time the Plan was not pruned; the strategy of 40 years was abandoned and India liberated itself from the Fifties. Perhaps the fault was not with the Fifties but later decades where the policymakers became more dogmatic and myopic. Now India has to catch up with 40 years of bad policy.

In overall Prof Desai confuses many things that were happened in the independence India some time he deliberately hides the facts which is actually imperative to non-economics readers.”

From Rahul Bajaj:

  • “Before independence, we blamed the British for India’s slow development. But what happened after independence? Look back at the 1950s and 1960s and we find no one to blame but our own backward looking policies. So, we need to look ahead than look behind — there is hardly anything for us to learn from the 1950s.
  • The socialistic economy has done good to nobody, by and large.
  • Till 1960, India was ahead of most of the South East Asian countries. Today it is lagging behind China, many South East Asian countries, let alone, Japan, America and Europe. It was all due to the non-progressive policies of our government. The Industrial Regulation Act, 1956 was passed. And in 1969 the MRTP Act came into effect. It opposed the concentration of economic power in the hands of a few. A misguided concept. Industrial Licensing Act was equally bad.
  • There are some 200 companies in the public sector. Many are existing at the expense of the taxpayer. What value are they adding to the Indian economy? Hence, disinvestment is a must.
  • The whole decade of 70s was a difficult year for Indian industry. From the industrial point of view, nothing much happened. No new technical collaborations were approved and there were no new joint ventures in the private sector. Even the older technical collaborations that expired were not renewed. By the grace of socialistic economy, even today we have a per capita income of less than $1000 per annum. What are we proud of? What kind of socialism is this? The industrialists are getting richer, politicians are making money, and there is a nexus between politicians and crooked businessmen. I don’t see this as a sign of a good economy or a progressive country.
  • It was only the mid 80s that saw things picking up to some extent under the leadership of Rajiv Gandhi. He was a bright, young man of integrity who had very good intentions to take India ahead but he did not have the right kind of advisors. His famous speech on the brokers in Bombay and that only 15 paise in a rupee reached the intended beneficiary indicated that there was corruption and inefficiency in the functioning of the government.”

Its’ my turn, the Rahul’s sympathy is though undue but there is no other way to do but he tried his best to due credit to Nehru but could not!

Nothing interesting in Prof MS Swaminathan’s piece on “From Green to Ever-Green Revolution”. But one thing that I have not mentioned in this blog is the fights between Prof MS and C Subramaniam for taking credit in who is real father of Indian Green Revolution?

One senior most economist Prof Dr. V. Shanmugasundaram told me in University of Madras that the actual father of Indian Green Revolution is C Subramaniam not Prof MS Swaminathan!

From B.G. Verghese:

  • “The first decade of India’s Independence laid the foundations of the new Republic that came into being on January 26, 1950.The liberal Constitution adopted then made democracy the instrument rather than the end product of a social and economic revolution, an event that stood history upside down and worked despite many doubts. Yet in his final address to the Constituent Assembly, Ambedkar warned of a dangerous “social democracy deficit”. The political principle of “one man, one vote” would need to be matched by the economic and social principle of “one man, one value”, a huge contradiction in what was then and even now a very hierarchical and stratified society from which so many of our ills continue to flow today.”

From Murad Ali Baig:

  • “General Motors and Ford had begun local assembly in 1942 to support the war effort but stopped production as soon as the Indian government announced its first industrial policy to disallow total imports. After the war, new car launches were quite modest and infrequent. India’s first locally assembled car had been Premier Automobile’s Fiat 500 in 1944, followed by the Fiat 1100. Then came Standard Motor’s Standard 10 in 1947 and Hindustan Motor’s Hindustan 10 in 1948. In 1945 Mahindra & Mahindra had also begun making the jeep that had a large civilian following despite being mainly intended for the army and it was considered a very macho machine by those who were able to get one from army disposals. But they were overshadowed by fully imported cars that were allowed to be imported for some time.
  • Although I had got my driving licence driving my father’s imported 1955 Chevrolet Bellaire that we thought was a most magnificent vehicle it started getting competition from Premier Automobiles who had started producing big Dodge and Desoto cars. Standard Motors had also moved up to bigger cars by producing a very ugly Standard 18. The Hindustan 10 and Fiat 100 were however the most popular although the earlier imported Austin 10 cars remained the mainstay of the fledgling taxi trade.
  • Though the cars were exciting they were not very reliable. Engines had to be overhauled every three or four years and they broke down every month or two. Drivers had to always carry extra fan belts, radiator hoses and distributor parts so that the roadside repairers could quickly get them moving. There were also quite a few horse and bullock carts on the roads so punctures from the nails of their worn out shoes were a regular thing. We considered ourselves lucky if a new set of tyres lasted over 15,000 kilometers.
  • Thank God that some things have changed. You have come a long way baby.”

Super power or poverty

Professor Jagdish Bhagwati on “bricks without mortar!”

A bit obnoxious on economists

Prof William Easterly writes in his blog that:

“…economists have no scientific evidence base for explaining or predicting year to year or even decade to decade variations in growth rates.”

Statues eat a lot!

