Tuesday, August 11, 2009

Barking up of Children’s life

When I was in school my teachers in government school had no idea how to teach English subject (forget about how they have passed such subject in their student life) they lacked in every skill. In my class, out of ten at least 7-8 student will enroll private tuition for English and Mathematics and the results pass out was always 90% and above.

Infact, these private tuitions have different kind of inefficiency but all are not in same quality, so in way these private tuitions have taught at least to pass the odd government exam. But for years I was confused how and why it happens like this but later when I started reading large literature. I find, they are stupidly inefficient institution, they have union power, they influence through politicians and over a period they have never like the word ‘performance’ and the end results is barking up of a beautiful tree!

It is not that easy to “eat, shoot and leave” these mammals from Indian soil!

Mythili Bhusnurmath has a good piece on why do bark up the wrong tree which is otherwise a beautiful tree!

She writes in ET:

  • “In such a scenario the demand for tuitions will not go away, ban or no ban; more so in view of the huge mis-match between demand and supply of seats in good institutions of higher education, Hence, rather than legislating a ban that will prove impossible to enforce and additionally, will serve no purpose, it would be far better for the govern-ment to focus its attention on improving the quality of schooling so that children do not feel the need for private tuition.
  • Agreed, this is easier said than done; agreed also, that this is some-thing we’ve been trying to do for years without success. But there is one reason why we may be a little more successful this time round: the voucher system wherein 25% of the seats in all private schools will be open to children from under-privileged backgrounds who would be given vouchers by the government to pay their fees.
  • This means children will now be able to choose which school they wish to attend. At the same time competition between private schools competing for additional funds brought in through vouchers will improve teaching quality.
  • The amount involved is huge. According to Parth Shah of the Centre for Civil Society, by the time the present lot of class 1 students reaches class 12, as many as 30 million children will be at-tending private schools with government support.
  • Yes, this may not improve matters in government schools where teachers’ salaries and funding are assured but here the principle of neighbourhood schools with the Panchayats being given the responsibility to appoint and monitor the performance of the teachers could improve the quality of schooling. Banning private tuitions won’t!”

“Social Justice” and “Social Choice” are nonsenses: Friedrich Hayek and James Buchanan

John Gray on “A just society will accord its members a range of basic liberties but also the capabilities needed to make use of them”

From The Economist:

  • AT THE disputed crossroads where economics and ethics meet stands Amartya Sen, a Nobel-prize-winning economist who thinks like a philosopher. In a dauntingly impressive flow of books and papers over 40 years he has done much to change both disciplines for the better, humanising the one, bringing content from the real world to the other. His work is technical, however, and the fine detail has sometimes hidden the shape of the whole. Mr Sen’s latest book answers both difficulties in magisterial style.
  • In the courtliest of tones, Mr Sen charges John Rawls, an American philosopher who died in 2002, with sending political thinkers up a tortuous blind alley. The Rawlsian project of trying to describe ideally just institutions is a distracting and ultimately fruitless way to think about social injustice, Mr Sen complains. Such a spirited attack against possibly the most influential English-speaking political philosopher of the past 100 years will alone excite attention.
  • Virtually every claim Mr Sen makes will be objected to by someone. Right-wingers who follow Friedrich Hayek or James Buchanan will treat “social justice” and “social choice” as nonsenses. Mr Sen wants to humanise canons of “maximising” rationality; behavioural economists, much in fashion, aim to ditch them altogether. Rawlsian liberals will rally to the defence of their hero.

Techno-economic nobels

Prof S Ambirajan on 2001 Nobel Prize winners in Economics:

  • “It is not easy to summarise the work of even one of them because of the vast range of subjects they have traversed, but it is almost impossible to give a flavour of their combined work especially to a largely non-economist readership. Yet what they have done in the field of technical economics has considerable significance for everyone. Broadly speaking their work exhibits the following characteristics. First, their analysis is highly sophisticated and technical unlike an earlier generation of economists who while retaining the high level of technicality and sophistication, nevertheless tried to communicate to the non- specialists both within and outside the profession. The language of Mr. Heckman and Mr. McFadden is of a very specialist variety couched in advanced mathematics addressed specifically to fellow specialist practitioners taking for granted considerable prior knowledge.
  • Our academic tsars need to ponder why the quality and quantity of research output in India is so abysmally low and infinitely inferior to what comes out of American universities.”

