Saturday, June 13, 2009

Fallacies in First Past The Post election system

S. Srinivasan writes:

“Belgium was the first country to introduce proportional representation in 1899 for national legislative elections to its lower chamber.

Today, besides Belgium, Australia, Austria, Cyprus, Denmark, Finland, Germany, Greece, Iceland, Ireland, Malta, Monaco, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Portugal, Spain, Sweden and Switzerland adopt one of the many models of proportional representation.

Single transferable vote, choice voting or the Hare-Clark System are systems that asks the voters to rank candidates on the ballot. Voters’ choice is based on ranking the candidates rather than on choosing a party, so voters can choose between candidates from the same party or vote for candidates from different parties.

The single non-transferable vote system enables the voter to cast a single vote for one candidate in a multi-member constituency. In a four-seat constituency, among the candidates contesting, the four receiving the largest number of votes individually would win the seats.

The Party List System is currently adopted by many democracies in Western Europe. This model has two variants. Each party nominates a list of candidates equivalent to the number of seats to be filled from a constituency.

In the ‘Closed List System’, the party fixes the order in which the candidates are listed and elected and the voter casts one vote for the party list as a whole. Thus, if a party wins enough votes to be awarded three seats, the first three candidates listed on the ballot are automatically elected. On the other hand ‘Open List’ allows voters to choose the candidate they like. Votes are cast for candidates and not for parties.

The most popular model adopted and considered fit for adoption by many countries is the German model known as the Mixed Member System, that includes members elected both from single-member constituencies and from party lists. In many cases, half the seats are filled from single-member constituencies and the other half from the party lists. Voters cast two votes; one for the local candidate of their choice and one for the party of their choice.”

Friday, June 12, 2009

Global Recession and Liberalism

A talk by Dr Parth J. Shah  on “Global Recession: Chances and Challenges of Liberalism”,

Bravo Ruskin Bond Sahib

“When the great socialist government of Uttarakhand has destroyed Dehra Dun, Ruskin Bond’s town will still be there.”

Frum on Mark Levin's "Liberty and Tyranny"


All the private medical, dental, engineering and management institutions are not profit oriented!

Manoj Pant has article in today’s ET with some facts about higher education and FDI in India but entirely his ideas are not new, in fact how can any one expect anew idea from Marxist stricken university like JNU? 

  • “……all the private medical, dental, engineering and management institutions are not profit oriented! 
  • FDI in higher education will squeeze state institutions. This is probably the main concern. That public sector institutions hampered by state controls would not be able to compete with the foreign institutions. There is no “level playing field”. But the counter argument is compelling: if state-run banks could be subject to competition from private foreign banks why not state-run educational institutions? As in the case of state-owned banks (who also have a social commitment) is it not possible that state institutions would also improve their services with competition?  
  • FDI would bring in competition. This is easily the strongest argument in favour of FDI. Today state-run higher education can accommodate only about 10% of eligible students. Even with the ambitious plans to have new central universities this figure would only go up to about 15%. As recent media exposes show, private institutions are fleecing students via both regular and capitation fees. 
  • Many unscrupulous state institutions have aided this process via what are called “deemed (doomed?) universities” or “affiliated institutes”. As a consequence, the better students are looking for foreign pastures while the wealthier ones obtain dubious degrees. What is even worse, the dubious institutes (many linked with domestic schools) are tying up with even more dubious foreign institutes in granting “foreign” degrees. 
  • That is really the problem. With insufficient domestic capacity, private institutions are having a field day. In fact, the principal opposition to FDI in higher education would really come from this private sector. As is well known, most of the private education providers have links to business and/or are owned by politicians. So who will push through legislation allowing competition? Which politician would kill the goose which lays the golden egg? 
  • It is impossible that, in the near future, the state will generate sufficient capacity to raise the gross enrolment ratio in higher education to 30-35% as in most comparable developing countries. In fact, spreading the state control too wide might well result in decline in quality of existing state institutions. Historically, R&D normally emanates from universities and the Indian state can ill afford to allow things to slide here. But why bat for the private sector?”

When the rupee crumbled

“Her cabinet had endorsed devaluation earlier in the evening, with Manubhai Shah alone dissenting. Only at the eleventh hour did it strike the prime minister that she must also consult the powerful Congress president, K. Kamaraj. According to R. Venkataraman, then a member of the Planning Commission and later President, who was acting as interpreter because Kamaraj spoke only Tamil, the Congress president “hit the ceiling” and told her that she was “courting disaster”. Kamaraj also muttered to RV: “A big man’s daughter, a small man’s mistake”. However, it was too late to change the process already set into motion.”

Thursday, June 11, 2009

Street is no mood to listen like you think!


Yes, says Philip Delves Broughton:

“Time after time, and scandal after scandal, it seems that a school that graduates just 900 students a year finds itself in the thick of it. Yet there is remarkably little contrition. ....You can draw up a list of the greatest entrepreneurs of recent history, from Larry Page and Sergey Brin of Google and Bill Gates of Microsoft, to Michael Dell, Richard Branson, Lakshmi Mittal — and there’s not an MBA between them. 

Yet the MBA industry continues to grow, and business schools provide vital income to academic institutions: 500,000 people around the world now graduate each year with an MBA, 150,000 of those in the United States, creating their own management class within global business. Given the present chaos, shouldn’t we be asking if businesseducation
 is not just a waste of time, but actually damaging to our economic health?” 