Today’s ET editorial woos politicians for statues:

“Tamil Nadu and Karnataka just seem to have buried the hatchet by unveiling a statue”

“The battle even extended to erecting statues of each other’s saints and poets. Yet, with the unveiling of Tamil poet Thiruvalluvar’s statue in Bangalore, we might yet enter a new era of actually tolerating each other’s presence. And we do this by erecting each other’s statues in our own territory.”

Can you sue the injustice?

Shiv Visvanathan writes in a different angle in today’s ET that the “Justice is often a strange experience. It is like a form of pregnancy. Its rituals of gestation, its modes of realisation consume time. Often by the time it arrives, the victim is too tired to celebrate. Yet, the search for justice has a powerful sense of drama. The procedures invented to articulate it can be radical.”

Tuesday, August 11, 2009

The Idea of Blender and Confession=Fiction of Social Justice

In an interview to Utv Prof Sen says something which is terribly wrong and fundamentally unsound. We have seen in India in the last fifteen or twenty year’s that the 80s and 90s economic reforms have greatly helped Indian economy. One needs to have open mind to recognize these facts before jumping to criticize.

Prof Sen says:

  • “……..capitalism is a very confusing term, to some it means complete reliance on the market and for others it means the society which we have today in America, Europe, Japan, South Korea, etc. but they are quite the same because while Europe has the national health service, America does not have that but has public pensions, medical and other kind of insurance. I think the success of the capitalist economies has been based upon these mixed services and people forget that.”

What is that mammal of “mixed services” or “mixed system” did he ever pen it, what is that all about?

  • “So asking the question that we need new capitalism, does not seem to properly identify what was happening earlier. Secondly, we do not know whether we should call it new capitalism as the state has a bigger role to play in many bigger areas, that it would like to extend and not just in the United States but also in India. We also need to have educational arrangement provided by the government without stifling the private initiative. So do we call it a new capitalism or new something , I think it is silly to worry about that and one of my heroes Adam Smith, who is considered to be a great guru of unrestricted capitalism, never used the term capitalism and I think theory of the invisible hand that is attributed to him, I think he hardly ever used it…, There were three uses in his entire life of that and two of them are negative and one case is I think a reference to Lady Macbeth and the bloody hands so he didn’t think that the market did all that good…
  • ..find what kind of institution or the mix we would want..”

Very soon we are going to celebrate our 62 Independence Day Prof Sen still argues “find what kind of institution or the mix we would want” in way all that is not that bad but I ponder what was our leaders contribution to this country, what kind of institutions we wanted actually, and what they did?

Narega rhymes with karega

When I read Ila Patnaik’s article I remember my visit to some villages near by Indore city in 2006 (at that time I was in Indore University working as a research faculty). The visit was part of our workshop. It was a rural appraisal kind of thing. One thing I still remember freshly is the toilet facilities it was peculiar that every villager had used the ‘toilet’ for goat shed etc. The reasons are many for why village people were not interested to change their habit like the urban people. Among others the reasons include available of water, some sort of uneasiness, people have to wait for long, etc. The Madhya Pradesh government was funded this toilet building programme (one in every household) for a sanitation development.

So, this scheme was biggest failure and money spend was completely waste. Though, many argued that at least the village people were used for putting goat, etc. Some of these folks were also argued that even 10-20 percent of people get benefit from public distribution system (PDS) they said it was great achievement! What a stupid!

If you demand anything from the government don’t forget to think that they will never ask you to pay higher tax but they will coerce (may be theft is right word) you to pay more taxes.

Government is not meditation but motivation by oneself

Deep Joshi is the founder of PRADAN and won 2009 Magsaysay prize. He says in an interview to BS that the “government is not qualified to take up community development”, but don’t expect anything more from this interview except the below one question. Infact saying something like this is dangerous for true open society “So people are still far away from the point when they know they can get work on demand. Once that point comes, nothing can stop them.”

Do you think our BDOs should be qualified in social work? Or should the government do development work at all?

BDOs (block development officers) today are not qualified for the job they do. Anyone will tell you that the system is not working. Tell me: Have you seen a BDO sit on the floor with village women? The state's currency is power and the bottomline is coercion, whereas development requires motivation to extend oneself. The government is good for providing defence, resource transfer. But, for running development activities, there is a conceptual flaw in it. The sad part is no one seems to apply his mind to this matter.

Call it Education as national enterprise

Kapil Sibal on RTE bill that was passed on 4 August, 2009

There has been a mushrooming of deemed universities of late. You have found some of them not up-to-the-mark.

I have directed that new approvals (for deemed universities) be frozen. It is necessary that deemed universities operate in a transparent manner- they should have websites where details of faculty, equipment, student-teacher ratio etc. are given.

It is not that all deemed universities — there are 130 of them including 35 in the government sector—are not conforming to acceptable standards. There are only a few black sheep. We may have to undertake review of some 15-20 such institutions and ensure that they adopt necessary structural reforms.

How do you view a “shape" when one is blind?

Paul Krugman on free market economics in an interview to ET Now:

Markets as self-adjusting, self-correcting god-like mechanisms. Do you think that dogma is out of the window now?

There’s a great seductiveness to efficient markets here. So, efficient markets have been very hard to kill. And, I think, it may survive even this. The Asian crisis, the dotcom bubble, all of those should have severely shaken faith in self-regulating markets and yet that faith persisted pretty well. So, I’m not sure that even this will kill it.