In an article Mr S. Muthiah said:

  • Ambirajan says, 'Did a poor schoolmaster's son from a small town in Saurashtra, with hardly Rs. 25,000 with him in l958, have any chance against a combination of the powerful Parsi business families...and Marwari merchants, not to mention the avaricious political class controlling the levers of a permit-licence-quota raj...? Dhirubhai Ambani could have led the virtuous life of an ethical yarn dealer in the backyards of Bombay and lived in a spartan chawl.

Monday, August 10, 2009

Ambirajanomics!

Dr. S. Ambirajan was eminent historian in political economy. He was the son of Dr K.R. Srinivasa Iyengar a distinguished professor at Andhra University. “Ambirajan was a true liberal” died on 4 February 2001.

“Particular skills….benefit both the parties to the transaction”- Dr. S. Ambirajan

The following are some excerpts from his article published in the Hindu:

  • “The economists' questions are even more important because they address themselves to the implications of policies for the long run interest of the economy and the totality of the socio-economic system. Politicians' policy agenda invariably focus on the very short term results and/or aim at vociferous sectional interests. The pervasive issue for the economist is the relationship of costs to be incurred and the expected benefits of any suggested action. He is interested both in the open and the hidden costs to society, and more particularly as to who will suffer the losses of bad decisions because all policies involve transfer of resources with losers and gainers. He will also factor in some of the most fundamental traits of human behaviour when examining different ways of achieving the same economic ends. The economist knows that choosing one thing in a world where everything is scarce means giving up another. This will naturally involve studying alternative policies to achieve the same objectives. Politicians then, if they are genuine about the welfare of the totality, must pay heed to economists who may often bring unpleasant tidings about their pet projects.
  • There is a charming naivete about a demonology where the trader who buys and sells is considered an unwanted ogre. We need to remember that as long ago as 1776, Adam Smith underlined how human prosperity is derived from specialisation which is a consequence of the propensity to ``truck, barter and exchange''. No system of economic organisation has been able to buck this innate nature of human beings. A trader who stands between the producer and the consumer is a specialist in his own job, and brings particular skills to benefit both the parties to the transaction.
  • Trading is a spontaneous institution that emerged to reduce transaction costs which are inevitable in any exchange situation that goes beyond the most rudimentary barter mechanism prevalent in very poor unsophisticated economies. If a trading chain develops snags, policy should try to identify the sources of the increases in transaction costs to remedy it. Instead the ``farmers' fair'' actually adds to transaction costs, the only difference being to shift the cost burden from the farmers and the consumers to the general tax payer. This does not make any economic sense.

Other readings

S. Ambirajan Memorial lectures:

Books:

The Idea of Fiction of Social Justice!

So, Prof Amartya Sen’s latest book “The Idea of Social Justice” is out and many of you may be thinking heavy bites probably the notion of justice in India! As I have posted here my first take on his book.

When we see people talks on the idea of justice on the same line of Sen’s argument it seems to be that these people never dare to think beyond their writers or teachers.

Let’s go back to some of Sen’s interview and excerpts from this book:

From the ET NOW Interview:

  • “….all our policies relate to injustice because none of our policies, even ones like the employment guarantee scheme, will make the world perfectly just, it will only make the world a little less unjust.
  • ……..the democratic institutions might exist but their utilisation might be quite limited, partly through our own fault because we don’t engage enough, partly it’s about the way the media is organised and its limits or the way the parties are organised.
  • ……….there is a school of thought which is very powerful, that took that view. But there is a little bit of a contradiction there. Those that take the view that human beings act only on self interest, they should have been in favour of regulation. Because human beings won’t spontaneously act that way. But you have a peculiar combination of people believing in self-interest but holding the view that regulation is bad. It’s a mystery.
  • The solution to the mystery is a belief in the effectiveness of the neeti of the market. The market is so magical, even though everyone is acting in their self interest, it’s working out in the interest of everybody. That requires a very special theory. People often attribute it to Adam Smith, but Adam Smith explicitly denied that. I think it’s the theory of the so-called efficient market. Self adjusting, self correcting, self directing market system. And that kind of faith in the neeti is completely unjustified.
  • ………stupidity arises from the institutional faith in the magical power of the market as a neeti. If you study air crashes, you will find that if there is one thing that goes wrong, the plane still flies. You need several things to go wrong on top of one another for the plane to nose dive. What went wrong with the market economy story was a similar combination of mistakes that were made.”

First of all if your dare to think ONE STEP Ahead of Sen’s understanding say from F A Hayek point of view, even beyond I’m sure you will say that there is no such thing as “Social Justice”.

Instead of saying “all our policies relate to injustice because none of our policies” we should ask are they aimed at people’s individual freedom, liberty and property? The answer is a big NO!

It is completely illusion to say that “we don’t engage enough” infact, if The State is minimal there is greater participation among people for their needs.

While attacking this book Acorn argues “Dr Sen’s line is dangerous because it threatens to reduce the importance of individual rights and freedom, and supplant them with the discourse of social justice”.

Other readings:

From Mint book review The rational synthesis

From Outlook interview “I am a friend of the Left and my politics has been on the Left, but sometimes it’s difficult to recognise what is Left, what is Right. I am in favour of fighting today’s battles rather than yesterday’s battles.”

From his book excerpts published in The Hindu “Justice and the world”

The Nobel Prize-winning economist is inspiring Labour politicians with his theory that inequalities of power matter as much as inequalities of income.

How “relevance of Amartya Sen” ideas?

Book review from OutlookIndia ‘Doing’ Justice

NCAER's DG ‘Fraud’!!!

“It is appalling to have to tell you of a case of credentials’ fraud on the part of the Director General, NCAER. He has yesterday admitted in an email to me that he has no Princeton PhD in economics.”

“There is no claim that I submitted my Ph.D.; if you note, the same announcement refers both to me as Mr and to my degree as MPA.”

Wednesday, August 5, 2009

“If you had known anything, we wouldn’t have been in this mess today”.

The following text is from a interview with Shekhar Gupta.

I am posting only the interesting conversations that relates to C Rajagopalachari and his Swatantra Party.

Shekhar Gupta: Tell us about your first election, your first experience of politics. Did you just walk into it, not knowing what it meant, or you had thought about it?

Maharani Gayatri Devi: I don’t know if you have heard of C Rajagopalachari and his Swatantra Party.

Shekhar Gupta: Yes.

Maharani Gayatri Devi: People came to me to talk about the Swatantra Party and what Rajaji wanted to do. I thought it was a very good idea. I had great respect for Pandit Nehru, but didn’t like his policy of nationalising everything. Free India, swatantra Bharat, swatantra janata was what I believed in.

Shekhar Gupta: You believed in free economy?

Maharani Gayatri Devi: Of course. When these people came to talk to us, I asked my husband, “May I join the Swatantra Party?” He said, “Yes”. I was going out for a ride in the morning and I sent for the secretary in Rajasthan and joined the Swatantra Party. Then when the election time came near, they asked me to contest from Jaipur. I had no intention of being a Member of Parliament. My husband said, “You’d be the obvious choice”. The election campaign began, it was an eye opener. In those days people didn’t know how to read and you had a list of the names of the candidates. The Swatantra Party’s sign was the star.

Shekhar Gupta: During those five months in jail, did you regret being in politics?

Maharani Gayatri Devi: I never regretted being in politics, I never regretted being in the Swatantra Party, I never regretted being a chela of Rajaji’s. He believed that India should be really free.

Shekhar Gupta: If you look at the two personalities, he and Nehru, both towering personalities, where did they differ?