But T T Ram Mohan of IIMA seriously  think:

"But much of the talk about B-schools creating ‘ethical leaders’ can be dangerous nonsense. "

The Age of Milton Friedman


Wednesday, June 10, 2009

Fallacy is the State of Economists mind

Since the mega event of major financial crisis in US followed by UK, economists and analysts around the world did (and continues even now) all kind of noises about the reasons for collapse and the magic of economic recovery. 

There are three groups of economists/analysts at least in my view. One group argues based on the people who warned in the pre crisis which said the central bank was dead sleep, in the sense that they failed to see their actions in terms of trend in interest rate, credit flows, risk involved in 100% loan etc, the second group which is the post crisis accident group which argues by blaming the notion of capitalism, wait, this group neither understand the central banks regulations in the past and what they did and did not do and finally the third group which is part of first group. This group accepts the central bank failure along with government and absurdly proposes to print more money or increase deficit financing like anything to recover the economy.

As for as the Indian economy which I continue to observe and it is natural to ask how Indian economy pushed into slowdown and what is the evident to say Indian economy is severely affected by the US financial crisis? 

There is another group which is mixed of all argues that the world and Indian economy is in economic crisis which is stupid. Further this group does not understand difference between economic and financial crisis and the results is absurdly comparing the current crisis with 1930s. More importantly by ignoring the facts of Milton Friedman and F A Hayek who best explained what cased the 1930s depression. 

Indian economists/analysts are no different from rest of the world. I mean how the hay of noise mounted by economists and analysts with out figuring out the reality. 

Precisely a few people said what Mr Jha said which I think right in an article published in today’s ET. 

What went wrong in the Indian economy and how unnecessarily we are in slowdown is best explained by economist Prem Shankar Jha: 

  • “But in 2008 the economy had already slowed down sharply because of the increase in interest rates that the Reserve Bank had engineered in 2007. So a more pertinent comparison is with 2007. In January to March 2007 industry grew at 12% a year. This dropped to 7% in the same quarter of 2008. It has fallen to minus 0.9% this year. The last 12 months’ decline has not therefore been caused by the global economic recession alone.  
  • The reason is that the slowdown did not begin in October last year but in 2007 when the RBI mounted its battle against the phantom of inflation by savagely reducing the supply of available credit in the market. It had had all the time it needed to spread from the consumer durables into the capital goods industries. 
  • The most unequivocal sign that the deceleration is continuing to deepen is the sharp drop in the volume of new lending by the commercial banks. Net bank credit has actually fallen by Rs 37,000 crore in the six weeks between April 10, and May 22. While seasonal factors are partly responsible for this, the main cause is a drastic slowdown in the growth of bank lending that has been evident since November. As a result, In the previous full year (May 23, 2008 to May 22, 2009) credit extended by the commercial banks expanded by only 15.7% against 25.3% in the corresponding period of 2006-7”. 

Indeed the whole article is worth to read.

Moribund free marketers in the TOI

A socialist commentator writes in the TOI that “The rich in India are among the world's most under-taxed. Since the 1930s to the Thatcher-Reagan era, the western capitalist countries had a top tax rate of 60 to 80 per cent and a direct tax-GDP ratio of 35 to 55 per cent. India's ratio, under 10 per cent, cannot fund public services. These changes will be resisted tooth and nail. But if the Congress recognises the roots of its own success, and Rahul Gandhi takes his social sector commitments seriously, the government must forge ahead with the New Deal.” 

Tuesday, June 9, 2009

Our BEd programs are a complete joke

Our BEd programs are a complete joke

Reading the history means reading somebody’s mind

Yes, re-reading the “machinery of government” or The State is worth like anything says economist Bibek Debroy in the Indian Express. He quotes something which is terribly practical for a century if the India choose to go like in the past.

Let’s go to the quote:

From a report on Reorganisation of the Machinery of Government and the author was N. Gopalaswami Ayyangar, 1949.

  • “There is need for carrying out organisational changes in the existing set-up of the machinery of government. This is so because there is insufficient coordination in the framing of policies and plans and inadequate speed and efficiency in their execution... It is necessary to bring about such changes in machinery and procedure as would render the process of expenditure sanction more intelligent, well-informed and speedy, and thereby remove the sense of frustration which afflicts, at any rate, several ministries and departments at present; and, at the same time, to tighten up the process of budget control of expenditure, and to promote economy-consciousness and sense of financial responsibility throughout all administrative departments. These are the effective safeguards against extravagance.”

From A.D. Gorwala’s Report on Public Administration1951:

  • “This feeling is intensified by a fairly general belief in the lack of integrity of many of those in high position... No government, least of all the Government of India, at the present juncture, can afford to proceed on the basis that it is better to attempt many things than to achieve a few. If it does so attempt, it must dissipate its energies and resources to little purpose. The basic things are food, clothing and shelter... It does seem that today, after providing for the legitimate requirements of external and internal security, the most important task of Government is that which falls within the economic sphere... There are undoubtedly many other activities in which a modern government has to take part and these cannot altogether be ignored, but the effort and expenditure... on these must obviously not be such as to prejudice the fundamental task, for, if this fails, everything else must also fail.”

From Dr Manmohan Singh speech at Conference of Chief Ministers and Chief Justices September 18, 2004:

  • “The institutions of governance fashioned by our founding fathers of our Republic have served us well over the last five decades. However, it is fair to state that many of the institutions have been of late showing signs of stress and today, the efficiency and effectiveness of many of these institutions are being questioned. There is growing dissatisfaction regarding the functioning of the executive and the legislature and their ability to deliver effective governance to meet the needs and challenges of our times.” 

Father of the cell phone

Father of the cell phone

A broken school system

A broken school system

Without Nath everything is hunky dory

Without Nath everything is hunky dory