Maharani Gayatri Devi: Both were great friends. When Pandit Nehru had to send somebody to America to talk to Kennedy, he chose Rajaji. I admire Rajaji because he had a vision for India.

Shekhar Gupta: The war?

Maharani Gayatri Devi: Yes. Prof N G Ranga of the Swatantra Party told me, “Jawaharlal will make fun of me” and I said, “In what way?”. He said, “You wait and see”. When Pandit Nehru was replying to a debate on China, he said, “Prof Ranga... professors will know more than he does”. So I got up and said, “If you had known anything, we wouldn’t have been in this mess today”. He sat down and another Member of Parliament stood up and said, “I didn’t hear what the honourable lady member said”. So I said, “May I repeat it. That if you, the Prime Minister, had known what was happening we wouldn’t have been in this mess today”. The next day the secretary of the Lok Sabha said, “Maharani saheb, how could you be rude to someone older to you?”

Shekhar Gupta: You interacted with leaders, princes, princesses.

Maharani Gayatri Devi: C Rajagopalachari, definitely. And strangely enough, Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru. He loved India and India loved him. But the things he did were not right for India.

So you have that as one fact

Prof Jagdish Bhagwati on “India is the worst user of anti-dumping actions, not the U.S. or the EU. But when you actually look at the value of trade you discover that it is minuscule compared with what the U.S. and the EU are doing.”

The road to urban and cities: Antidote is road, road road you count now

Sanjeev Sanyal argues that the India “public transport systems do not work efficiently when the city is spread out and commuters cannot easily walk to the bus/metro stop. The existing large cities are already bursting at the seams and we will have to expand existing towns/cities, urbanise villages and build brand new towns…….. it is essential that we revive small mofussil towns as economic, social and cultural centres”.

European socialism

Pallavi Aiyar on European socialism: “You see ma cherie,” he said patiently, as if to a child, “why would anyone work to earn ¤1,200 a month if they can do no work and earn ¤1,000? In fact, you have to be quite stupid to work.”

Who are we fooling?

Chetan Bhagat has a piece which is reasonable thoughts and great observation. His anger is valid but what to do with that? Will the politicians mind these words, you know for them it’s merely ‘words’. Will the public listen until next election that won’t be possible, but nothing is impossible in free market economics!

For record I am posting his full article below. But what I feel is that the title of this article would have named as MUDDLED ECONOMCIS!

Mandi economics Chetan Bhagat, August 04, 2009 The Hindustan Times

  • The shortfall in the monsoon has created anxiety among farmers across the country with several leaders having expressed their concern. In the name of caring for the affected rural poor, cheap rice is being provided in many places. But before I get into that, I want to share a little story.
  • The other day when I went to the airport, I was told that the flight was delayed. I felt disappointed but had no choice. As compensation, the airline gave me one sandwich. After three hours, they told me the flight was cancelled. However, this time they gave me two sandwiches. I argued about my missed flight. How would I reach my destination? They said they were a caring airline and so they could give me three sandwiches. The flight never took off.
  • What would you want to do with such an airline? Will you call it a caring people’s carrier? No, I am not talking about any particular airline or ranting about my mishap at the airport. It’s merely an analogy pointing to the attitude of the government towards the farmers of India. On the face of it, there are subsidies, loan waivers and cheap rice. However, none of these creates real progress or changes the face of agriculture in India.
  • Before we start blaming the rain gods yet again, I want to know why are we so dependent on rain-fed agriculture in 2009? If India is an agricultural country, shouldn’t we have done some massive infrastructure projects across the country? Over two-thirds of our agricultural land is dependent on rains. China has only one-third of its land unirrigated. Developed countries depend very little on rain. This dependence creates high fluctuations in the output year after year. Apart from the volatility, we are not efficient either. China can produce twice the amount of rice for every acre of land as us. Australia can produce five times the rice per acre than India.
  • Who are we fooling? The Indian farmer is not cared for. He is on drip-feed in a hospital being kept alive for votes. The cheap rice one-upmanship seems great in the short-term, but will it help close the massive efficiency gap or the rain dependence? And if this gap is not closed, can India ever really progress?
  • There are other negatives created by such subsidies. The government has to borrow, which, in turn, leads to higher capital costs for power and transportation infrastructure projects. It also leads to inflation. Yes, we can continue to live like this: constantly rising prices, the rare infrastructure project that is too little, too late, and poverty with attendant problems like poor healthcare and low literacy.
  • Yet, this can change. Many South East Asian countries were in a similar situation 20 years ago. However, these countries have implemented sound economic policies, focused on massive, long-term developmental projects (rather than cheap vote-bank politics) and changed the face of their countryside.
  • It is easy to blame politicians. However, we elect them. And the fact is that subsidies do result in votes. The intoxication of cheap rice is heady. It makes the voter believe the government is doing something. A lot of people may even think, ‘Grab whatever you can. The government won’t do anything else anyway.’ But can we sustain this? Is this good for the country in the long-term? Do you want to give your children the same India that you inherited? Or want to leave them a better place?
  • Famished, destitute people must be fed. (By the way, why don’t we give them cooked rice in specified centres to avoid misuse and re-trading?) However, a leader’s job is to build for the future. I’d like the local panchayats to accept the rice, but demand more from the leaders.
  • Talking about development in agriculture, it is not only about irrigation projects and enhancing crop yields. There are many other areas of improvement. In Hong Kong and Singapore, milk and butter come all the way from Australia. If an Indian software company can provide service abroad, there is no reason why an Indian farmer should be denied such a lucrative market.
  • We can say we need to keep the milk for our own country. There are two holes in that argument. One, if a farmer makes money, he will invest in more cattle or efficiency improvements and production levels will rise to meet demand in India as well as abroad. Two, we (rightly) don’t force our corporate sector companies to sell their products exclusively in India. Then how can we force the farmer? To cut off a source of income and then offer cheap rice — is that caring for our rural citizens?
  • The government and quasi-government entities keep a tight control on dairy and farm produce for food security reasons. However, the fear is over-blown and government involvement has prevented world- class output. Food that wasn’t grown due to poor efficiency is food destroyed. The government is not saving food; it is destroying it. There are global companies who operate across the world. While they are private enterprises, they have benefited millions around the world.
  • Let’s demand the same world-class treatment from our leaders.
  • Agriculture can be India’s competitive strength in the world, if we become serious about it. The Indian farmer feeds us. We must nourish the nourisher to ensure he will still be around for us and the generations to come.

Chetan Bhagat’s latest book is The Three Mistakes of My Life

Sambhog is a theory of free market economics which never applies to SOCIALISM

Reading modern history of economics is like having long chat with my girlfriend in villages where there is no road, electricity, television, telephone, mobile, newspaper etc. But MY THOUGHT GOES TO HER LOVABLE HEART!

What is globalisation? If anything changed on the present phase of globalisation it is this that Sowell emphases in his book The Applied Economics chapter Labour. Precisely Sowell argues that if anything changed like revolution it is the labour choice to work in traditional profession or the modern free market creations of millions of new professions which unfold even now may be forever.

Aakar Patel had a column in mint which track quite exactingly the love of labour and gains out of it.

He writes:

  • “Jobs are opening up to millions of young people across India who are leaving traditional professions, or farming, and becoming office workers. They are equipped for this work because they have learnt English, a new language: Most of them are the first speakers of it in their families. When they come to the office, they are trained to execute tasks; they are instructed to improve themselves through the process of evaluation. There are seniors, and managers, in the office who have done the work before and tell them how to be more effective.
  • They become individuals in the Western sense; they are judged by what they do and not who they are, as their fathers would be in their communities.
  • They encounter office hierarchy and Indians instinctively know how to address someone above their station, and below.”

Who own’s who and who harms whom?

Private property giant and Prof Walter E. Williams has a nice piece in which he argues:

  • “In a free society, many conflicting harms are settled through the institution of private property rights. Private property rights have to do with rights belonging to the person deemed owner of property to keep, acquire, use and dispose of property as he deems fit so long as he does not violate similar rights of another. Let's say that you are offended, possibly harmed, by bars that play vulgar rap music and permit smoking. If you could use government to outlaw rap music and smoking in bars, you would be benefited and people who enjoyed rap music and smoking would be harmed. Again, there is no scientific or intelligent way to determine whose harm is more important. In a free society, the question of who has the right to harm whom, by permitting rap music and smoking, is answered by the property rights question: Who owns the bar? In a socialistic society, such conflicting harms are resolved through government intimidation and coercion.”

India is an emerging delusion but the antidote is wakeup and stand for Rule of Law

Soutik Biswas has a book review in Mint Lounge which I think fair enough. Some excerpts.

  • “Monarchies, fascism and communism have been discredited. Theocracies don’t have many takers. Roy, however, wonders whether democracy should be the “utopia that all developing societies aspire to”. Her political insight lags far behind her clever prose. Sample this: “What happens once democracy has been used up?” Used up? How? Then she continues, “What happens when each of its institutions has metastasized into something dangerous? What happens now that democracy and the Free Market have fused into a single predatory organism with a thin, constricted imagination that revolves almost entirely around the idea of maximizing profit? Is it possible to reverse the process? Can something that has mutated go back to being what it used to be?” What did it use to be? Weren’t democracies and free markets always compatible? Is this an activist’s cant or a writer’s rant?
  • Roy’s apocalyptic pitch continues: “Could it be that democracy, the sacred answer to our short-term hopes and prayers, the protector of our individual freedoms and nurturer of our avaricious dreams, will turn out to be the endgame for the human race?” So, what fascism and communism and feudalism couldn’t do, democracy might. The end of the world is nigh, thanks to democracy’s failings.
  • In all these respects, India remains a work in progress. The country is still quite a distance from being a truly “liberal democracy” in which democracy extends from being a mere celebration of free and fair elections to a rule of law, and protection of rights to speech, religion, property and so on (Journalist Fareed Zakaria calls this “constitutional liberalism”). Also, it is common knowledge that democracy hasn’t always led to liberalism and elections don’t necessarily lead to more democracy—after all, Adolf Hitler was voted into power through free elections.”

More interestingly:

  • “Democracies have often been imperfect, with rulers abusing power, undermining human rights, stoking intolerance, and promoting sectarianism and bigotry. It is surprising to see Roy writing off democracy because it is not delivering all the goods; this is hardly a revelation. Indian democracy is even more complex.”

Saturday, August 1, 2009

Who violate (or often discriminate) in the society? - The State

In 2004 August I visited Kendriya Vidyalayas School at Manpur near Indore in Madhya Pradesh I thought exactly the same point what Ashok is doing.

“Well-known education activist and lawyer Ashok Agarwal says the Bill should have insisted that all government-run schools should be of the level of the Kendriya Vidyalayas. “The government is spending public money on running exclusive schools meant for people of a higher socio-economic status whereas children of the poor and the marginalised sections of society are forced to make do with less than a tenth of the expenditure. “This is in utter violation of Articles 14, 21 and 21A of the constitution,” says the lawyer who has filed a public interest litigation in the Supreme Court against the discriminatory system and sought a direction that all state and state-supported schools should adhere to a standard framework with a clearly defined per capita expenditure and also follow a common framework for admission. The PIL was filed in June 2008 and notices have been issued to the 36 respondents. In April this year, a committee was set up by the Central Government to look into these issues.”

It is also equally important to ponder how these “higher socio-economic status” people gets information for their individual development vis-à-vis the poor people in other side of this country.

That is what F A Hayek has discovered in his life time that it is not that resources alone scare but information or knowledge is scare among people especially the poor.

In a great piece on Hayek ideas Jesse Larner writes “A complex economy is something no person or institution can understand. But it can generate a sustainable order, with a rational allocation of resources, as individuals respond to their own circumstances and make choices as consumers and entrepreneurs, signaling the subjective value that they place on goods and capital stock through the price mechanism: One of Hayek’s most original contributions to economic theory is the insight that economic systems are based primarily on information rather than resources.”